/r/MagicalWhatIf

Photograph via snooOG

Ask the questions to weird for HistoryWhatIf or FutureWhatIf

Rules and Regulations

  1. Threads should be based mostly in reality with at least one "fantasy" element. Such as "100 US Marines find themselves in the Roman Empire" or "In 2020 Vladimir Putin gains superpowers".

  2. Comments should accept the premise of the thread as true but answer the question realistically. Meaning, don't question how or why 100 Marines were sent back in time. Just give your thoughts on what would happen.

  3. No insults. Keep it civil and don't correct spelling or grammar. Do not encourage trolls.

  4. No low effort posting or commenting. Answers should provide in-depth answers. Not jokes or images and no bots or personal politics.

  5. Use the [Geography] tag to indicate points of divergence based on different landscapes. Use the [DBWI] tag to signify double blind what-ifs. Use the [Challenge] tag for posts where you're asking how something could have happened different rather than what if it happened differently. Use [HWI] for historical based questions and [FWI] for future based questions.


Other subs you might enjoy

/r/MagicalWhatIf

524 Subscribers

1

MWI: Satan is Jesus's father

So Christianity assumes Yeshua Bin Nazareth's father was the Abrahamic god. What changes if Jesus's father is not God, but Satan, meaning he is literally devil-spawn?? He still has the same powers and stuff for reference.

0 Comments
2024/04/03
18:15 UTC

1

Vladimir Putin is now a stereotypical Hollywood Vampire

What changes in Russia now that the guy is effectively immortal as long as he doesn't go out in the sun, stays away from wooden stakes and drinks the blood of Russians to survive?

0 Comments
2024/03/30
23:44 UTC

1

MWI: Taylor Swift gets the powers of a stereotypical Disney princess

What changes now that Taylor Swift can now summon animals to do her bidding?? Given she is now a Disney Princess, her pet cats can speak British English and are smarter than regular cats. She also has a belief Travis Kelce is her true love and is willing to marry him on TV. Her antagonist is Kandiss Taylor(failed candidate for Gov. of Georgia), who is an evil hag who thinks Taylor serves the devil. How is her career affected, given that she's already a singer, now that she has magical powers?

0 Comments
2024/03/24
23:49 UTC

1

What if Mariah and Joseph Joestar from JJBA have a kid?

What if things in the '"Bastet" Mariah' story arc took a very different turn in the end where Joseph tries a last plea but Mariah doesn't refuse despite finding Dio Brando more attractive than the old man and that Mariah doesn't suffer a crushing defeat. Instead it ends well, leading to a possible affair that Joseph's wife Suzi does not know about?

Who would the child be? What would the child look like? Since if the child can be a protagonist in the JoJo's Bizarre Adventure anime series, what would the name of the part called?

0 Comments
2023/06/16
03:19 UTC

1

Taylor swift wins the presidency in 2024

What changes if she ends up magically becoming the nominee and replaces Biden who is no longer the Democratic nominee? This is magical and nobody remembers that she wasn’t there.

0 Comments
2023/06/09
20:03 UTC

1

Khashoggi is turned into a vampire

How does Saudi Arabia get handled after they turned Jamal Khashoggi into a Hollywood vampire?

0 Comments
2023/06/07
01:40 UTC

1

What if Jesus listened to Satan and did things like turn random rocks into bread?

0 Comments
2023/06/05
21:37 UTC

1

What if Vladimir Putin converted to Mormonism

What would change if none of his actual policies changed but he was now the first Mormon to rule Russia?

2 Comments
2023/06/02
20:23 UTC

2

What if Sanna Marin had cat ears and tail for real?

25 Comments
2023/06/01
17:08 UTC

1

An asteroid the size of the one in Mexico 65 million years ago strikes in the same spot during Emperor Trajan’s reign

0 Comments
2023/06/01
13:06 UTC

1

Modi now has an elephant head and a human body just like Ganesh

0 Comments
2023/05/29
13:13 UTC

1

Claire Dunphy runs for President in 2016

How well would she have done in the Democratic Primary against Hillary or Sanders?

0 Comments
2023/05/26
13:10 UTC

3

What if Satan won against God in his rebellion in heaven and he now ruled heaven and threw God into hell?

0 Comments
2023/05/24
13:04 UTC

1

The Second Coming occurs in St Augustine’s lifetime

What happens if the Second Coming occurs late in antiquity??

0 Comments
2023/05/23
00:53 UTC

1

It is revealed that JFK was shot by a theropod dinosaur with a sniper rifle who wanted revenge against mammals.

1 Comment
2023/05/21
13:19 UTC

2

NASA discovered wreckage of Nazi UFOs in the 1960s.

0 Comments
2023/05/18
12:12 UTC

2

Angels help the North win the Civil War faster

How would divine aid in the form of angels help the Northern cause defeat the Confederacy and how would reconstruction go?

0 Comments
2023/05/15
13:04 UTC

2

What if every Spanish woman got cat ears and tail in 1790’s (Then it would have their daughters, granddaughters,…)? How would it change history?

4 Comments
2023/05/14
06:37 UTC

3

The second coming occurs in the middle of World War I in 1916

What happens if, around the time Ireland has its Easter Rising, Jesus lands on Ottoman ruled Jerusalem?

0 Comments
2023/05/12
13:05 UTC

2

Putin bitten by a vampire

On December 31st 1999, shortly before taking power, Putin has been bitten by a vampire and will rule Russia by biting the country’s metaphorical neck?? What changes about his reign if he is a stereotypical Hollywood vampire instead of a human?

0 Comments
2023/05/10
13:39 UTC

2

Aliens land on the Earth after a zombie apocalypse

What would aliens think if they landed on Earth during a zombie apocalypse and humans were rare?

0 Comments
2023/05/09
13:17 UTC

1

Zimbabwe now has nuclear weapons

What changes if Zimbabwe now magically has nuclear weapons?

1 Comment
2023/05/05
13:00 UTC

2

World War I with magic

What if the Western Front now has stereotypical Romero era zombies in the trenches due to some kind of chemical gas?

0 Comments
2023/05/03
13:03 UTC

1

Alien fleet lands on Mars on 9/11

What changes if an alien fleet lands on Mars and is shown to be mining minerals. To make matters worse, it is also literally 9/11.

1 Comment
2023/04/28
16:35 UTC

2

Nicolas Maduro is turned into a giant sentient raccoon

He can still talk and speak in Spanish, but he now rules Venezuela while looking like a giant raccoon. His personality is exactly the same.

0 Comments
2023/04/26
19:15 UTC

2

What if bears used toilet paper like the Charmin commercials?

1 Comment
2023/04/23
21:22 UTC

1

MWI: the Rapture happens in 1843 or 1844

What if groups like the Millerites were right and they got raptured into heaven in the 1840’s???

0 Comments
2023/04/22
13:05 UTC

1

The events of the TV Show Lost all really happened

0 Comments
2023/04/19
13:18 UTC

2

Every confederate statue and memorial is thrown into the ocean by aliens

What changes if this magically happens??

1 Comment
2023/04/18
02:43 UTC

1

Mohammed Bin Salman is turned into a rubber duck

What changes now that he is now just a rubber duck with his consciousness trapped inside an inanimate rubber duck?

0 Comments
2023/04/17
03:07 UTC

Back To Top