*** Please read the sub rules located on the sidebar ***

******************************

KEY OFFSEASON DATES:

• 9-Feb Super Bowl LIX (Caesars Superdome, New Orleans, Louisiana)
• 18-Feb Clubs may designate Franchise or Transition Players. Ends Mar. 4
• 24-Feb NFL Scouting Combine (Lucas Oil Stadium, Indianapolis, Indiana). Ends Mar. 3.
• 10-Mar Negotiation Period. No contracts official until...
• 12-Mar The 2025 League Year and Trades/Free Agency signing period begin at 4:00 p.m.
• April 24-26 NFL Draft, Green Bay, Wisconsin. Giants pick 3rd in the first round.
• Other key dates

******************************

Check the pinned, weekly Mock Draft Mega-Thread early and often. Folks post new mocks (almost) daily.

******************************

What would you like to discuss today?

It is Monday and that means the mock draft thread resets and you can post your new mock drafts to you heart's content. Please indicate if your mock is what you think SHOULD happen or if it what you think WILL happen.

Mock drafts outside of this thread or the r/nygiants Daily will get removed.

Resources: https://www.profootballnetwork.com/mockdraft https://pff.nfl.com/ https://fanspeak.com/ontheclock-nfl-mock-draft-simulator/index.php https://thedraftnetwork.com/

Bought this for 5 dollars at a local flea market and was wondering if I came out with a steal?

I combined the round 1 QBs from 2024 with the projected round 1 QBs in the 2025 class. The first thing you'll notice is that there were twice the amount of Rd.1 QB prospects in last year's class. But where I was personally surprised was that when you compare the class averages for their experience and production, there isn't really a gap in experience or on-field production, compared to the negative portrayal of consensus QB grades this year. The biggest gap is that you saw more QBs with great to elite traits last year. For example, Jayden Daniels has elite rushing ability, and Daniels/Maye/Penix have great-to-elite arm talent. Cam Ward has a great arm, but Shedeur and Dart have average-to-good NFL arms rather than great-to-elite. However, I think its important to remember that the greatest QB of all time didn't have elite arm talent or mobility. The 2025 QBs are more experienced on average with more games played and more career attempts. The 2025 class average PFF grade and passer rating are almost identical to the 2024 class. Their yards per game is greater and TDs per game are about equal. Completion rate and big time throw rate are about equal and yards per attempt is actually greater for the 2025 class. Essentially, there isn't a drop-off in experience level or production, so despite the 2025 QB class having less elite traits, they have been equally impressive on the field which is indicative of their skill level. While there are less round 1 caliber QBs in 2025, the prospects are still good to great prospects and round 1 caliber QBs.

https://preview.redd.it/xytw8qk52rge1.png?width=1181&format=png&auto=webp&s=621bdc2783dac3962dd167aec9ac98275de27b25

I don’t generally follow draft prospects closely, so maybe I’m missing something. Looking at CU’s record this past season, they didn’t seem to play anyone difficult and when they played BYU, Sanders couldn’t even keep them competitive. Seems to me like the criticism of Dart not showing up against legit teams should be applied to Sanders.

Edit: I appreciate all the responses. After further review, it’s unlikely to matter who we draft as we are the Giants and will likely continue to suck until further notice.

*** Please read the sub rules located on the sidebar ***

******************************

KEY OFFSEASON DATES:

• 9-Feb Super Bowl LIX (Caesars Superdome, New Orleans, Louisiana)
• 18-Feb Clubs may designate Franchise or Transition Players. Ends Mar. 4
• 24-Feb NFL Scouting Combine (Lucas Oil Stadium, Indianapolis, Indiana). Ends Mar. 3.
• 10-Mar Negotiation Period. No contracts official until...
• 12-Mar The 2025 League Year and Trades/Free Agency signing period begin at 4:00 p.m.
• April 24-26 NFL Draft, Green Bay, Wisconsin. Giants pick 3rd in the first round.
• Other key dates

******************************

Check the pinned, weekly Mock Draft Mega-Thread early and often. Folks post new mocks (almost) daily.

******************************

What would you like to discuss today?

I think spending the 3rd pick on QB is a huge mistake.

I liked Milton as a prospect last year, and thought he would be picked earlier than the 6th round.

How would he compare to this year's prospects?

Would a 4th round pick be reasonable for Milton considering he was a later draft pick?

Sanders has elite level pocket presence and mobility within the pocket but really lacks quick twitch throws and rapid decision making. He needs a line that can buy him time. He needs a team purpose built around him to succeed. I don't see him going to any organization and making huge changes for them, they need to change to make him successful. Giants are ill-equipped for Sanders right now and I see him getting lit up. I could see this go the way of Bryce Young losing all confidence in himself. Cam Ward is an easy #1, and honestly think Jaxon Dart is a straight baller that could suit the Giants well.

https://youtu.be/1MR7zfH4YvU?si=mJsHQlk4kLuex7sP

*** Please read the sub rules located on the sidebar ***

******************************

KEY OFFSEASON DATES:

• 9-Feb Super Bowl LIX (Caesars Superdome, New Orleans, Louisiana)
• 18-Feb Clubs may designate Franchise or Transition Players. Ends Mar. 4
• 24-Feb NFL Scouting Combine (Lucas Oil Stadium, Indianapolis, Indiana). Ends Mar. 3.
• 10-Mar Negotiation Period. No contracts official until...
• 12-Mar The 2025 League Year and Trades/Free Agency signing period begin at 4:00 p.m.
• April 24-26 NFL Draft, Green Bay, Wisconsin. Giants pick 3rd in the first round.
• Other key dates

******************************

Check the pinned, weekly Mock Draft Mega-Thread early and often. Folks post new mocks (almost) daily.

******************************

What would you like to discuss today?

*** Please read the sub rules located on the sidebar ***

******************************

KEY OFFSEASON DATES:

• 9-Feb Super Bowl LIX (Caesars Superdome, New Orleans, Louisiana)
• 18-Feb Clubs may designate Franchise or Transition Players. Ends Mar. 4
• 24-Feb NFL Scouting Combine (Lucas Oil Stadium, Indianapolis, Indiana). Ends Mar. 3.
• 10-Mar Negotiation Period. No contracts official until...
• 12-Mar The 2025 League Year and Trades/Free Agency signing period begin at 4:00 p.m.
• April 24-26 NFL Draft, Green Bay, Wisconsin. Giants pick 3rd in the first round.
• Other key dates

******************************

Check the pinned, weekly Mock Draft Mega-Thread early and often. Folks post new mocks (almost) daily.

******************************

What would you like to discuss today?

• Eagles get up big in first half

• Saquan has two monster runs for TDs

• Eagles victory seems inevitable

• A costly turnover gives Chiefs hope

• Mahommes things ensue

• Costly 4th down penalty keeps late drive alive

• Chiefs force overtime

• Eagles get possession first

• Eagles score, decide to run Philly Special for 2 pt conversion to no success

• Chiefs do Chief things in score in short fashion on bomb to Travis Kelce

• Questionably misogynist man makes game winning XP

• Chiefs celebrate history

• Cameras cut to T-Swift hugging Britney before they leave to join their loved ones on the field

• Travis hugs Taylor

• Travis and Taylor get interviewed in a seemingly coordinated fashion

• Travis gets on one Knee

• Taylor is in tears

• But Not Happy Tears

• Taylor admits that Travis is not the love of her life

• Taylor begins making out with Andy Reid

• Chaos ensues

• Mahommes comforts hurt friend

• Super Bowl Aftermath is less than celebratory

• Mahommes decides he cannot play under Andy Reid

• Mahommes demands a trade with Kelce as a package deal

• T-Swift releases secret album "Reiding Between the Lines"

• OP learns Mahomes is spelt with one M after the O

• Mahomes decides to go somewhere with promising young WR talent

• Giants trade for Mahomes and Kelce

• Giants draft Travis Hunter

• Giants come into league with the highest expectations in years

• Giants go 17-0

• Giants Win 2026 Super Bowl

I know it's unlikely but I think we can all agree this is the best case scenario.