I started watching when it came out in fifth grade and I literally stopped being homophobic and found out I’m within the LGBTQIA spectrum because of this amazing show. It holds such a special place in my heart.

Since Josh Rush posted a picture of him and Luke Mullen hanging out with the caption "the return of Tyrus" (possible hint of something maybe? 👀) I've started thinking about the show again so I thought I'd make a major character tier list! Note that this is all relative and is based on how I overall would rank the major characters taking into account storylines, development, etc. across all 3 seasons.

S tier: Buffy, Cyrus, TJ

A tier: Marty, Amber, Celia

B tier: Bex, Bowie, Walker

C tier: Andi, Jonah

D tier: Miranda

F tier: Kira

We don't talk about tier: Ham

Lmk your thoughts/different opinions!

There's a new show on Netflix called DI4RIES - its italian TV show about group of kids that are in middle school and are dealing with their lives. After watching a few episodes, I realized it reminds me Andi Mack. The story is simple and chill, yet its kinda complex considering episodes have around 30 minutes and the rating is 7+. It also features queer characters (and they even show kiss between them) and neurodivergent character, and there are some other important themes.

I say you should give it shot, it would also help to boost views so the show gets renewed

I personally really like the premise of the show and I think this premise of someone’s apparent older sibling turning out to be their biological parent as something should be explored more so here’s what I’d do:

• Gender Swap: Andy Mack lives with his parents. He has an older 29yo brother Beck. On his 13th birthday, he discovers Beck is his biological father, cue drama.
• Gender Balanced Friend Group: He has three best friends since 5th grade.
  • A guy Liam who just came out as bi
  • A girl Olivia who is the youngest in a family of six siblings.
  • A girl Emma who who has an eating disorder
• Main Character Love Interest(s): Fraternal Twins named Micah (M) and Ariel (F)
• Liam's male love interest is the brother of Micah's female Ex Addison
• Non-parental siblings: As seen in the above points, lots of the characters actually have siblings.
• The second twist is that Olivia's oldest sibling is a 29 year sister who always seems to avoid Andy Mack when he is around and also seems to know Beck very well. Why? Well, at the end of Season 1 Andy will discover that she's his biological mother. And *that* causes a lot of interesting intrigue since it changes his relationship with Olivia (who is now also his aunt technically), her family, and shakes up the dynamics of the friend group.

What do you think?

Considering Amber used to be mean, do you think she and Kira would have been friends before Amber became nice?

View Poll

View Poll

Cyrus coming out for the first time in season 2 was the reason I got addicted to this show! I had never heard of Andi Mack until I read one day the Disney Channel had it’s first gay character, then watched the scene where he tells Buffy. It was really amazing to me especially since I grew up watching Disney Channel but never had that representation in the old shows. I remember that a few years earlier, Good Luck Charlie had an episode with two moms, but even that was a one-time thing. Other than his coming out, I love Cyrus’ character in general. He’s always so funny and loyal to his friends.

Crying right now from the memories.

Was Andi in the right to pursue Jonah even after she found out Cyrus had a crush on him? I say no because its just friend code right? Let me know what you guys think

That piano song is so perfect but I can't find it anywhere. I've checked tunefind, imdb . . . none of them say what the song is. Does anyone know what it is?

(the song that plays at 1:16 in this video, right after Cece says "I just climbed a mountain in heels!" : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KuG5FBaO97Q&list=PLeMCc6hO9BE7pykx1Mv1oBbxHPqwY0H-i&index=6)

I remember watching the first episode since I saw commercials for it and thought I’d check it out. I had told my friends about it who hadn’t watching it yet and we binge watched all the episodes out at the time (it was only up to S1 E5) I hadn’t seen episode 5 yet as it premiered that day and we watched it all together for the first time. We all lost our minds at the end with the boy that Amber was with wondering what would happen. We were total Jandi shippers at the time. It sucks we never learned who that boy was and it never turned into anything. My friends and I would attempt to get together to watch every episode. Most of the time we just would video chat while watching. I cried at Buffy leaving and Bex and Bowie’s wedding obviously. When news of the shows ending came to be, I cried. Don’t ask how many times. I’m surprised I still have tears in my tear ducts. We did have a viewing party for the series finale. We had Baby Taters, Milkshakes, Name Cookies, and made homemade bracelets like Andi would. This series is such a great part of my life and I can’t imagine my life without to be honest. Thank you Andi Mack, for all the amazing memories.

Personally I think I would lead us into the gang going in to high school now

I guess a turning of the page?

But based on the finale I think andi would go to sava and struggle keeping up with the other student so she gets assigned a "tutor" that being Walker

I didn't like how they written of Walker so poorly so it would be nice to see him come back

Andi and Walker talk about whats been happening between the two of them for the past year and walker wants to know why the group ghosted him

This would lead to Andi not wanting to tell walker the reason so I guess this would start the seasons first "conflict"

With the gang in HS now they go mostly through it without andi and the gang of Buffy, Cyrus and Jonah get lonley and feel like they are missing something

This is where Amber gets more involved with the group with them, now in the same HS as amber she begins to "show them the ropes" and a way for her to start being more nicer to the group instead of just andi

I feel like kira could be there to somehow and maybe her and Amber interact, going along with amber trying to be a nice girl Amber could try Kira to be more nicer in the same way Cyrus did with TJ

And sadly I feel like Bowie and Bex would just be somewhat of side characters here since they got married I don't see much of what they could do this season

maybe have walker show andI how to be more expressive and make her more rebelious

This would remind bex of her old self and try not to let andi become what she was going to this could also show cece how much more responsible she really is

I feel like TJ and Cyrus need to be more expressed as a couple esspecialy after waiting all of season 3 to see them together also going with andi macks way of teaching about touchy subjects I feel like it would be really good to see them talk about homophobia and same sex couples with them together now

Jonah definatly needs to work on himself maybe use cyrus's mom to get Jonah therapy sesions? Idk

(Also sorry for my bad spelling)

What do you guys think how would you flesh out season 4?

Sometimes I scroll through the Andi Mack tag on Tumblr and I get hit with a massive wave of nostalgia. I miss this show so much. I miss the fandom so much! I miss all the reactions to the episodes that EmmaDoodlebug, Ashlee Rose, Billy Maier, etc did. I miss all the crazy theories we made up after watching the promos. I miss the cast doing Instagram lives with each other. I miss everything about this show and fandom, but now it's gone....

Andi Mack really taught me a lot of things and even after two years of cancellation I am waiting for Season 4. Disney+ please give us Andi Mack's more seasons. We won't ask more from you🥺