/r/shittysocialscience

Photograph via snooOG

Would you like to know why poor people are biologically inferior to rich people? Do you ever wonder what it would be like to confine a bunch of people to a system of underground caverns to test their cooperation skills? Interested in the viability of electroshock therapy in improving intelligence tests? Ask away! Multiple, conflicting answers encouraged, falsifiability discouraged.

>

Would you like to know why poor people are biologically inferior to rich people? Do you ever wonder what it would be like to confine a bunch of people to a system of underground caverns to test their cooperation skills? Interested in the viability of electroshock therapy in improving intelligence tests? Ask away! Multiple, conflicting answers encouraged, falsifiability discouraged.


Message the mod if your post gets caught in the spam filter or if you would like flair. Messages should contain your cranial dimensions and verification of teutonic or alpine heritage. Flair recipients should have at least a bachelor's level education in a made-up, historically superseded, or otherwise discredited field or school of thought.

Original research is encouraged. An answer unquestioned is a fact; a question without an answer is philosophy.


Rules Norms

  1. Answers should not consist of "facts", whatever you think those are. Bourgeois pig.

  2. If you see submissions in /shittyaskscience that deal with social issues, please repost them here. Replication Plaigirism is essential to science.


You might also enjoy:

. .
shittypolitics shittydebatecommunism
shittyconspiracy shittyideasforadmins
askpolitburo Putin2012
scoreball outside
fieldnipples spacedocks
treessuckingatthings treessuckingonthings

/r/shittysocialscience

2,921 Subscribers

4

"Ordinary Men" and the Sociology of War Crimes: Unveiling the Dark Side of Social Conformity in WWII

I've been engrossed in the powerful book "Ordinary Men" by historian Christopher Browning. This profound historical investigation unravels the perplexing social dynamics of war crimes committed by seemingly 'average' individuals during the tumultuous era of World War II.

For an in-depth analysis of this social-historical study, you can check out the link in my bio. However, I've extracted and synthesized the main findings and thoughts below for a more digestible discussion.

Why this social-historical study captivates:

Christopher R. Browning, a well-established scholar in Holocaust and WWII war crimes history, undertakes a significant sociological exploration.

The rigorous research methodology applied, illustrating the interplay between individual agency and social structure (explained further below).

The book's core proposition that 'ordinary' individuals can metamorphose into war crime perpetrators under specific societal circumstances is a fascinating revelation about the sociological dimensions of human morality, behavior, and accountability during conflict.

Peering into the methodology:

Browning delves into the social dynamics of the Reserve Police Battalion 101 from Hamburg, a group of about 500 men deemed too old for regular military service during WWII.

Through an exhaustive study of their testimonials and reports, Browning paints a chilling picture of their actions and motives during the Holocaust, through the lens of social structure and agency.

Browning's candid outlining of his methodology and data references lends robust credibility to his unsettling conclusions.

Key findings from a sociological perspective:

The battalion members were mostly not zealous Nazis but ordinary middle-aged workers.

These 'ordinary men' chose to partake in executing horrific acts voluntarily, highlighting a disturbing absence of coercion and underlining the impact of social pressure and conformity in committing war crimes.

Contrary to Daniel Goldhagen's thesis in "Hitler's Willing Executioners," Browning's work posits that inherent anti-Semitic sentiment among 'ordinary' Germans was not the only social force behind the Holocaust.

Sociological significance:

This socio-historical study compels us to rethink our traditional sociological understanding of 'normalcy' and 'deviance,' prompting us to reevaluate our potential for brutality under certain social circumstances.

It accentuates the power of authority, societal norms, and the anonymity provided by war in shaping human actions, shedding light on the grim reality of war crimes as a sociological phenomenon.

It encourages us to ponder on proactive measures that can be incorporated into our social fabric to uphold our ethical boundaries and prevent such atrocities in future conflicts.

I'd love to hear your perspective:

How do you believe social influences would have affected your behavior in similar circumstances? Why?

As a society, how can we shield ourselves from the potential for such horrendous acts?

P.S. If this type of sociological analysis fascinates you, I regularly post comprehensive studies like this one on my YouTube channel, linked at the beginning of this post. I also produce documentaries on critical issues like the Holodomor. These videos aim to delve into the profound questions and implications of the phrase "In filth it will be found".

1 Comment
2023/06/28
17:02 UTC

0

Is the opposite of “Woke”, MAGA?

2 Comments
2023/04/03
01:03 UTC

1

Is everybody everybody's equal?

The most people think, that everybody is worth the same. This is found Fundamental for a democracy.

But is this right? If everybody is the same, why are some people born with more talent than other?

If everybody is equal, why is my time less or more worth than others? Because i have a better of worse study, but isn't this inequality too? Some can visit a better University and can have a better Job only because they have the right basic condition wich you are born with?

Doesn't this mean, that with your birth, your future and your life is already set up to a limit? If you doesn't have enough hight, you can't become a pro Basketball player. If you doesn't have enough money, you can't study on a good University. In booth scenarios you can't increase your wealth, only because you are born wrong.

Doesn't thees all arguments say that not everybody has the same chances than others and that the equality is a lie?

3 Comments
2023/02/17
19:26 UTC

5

If Bernie Sanders gets elected, will he overthrow and replace himself with a far-right dictator?

1 Comment
2020/02/28
03:41 UTC

0 Comments
2020/02/12
12:54 UTC

7

Why do people is Europe drive on the wrong side of the road rather than the right side?

4 Comments
2018/12/20
21:57 UTC

7

Would replacing Mike Pence with an Ivanka Trump blow-up doll shake up the White House?

Que?

0 Comments
2018/12/14
01:54 UTC

6

Serious question about masturbation

At what frequency does the average person masturbate? And, given that, if you were to randomly select a human at a random day/time, what are the odds they would happen to be "taking the self-guided tour"? Please cite your sources and show any math.

2 Comments
2018/12/05
14:11 UTC

7

What are the factors that have lead to the gentrification of Sesame Street

4 Comments
2018/10/27
15:01 UTC

8

What if I want to be a slave?

7 Comments
2018/09/12
02:12 UTC

5

Why do Puerto Rican people eat apples? If I eat an apple, am I become Puerto Rican? Do apples only keep Puerto Rican doctors away? What kind of apples?

3 Comments
2018/05/05
02:46 UTC

5

Is evo psych a widely accepted form of science? Is it the consensus?

11 Comments
2018/03/07
03:16 UTC

8

How could Aung San Suu Kyi have masterminded the genocide of Rohingya Muslims? She's Buddhist. Aren't Buddhists are supposed to be peaceful and shit?

6 Comments
2018/03/07
02:46 UTC

2

Why are school shooters so unpopular? Isn't it better for national education to have something that shoots out schools?

Like, boom, school here, school there, schools everywhere!

1 Comment
2018/02/28
02:38 UTC

7

How did Norway achieve a population of 100% Olympic athletes?

3 Comments
2018/02/26
06:46 UTC

9

Why didn't President Clinton invoke the Insurrection Act when Star Trek: Insurrection came out?

1 Comment
2017/12/11
02:11 UTC

4

Why doesn't the government send out Captain Price to take out ISIS?

0 Comments
2017/10/24
00:04 UTC

14

Is it still gay to have sex with a man but while closing your eyes and pretending it's a woman?

Asking for a friend btw

6 Comments
2017/09/16
05:44 UTC

11

How do I find out if something dated 8/8 is August 8th or the 8th of August?

0 Comments
2017/08/06
01:35 UTC

3

Why don't the Triads kill people using five thunderbolts if they're mentioned so much in the 36 Oaths?

0 Comments
2017/08/05
03:35 UTC

19

If global warming isn't real then why did Club Penguin shut down?

3 Comments
2017/06/23
05:03 UTC

8

What government permits are required to construct a reality?

3 Comments
2017/06/14
13:27 UTC

3

Why does North Korea's national soccer team have left wingers on the team when the country is right wing?

1 Comment
2017/06/13
22:52 UTC

0 Comments
2017/06/06
09:33 UTC

14

Why does the West Marlboro Baptist Church hate fag so much if they are named after a cigarette company?

2 Comments
2017/05/28
04:18 UTC

16

Why don't poor people just take a small loan of $1,000,000 from their father?

2 Comments
2017/05/27
01:34 UTC

4

Why hasn't ZZ Top used their teleporting powers for anything greater than music videos?

1 Comment
2017/05/20
11:54 UTC

3

Governments around the world publish official poverty lines. Where can I find the official wealth lines?

1 Comment
2017/05/06
01:13 UTC

9

Why are all Spanish songs so gay?

3 Comments
2017/04/05
14:52 UTC

Back To Top