/r/nycrail

Photograph via //r/nycrail

Passenger and freight rail and trains, including transit, in and related to New York City.

This subreddit is dedicated to rail transportation in and related to New York City, including transit, commuter, long distance and freight.

Questions are welcome.

We have a Discord server!

Posting & Commenting Rules

Rule 1: Be nice to others.

Ad hominems and personal attacks against other redditors will be removed.

Posts or comments disparaging people or groups on the basis of race, ethnicity, place of origin, religion, sexual orientation, sex or gender will be removed.

Posts or comments advocating for crimes against another person or group of people will be removed.

Rule 2: Posts should be about NYC-area rail.

Posts about other forms of NYC-area transportation are allowed as long as they have some relation to rail.

Links to content about rail transportation outside of the NYC region are allowed, but they must include a submission statement relating them to NYC-area rail.

Rule 3: Respect laws.

Posts or comments requesting or providing information about how to engage in illegal activity will be removed.

Rule 4: Keep posts high-quality and unique.

Double postings and news articles that don't add to previous conversations will be removed.

Poll posts are not allowed.

Low-effort posts with little interest or basis for discussion will be removed at the mods’ discretion.

Rule 5: Media posts must have a descriptive title.

All media posts (photos, videos, etc) must include a meaningful title and/or must be accompanied by a comment introducing the content explaining the significance of what is being posted.

All fantasy map image posts require a submission statement explaining the major changes or features of the map. If this is provided or already exists through a blog post, a link to said post is sufficient.

Repeat violations of the above rules may result in a temporary suspension.


/r/nycrail's public mod log


AMAs:

MTA subway track worker, March 2017

Tess Stahl, October 2016

Max Diamond, January 2016

Max Diamond, November 2015

Max Diamond, October 2015


Interested in holding an AMA, or want to make a subreddit suggestion? Feel free to contact us via modmail!


Resources:

The Absolute Beginner's Guide to the New York Subway

Dj Hammers videos on YouTube

Secrets of the Subway

vanshnookenraggen's NYC Subway Track Map


Related subreddits:

NYC-area:

/r/AskNYC

/r/newyorkcity

/r/NYC

/r/NYChistory

/r/nycbus

/r/OMNY

/r/nycmaps

Outside NYC-area:

/r/Subways

/r/trains

/r/transit

/r/TransitDiagrams

/r/nycrail

111,121 Subscribers

0

I did your mom

0 Comments
2024/05/04
20:48 UTC

0

How to know the train schedule from night before ?

I have been trying to arrange my schedule and catch the train on time. Yet I can’t find how to locate the schedule of trains from a day or two before.

Would appreciate your help if know. Thanks

2 Comments
2024/05/04
20:46 UTC

2

Why is there an S shaped turn on the R W between City Hall and Cortlandt?

The turn between those two stops is so aggressive!

5 Comments
2024/05/04
19:55 UTC

4

7 vs E

This is my first post on this subreddit. I am a high school freshman, so I don’t really have much knowledge about the train system. I’ve been having this argument with someone else(also a freshman) and I will die on the hill that the E is better than the 7 train. The people here probably have much better experience and knowledge about the train system than I do, so what do you all think(specifically, please give me substantive evidence on why you think one is better than the other)?

3 Comments
2024/05/04
19:34 UTC

15

Amazing Shot I got on the J Train crossing the Williamsburg Bridge

I was crossing the Williamsburg Bridge on the Jamaica Bound side of the bridge. The view is just beautiful

0 Comments
2024/05/04
18:54 UTC

8

Doctor Who wrap on the shuttle train!

0 Comments
2024/05/04
18:05 UTC

46

I made an interactive NYC subway visualization showing stations, services, convenience by neighborhood

14 Comments
2024/05/04
18:01 UTC

0

What are shuttle buses?

I was just walking until i saw a orange paper saying shuttle buses with an arrow then a shuttle bus came thru and i was like “what?” so im asking if anyone knows what is it?

4 Comments
2024/05/04
17:45 UTC

9

Local F doesn't announce 36th Street.

I've noticed that when the Jamaica bound F goes local in Queens Boulevard, the automated announcements never announces "This is 36th Street." and most conductors announce it manually. However, when the F was re-routed over the E line and going from Queens Plaza to 36th Street, it gets announced. I thought they would have fixed that glitch by now.

2 Comments
2024/05/04
17:22 UTC

2

Train Operator Requirements question

In Summary, for the requirements it said if you have an accident record you may be disqualified. My Car one day hydroplaned into a concrete wall and it was totaled. Does that mean I'm disqualified already?

2 Comments
2024/05/04
16:36 UTC

23

Attention everyone 🗣️

2 Comments
2024/05/04
15:02 UTC

66

Waiting for the 7

15 Comments
2024/05/04
14:25 UTC

41

What is this thing?

Sorry for the poor filming. Spotted at 10pm on the northbound platform at 66th st-Lincoln Center.

24 Comments
2024/05/04
13:56 UTC

2

MTA train operator exam.

Hello, I have the exam ready to take on May 18, 2024. I am currently working on getting my driver’s license. Will I still be considered for a job opportunity after the exam? I should have my drivers license ready by summer time.

Thank You.

2 Comments
2024/05/04
12:40 UTC

4

Updated AirTrain Map

The link to the map is:

https://tennessine.co.uk/metro/737f7f7c39181d4

Mods if i put this with the wrong flair, just let me know.

1 Comment
2024/05/04
10:55 UTC

175

Is it true never to sit on the end seats??

189 Comments
2024/05/04
10:35 UTC

14

Bronx S Train

There used to be elevated tracks that connected East 180th Street to Westchester Ave (Near Whitlock Ave Station) in the Bronx formerly owned by the NYWB. It has already been taken down, but I was wondering, do you think it would have been a good idea to run an S train on that track to provide a connection between the 2, 5, and 6 trains without going to Manhattan?

3 Comments
2024/05/04
02:42 UTC

69

They matched the tiles wrong at Nostrand

13 Comments
2024/05/04
02:38 UTC

1

Transit Museum Collection

Question - Is there any way to know about the Transit Museum subway fleet in the museum at any time? If not, does anyone know what trains are in rn?

2 Comments
2024/05/04
02:03 UTC

20

How people gonna get to/from greenpoint on Sunday?

No g train. The drawbridge is closed due to the bike tour. Which means the shuttle bus and local bus can’t get on the draw bridge to and from greenpoint. Ferry service doesn’t start until 9-10am. Walk from the L at Bedford Ave?

I hope the pedestrian foot path and those set of stairs are open so that people can at least walk to the 7 or E train

10 Comments
2024/05/04
01:14 UTC

1

Metro North electrician career

I’m looking at the current metro north electrician position they have posted, my question is do they have level to the positions?like electrician A/B, lead? With other companies ie coned they have general unitility worker, mechanic B, mechanic A they each have pay scales but you can move up to a B mechanic then A mechanic after doing training and getting experience.

0 Comments
2024/05/04
00:21 UTC

24

Question about DeKalb Junction

Hello! I’m a daily Q rider so I often pass through this junction, and I’m starting to notice how around 8 times out of 10 the Q doesn’t really hold, rather just slow down near there. Today I was at dekalb and a N train went past my Q on the express track yet dispatch held that N for my Q to go through first even though the N was ahead. With this observation, does the Q have priority over the other lines at DeKalb, or is this just me being lucky?

12 Comments
2024/05/04
00:11 UTC

14

Vertical digital advertisement screens are everywhere in the NYC subway stations. Where are the horizontal digital ad screens?

Perhaps an odd question, but…according to the MTA, there are both vertical and horizontal digital ad screens in NYC subway systems. But I'm straining to think of when I have seen these horizontal ad screens.

https://preview.redd.it/hrtbh9y6v9yc1.png?width=495&format=png&auto=webp&s=0c9d8082099305d0ec34b65d2ac580038807a8ea

Which stations have these screens?

14 Comments
2024/05/03
20:33 UTC

0

Interesting service restructuring idea I thought about, courtesy of The SubwayNut

I was reading the Subway Nut's page on the R train where he talked about how the line went to Astoria and swapped with the N for direct depot access. However he pointed out that reinstating this and rerouting the N via 63rd could allow the R to be completely deinterlined and run smoothly just like the 1 train. I thought about how this would work and maybe even going a step farther. Here's my entire idea:

  • Send R train back to Astoria and have it run more frequently
  • Reroute N via 63rd, running local in Queens to Continental; no more crossing over for 49th and have it run express on Broadway 7 days a week
  • Reroute weekday M to 96th/2nd, so the SAS doesn't have just the Q train
  • Re-extend weekday G trains to Continental
  • F train back to the 53rd for good
  • No more W train

Actually as I write this I now realize that this would mean 57th/6th wouldnt have any weekend service unless the M train goes there. The reason I thought having the F go back to 53rd was important was to keep Queens Plaza with enough manhattan service and to reduce congestion at Lex/63.

How bad can it really be to deprive the R of direct depot access if it means that 4th ave local stations get much better service?

This idea would basically make the QBL almost how it was pre-1987 except with the N via 63rd and the E on Archer.

I suppose another option (a less drastic one, more like the Subway Nut) is to still do the N/R swap but keep the M on QBL and F on 63rd. However they'd still need to extend the G on weekends (like in the 2000s) or Queens Plaza will have nothing but the E train and local passengers trying to get to LIC on the weekends will be furious.

I'd need to think more about how this would affect late night patterns. I mean the R should be a 24/7 service local on the full route. Maybe the N would become the shuttle terminating at Whitehall. Not sure how it would work on the Queens end. Devil's in the details. Obviously have to consider all potential adverse effects and listen to public input.

SubwayNut also mentioned that if the Astoria-Bay Ridge service isn't feasible, another option is to reinstate the diamond brown R. Or I suppose extend the W train to 95th on rush hours.

At least none of these ideas require any physical construction beyond replacing signs.

11 Comments
2024/05/03
18:25 UTC

0

The MTA should use NATM/SEM for the 125th St extension.

For 2nd Avenue Subway after Phase 2, extending West on 125th St, the MTA should use NATM/SEM instead of TBM for the tunnels b/c it's said to be cost effective and the tunnel would be created in soft ground. Plus it's easier to construct a line at shallower depths with NATM/SEM. The line should be a single hole with 2 tracks, the hole can be the width of the cut and cover tunnels and have the centerpillars separating them with some walls between them like the 4th Ave line. Do y'all agree with this idea for the SAS 125th St extension?

7 Comments
2024/05/03
16:34 UTC

4

PATH Conductor/Operator Applications

Is anyone familiar with the hiring process for PATH road crews (TO/CR)? I’ve never seen a formal application portal or openings on Port Authority’s website and was wondering if I was looking in the wrong place.

1 Comment
2024/05/03
16:31 UTC

176

Why is the green line thicker than the rest?

42 Comments
2024/05/03
16:30 UTC

Back To Top