/r/freefolk

Photograph via //r/freefolk

/r/FreeFolk is a wide open and lightly subreddit to talk about anything related to GRRM's "Game of Thrones" universe.

We are open again for user feedback before we decide on the next stage of this subreddit.

This is a wide open and minimally moderated subreddit to talk about the Game of Thrones/ASOIAF spoilers, leaks, books, and shows. (About Us)


General Rules

  • SAY ANYTHING YOU WANT

  • DO NOT KNEEL


Community Voted Rules

Rules added or removed by annual community vote. Expanded rule examples can be found here.

  1. No reposts

  2. No karma bots/whoring

  3. No politics

  4. No slurs based on race, sexuality, etc

  5. No complaining about spoilers

  6. No non-GoT/ASOIAF posts


Thenn Thursdays

Have you gotten new merch or created something inspired by GoT/ASOIAF? Share it in the weekly Thenn Thursday thread!

Do you have a subreddit, discord, YouTube channel, ect. That you want to promote? Please message the moderators beforehand and make sure it's ok. Otherwise your post will be removed and you may be banned from posting again.


SPOILERS/LEAKS EVERYWHERE

We do not deliberately spoil other people, but we do not hide ourselves away either. Decisions to stay on /r/all, or our community rules, are voted directly on by the community. See the June 2019 vote.

r/Freefolk neither encourages nor discourages piracy. We take action to enforce Reddit's sitewide rules and those voted upon by the community. We believe people are mature enough to decide for themselves when, how, and what content to view.


THREADS PEOPLE LOOK FOR

"Remake Season 8" Petition

SameYou Fundraiser for Emilia

Mencap Fundraiser for Kit

Season 8 News and Leaks


FREEFOLK IN THE MEDIA

BBC: Emilia Clarke thanks Game of Thrones fans for fundraiser

Newsweek: How ‘Game of Thrones’ Leaks Happen: Reddit’s Freefolk Mods Outline the Life of a Spoiler

WSJ: ‘Game of Thrones’ Spoiler Alert: A Spanish Doctor Will Tell You How It Ends (fookin' paywall)

Gizmodo: Game of Thrones Petition to Remake Season 8 Reaches a Million Signatures


INTERACT

Freefolk Discord Server
@RedditFreeFolk on Twitter


ALLIES


/r/freefolk

1,241,335 Subscribers

0

Aenys Targaryen had bastards retcon?

So, I was going through my first edition of GOT and Aenys had bastards?

Yeah their names were Penus Waters who tried to claim balerion and got roasted

Waginuh Snow- married Gilbert Bolton

Uretheron the blind dragon- was born blind and became a knight

Ovaris Storm- drowned in the shipbreaker bay

2 Comments
2024/11/09
18:30 UTC

45

Savage Varys.

1 Comment
2024/11/09
17:57 UTC

4

This show would have been paced better if they did the ten year time jump between seasons 1 and 2.

It goes without saying that house of the dragon has a massive pacing issue with some episodes dragging on and others happening after several year time skips.

The ten year time jump was jarring to say the least for people who didn't expect it and I feel like it wasn't necessary. Milly was very popular as Rhaenyra and Emily was very popular as Allicent, those actors could have carried the whole season. And we would have had the time to explore more relationships that are severely underdeveloped as it stands now. Like maybe we could have gotten a scene where Rhaenyra actually has a conversation or interaction with any of her siblings, imagine that - in a story about a family feud.

And then in season two that allows us to have more time with the new characters like Rhaenyra and Daemon's children, who are barely existent as it stands now and have no personality apart from emotional support mule or emotional wreck. Plus you wouldn't have to age down the younger kids if you put a short time jump in the middle of season two. Characters like Aegon 2 and Viserys 2 are toddlers right now but in the book at this point they were fully talking children. Considering how important they are to the end of the story giving them characters would have been nice. Same with little Jaehearys and Jaeheara, if we actually saw them before blood and cheese and had an emotional attachment to them that scene would have hit like it needed to.

And the most important point for me, more dragons. If they limited the time skips they could have allocated that money to the dragon cgi budget and maybe possibly given us at least one scene where each dragon rider interacts with their dragon. Honestly that was my bare minimum requirement for the show and it couldn't even do that. We saw sunfyre once before he was mutalated and who knows where the hell dreamfyre is, just the second oldest dragon - not important I guess. If you can't afford to show the dragons why make a show about dragons? it's beyond me.

But I don't know I'm not a screenwriter or director so maybe I'm confused or missing something. Why were the time jumps mid season necessary, it's rushed the story too much and now they're slowing down too much to compensate. It's a whole mess now and makes me regret ever being excited for this show. What a waste of potential.

That's my opinion but I'd like to hear yours.

1 Comment
2024/11/09
17:53 UTC

0

why did syrax descend upon the mob

Why did Syrax descend upon the dragonpit mob? I know she was "well fed" and hadnt hunted in years. But surely dragons have some natural instincts, to use wings and fire in fight with non- dragons? was she perhaps searching for Joffrey? or was her bond with Rhaenyra flooding her with bloodlust?

9 Comments
2024/11/09
17:05 UTC

128

Liam Cunningham appreciation post. A beautiful human being.

8 Comments
2024/11/09
16:37 UTC

461

kudos to her but thats the most Westerosi name ever

24 Comments
2024/11/09
13:37 UTC

246

Margaery was playing with wildfire

24 Comments
2024/11/09
12:40 UTC

158

Average Wyman Manderly interaction in Dance

2 Comments
2024/11/09
12:22 UTC

1,011

Fans after 2 years of waiting

24 Comments
2024/11/09
00:51 UTC

950

Our What Should Have Been...

235 Comments
2024/11/08
23:19 UTC

0

So far a good show, why the hate?

Episode 5 and still interesting and a lot going on. Why does this show (or 2nd season) getting so much hate from the freefolk of Redditsteros?!?! WHAT SAY YOU!?

PD: Talking about House of the Dragon. Everyone knows GoT was good until it catched up with the books.

14 Comments
2024/11/08
21:53 UTC

1,129

Poor oberyn

M

13 Comments
2024/11/08
18:35 UTC

6

watched this scene stoned and started crying because i was afraid her scrotum neck was going to touch me

0 Comments
2024/11/08
16:32 UTC

4,560

I swear, Jorah must have fished out a different dwarf...

110 Comments
2024/11/08
15:50 UTC

1,040

My guy had no idea how right he was.

20 Comments
2024/11/08
12:54 UTC

8

I forgot how much the stark genius shines through in the first book

Under the heavy weight of her furs, Catelyn shivered. "A lens is an instrument to help us see."

"Don't play the fool. Stannis and Renly are one thing, and Eddard Stark is quite another. Robert will listen to Stark. Damn them both. I should have insisted that he name you, but I was certain Stark would refuse him."… They were talking about Father, Bran realized.

0 Comments
2024/11/08
12:31 UTC

51

Ned not trusting his wife with truth about Jon

I finally decided to rewatch for the first time since season 8 aired.

Maybe it’s explained in the books, but why did Ned not trust his wife with who Jon really is? I’m pretty confident she would play whatever part he wanted her to in order to conceal his identity.

Why would he choose to instead have his wife think he cheated on her and subject Jon to a lifetime of resentment from her?

65 Comments
2024/11/08
03:51 UTC

2

Tyrion Should Have Joined Up With The Wildlings, And If They Didn’t Accept Him, The Whitewalkers

Tyrion was destroyed morality, spiritually and his dignity tarnished for a crime he didn’t commit. His love interest betrayed him, his entire family hated him even though he was the best of Tywin’s children and his morality was beyond everyone else’s. He constantly used his mind to help those around him without any thanks or for any rewards. The inhabitants of Westeros not only are nothing but backbiting savages but bit Tyrion, one of the best hands the ever fed them (pun intended as he was hand of the king). And this isn’t even bringing up the fact Tywin killed his first wife, dooming him to misery for the rest of his life.

If I were Tyrion after that brutal verbal beat down Shae gave him in the form of implicating not only him but a teenage girl in the assassination of a royal asshole like Joffrey, I’d give up all my faith in humanity. Once Tyrion escaped, I wished he’d go to Mance Raider and dole out any useful information he could give him as well as all the gold and silver he had left at his disposal. And if not that then help the white walkers in any way he could. The world of GoT is shit and there’s no fixing it. Tyrion should have watched the world burn after he gave everything he could to its citizens.

Yeah, I know this is a bit unhinged but every episode of this series has been an hour long series of brutal murders, r@pe and genocide with the royals either contributing to the madness or failing to contain it. There’s no staving back all the horrid crap. If GRR Martin ever finishes the novel series he should have Tyrion giving the white walkers or wildlings the keys to the kingdom and drink wine as he watches the last of the land burn to a crisp. Honestly, people, I’d only feel sorry for Sam and Arya dying. #GoWhiteWalkers

13 Comments
2024/11/07
22:01 UTC

0

I'm sorry

2 Comments
2024/11/07
20:06 UTC

0

question about moon tea

So, i dont have the exact quote but it is mentioned that drinking the Moon Tea, Hoster Tully gave Lysa to abort Petry's child almost killed her and rendered her borderline infertile.

But we know Pycelle tells Cersei, "I grieve to say . . . Queen Margaery is no maiden. She has required me to make her moon tea, not once, but many times."

So, for Lysa drinking moontea once almost kills her but Margerys remains healthy despite drinking it repeatedly

9 Comments
2024/11/07
18:07 UTC

54

i forget how many magic moments book Cat has

When she gets the letter from Lysa she says ""There is grief in this message, Ned. I can feel it."" While, we know the letter was fake/a lie it was the harbringer of grief, and lead to Catelyn arresting Tyrion

"I prayed for it," she said dully. "He was my special boy. I went to the sept and prayed seven times to the seven faces of god that Ned would change his mind and leave him here with me. Sometimes prayers are answered." Her prayer got answered just in a horrid way

She alone the warning in the dead stag and direwolf they found

When the shadow kills Renly, she "feels" stannis' presence but Brienne did not

In COK she is praying in an abandoned sept and has visions of the seven interposed with faces of people she knew

7 Comments
2024/11/07
14:47 UTC

2,977

So much for Valyrian superiority

65 Comments
2024/11/07
14:27 UTC

388

Oh Tywin

39 Comments
2024/11/07
13:05 UTC

31

Let's talk about them TOXIC (hotd) 'Butterflies' GRRM was talking about.

I can speculate on a few, and I believe we've already seen manifestations/hints of some.

  1. Severed/corrupted parent-child bonds, which is something that NEVER happened in Fire and Blood. We saw Alicent betraying her 3 sons. And some have even gone ahead to predict that Alicent will be the one to poison Aegon in the end of the story. There were also rumors from 4Chan few months ago that Ryan and Sara were considering making Jace overthrow Rhaenyra temporarily with Corlys' help because they don't find her competent enough. Another grotesque rumor is that they had planned for Aemond to lust after his own MOTHER. We're all holding our breath, hoping Harrenhal doesn't traumatize us in season 3, because a writer has a mom-son kink that gave us the Daemon/Alyssa scene as some twisted form of foreshadowing bullshit they're contemplating rather than just adapting more important themes in grrm's STORY.
  2. Rhaenicent/Rhaenyra and Alicent become lovers rather than enemies. I don't think this needs explaining. It greatly reduces the stakes of the story and turns the leading women in this conflict into traitors against their own family members and idiots who could've ended the war before it started by just kissing and making up lmao.
  3. Exclusion of key characters: Nettles and Maelor's absence will cause a big imbalance, especially when you notice how shallow the replacements for these characters' arcs are. Rhaena is NOT an inspiring low born girl and Rickard Thorne dying defending Jaehaera, who will live anyways, just isn't as interesting and tragic.
  4. Tampering with asoiaf lore: First thing that comes to mind is how the dragons were handled in season 2 e.g how they're claimed, who they let claim them, where they live. The writers fucked up by being wishy washy and it might cost them ahead.
  5. Condensing the timeline: as a result some events have to be merged, especially battles e.g the writers could be forced to combine the battle of the Gullet with the taking of King's Landing, which is all too much if you ask me. Also, some characters that must exist don't (Maelor) and others that do are too young or too old (so we will never get Aegon iii escaping on Stormclooud, or him witnessing hismother be fed to Sunfyre). Do you see the problem?
  6. Man bad woman good agenda: Exhausting nonsense that turns female characters into boring, righteous players robbed of agency in the war, while giving all the action, agency and popularity to male characters. Let's not even talk about how the women have no role, apparently, in each other's misery. There's a joke circulating in the fandom that Helaena will just kill herself because of fulfilling the prophecy rather than being moved by a fresh triggering event (and grrm has already complained about this). Why? Duh! Because neither Rhaenyra nor Mysaria can play active roles in the death of another woman, didn't you know? These things just cheapen the womens' stories, on top of making them boring and annoying. I want to nuke this gender based morality out of this world so bad! But you can be SURE you will be seeing more of it in the coming seasons.
9 Comments
2024/11/07
09:06 UTC

0

Let's play a game

45 Comments
2024/11/07
07:53 UTC

Back To Top