/r/mlb

Photograph via snooOG

Subreddit for Major League Baseball. Reddit’s #1 MLB Community. From discussions, news, and highlights from all thirty teams.

/r/mlb

2,993,213 Subscribers

0

I found this on the brewers roster

7 Comments
2024/12/14
00:20 UTC

6

Why do teams not hold on to young talent like they do in the NFL or NBA?

Genuine question here, im not new to baseball but last year was the first year i watched more then 1 regular season game on tv (i watched about 20 or so) and attended about 5 or 6 games live at the diamondbacks stadium. Ive known the rules and older legends and a good amount of recent players so im not unfamiliar.

Why does it seem like teams dont value young great talent?? I look at a team like the white sox.. They have arguably a top 2 or 3 pitcher in Garret Crothet and a HUGE upside guy in luis Robert on their team and they almost moved BOTH of them last year and just traded the pitcher.. Skubal left, Kyle tucker just got traded, bellinger years ago, im sure there are a ton more examples just of the last 4 years of a lot of 25-26 year old great talents being moved for prsopects.. i dont get it. Traditionally in sports teams keep their young talent unless there is a genuine locker room or team chemistry issue or the front office is just super cheap. Very rarely do we see great young talent moved. I know rebuilding blah blah blah but like are you not going to be always rebuilding if you trade your bright pieces away? Add to it, pay the people that fans want to see.. what do you guys think? Teams in the MLB do this way to much in my opinion. It feels like they want to stay in poverty.

67 Comments
2024/12/13
21:52 UTC

86

Why did Aaron Judge fall to 32nd overall?

Listen, I know the MLB draft is far more of a crapshoot than any other draft, and baseball is more about development than drafting. Getting drafted 32nd overall among the thousands and thousands of prospects in that class is very good. But the draft does matter, and there are always the big name, "can't miss" prospects. Bryce Harper, ARod, Ken Griffey Jr., Stephen Strasburg, etc. So how did Aaron Judge, who's 6'7, 282 pound of muscle, no personal baggage, all-conference in all 3 years he spent in college, freshman all American, college home run derby winner, fantastic bat (900+ ops Freshman and Sophomore year, 1100+ Junior year), solid outfield glove, quite fast for his size, freak athlete who was recruited to play tight end at multiple big power 5 schools (including Stanford, UCLA, and Notre Dame), and no real injury concerns that I'm aware of, fall so low in the draft?

122 Comments
2024/12/13
16:11 UTC

28

Carlos Delgado’s hall of fame vote

I believe the people that vote for the HOF did Carlos a great disservice. Now I’m not saying he should be in the Hall of Fame but to not receive 5% of the vote to stay on the ballot another year is ridiculous. 473 hrs , 1500 rbi 280 ave in basically 13 full seasons.

59 Comments
2024/12/13
15:27 UTC

54

Clearing up the Soto contract for everyone

I’ve seen so many people on this sub over the last few days say that Soto left the yanks over $5M or because of a personal vendetta against a security guard. If anyone believes it was for anything other than money, please see the details below and let me know how it WASN’T just money that was the motivating factor.

Yanks offer:

  • $760M/16 yrs
  • $60M signing bonus

Mets offer:

  • $765M/15 yrs

  • Opt-Out after year 5 which would increase AAV to $55M/yr instead of $51

  • Luxury suite for all home games and an additional 4 luxury seats in the field level bowl

  • security for him and his family for all road & away games

  • $500K bonus for 1st mvp win with that going to $1m for any mvp won after that

  • $250K for finishing 2-3 in MVP

  • $150K for finishing 4-5 in MVP

  • 22 from Baty without having to give anything up to Baty himself

  • $75M signing bonus

149 Comments
2024/12/13
15:23 UTC

312

Baseball Celebration 80s vs Now😂

62 Comments
2024/12/13
13:36 UTC

0

how would you grade the Yankees offseason?

21 Comments
2024/12/13
13:04 UTC

146

Sotos reason for going with mets.

Lol yeah in other words they just paid the most lol 😆 he could even find the right words to answer this lol

241 Comments
2024/12/13
06:11 UTC

85

What are some underrated swings you like?

Xander Bogaerts has a very underrated swing. So pretty and effortless. It reminds me of Josh Hamilton's swing except right handed

142 Comments
2024/12/13
02:26 UTC

1

Any tips on buying tickets to the Tokyo games?

My dad and I are both Cubs fans. We have never been to Japan before and my Japanese is rudimentary at best. Does anyone have any advice on how I can potentially get tickets to the Tokyo Series games?

I checked online and the machine translation said something about a lottery, but I'm not sure how the process works especially if you don't live in Japan. If anyone else has been to an MLB game in Tokyo, any assistance is appreciated!

3 Comments
2024/12/12
23:34 UTC

10

Baseball Tonight still on the air?

Forgive me for not being in the know but I just recently got cable back and was wondering if Baseball Tonight is still on ESPN during the season. I thought it was a good way to follow the league

21 Comments
2024/12/12
23:29 UTC

62

“Michael Jack Schmidt” premieres tonight at 8pm ET on MLBNetwork 🔥

7 Comments
2024/12/12
23:06 UTC

0

Roger clemens left handed pitcher Mandela effect

Growing up roger clemens is the reason I wanted to play baseball and the reason I started to pitch I remember telling everyone I wanted to be just like roger clemens but only difference was he's a left handed pitcher so I have a bunch of old baseball and football and basketball cards I found some rogwr clemens cards worth a couple grand I was telling my friend the same story and I said wtf his gloves on his left hand I thought he was a left handed pitcher and My friend said he is ,we looked it up and it says he's right handed this completely confused me because I remember growing up knowing roger clemens pitched as a left handed pitcher ( does anyone else remember this ? I found 2 prices of residue showing him with his glove on his right hand holding the ball with his left hand either he learned how to do both or Mt whole life was a lie !

32 Comments
2024/12/12
17:12 UTC

3

MLBTR breaks down the Crochet trade

Here's the analysis, starting with this pair of comments:

In return for two years of Crochet’s services, Boston is giving up a massive prospect haul. Teel is the clear headliner, ranked by Baseball America as the #25 prospect in the sport. ...

In addition to Teel, the Red Sox are also dealing 2024 first rounder Braden Montgomery. The 12th overall pick in this year’s draft, Montgomery is a switch-hitting outfielder who has yet to make his pro debut but slashed .322/.454/.733 in 295 trips to the plate for Texas A&M this year. BA ranks Montgomery as the #59 prospect in baseball while MLB Pipeline ranks him as the #54 prospect in the sport.

From there, the piece looks at possible next steps by Boston.

5 Comments
2024/12/12
16:35 UTC

73

Worf: most kills in one inning. Death to the opposition!

13 Comments
2024/12/12
16:24 UTC

27

Why is the Eutaw Street Warehouse at Camden yards which 460 ft away from home plate so hard to reach?

Why do homeruns at Camden Yards never hit the warehouse in right field? The only one who has was Ken Griffey JR during a homerun derby. The warehouse is only 460 ft from homeplate. You think since its existence someone would have reached it in regular MLB game. Is there an airflow or something else that stops them from reaching the warehouse?

32 Comments
2024/12/12
15:57 UTC

10

Hall of Fame voters/voting needs a change

It’s that time of year again where the Hall of Fame voting has started. Ichiro is on the ballot and should be a 1st year unanimous hall of famer. Unfortunately I foresee him missing the unanimous vote by a few because some writers will protest a blank ballot or not vote for him so their name will be talked about. Griffey and Jeter a few years ago both only missing by a vote or two is absurd. The whole process needs to be updated. There are certain players where we all agree is a 1st ballot HOFer and they miss out due to the ego of a writer.

59 Comments
2024/12/12
15:16 UTC

91

I’ve been a Red Sox fan my whole life but it feels now more than ever, big market baseball is killing smaller teams

We have seen the dodgers become the federal kings, Sox, Yankees and Mets put up nearly a billion for Soto and more and more the free agents basically seem to have their eyes on BOS, NYY, NYM and LAD.

It kinda sucks.

What can be done to enhance the competition?

373 Comments
2024/12/12
14:20 UTC

0

Vlad Guerrero Jr to Angels? Hear my out

Ok. I recently got back into baseball after being gone so long. Mike trout is one of the greats and greatest ever Angel.

To keep him, and keep him happy, Angels should make a play for Vladdy Jr.

  1. They are in LA. The Dodgers are relevant and hot...the angels...not so much.

This would make TV and streaming partners, fans and neutrals care

  1. They are in SoCal...with that giant market they need to spend cause they can make it back and grow their potentially already huge fanbase.

  2. Vlads father is in the hall as an Angel and fans would love the connection with his dad and the Halos.

  3. This would show Trout they are willing to spend big money and he would not want to leave.

  4. And its SoCal. Vlads first language is Spanish...obviously Socal has a huge Spanish speaking populous. So for him it could be an easier place to fit in.

I'm not an Angel's fan but thoughts.

7 Comments
2024/12/12
06:12 UTC

0

Juan Soto is not better than Otani (when also pitching). Prove me wrong.

This post is here to generate discussion. Please be civil.

84 Comments
2024/12/12
04:28 UTC

342

In honor of a post I saw here yesterday, here is the actual comparison of trout and sotos first 7 years, with a difference of 20 PA’s instead of 500

Trout still clears, but that post from yesterday was obviously done to exaggerate and mislead.

157 Comments
2024/12/11
21:59 UTC

49

Anyone hear ever met an mlb player if so who was it and were the nice

I met Mookie Jordan Romano George springer and Captain Kirk all of them were very nice

510 Comments
2024/12/11
20:49 UTC

Back To Top