/r/MusicCritique
A community of musicians providing and seeking critique on their work. All genres welcome!
In its current form, this subreddit is only a dumping ground for promotions. I have disabled it to prevent misuse.
Please Take a Moment to read our Rules/F.A.Q page!
Welcome to /r/MusicCritique
Here amateurs and professionals alike can post their original songs, samples, remixes, and demos to have them critiqued by the community.
Please use SoundCloud to post your songs.
Contests
We need more contests to post here. Please PM me with any suggestions.
Artist of the Week
Important
Users are highly encouraged to critique other songs before posting their own work. If you like a song enough to upvote it, please take a moment to leave a comment for the artist. Remember, you can learn as much critiquing as you can creating songs. Thank you!
Content Policy
Criticizing someone's music can be a highly sensitive activity. Members are required to behave professionally and responsibly at all times. This sub-Reddit is focused on employing your musical knowledge to help improve songs. Any content not related to the goals of this sub-Reddit may be removed without notice.
Promotion
No promoting. We are not here as fans to help your rise to the top. We will help with feedback, however.
If you want to promote, check out these sub-Reddits:
- /r/ListenToThis (Post your track)
- /r/RadioReddit (Post your song for broadcast)
- /r/Composer (For contemporary music)
- /r/AcousticOriginals (Songwriters looking for feedback)
- /r/MusicInTheMaking (Play music with other Redditors)
- /r/ThisIsOurMusic (For all the rest and promotion)
- /r/TheseAreOurAlbums (Promote your album)
Helpful Links
/r/MusicCritique
13,325 Subscribers
[FEEDBACK] Hovey - Butterfly made kisses - Indie pop
Hello! ! I recorded vocals for the first time over a beat I found on YouTube and wanted some input on ways to improve the vocals mixing. etc. Any feedback is appreciated :)
18:29 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Joshua Browne - Waiting on me - Hip Hop
17:21 UTC
[feedback] I Wanna Make Your Whole Week - Barty Ram Music - Sultry & electrifying
16:58 UTC
[feedback] - seöa - blood is my fav color v2 - electronic
13:28 UTC
[feedback] me - untitled 1 - lofi
could you give me feedback on how to extend it without it sounding the same
06:04 UTC
[Feedback] Anthony montana - intoxicated love - dance pop
23:33 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Spells and Curses - Little Things - Alt Rock
18:33 UTC
[FEEDBACK] God Lay Dying - Deep Into the Silent Nothingness - industrial/edm
06:55 UTC
[Feedback] Phenom - All Night - R&B/Rap
Want to know If I sound good and where can I improve in mixing the song and vocals (This is my first song)
21:26 UTC
[Feedback] FrenchDad - The Entertainer EDM Remix - Electro
16:50 UTC
[FEEDBACK] İNSİCAM - Bekle dur - Indie
08:20 UTC
[FEEDBACK] God Lay Dying - Cherry Blossoms - instrumental
06:55 UTC
[Feedback] Mandy - I'm Sorry - Rap??
⚠️TW: suicidal ideation/substance abuse⚠️
So, I wrote this song a few years ago and until now I have NEVER had the guts to share it publicly,
The recording is a VERY rough draft and the backing track is as bare-bones as it gets, so it's basically just a concept piece at the moment.
That said, I am not very confident in my abilities as a writer and would love for someone to listen and just tell me if it has any potential to be worth anyone's time??
It's certainly not that great in its current state, but I'm kinda trying to figure out if I should abandon it altogether or try to develop it into something more.
10:45 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Eleanore - All I Wanna Do (Demo) - Rock
05:28 UTC
[Feedback] Scammeisha the Scam Artist - Kigaeru - Hip Hop
02:09 UTC
[Feedback] I Like Cars - Vailo - Grunge
01:52 UTC
[feedback] CJ Durso - Shadows on the Ceiling - SynthPop
I’d love some feedback on any aspect of the song. Especially the vocals as this is my first release as a singer!
23:59 UTC
[feedback] mickey blurr - killer - experimental rock
https://mickeyblurr.bandcamp.com/track/killer-2
I took a 4 year break from music due to depression and incrementally wrote a record, which I just released today. I played my first show back in october 2023 and then gradually recorded these songs.
while I didn't release this one as a single formally, I consider it to be sort of the 'centerpiece' of this EP and would be interested to see what people think of it, mostly in terms of production and instrumentation. lyrically, I am very confident that it is what I wanted it to be and I don't think anything could change my perspective on that. but I wanted to experiment with certain musical ideas, like an infinitely sustained note which is perpetually in the background and using the low end of a piano instead of a bass guitar.
20:20 UTC
[FEEDBACK] İNSİCAM - O saatte - Alternative Rock
19:00 UTC
[feedback] Nyehvo - Calma - Electronic
https://soundcloud.com/nyehvo/calma?utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing
It's a bit all over the place, but any input is greatly appreciated. Also, if there are any tutorials or places I can learn, please share as well. Thank you!
18:59 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Fatjosh - Vent - Rap
16:38 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Lisztlovers- When Johnny Comes Marching Home - Piano Cover
21:27 UTC
[FEEDBACK] keyshore your - love - New Age
15:35 UTC
[FEEDBACK] keyshore - cheer up - New Age
15:33 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Skystrobe - Isolate - Progressive Metal
01:17 UTC
[Feedback] Monty - Borderlines - UK Rap
Feedback wanted
Song inspired by being with someone who suffers from a personality disorder
20:24 UTC
[FEEDBACK] Neozxn - Lael - VGM
Not sure if the genre is actually VGM, but I was heavily inspired by music from the nier series, there’s piano strings choir and all that.
05:38 UTC
Back To Top