/r/AskHistorians

Photograph via //r/AskHistorians

The Portal for Public History.

Please read the rules before participating, as we remove all comments which break the rules. Answers must be in-depth and comprehensive, or they will be removed.

  1. This Week's Theme is Indigenous Nations

New to /r/AskHistorians? Please read our subreddit rules and FAQ before posting!

Apply for Flair

  • Upvote informative, well sourced answers
  • Downvote and Report comments that are unhelpful or grossly off-topic

The Rules, in Brief

1. Be Nice: No Racism, Bigotry, or Offensive Behavior.
2. Nothing Less Than 20 Years Old, and Don't Soapbox.
3. Questions should be clear and specific in what they ask, and should be able to get detailed answers from historians whose expertise is likely to be in particular times and places.
4. Write Original, In-Depth and Comprehensive Answers, Using Good Historical Practices.
5. Provide Primary and Secondary Sources If Asked. No Tertiary Sources Like Wikipedia.
6. Serious On-Topic Comments Only: No Jokes, Anecdotes, Clutter, or other Digressions.
7. Report Comments That Break Reddiquette or the Subreddit Rules.
8. Please Read and Understand the Rules Before Contributing.

Resources

Flair

Our flaired users have detailed knowledge of their historical specialty and a proven record of excellent contributions to /r/AskHistorians.

Flair categories

To nominate someone else as a Quality Contributor, message the mods.

Upcoming Events

Please Subscribe to our Google Calendar for Upcoming AMAs and Events

May 25th | Panel AMA with /r/AskBibleScholars

Previous AMAs | Previous Roundtables

Features

Feature posts are posted weekly. The current rotation is:

Related subreddits

Follow us on social media

/r/AskHistorians

2,174,683 Subscribers

0

What role did the war fan play in warfare in general and in the Sengoku Jidai in particular and how did it's use advance and decline with time?

1 Comment
2024/11/20
08:08 UTC

1

What factors led to the increasing political power of Roman imperial women?

Thinking of people like Julia Domna and Julia Maesa. Maybe there isn't a trend at all but it seems notable.

1 Comment
2024/11/20
07:20 UTC

0

Why didn't the U.S just allow lemay to carpet bomb north vietnam?

1 Comment
2024/11/20
05:58 UTC

4

Were there organizations similar to labor unions before the rise of capitalism?

As the title says. I was just wondering, as I've been reading about strikes and the rise of unions in the late 19th century for one of my classes. I don't have the best knowledge of the Medieval era nor much of the Early Modern Era, so I was just wondering if anything close to the idea of labor unions existed in feudal and pre-capitalist societies.

2 Comments
2024/11/20
05:56 UTC

7

How did so many Indians go to England to be barristers?

The cultural exchange of Indians and the Empire has been studied at length. But I was particularly interested in the fact that so many Indians actually went abroad to study as Barristers and then return to their country. People like Nehru, Gandhi, Ambedkar were all trained as barristers. Is there any relation to these people studying law abroad and coming back and joining the freedom movement?

1 Comment
2024/11/20
05:38 UTC

1

How did the Great Depression affect Christianity in the US?

I'm looking into how pastors navigated the Great Depression, primarily regarding Baptist (focusing on the SBC) and Pentecostal/Charismatic denominations.

I'm having difficulty finding resources, so I thought I would see if I could get some help with this. I'm looking more at a level of pastor to congregation rather than amongst leadership.

What I'm primarily looking for is:

What rhetoric was used to explain the Great Depression to the congregations?

How did the Great Depression affect relations between White and Nonwhite churches? I did find some, especially as to why the Assemblies of God broke off, but more examples is better.

Thank you for any assistance.

1 Comment
2024/11/20
05:30 UTC

6

What is the history of the Turkistan Islamic Party?

Hi, I've been doing some reading on this recently and I'm interested in the origins of this group. The short summary that I've seen so far is that there has always been separatist sentiment in Xinjiang/East Turkestan, but I can't really find any information about why this specific group popped up in the 90s.

My instincts go to the training of the Mujahideen during Operation Cyclone and the general Soviet Invasion of Afghanistan. Is there any connection between these events and the foundations of the party? All I can find is that they were "influenced" by this, but I'm not sure if this was direct or just inspiration. Were there any key domestic policies in China in the 80s and 90s that led to this?

1 Comment
2024/11/20
04:48 UTC

0

Where there any leaders/politicians throughout history that had a positive change of heart?

I could think of several where they had a negative change of heart, like getting on board with something oppressive, but has there ever been an example of someone with political power who had a positive change of heart where they went against a regime/system that harmed others/was oppressive that they had previously supported?

1 Comment
2024/11/20
04:29 UTC

2

After the second world war, why did Russia take the Kaliningrad Oblast?

1 Comment
2024/11/20
04:08 UTC

169

Why was an FBI warning shown before watching a VHS at home? How did the FBI get involved with at home movies in the first place?

5 Comments
2024/11/20
04:04 UTC

38

During segregation, did every single place have at least 4 restrooms? Were there some places that were too small so they only had white restrooms? (American segregation)

3 Comments
2024/11/20
03:46 UTC

3

Are there any records of Russian Nobles complaining about the 1861 emancipation of serfs?

I am looking for a primary source (ideally in English) from a Russian noble or serf owner(?) attacking the emancipation of the serfs, either from just prior to the emancipation or the few decades after.

I am several weeks behind on this college assignment. If anyone can lend a hand, it would be appreciated. Everything I can find is in Russian and I cannot read it.

1 Comment
2024/11/20
03:45 UTC

23

Did christian nobles ever claim descendance from figures in the Bible?

So I have heard about medieval christian royal families claiming a descendance from figures of classical myth, especially Troy, which the roman nobility of the Republic engaged in too, if I am not mistaken. This was probably done to imbue your own rulership with some special significance or legitimacy.

So did anyone ever claim that a biblical figure was the ancestor of their line? And if not, was there a reason for this? Jesus and Mary are from a modern perspective obvious no-gos, but there are plenty of other people in the NT (or even OT) where it would seem "fine" to claim a descendance.

7 Comments
2024/11/20
03:41 UTC

1

Would you say the modern obsession with Japanese history, media and aesthetics is comparable to egyptomania?

1 Comment
2024/11/20
03:37 UTC

1

app/website for historical thinking?

my brain struggles to create connections within history quickly, which can cause info to become muddled and i lose it.

is there a app/website (such as Brillaint, which is used for math stuff) to help me with this skill?

1 Comment
2024/11/20
03:26 UTC

2

What was going on in humble Guangxi in the mid-19th century that made it, rather than Hong Xiuquan’s home province of Guangdong, the petri dish of the Taiping Rebellion?

2 Comments
2024/11/20
03:25 UTC

30

When John Brown committed the Pottawatomie massacre, did local authorities know that it was him?

As I understand it, John Brown committed the Pottawatomie massacre in 1856 in response to the sack of Lawrence, KS by pro-slavery forces. Given the fever-pitch of tensions at that time and in that place, I would assume that local (pro-slavery) authorities were intent on finding the perpetrator(s) of the massacre and bringing them to justice. However, I don't know what kind of investigational capacity was available, what resources were actually brought to bare, and if there were an investigation, what the result was.

My question is what kind of investigational capacity was available in that time and place, what resources were actually brought to bear, and if there were an investigation, what the result was.

1 Comment
2024/11/20
03:02 UTC

147

At what point in hitlers rise to power did it become impossible to flee the country?

as a Jewish citizen? Then as just a German citizen? What was the purpose for forbidding travel? What led up to a shutdown of escape? Thank you for your response.

17 Comments
2024/11/20
01:43 UTC

0

Did soldiers in WW1 jerk off in the trenches?

This is a real question haha. I've wondered about this since I watched 1917, like 6 years ago, where one of the main characters jokes about masterbating.

3 Comments
2024/11/20
02:53 UTC

1 Comment
2024/11/20
02:46 UTC

2

Do Native American feathered headdresses and mesoamerican penachos have a common origin?

2 Comments
2024/11/20
02:35 UTC

14

Am on 2nd book of Foote’s The Civil War. All of these extensive letters that he is quoting verbatim from all of the different generals and Cornels, and minor characters… where did all of them come from. Like did everyone in the 1800s just save every single letter that they ever received from anyone?

4 Comments
2024/11/20
02:30 UTC

2

What type of weapons did the qing use throughout the entire dynasty?

a lot of the sources i looked at had several different weapons but they vary

1 Comment
2024/11/20
02:24 UTC

2

I’m in Valjean’s time and situation: newly paroled, everyone is turning me away. Can I just say my documents got lost and start anew or would I be traceable somehow?

1 Comment
2024/11/20
02:06 UTC

1

Why were Spaniards targeted so much during the Mexican Revolution?

I'm reading Alan Knight's book on the Mexican Revolution and it seemed that Spaniards were especially targeted for reprisals while other groups, notably Americans, were more likely than not to escape reprisals. I was wondering why this was.

1 Comment
2024/11/20
01:40 UTC

55

In American movies, the US president's security is often seen aggressively preventing him and his family from doing a variety of things for security reasons, even if they were prepared to take the risk. Have there ever been any recorded instances of this happening?

2 Comments
2024/11/20
01:38 UTC

0

Out of every continent does Europe have the most wars?

Whenever I read about history it always seems Europe is at war or tensions are high and there is about to be war. Is it true that Europe has the most wars? And if so, why? Is it because there's a lot of countries or ethnic groups

9 Comments
2024/11/20
01:33 UTC

0

Does the 2nd amendment have racist roots?

What the subject is…

I came across this article https://www.npr.org/2021/06/02/1002107670/historian-uncovers-the-racist-roots-of-the-2nd-amendment?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAR1qBwFtv0tGvvWKbEpThlejNh7Kr0_XUJADzbDKqQtUCKXT4gGMWTIK_ww_aem_IxsVTfPdAPLvB6tLVFGu9w

and I had a hard time drawing the same conclusions as the author. Has anyone here conducted research on this topic?

5 Comments
2024/11/20
01:15 UTC

5

How do academic historians view the concept of “Western civilization” nowadays?

There is a recent book by Josephine Quinn titled How the World Made the West, whose stated aim is to challenge "civilizational thinking". In it, she says the following:

I will argue here that there has never been a single, pure Western or European culture. What are called Western values - freedom, rationality, justice, and tolerance - are not only or originally western, and the West itself is in large part a product of long-standing links with a much larger network of societies, to south and north as well as east.

Back in 2023 another book was released by Naoíse Mac Sweeney, titled The West: A New History in Fourteen Lives. Part of Sweeney's goal is to dismantle what she called the "grand narrative of Western civilization”.

These are not new opinions. For the past few years I've seen various articles similarly criticizing the concept of "Western civilization".

Is this a mainstream view in academia?

1 Comment
2024/11/20
01:14 UTC

4

Did Indigenous Americans Have Any Notions of the World Beyond the American Continent?

Hi guys, I was recently reading about encounters between Norse peoples and indigenous Americans during Leif Erikson's initial voyage to Vinland and subsequent attempts to further explore Vinland by other Norse peoples (e.g. Thorfinn Karlsefni). This led me to wonder if this encounter with non-indigenous peoples led the indigenous Americans to form some sort of conception of the world beyond their own; and, connected to this, if indeed the indigenous Americans already had some set of beliefs about what existed beyond their world, and how their encounter(s) with the Norsemen affected these beliefs? I find this especially interesting considering that, to my knowledge, indigenous Americans weren't a nautical people who explored the seas much, and so this also led me to wonder what sorts of beliefs they may have had about the open ocean? I'm not particularly well read in the historiography of either Viking history or pre-Colombian American history, so any insight would be appreciated!

1 Comment
2024/11/20
00:45 UTC

Back To Top