/r/muacjdiscussion

Photograph via snooOG

As /r/circlebroke puts it: circlejerk without the satire. This is where you can complain about trends in makeup or on MUA, talk about anything makeup related, have casual conversations... really anything so long as you follow some rules below.

Yes we are bitter people.

Anyone is welcome.

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)


Rules:

  1. All posts must encourage discussion. Simple questions/topics should be kept to our daily recurring stickied threads. Refer to the Wiki for further explanation about this rule.

  2. Play nicely with each other. Keep things civil. Absolutely no racism or sexism or overall bigotry will be tolerated here.

  3. Follow reddit rules. No personal information, no self promotion. Please follow reddiquette and the content policy.

If you see anything suspicious/weird/rule breaking, report it and/or send a message to the mods.


We have a few recurring threads that you can jump into if you like.

Weekly Threads:

  • Miscellaneous Monday - For discussion of nail polish, bath/body, hair care and styling, etc.

  • Temper Tantrum Tuesday (y u so mad tho) - Rant about allll the things.

  • Wish List // What I'm Not Gonna Buy - Wednesdays. Tell us what you're hankering for and we'll talk you into or out of it. Get reviews on wish list items. Talk about your anti-hauls.

  • Request a Review Thursday - Interested in a new product? Come on in and ask your fellow makeup lovers for their thoughts!

  • Friday Free Talk - Settle in for a chat about whatever.

  • Faves and Fails Friday - A reviews thread! Tell us about the moisturizer that made you break out, or the setting spray that finally keeps your oils at bay.

  • Simple Questions Saturday - Questions! Simple ones! On Saturdays! Ask them, answer them, or just read through them. When it comes down to it, are we REALLY the boss of you? (Please use our guidelines when requesting help identifying undertones and face/eye shape and constructive criticism.)

  • Suggest a Product Sunday - Need a new mascara that won't smudge? Searching for the fullest-coverage concealer known to man? Ask away!

  • Skincare Sunday - Feel free to talk about your skincare regimen, new products you've been loving, pretty much anything skincare related!

. . .

Biweekly Threads:

  • Tips and Tricks Tuesday - Share new tricks you learned to take your makeup to the next level!

  • Keeping It Real - Every other Saturday. Maintaining a sense of realism in makeup by discussing the "imperfect" side of beauty.

. . .

Monthly Threads:

  • End Of Month Overview - Hauls, empties, epiphanies, insights, tears, laughter, and maybe even a celebrity guest or two. Probably not though so don't get your hopes up.

Take a gander at our Subreddit Resources:

  • The Devil Is In The Details - The how, when, why, and what of application, technique, products, and what have you in a thirteen part post series.

  • HG Products Lists - MUACJD ApprovedTM products and tools across all price points and categories, very neatly compiled.


We have an official channel on Snoonet! Use this for instant messaging with your MUACJD peers.

Link here.

Plenty of information is available on /r/snoonet for further help on working the IRC/Snoonet system.

Same rules for this sub apply on the channel.


Sister Subreddits:

If you're a mod and would like to put your sub up to be one of our sister subreddits, hit us up!


Somewhat Related Subreddits, aka The Beautysphere:

/r/muacjdiscussion

92,206 Subscribers

1

Request a Review Thursday

Thinking of splurging on a new product but not sure how it performs? Having trouble finding reliable reviews on Youtube?

Ask others who may have the product to write a quick review for you!

If you'd like to provide a review, please reply to the requester's comment with your thoughts!

0 Comments
2024/10/31
04:00 UTC

1

End Of Month Overview

It's time for our monthly review of the things we bought, passed over, finished, rediscovered, loved, or hated this month!

0 Comments
2024/10/31
04:00 UTC

18

What are your HGs from Chanel/Dior/Guerlain?

Been having a rough couple of weeks and I really want to treat myself. Can be anything; skincare, makeup, fragrances. I'm game for anything. TIA!!

15 Comments
2024/10/31
00:24 UTC

12

Wish List // What I'm Not Gonna Buy (Wednesday)

  • Tell us what's on your wish list and why.
  • Tell us what you're not gonna buy... and why.
  • Ask for a TMO/TMI (talk me out/talk me into) things on your wish list if you need some outside opinions. Be sure to give us reference information to help us help you!
  • Request opinions, reviews, swatches, on wish list items to help you do your research.
  • Discuss upcoming releases - purchase or pass?
  • Anything else that's related!
16 Comments
2024/10/30
04:00 UTC

4

Temper Tantrum Tuesday

Post all the rants here!

2 Comments
2024/10/29
04:00 UTC

44

Downsizing your makeup collection; what and why?

Makeup is a form of expressing ourselves in many forms and everyone has a different perspective of what «art» is. With internet there’s access to Instagram, Tik-Tok, YouTube etc. and the power of influencing and marketing can make us intentionally or not to buy a lot of things either because we want to, need to and many other reasons. Well, sometimes things can go a bit overboard if we’re not careful. If there’s a thought that you want to downsize your makeup collection, what category (or categories) would you like to downsize and why?

I’ll go first; Ideally, I would like to downsize my lipstick collection because from when I was a teenager, I had (and still do) a weakness for lip products. I like variety but I don’t need every single one that belongs on the market haha. Also, eyeshadow palettes; I have 4 but my goal is 2 because I don’t use it very often and it’s not necessary to have that many!

38 Comments
2024/10/28
21:02 UTC

6

Miscellaneous Monday: Anything beauty-related! Skincare, nail polish, bath/body, hair care and styling, fragrance, etc

Review products, rant and rave, ask for and give advice - go where your soul takes you!

7 Comments
2024/10/28
04:00 UTC

4

Skincare Sunday

Welcome to our alliterative and regularly reoccurring thread for discussing all things skincare!

Suggestions for relevant and educational activities:

  • Venting about a trend in one of the skincare subs.
  • Sharing research or information on products or ingredients.
  • Asking for or giving advice on products, routines, or non medical skin issues.
  • Ranting and raving about skincare items you've been experimenting with.
  • Shouting "Fuck this" or "Hallelujah" about the current state of your skin.

Don't forget to share any relevant info about your skin type if you're sharing your experiences with a product, and if you're asking for advice or recommendations please include your budget and general location so we can give you better help.

17 Comments
2024/10/27
04:00 UTC

4

Suggest a Product Sunday

Finally a place for all those product-related threads! Need a new full-coverage foundation? Can't find a mascara that doesn't give you raccoon eyes? Ask for product reccs here!

0 Comments
2024/10/27
04:00 UTC

27

Disposable spoolies suck!

Spoolies suck, at least the ones I can get here, even when I use good quality mascaras I always get mediocre results because of ugly disposable spoolies. Since I don't know what to do, especially when I have occasional clients like film extras, etc. I always ask to bring their personal mascaras or use a cake mascara (but still, I get poor results in this case). What should I do with important clients instead?

17 Comments
2024/10/26
15:42 UTC

11

Keeping It Real

After an excellent recent post from /u/5Gs-Plz , you guys wanted to have a regular space for, as the OP put it, maintaining a sense of realism about makeup. In their post they asked:

We never see end of day photos of makeup and it is very difficult to feel positive about how makeup breaks down during the course of a day. I was thinking maybe we could dedicate this post to photographs of how our makeup looks at the end of a long day? I would be curious to see how it wears.

Does your mascara flake? Does your foundation disappear around your nose? Or does your eyeliner smudge?

You can certainly share photos and talk about your end of day faces, and it'd also be cool to talk about other aspects of cosmetics and beauty in general that we don't see/hear a lot about, which is when things aren't perfect.

0 Comments
2024/10/26
15:00 UTC

9

Benefit Powderflage - any dupes?

Does anyone remember Benefit Powderflage, the undereye powder? This product was my holy Grail for setting my concealer, and I haven’t been able to find anything like it since they discontinued it. If anyone has any recommendations, I would love some. 😊

1 Comment
2024/10/26
04:19 UTC

3

Simple Questions Saturday

Could be about products, trends, techniques, etc. Ask! Answer!

0 Comments
2024/10/26
04:00 UTC

13

Faves and Fails Friday

Found your new HG lipstick formula? Tried a moisturizer that broke you out? Rant and rave about your best and worst products of the week!

8 Comments
2024/10/25
04:00 UTC

3

Friday Free Talk!

Hi :)

1 Comment
2024/10/25
04:00 UTC

70

Is there any items you regret decluttering?

Hey all! Curious subject today... Is there any items you regret decluttering? Either because the item ended up discontinued and you realized you actually liked it and only got rid of it because you wanted to try something new, and now can't re-buy it? Or maybe you bought backups and sold them because you thought it was silly to have on hand, but now realize you would actually need/use it?

I used to have a backup of one of my favorite Nars eyeshadows, Kari, and sold it. I feel like such an idiot lol it's one of the few pinky mauve shades which doesn't turn orange on me, and I actually love using it as a blush and eyeshadow for a nice monochromatic look. I still own the one I currently use but with the pan getting more and more of a dip I'm really starting to regret getting rid of my backup. And figures, my other favorite eyeshadow is Nars Himalia which has a similar dip forming in the pan and it's the PERFECT brown for me for a one and done eyeshadow look. I wish Nars never got rid of their dual intensity formula, it's really the best and honestly cant find anything that compares.

44 Comments
2024/10/24
13:55 UTC

3

Under eye bags cover up help

I’m returning back to work in a few days. As FTM needless to say the bags under my eyes are definitely there. I work as a hair stylist and the lights in my salon are very bright, it shows everything which is great for doing hair but not so much when trying to figure out the right makeup routine/ under eye coverage. Does anyone have any tips or can share what products works for them?? I do drink a ton of water and stay very hydrated as much as possible considering EBF/pumping for daycare purposes.

2 Comments
2024/10/24
08:49 UTC

9

Request a Review Thursday

Thinking of splurging on a new product but not sure how it performs? Having trouble finding reliable reviews on Youtube?

Ask others who may have the product to write a quick review for you!

If you'd like to provide a review, please reply to the requester's comment with your thoughts!

22 Comments
2024/10/24
04:00 UTC

5

Quality of Hourglass mini ambient lighting powders versus full size?

Does anyone know if the quality or performance is weaker on the mini sizes? The mini size seems like it would be plenty enough for me, but I'd shell out for a full size if there was difference in quality

7 Comments
2024/10/23
14:25 UTC

6

Wish List // What I'm Not Gonna Buy (Wednesday)

  • Tell us what's on your wish list and why.
  • Tell us what you're not gonna buy... and why.
  • Ask for a TMO/TMI (talk me out/talk me into) things on your wish list if you need some outside opinions. Be sure to give us reference information to help us help you!
  • Request opinions, reviews, swatches, on wish list items to help you do your research.
  • Discuss upcoming releases - purchase or pass?
  • Anything else that's related!
6 Comments
2024/10/23
04:00 UTC

68

now that it’s almost the end of october, what have been your favorite fall lip products?

i love a moodier lip for the fall time in all types of colors: reds, browns, and berries. (dark lips for fall? groundbreaking). here are my favorites:

  • revlon rum raisin and raisin rage: such cult classic lipsticks for a reason. rum raisin is more of a everyday color for me while raisin rage is a bit more bold and red but still muted and vampy. super moisturizing and comfy on the lips. some days i put these on bold and other days i blot the color a bit

  • clinique black honey lip oil: more pigment than the lipstick, thin formula and hydrating on the lips. not sticky at all

  • kulfi lassi lips in tamarind- such a gorgeous glossy lip stain. the stain is super pretty and brown and isn’t patchy

  • morphe trendsetter liner with a clear gloss: super pretty deep brown comfortable lip liner

54 Comments
2024/10/23
00:22 UTC

8

Temper Tantrum Tuesday

Post all the rants here!

10 Comments
2024/10/22
04:00 UTC

34

Pouring one out for another discontinuation

I don’t know if I just have really bad taste or what, but my current foundation obsession appears to be being discontinued.

It’s the L’Oreal Age Perfect Balm. When it went on sale recently I managed to get a decent stockpile of my shade (fair 20), but it’s such a bummer.

I just went through this with the Believe foundation from Dollar General, but I love the Age Perfect even more. It’s super travel friendly, and such a perfect match and my dry skin just loves it.

I think this would’ve been huge if it wasn’t marketed for anti-aging.

3 Comments
2024/10/21
22:27 UTC

46

What concealers are we all loving at the moment for our under eyes and blemishes?

55 Comments
2024/10/21
12:59 UTC

29

What are some of your favourite resources for learning about make-up throughout history

I just found this playlist on the English Heritage YouTube that looks super interesting

Where else can I go to learn about make-up in different time periods, countries etc?

7 Comments
2024/10/21
10:59 UTC

3

Miscellaneous Monday: Anything beauty-related! Skincare, nail polish, bath/body, hair care and styling, fragrance, etc

Review products, rant and rave, ask for and give advice - go where your soul takes you!

8 Comments
2024/10/21
04:00 UTC

5

Skincare Sunday

Welcome to our alliterative and regularly reoccurring thread for discussing all things skincare!

Suggestions for relevant and educational activities:

  • Venting about a trend in one of the skincare subs.
  • Sharing research or information on products or ingredients.
  • Asking for or giving advice on products, routines, or non medical skin issues.
  • Ranting and raving about skincare items you've been experimenting with.
  • Shouting "Fuck this" or "Hallelujah" about the current state of your skin.

Don't forget to share any relevant info about your skin type if you're sharing your experiences with a product, and if you're asking for advice or recommendations please include your budget and general location so we can give you better help.

0 Comments
2024/10/20
04:00 UTC

6

Suggest a Product Sunday

Finally a place for all those product-related threads! Need a new full-coverage foundation? Can't find a mascara that doesn't give you raccoon eyes? Ask for product reccs here!

0 Comments
2024/10/20
04:00 UTC

85

I'm a little fascinated by how similar the new Kiko Milano eyeshadow quints look to the Pat McGrath ones

Kiko here, PMG examples here and here.

Thoughts? Not the shades obviously - the packaging and the look of the formulas.

Kiko EUR 26.99 (about USD $30), PMG USD $38. The Kiko ones are made in Italy. I couldn't see 'made in' info on the PMG website 🙄, but I do own one of the earlier quints (Bronze Bliss) and it was made in Italy.

Anyway, I am guessing that they were made in the same factory. I would love to know how similar the formulas are. Unfortunately the colours are not for me... otherwise I would probably perform the rituals and sacrifices needed to get Kiko in my country so I could compare them for science 🤭

Edit: No ritual sacrifices necessary! Looks like an intrepid European youtuber named BoB has filmed a comparison. I'm watching now but the tl;dr seems to be the formula is the same.

34 Comments
2024/10/19
15:06 UTC

4

Simple Questions Saturday

Could be about products, trends, techniques, etc. Ask! Answer!

3 Comments
2024/10/19
04:00 UTC

Back To Top