/r/nycrail

Photograph via //r/nycrail

Passenger and freight rail and trains, including transit, in and related to New York City.

This subreddit is dedicated to rail transportation in and related to New York City, including transit, commuter, long distance and freight.

Questions are welcome.

We have a Discord server!

Posting & Commenting Rules

Rule 1: Be nice to others.

Ad hominems and personal attacks against other redditors will be removed.

Posts or comments disparaging people or groups on the basis of race, ethnicity, place of origin, religion, sexual orientation, sex or gender will be removed.

Posts or comments advocating for crimes against another person or group of people will be removed.

Rule 2: Posts should be about NYC-area rail.

Posts about other forms of NYC-area transportation are allowed as long as they have some relation to rail.

Links to content about rail transportation outside of the NYC region are allowed, but they must include a submission statement relating them to NYC-area rail.

Rule 3: Respect laws.

Posts or comments requesting or providing information about how to engage in illegal activity will be removed.

Rule 4: Keep posts high-quality and unique.

Double postings and news articles that don't add to previous conversations will be removed.

Poll posts are not allowed.

Low-effort posts with little interest or basis for discussion will be removed at the mods’ discretion.

Rule 5: Media posts must have a descriptive title.

All media posts (photos, videos, etc) must include a meaningful title and/or must be accompanied by a comment introducing the content explaining the significance of what is being posted.

All fantasy map image posts require a submission statement explaining the major changes or features of the map. If this is provided or already exists through a blog post, a link to said post is sufficient.

Repeat violations of the above rules may result in a temporary suspension.


/r/nycrail's public mod log


AMAs:

MTA subway track worker, March 2017

Tess Stahl, October 2016

Max Diamond, January 2016

Max Diamond, November 2015

Max Diamond, October 2015


Interested in holding an AMA, or want to make a subreddit suggestion? Feel free to contact us via modmail!


Resources:

The Absolute Beginner's Guide to the New York Subway

Dj Hammers videos on YouTube

Secrets of the Subway

vanshnookenraggen's NYC Subway Track Map


Related subreddits:

NYC-area:

/r/AskNYC

/r/newyorkcity

/r/NYC

/r/NYChistory

/r/nycbus

/r/OMNY

/r/nycmaps

Outside NYC-area:

/r/Subways

/r/trains

/r/transit

/r/TransitDiagrams

/r/nycrail

130,833 Subscribers

4

Jamaica Yard Isn't Maintaining Doors

I don't know how, but seemingly there's a perennial issue that I see on E, F, G and R trains where there's some kind of issue with the doors. It's bad, and I see some door issue multiple times a week on in-service trains.

Doors with a leaf that doesn't open, doors with a malfunctioning indicator light above the door that goes off randomly, doors where one leaf opens later than the other leaf in the pair, doors where the latch audibly cycles multiple times before the leaf opens.

The R-68s and R-46s out of CI and Concourse seemingly do better with door function than the 160s from Jamaica despite being significantly older.

From the outside, it seems like Jamaica's maintenance program is the only common factor here, and that the Jamaica maintenance procedure needs some kind of stand-down.

If there's some kind of inside baseball I'm missing here, I would love to hear it. Or if you're just wanting to commiserate, that's fine too.

2 Comments
2024/12/02
12:53 UTC

1

R train truth?

What is the REAL reason it runs every 10 minutes at rush hour?

1 Comment
2024/12/02
12:51 UTC

2

F Express Still Exist?

Haven’t seen my usual morning F express in about a week. Did they quietly do away with the whopping TWO morning F express trains?

3 Comments
2024/12/02
12:23 UTC

6

5 Train Drivers, (or Riders)

do yall agree that they could have done better with building this sharp ass curve?

4 Comments
2024/12/02
11:47 UTC

19

favorite subway station?

i’m gonna be in the city soon and i want to go to some interesting stops (or your favorite line). i live in CT so i don’t always have time to just go to different subway stops while im in new york but i’m open to going anywhere.

33 Comments
2024/12/02
04:23 UTC

25

all trains in 1 day in… 4-6 hours???

i was messing around creating a route to take all the subways in one day. i made a pretty good one and decided to use the mta schedules to see how long it would take and it came out at 4:03 minutes?? adding in up to a few hours that’s still only 6 hours, which seems really short from how long i’ve heard it taking in the past. where did i go wrong? what problems should i expect with this route? spreadsheet w/ stations and times

https://preview.redd.it/fme8milj7c4e1.jpg?width=2362&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e18517c014e6169edcb564c1b8b5af497f4cdad5

4 Comments
2024/12/02
01:22 UTC

0

Station Names in the NYC that need to be shortened

  1. Sutphin Blvd-Archer Av-JFK

Reason: JFK is 5 miles away from the station 2)Jamaica Center-Parsons/Archer Reason: Archer Av is already signified in the station before that Thats all lemme know if you know any others in the comments

24 Comments
2024/12/02
01:02 UTC

5

omny reader suddenly saying my card isn’t accepted.

so I have a transit benefit debit card from my employer that i’ve had set up in apple pay on both my phone and watch since july. starting about a week and a half ago, i’d get the “card not accepted” message on the omny reader whenever i’ve tried to tap my watch to pay. this has happened on both buses and at turnstiles for the subway. i saw some people on here recommend deleting the card from apple pay and then re-entering it, but i tried this and it only works once, maybe twice afterwards, and then goes right back to saying “card not accepted” when i try to use it again. i also can’t seem add the card to my account on omny’s website, possibly because of restrictions from the card’s distributor and only being able to use it with specific merchants. anyone else ever experience this?

4 Comments
2024/12/02
00:06 UTC

13

Why do the trains on the two subway divisions have different sets of doors?

So I know that A Division trains have three sets of doors per side per car, while B Division trains have four sets of doors per side per car. Why is that? Is it an homage to how the previous companies configured their cars (i.e., did the IRT run its trains with six sets of doors per car and did the BMT and IND run theirs with eight sets of doors per car?)?

16 Comments
2024/12/01
21:12 UTC

0

retiring R44/46 trains?

are they really retiring the R44/46 trains next year??

11 Comments
2024/12/01
20:25 UTC

0

Lost all my luggage in the subway

I boarded the E line and was on my way to the airtrain. I had 5 luggage pieces. Got into a nice sit and took 20mg of Melatonin.

Just as we arrived to the air train I jumped and left the subway. This is when I noticed I had left my entire luggage in the train.

What can I do?

7 Comments
2024/12/01
20:17 UTC

1

Is it feasible for the 7 train to run exp service west of 74 St without using the middle track?

8 Comments
2024/12/01
19:49 UTC

23

which train lines are hardest to drive on?

lover of trains w no technical knowledge whatsoever so pardon the q if i’m using wrong vocab - but which lines / stretches of lines (at which times?) are hardest for train crew to manage?

21 Comments
2024/12/01
19:34 UTC

185

2024 Holiday Foamer-fest has begun

8 Comments
2024/12/01
18:56 UTC

227

Forget the candy ladies

I would pay good money to have someone walk through the cars correcting bad behavior.

“Take that backpack off”, “move away from the doors” “put your headphones in”

Anyone?!?

49 Comments
2024/12/01
18:26 UTC

60

new bullet debut

📸 credits to fantherailsbc

7 Comments
2024/12/01
17:37 UTC

96

my favorite summer excursion from the sky! Rockaway extension of the A alongside Jamaica Bay Wildlife Refuge

a very lucky takeoff, with the train in the shot. it's a lovely place to visit by train, bike or plane.

3 Comments
2024/12/01
17:11 UTC

0

E train at WTC filled with homeless

So Thanksgiving, came back to NYC from Exchange Place at midnight. Went to the E train at World Trade.

First seven cars were filled with the homeless. One other family and my wife and I found one bench free. A homeless guy came from another car and deliberately sat across from us. Crushed a soda can, tossed it and stared at us all. We got off at Canal and waited for an A.

Now as to the platform. Three MTA employees just standing around and two cops on their phones.

I mean you could make the first cars only for paying customers and put a cop in that car. That one homeless guy wanted to do something so I put my hand in my coat pocket and made it look like I had something to deter him. He grimaced and sat back down but glared at the 6 of us sitting across from him. FELT incredibly safe do nothing City employees.

34 Comments
2024/12/01
17:03 UTC

4

What’s the best J/M station to transfer between the J and G? Hewes Street or Lorimer Street?

Looking for fastest, least annoying, etc. or are they equal?

3 Comments
2024/12/01
16:44 UTC

30

From last week's R211 reroute via 2nd Avenue

0 Comments
2024/12/01
15:59 UTC

552

So Councilwoman Vickie Paladino (yes this is her ACTUAL account) really is the modern Robert Moses.

110 Comments
2024/12/01
15:21 UTC

5

Question about the direction trains come from?

So my dad has a theory that the direction from which a train comes in relation to the platform is regular. He says in the case of a single-train platform (eg. 66th st 1 train) the train is always coming from your left, whereas with double platforms where the trains are going in opposite directions (eg. the 4/5 at Atlantic or the 2/3 at Penn Station) the trains will always come from your right (this is assuming that you’re facing towards whichever train is coming). This obviously doesn’t mean anything for double platforms where the trains are going in the same direction (like the 72 st 1/2/3). But is he right? I can’t think of any counterexamples.

16 Comments
2024/12/01
06:29 UTC

49

155th Street B/D Station

11 Comments
2024/12/01
04:19 UTC

9

What are all the different types of trains that run in the subway?

From time to time I’ve seen non-passenger trains and I’m just so curious what they all do. Most of the ones I see are only like 4~ sections long but sometimes I’ve seen longer ones. Usually they have some bin looking things on them idk how to even describe them. I did see a vaktrak the other day so I know what that is now but what else is there??

4 Comments
2024/12/01
03:29 UTC

Back To Top