/r/AskHistory

Photograph via snooOG

For asking casual questions about History. Also see r/History or r/AskHistorians.

For asking questions about History.

Rules:

  1. Discussion should be in good faith. No trolling, ragebait, or bigotry of any kind. We may also remove posts that we believe will lead to flame wars and rage arguments in the comments. We reserve the right to use mod discretion in applying this rule.
  2. Please follow Reddiquette.
  3. Only questions about history (events prior to 01/01/2000). No current politics. No current events. No current movements.
  4. No genocide denial, racism, or similar rhetoric.
  5. Keep "what if" questions reasonable. "What if" questions (also known as counter-factual questions) should include an explanation of what legitimate historical information you're looking for. "What if Lincoln had not been assassinated" should include the question "How did presidential and congressional reconstruction plans differ?"
  6. No AI-generated content. This is an "ask" sub, and a discussion sub. Please do not post AI-generated posts or comments. If using this reason to report content please be sure its a bot, and not just someone with an annoying typing style.

We cannot and will not entertain butterfly-effect style questions. You can take such questions to r/WritingPrompts or r/HistoryWhatIf/

Related subreddits:

/r/AskHistory

178,556 Subscribers

21

What was the most colonised country in the world?

My partner is Filipino and the Philippines has been colonised three separate times so we were wondering if there’s a country that’s been colonised more than that.

49 Comments
2024/11/10
21:08 UTC

2

Lost Ancient Knowledge

Are there any genuine, properly-documented examples of modern people discovering "lost knowledge" in recovered ancient texts that is both true and new to modern science?

3 Comments
2024/11/10
20:35 UTC

19

When did the US tighten its immigration policies, vs the Ellis Island days?

I’ve noticed when I talk to people about their ancestry, many people have a story about an ancestor coming to America with $5 in their pocket, changing their name at the entry port and starting a life in the US. Not to get political, but obviously the landscape for immigrants trying to gain entry to the US these days is much different than it was then. What were some of the events that caused the US to tighten its policy and stop allowing so many people to come here, with such lax rules?

46 Comments
2024/11/10
20:34 UTC

1

What was Hitler’s justification for seeing the Aryan and East Asian races as equal, but the black and Jewish races as inferior?

2 Comments
2024/11/10
15:24 UTC

6

Would Mexico have been better off in the long run under Maximilian the 1st if he wasn't executed?

4 Comments
2024/11/10
16:26 UTC

2

What are the best contribution to the world by early Indians,Chinese,Greeks and Egyptians?

Indians,Chinese,Greeks and Egyptians had one of the earliest civilization and as an Indian i do know about some discovery made by Indus civlization but I really wanted to know more,even discoveries by other civlizations too.I am 17M excuse me if my question is bad

6 Comments
2024/11/10
16:05 UTC

14

Why was Australia an important colony to the British?

24 Comments
2024/11/10
12:12 UTC

1

When did the "Multimedia Franchise" era start?

I don't know if this is too recent or not

5 Comments
2024/11/10
09:14 UTC

66

Before Adolf Hitler came to power, did people take his rhetoric seriously or think he is just exaggerating?

Edit: This is a post about history, not recent politics. Hitler never have his own reality TV show and he didn’t own any casino. Also, United States didn’t suffer from Treaty of Versailles like Germany did after World War I. This is not about recent politics

137 Comments
2024/11/10
04:50 UTC

10

Why isnt the famine in Greece in WW2 considered genocide?

Why is the killing of Greeks by the Three Pashas called genocide but the Nazis straving 10% of Greeks to death not? The Holodomor is called genocide and that also involved taking all the food out of Ukraine just as the Germans did in Greece. Likewise Pol Pot straving his own people to death is called genocide. So why isnt the Great Famine in Greece?

If you steal someones heart medicine you intend for them to die, weather your primary motovation was for them to die or to sell it on the black market.

2 Comments
2024/11/09
21:29 UTC

23

What are some examples of the lack of historical knowledge we have of different historical periods?

Sorry if my title seemed a bit dubious. Specifically, I am looking for specific periods in human history that we don't have much knowledge of. The immediate example which springs to mind is the Bronze Age collapse, but I would definitely appreciate more examples.

35 Comments
2024/11/10
04:28 UTC

37

What factors caused Latin American cartels to be more violent than other criminal groups/syndicates?

All criminal groups can be said to be violent but the violence of Latin American cartels goes beyond what one would think of as "regular" criminal violence, the violence of the cartels is less similar to the muggings , brawls and drive-bys one would think of when the word criminal violence is said but it's more akin to the violence of militias, rebels and terrorist groups one usually sees in parts of Africa and the Middle East.

From Pablo Escobar assassinating government officials and setting off bombs in Colombia to Mexican cartels performing ISIS-style video executions and having pitched battles with government forces. As I said above this type of violence is not usual among criminal groups, even groups like Triads, Yakuza,Russian Mafia, Italian mafia don't commit this type of violence.

So I wonder what factors made LATAM cartels so violent was it due to neighboring the US ,was due to government corruption etc.

45 Comments
2024/11/10
04:28 UTC

16

How did Hannibal Barca sell his Roman prisoners of war into slavery while he was in Italy?

Hannibal captured tens of thousands of Roman soldiers which I assume the majority were Roman citizens. I know Hannibal sold his prisoners of war into slavery when Rome refused to pay a ransom such as after the Battle of Cannae. My question is how did this go about? Did Italian merchants come to Hannibal's camp and offer to buy Roman slaves? Did Rome allow their own citizens to be purchased into slavery? Was it legal to buy from the Carthaginian Army?

5 Comments
2024/11/10
04:17 UTC

0

Could anyone please tell me the Adena people of North America

I found a burial mound but it isn't like the other mounds around the area (it's not an animal mound or earthwork circle mound), I think this is a pyramid (or used to be)I don't think I am talking about the Hopewell(mound builders) But anything you can tell me about the difference between them or how they interacted,and I really want to know the reason for each mound) it would be very helpful thank you, Any help would be greatly appreciated

4 Comments
2024/11/10
04:01 UTC

38

How much control did France have over Louisiana as a whole

Louisiana was pretty big, larger than France. And I hear that Spain and later Mexico had little control over its northern lands due to the Comancherias. But was that the same case with Louisiana? Did they control it in all but name?

9 Comments
2024/11/10
01:55 UTC

3

When did accuracy in historical accounts start being valued?

Humans have always used storytelling as a way to teach lessons and forge bonds, and a lot of our early oral traditions & literature relied on allegory and metaphor to deliver its message.

But when did we start valuing accurate information in biographies and historical accounts? Was there a movement within different cultures to use more rigor in how we represented history?

10 Comments
2024/11/10
00:45 UTC

23

What are the most significant events to happen in the Southern Hemisphere?

I’ll start: Vasco da Gama rounded the Cape of Good Hope.

30 Comments
2024/11/10
00:03 UTC

0

Evaluating Stalin in WWII

Everyone knows Stalin killed millions. Did he help Russia win WWII, make their victory harder, or not really be that relevant?

19 Comments
2024/11/09
22:35 UTC

16

Did Vikings refer to themselves as Vikings or is it something other people called them?

45 Comments
2024/11/09
20:46 UTC

41

Why is the Qin Dynasty not spelt with a Ch as Chin Dynasty if China’s name is based on that dynasty?

Only in recent years did I learn that the Qin Dynasty is pronounced like “Chin” Dynasty. I also learned that China’s modern name is based on the Qin Dynasty and the people calling that territory by a variation of that name for a long time.

I always get so caught up in what I am reading sometimes that I forget to remember that I am learning about it in English, which uses Latin letters. Because of this my mind might have written it off as “that’s just how their people decided to spell it,” until of course I remember that China doesn’t use Latin letters, so it wouldn’t likely be their doing to spell it that way.

So who or why is it then that we spell the Qin Dynasty with a Q but China with a Ch? Should it not instead be either Chin Dynasty and China, or Qin Dynasty and Qina? I’d like to learn about the origin of this.

51 Comments
2024/11/09
18:28 UTC

3

What was the craziest year in Berlin?

It seems that when ever I read about history of the 20th century Berlin, there was a crazy year after another. Which one would you rank as the craziest and why? Older ones are fine as well, I just don’t know enough about history to refer to them.

22 Comments
2024/11/09
18:24 UTC

1

What is exactly a "Palatina" system?

I am studying the late Helladic period and this word came up a few times.

1 Comment
2024/11/09
18:18 UTC

21

Where is Genghis khan Tomb most likely to be?

13 Comments
2024/11/09
10:31 UTC

20

What was the most hopeful time in American History?

As a ‘05 baby I wasn’t around to feel the shift in the American world that was caused by 9/11, but frequently in comment sections I hear the phrase “the day the hope died.” Speaking from experience, it does seem like everyone is just surviving anymore in America, there feels like there is little to no hope left in much of anyone. This being the case, what time in America was the most hopeful for the future? The roaring 20’s? The 50’s coming off of WWII? The love and funk of the 70’s? The start of the technology age in the 90’s? When did we seem the most hopeful that we were going in the right direction, maybe even felt the most connected to one another as the fellow human being?

Conversely, when do you think “the hope died?” Did people nail it with 9/11, or was it even before that? After maybe? It seems like such a devastating and sobering time.

49 Comments
2024/11/09
08:46 UTC

4

Was Isaac Newton religious?

I recently learned that Newton was very knowledgable about the Christain religion and wrote to that effect too, although his writing were never made public. It's just fascinating to me that one of the most, if not the most, infuential scientists of all time was also religious and deeply believed in the existence of God. What does history say about Newton's religious beleifs?

50 Comments
2024/11/09
07:42 UTC

2

How bad was the harrying of the north for england?

Ive heard some people describe it as a borderline genocide and that it was worse for england then all of the viking age had been. So how bad was it?

2 Comments
2024/11/08
22:39 UTC

0

What did/does life in anti-democratic regimes look like?

A

24 Comments
2024/11/09
00:59 UTC

5

Much of Europe came to be thought of by the tribes, usually Steppe or Germanic, who came to live in different places. When do you usually stop thinking of those tribes and start thinking of those places by the kingdoms they came to be famous for?

People easily talk about things like the Franks, the Saxons, Romano-British, the Slavs, Magyars, Huns, Visigoths, Ostrogoths, Danes and Norse, the Pictish, the Bulgars, and similar.

But we hardly ever do something like call the wars between France and England in say 1204, let alone 1336 or 1415, as something akin to a conflict between the Franks and the Saxons (led by a line of kings from the Danes), the way we might say something akin to how the Romans under Justinian and Belisarius waged war on the Ostrogoths, Visigoths, Huns, and Bulgars.

What is the transition point to you and why? Multiple answers will be appropriate for different regions and nations.

15 Comments
2024/11/09
00:04 UTC

33

How did Irish Catholics in the British Army react to the Irish revolution?

A relative of mine was an Irish Catholic who was killed in World War I, as part of the British army and Irish Guards. A couple of years later, his brother and father were part of the Irish Republican Army. I know not to essentialise identities but it does seem like a peculiar contradiction to me.

How come so many Irish Catholics enlisted in the first place? And how did Irish Catholics in the British army react to the Easter Rising? Were they unable to do anything if they were already part of the army?

12 Comments
2024/11/08
23:23 UTC

140

Where is Alexander the Great buried?

Is it Egypt?, Iraq (Babylon)?, Greece?

I saw once that is said that the Roman emperor Augustus Caeser visited his grave once

55 Comments
2024/11/08
21:28 UTC

Back To Top