/r/MusicCritique
A community of musicians providing and seeking critique on their work. All genres welcome!
In its current form, this subreddit is only a dumping ground for promotions. I have disabled it to prevent misuse.
Please Take a Moment to read our Rules/F.A.Q page!
Welcome to /r/MusicCritique
Here amateurs and professionals alike can post their original songs, samples, remixes, and demos to have them critiqued by the community.
Please use SoundCloud to post your songs.
Contests
We need more contests to post here. Please PM me with any suggestions.
Artist of the Week
Important
Users are highly encouraged to critique other songs before posting their own work. If you like a song enough to upvote it, please take a moment to leave a comment for the artist. Remember, you can learn as much critiquing as you can creating songs. Thank you!
Content Policy
Criticizing someone's music can be a highly sensitive activity. Members are required to behave professionally and responsibly at all times. This sub-Reddit is focused on employing your musical knowledge to help improve songs. Any content not related to the goals of this sub-Reddit may be removed without notice.
Promotion
No promoting. We are not here as fans to help your rise to the top. We will help with feedback, however.
If you want to promote, check out these sub-Reddits:
- /r/ListenToThis (Post your track)
- /r/RadioReddit (Post your song for broadcast)
- /r/Composer (For contemporary music)
- /r/AcousticOriginals (Songwriters looking for feedback)
- /r/MusicInTheMaking (Play music with other Redditors)
- /r/ThisIsOurMusic (For all the rest and promotion)
- /r/TheseAreOurAlbums (Promote your album)
Helpful Links
/r/MusicCritique
13,156 Subscribers
[FEEDBACK] Elribone - Not quite what I had in mind - electronic
10:28 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Nøyre x Luciano D´Andrea - Under the Rain - indie / pop
14:38 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Good-Looking Corpse - The Reflection of the Sun - indie / alternative
05:12 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Jineta Sónica - Parece que fue ayer - Alternative Rock
11:59 UTC
[feedback] daybloom - No Strings - Alternative pop
Hello! We recently put out our debut single and would love to hear everyone's critique since any feedback helps when getting started. We have a lot more coming soon so follow along if you like what you hear! :)
14:34 UTC
11:19 UTC
[feedback] vu - JUST MAKE SENSE - Ken Carson Inspired
02:07 UTC
[feedback] - C6 Furina- Yubikiri no Hikari ft. Mai - electronic
17:14 UTC
[feedback] - seöa - victim game - electronic
13:36 UTC
[feedback] Rinnovare feat daadø - Abedul - Downtempo Folktronica
New album “Adiós, Por Siempre” Out everywhere now :)
04:47 UTC
[Feedback] Mat Bakari - c.a.s. / lost in the clouds - HipHop
What’s up everybody,
I’m Mat Bakari, an artist who’s blending lyricism, vibe, and soul. I’ve poured everything into my debut single—it’s a piece of my journey.
If you vibe with it, let’s lock in. If not, no harm no foul. 🙏🏾
🔥 Debut single out now under:
c.a.s. / lost in the clouds
Let me prove why I belong in your playlist. Your feedback means everything. Let’s build. 🎶
02:02 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Wraithballer - Space23 - Dreamy Pads and Reese Bass Blend.
Hi everyone,
I’m looking for honest feedback on my latest track. It’s a piece that blends dreamy, distant synths with a rich, resonant reese bass to create a nostalgic and otherworldly vibe. I’d love to know what you think—what works, what could be improved, and how it comes across overall.
I appreciate any critiques and insights you can share. Thanks for listening!
13:23 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Good-Looking Corpse - Mind and Body, Heart and Soul - indie / alternative
07:47 UTC
[FEEDBACK] C6 Furina - Yumeiro Heart ft. Mai - Songwriter
15:23 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Starbloom - When we were best friends - Singer songwriter
01:24 UTC
[FEEDBACK] The Vampire Dynasty - Life Moves Fast - Hip Hop
23:31 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Elribone - Not quite what I had in mind - electronic jazz
11:06 UTC
[FEEDBACK] shaey - redrum type - hip hop
05:37 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Middle Row Seat - Leiva - Hiphop
05:00 UTC
[FEEDBACK] SEVENSENT - I Am Poison - Metal
17:01 UTC
[Feedback] War On Gravity - Reform or Perish - Hard Rock
15:04 UTC
[FEEDBACK] J4NR - STAB MY EYES - Experimental Trap
08:29 UTC
[Feedback] glass flint - paper weight - rock
17:43 UTC
[FEEDBACK] CHANTARA - MANZANA - Pop
15:33 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Ura Hedge - Tilting at Windmills - Dubstep
DAWless live recorded and edited in Reason 13. Let me know what you think!
15:19 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Good-Looking Corpse - The Dying of the Light - instrumental
10:34 UTC
[Feedback] CLE Collective - Through The Haze - Prog Rock
16:14 UTC
Back To Top