Dear ERB Enterprises,

Dune has proven that when solidly and passionately realised an older, extremely influential IP can have not only a new life but be a zeitgeist creative, cultural and industry force.

The umbrella name we will use won’t be Barsoom or John Carter of Mars, but one which will make that last word ubiquitous, inseparable from the JCM property:

#The Mars Saga.

And as with all lasting sagas the first story will be crucial. We will find our Denis Villeneuve, or our Greta Gerwig.

And The first film will be called The Mars Saga: Dejah’s Quest.

It will be telling of the original story from the perspective of ‘A Princess Of Mars’ herself.

Upon this strong foundation, the remaining 10 Barsoom books will be adapted in exciting rewritten forms, with Dune and Dune Part Two as our touchstones (and Dune Prophecy, and Dune Awakening).

Once buried or put to the side, we will now fly the name MARS with pride.

To compare, Star Trek places a great deal of emphasis on the difference between the aliens' languages to the point where the native language is explored in certain episodes while still maintaining a universal lingua franca (English).

I personally think he made the right choice because creating a fictional language can quickly spiral into its own thing nearly independent of the source material i.e. the Na'vi language from James Cameron's Avatar movies.

The movie lost Disney something like $200 million and was widely seen as a marketing disaster. The movie itself is pretty fun. Audiences at the time, myself included, just didn't understand the John Carter title. Would they have garnered more interest naming it after the first story?

Since watching the John Carter movie I've always wanted to get into this series. I want to buy the books, but I usually prefer illustrated versions (like the Illustrated Editions for The Witcher series or the ones for A Song of Ice and Fire). I've researched but keep finding many different ones that seem to vary on quality and I'm unsure which to get.

I've seen theirs a graphic novel, but I would honestly prefer an illustrated book (since all the art, modern or old, of the Princess of Mars is amazing). Is the Graphic Novel good?

To celebrate the sub being on the road to hitting 1,000 members, I wanted make a 'share your story' for the underrated gem that is 2012'a John Carter of Mars (I don't call it John Carter).

It's not just any movie—it's a 'cozy movie', at least to me :)

For those unfamiliar, a 'cozy movie' is one that has a timeless quality, inviting viewers to escape into its world time and time again. It often features elements of hidden or alternative realities, much like JCM.

The film becomes a portal to another realm, enchanting us with its spellbinding landscapes, intriguing characters, and captivating narratives. These movies have the power to transport us, much like Lucy in 'The Chronicles of Narnia', from our ordinary lives into extraordinary worlds, always promising the comfort of return. This cyclical journey, coupled with the warmth of familiar characters and narratives, imbues it with a 'coziness'—a sense of solace, warmth, and familiarity that keeps us coming back, eagerly reliving the adventure while snugly wrapped in the blanket of nostalgia :)

Any time I see JCM, with the 'Inter Mundos' of it all, and John's research-filled study - that same feeling hits.

It offers a unique universe rich in lore and characters that feel like old friends. It's the kind of film that provides comfort, familiarity, and adventure in equal measure, perfect for a lazy Sunday afternoon or a late-night movie with snacks :)

Would love for others to share their cozy movie rituals around JCM!

I recommend reading Chapters VI through VIII in a single sitting because it dwelves so deep into the mythos of Barsoom, and further exploring the Therns through Phaidor and the First Born through Xodar. I felt pity for Phaidor during this section due to >!the rapid deconstruction of her worldview;!< and by stopping just before Chapter IX "Issus, Goddess of Life Eternal", it has already built up so much suspense, that you're left wondering if Issus >!really is a Goddess or just another phony.!<

On the other hand, reading one chapter per day is also a great plan because each one contains a lot of immersive worldbuilding. Subterranean regions are a big thing in this book. The flying ships, imaginative details, and the distance travelled by John Carter and company would be better served through a guided reading group rather than alone, IMO.

I'm really enjoying The Gods of Mars thus far.

I remember seeing those titles offered to listen for free somewhere that clearly wasn't Audible, but my usual audiobook sites don't show either book.

For me, I would focus on the trilogy because John Carter is the main narrator and he's a likable character, so it'd ease new readers into the 11-book series.

Kind of embarrassing, but in the 26 years or so that I've been a fan, I've only read the first four books. I'm working on Chessmen, now.

Anyway, which beasties are your favorites? I'm going to least for each book I've read, as they introduce more with each one.

Princess of Mars: White Apes. Just cool and menacing

Gods of Mars: The blue plant-men. They stuck with me all these years

Warlord of Mars: The Sith. Apts were interesting, but the encounter with the Sith was more menacing, I feel.

Thuvia: I mean, we've seen Banths before, but this is where they shined best, I think.

Overall: Tough. I'm going to have to go with Blue Men, but I also really wanna say White Apes.

Honorable Mention: WOOLA! He's the best individual beastie, but calots aren't the best species.

https://www.giantfreakinrobot.com/ent/john-carter-reboot-series.html?fbclid=IwAR2kfj9GZZ-ZDx234LardYpxducHVRQOms7gKw7FNVseu0rQk23rVr7_Y7Q

As I peruse the cluttered Barsoomian listings on Amazon, I note that plenty of outlets/people are selling the public-domain volumes of the series. Still, seemingly no one is publishing the last four volumes. Who holds the publishing rights these days, and where are they selling?

View Poll

i already have a trade back the garden of mars

View Poll

The books are great so far. Why did they get it so wrong in the movie!! Ugh.. hopefully someone else can do a proper movie or tv adaptation.