/r/eulaw

Photograph via snooOG

Subreddit for discussion of European Union law and related topics.

Welcome to /r/eulaw!

This is a place for those interested in European Union law to discuss all legal aspects of the EU. Anyone with an interest in the law or institutions of the EU is welcome. We also welcome discussion about related laws and institutions, such as the European Convention on Human Rights.

Resources

Below are links to some online resources relating to EU law. If you have any suggested additions to this list please PM the mods.

Related subreddits

The below subreddits may be of interest to readers of /r/eulaw (but they are not affiliated with this subreddit). Again, if you have a suggested addition to this list, please PM the mods.

Disclaimer

This is a subreddit for the discussion of law, not for legal advice. Generally, when someone asks a question about how the law applies to their situation, we are happy to let the conversation develop, but please remember that such threads are merely academic discussions of the law by people who may or may not be experienced or knowledgable in the area. You should not take anything you read here as legal advice and if you think you may have a legal problem or require legal advice you should contact a lawyer in your jurisdiction.

/r/eulaw

5,234 Subscribers

3

Where do I actually find which fractions of the EU parliament voted in favor of the 2035 Ban on Sales of Gas-Powered Cars?

I just couldn't find the actual results of the actual vote, only news pages with statistics on specific countries.

Regards

0 Comments
2024/04/09
18:07 UTC

1

Licensure requirements

Is it necessary to have a Bar license for Germany or any other EU country to be an in-house counsel?

For instance, in India we need to not have a Bar license unless we want to practice. We can be in-house counsels without it.

I have 5 years of experience as an in-house counsel for a NASDAQ listed SaaS company working in the field of transaction (procurement, partnership and customers), Intellectual Property Rights and Data Privacy.

Can LLM in EU law or any other law be insightful to make this career transition?

Please guide. Need your help. I would greatly appreciate any insight.

0 Comments
2024/04/08
14:09 UTC

2

How to find if a case has been cited in newer cases?

Hey all, I am trying to see how many times a case I'm analyzing (C-417/99) has been cited in other cases, and I cannot find the way either in Curia or Eurlex.

Every case I search on Curia only gives me the judgment for that case; I cannot seem to find the references for the cases. Any help would be appreciated!

2 Comments
2024/04/07
17:00 UTC

2

Advise to be an in-house counsel at EU

I am an in-house counsel with over 5 years of experience at a Nasdaq listed SaaS company in India. I want to pursue LLM and work as an in-house counsel at either Germany or Luxembourg. Can any one advice what is the best way to go about this and does any of these countries have a requirement to hold a license to be an in-house counsel? In India we don't have to write a Bar exam and hold a license to be an in-house counsel but I am unsure about EU countries. It would be of great help if anyone could guide me to make my dreams come true. I would also appreciate if any one who has been through a similar journey to advise about the universities and the steps they took to be an in-house counsel.

0 Comments
2024/04/05
21:21 UTC

2

Advise to be an in-house counsel at EU

I am an in-house counsel with over 5 years of experience at a Nasdaq listed SaaS company in India. I want to pursue LLM and work as an in-house counsel at either Germany or Luxembourg. Can any one advice what is the best way to go about this and does any of these countries have a requirement to hold a license to be an in-house counsel? In India we don't have to write a Bar exam and hold a license to be an in-house counsel but I am unsure about EU countries. It would be of great help if anyone could guide me to make my dreams come true. I would also appreciate if any one who has been through a similar journey to advise about the universities and the steps they took to be an in-house counsel.

Thanks in advance for the help :)

0 Comments
2024/04/05
17:34 UTC

2

Anyone here that can help me with EUR LEX?

Anyone here that can help me with EUR LEX? I need to find something relevant for CBAM and EU ETS.

5 Comments
2024/04/02
09:56 UTC

5

How does the EU manage to take on wealthy corporations in ways that America cannot?

I am an American, new to this subreddit and this topic. I suspect that lobbying and political contributions are the obstacles in the US, but maybe not. What does the EU do to prevent corporate control of government?

7 Comments
2024/03/21
16:25 UTC

2

Flag desecration

Are there any laws in EU that prohibit desecration of a russian flag?

2 Comments
2024/03/17
13:07 UTC

2

How does Microsoft get away with no refunds in the EU with Minecraft Marketplace purchases?

They offer no refunds under any circumstance.

2 Comments
2024/03/15
18:27 UTC

6

Does the European Accessibility Act (EAA) apply to internal company tools?

Hi there 👋 I’ve been reading up on the European accessibility act for 2025 and I can’t find any information as to whether tools that companies only use internally (employee facing tools) our subject to the same rules as the other services listed.

I was wondering if anyone has any information on this that they could share? Thanks.

0 Comments
2024/03/12
14:53 UTC

3

Are there any criteria for a Court to be considered a court of last resort in the meaning of 267 TFEU?

Pretty self-explanatory question, just wondering if there is any case law where the CJEU expanded upon the meaning of a 'court or tribunal of a MS against whose decisions there is no judicial remedy under national law' in 267 TFEU.

2 Comments
2024/03/08
10:38 UTC

0

About EU Tax

I am wondering if let's say I am a citizen of a non EU Union country and a EU Union country (Both registered paying taxes, etc. Can I buy from webiste digital programs or games with my EU card with address of my non eu country and avoid higher price?

2 Comments
2024/02/23
19:02 UTC

0

A new institutional Model for the EU?

I've been thinking about the possibility of a new institutional model in which the EU Commission would be appointed by the EP and the Commission would have budgetary, legislative initiative and initiative in international agreements as well. The EP would also have legislative initiative and it would appreciate the Commission's proposals.

The Member States just designate the European Central Bank members and the State Members would only sign new treaties related to the expansion of the EU competences and authorizing the entry of new Member States.

So, do you think this model would work? Or is it better the current system?

2 Comments
2024/02/23
16:45 UTC

1

Working at an EU institution

Hey people!

I wanted to ask you about the prospects of a law career at an EU instition.

I read a lot about the topic here and of course at the official EU site about getting a permanent/contract work. However I would like to ask, that how hard it is to actually get a position to work at (be it permanent or contract).

I am currenctly studying still, however when I graduate I want to start with an internship at an institution so that I may be able to get some experience. After that, I will try to apply for the CAST law and some permanent positions. However I often read that the Grade 5 "begginer" jobs are just as hard to get into as any other. Besides that, I have quite the anxiety that I would not be called into any interviews and just sit in the database.

As I have mentioned I am studing currently still, but I want to do some traineeships (I am specificly aiming for the Chemical agency) so I want to find something which could give me an advantage. Besides that, I want to do a legal english exam too, since I already have a C1 english certificate and I am currently learning german for the 2nd language requirement. I also play to learn french for better success chances.

My questions would be: Is it possible at all to get into a position after graduationg (or after the traineship ends) and what could I do more to increase my chances of hire?

Thank you all for your responses and help!

9 Comments
2024/02/22
21:12 UTC

4

International law or european

Hey all,

Last year international high school student here.

Been looking into law schools in europe and i've come across 2 degrees frequently. One being international law the other being european law. I wanted to know what are the pros and cons of both? What are the job prospects like?

And what does european law entail? Allowing me to practice anywhere in europe? work for internatiol firms?

I know its competitive for sure, but what are the prospects like. Done some research over google but thought id get some insight from you lot.

8 Comments
2024/02/13
12:58 UTC

2

Is there any rule or law concerning who may use the European flag??

I intend to fly the European flag in Europe day on sort of a flagpole but I don’t know if there is any law or rule against that. Also note that I won’t do it in an EU territory.

Thanks in advance!!

5 Comments
2024/02/07
16:55 UTC

4

How exactly does AI influencer marketing work under current EU laws?

Hi everyone.

You've probably seen something or other about AI-generated influencer personas used by ad agencies and folks who want to be influencers but keep their faces private. Assuming it's run by a person, not an agency, how might a sponsorship contract for such a 'digital influencer' look?

Would the person generating the content fit the traditional 'manager slot' and the influnecer, the traditional 'influencer slot'? Or can you effectively only use this as a billboard for your own agency/service/product, a la Clueless Agency (the Aitana Lopez people).

From a legal perspective, how does any of this work?

3 Comments
2024/02/07
09:14 UTC

2

Consumer protection

Hello! :)

I really need your help. If you could tell me what I can do in this situation I would greatly appreciate it!

I bought tickets from Viagogo, for a Big Time Rush concert happening 7th of July in Poland. I understand that I should have done more research on the page before, but I was really desperate and in a hurry to get them, so beforehand when checking quickly it seemed pretty legit, only after purchasing did I see really bad reviews as well.

So now, they told me I would receive my tickets on the day of the concert? When asked why would I receive them 4 months after buying, they said it's due to the tickets being sold in patches, all though the tickets have already been sold out by now and there will be no more releases.

They told me that if I do not wish to have the tickets anymore I can resell them on the website and they ignore me saying I wish them to just send me my money back. To the question of how would I even sell tickets that I don't have and would receive the day of the concert they didn't have much to say, only eventually promising they would make sure the tickets would make it from the original seller to the one I sell to. Which I obviously don't wish to do, as I would become a scammer myself then.

They say tickets are non-refundable, but after digging around online, it has been said that they don't release the money to the seller before the buyer has assured they got into the event. So even though they say they are a website from which citizens buy and sell, they are clearly able to control the money being transferred.

Also, it is advertised that you can pay with PayPal but when I got to the purchasing part it only let me pay with a credit card, so I can't use PayPal guarantee either.

I have asked them multiple times, if this EU law (Below), to my understanding their headquarters are in Switzerland, does not apply to them. So far they have ignored the question every time and changed the subject.

Please let me know if you have suggestions on what I should do next.

The law:

14-day right of withdrawal under the EU Consumer Rights Directive: If you sell over the Internet to consumers residing within the European Union, you have to offer them a right of withdrawal. This means that the buyer can return the item within a certain timeframe (at least 14 days) without giving any reasons. Generally speaking, the seller has to refund the full price of the item as well as the shipping costs and other fees to the buyer, unless the item is returned in a damaged condition. - EU consumer protection laws are always applicable when the seller sells to consumers residing in the EU, regardless of where he is operating his business (e.g. the US, China, Hong Kong, etc.)

3 Comments
2024/02/06
18:06 UTC

1

[US Citizen] When would I do passport control when leaving an EU nation?

I've only flown internationally once before--from Spain to Turkiye, then immediately from Turkiye to the US. We checked in with Spain's passport control, because, leaving the Schengen Area. We stayed at a hotel in the airport in Turkiye, so we never left the international zone, so no passport control.

These are the questions:

  1. I believe the requirement for US citizens to apply for a EU travel visa has been delayed until 2025. Is this correct?

  2. Let's say I am traveling from Madrid to Lisbon. I'm staying a couple of days there before resuming my trip back to the States. The ticket was purchase as a "layover", so I'm ticketed through from Madrid to my destination US location.

Do I still check in with passport control in Spain, or just get on my plane (because, Schengen zone nation to Schengen zone nation), and just check in with passport control in Lisbon when going home?

4 Comments
2024/01/30
17:22 UTC

0

Law on hydraulic replacement in chairs by consumer?

Is there a law that mandates a furniture company in the EU to conduct the repair of hydraulic cylinders in chairs, such that the customer does not have to do it themselves?

For example, the companies must either open official service centers nearby or send a professional technician to homes/offices for repairs related to hydraulic cylinders in chairs.

Is there such a thing?

1 Comment
2024/01/24
06:42 UTC

1

Proposal for Amendments to EU Laws Regarding Cash Payments and Emergency Measures

Context: Anti-money laundering: Council and Parliament strike deal on stricter rules

Please comment on my proposal related to the recent changes in EU rules on cash transactions. My native language is Bulgarian so I asked ChatGPT to help me with this proposal (to express my idea in English and in a proper format). I made some minor edits.

This is my first draft in English:

Subject: Proposal for Amendments to EU Laws Regarding Cash Payments and Emergency Measures

Dear [Recipient's Name],

I hope this proposal finds you well. In light of the current geopolitical situation, I would like to suggest amendments to the existing EU laws, specifically focusing on cash payments and introducing a rapid mechanism for lifting restrictions on cash transactions in case of force majeure circumstances.

Background: In times of peace, restrictions on cash payments have been implemented with the intention of increasing tax revenues, ultimately contributing to the financial resources available for various purposes, including defense. The idea is to channel these funds towards acquiring weapons for our defense reserves or supporting nations like Ukraine in their efforts to defend themselves against external threats, particularly from Russia.

Proposal: Considering the volatile geopolitical landscape, it is crucial to incorporate a mechanism that allows for the swift removal of restrictions on cash transactions in cases of force majeure. This would necessitate the intervention of key authorities listed below, ensuring a balanced and responsive approach to unforeseen circumstances:

  1. Minister of Finance or their Designee
  2. President of the Member State
  3. Prime Minister

Additionally, if none of the above authorities are able to issue directives promptly, the proposal suggests empowering the individual in charge of the military command to take decisive action.

Key Points:

  • Force Majeure Definition: Clearly define force majeure circumstances, encompassing situations that are beyond the control of the EU member states and pose a threat to the stability and security of the region.
  • Decision-Making Process: Establish a streamlined decision-making process whereby the Minister of Finance (or their designee), President, and Prime Minister have the authority to lift cash transaction restrictions individually. If none are available or capable of making decisions, grant this authority to the military commander as a last resort.
  • Communication and Reporting: Mandate transparent communication and reporting procedures to ensure that the public and relevant stakeholders are informed of the decisions and their justifications.

Conclusion: These proposed amendments aim to strike a balance between financial prudence during peacetime and the imperative need for swift decision-making in times of crisis. By introducing this flexible mechanism, we can ensure the EU's ability to respond promptly and effectively to unforeseen events, thereby safeguarding the interests and security of our member states.

Thank you for considering this proposal. I look forward to your insights and collaboration in enhancing the resilience and adaptability of our legal framework.

11 Comments
2024/01/20
17:57 UTC

2

francovich as a 'resolution'

Thoughts on Francovich and principle of state liability actually weakening EC law where its priorities are naive in wanting supremacy over the national legal order?

1 Comment
2024/01/10
15:49 UTC

2

3y warranty on electronic devices

Hey, I was told in another subreddit that the warranty period on electronic devices is 3 years for all purchases from 2022-01-01 on. I tried hard to find any information regarding a 3 year warranty, but my sources only say there's a minimum of 2 years.

Where does that 3 year warranty come from?

2 Comments
2024/01/08
20:16 UTC

4

Fight redirected

Hi, I was travelling from Frankfurt to Sarajevo. However, my flight has been redirected to Zagreb. After looking up EU law, the EU website says one of the options I am allowed as for them to rebook my flight.

The airline are refusing to do this though because they are saying that when we stepped off the plane we were agreeing to their terms and their only offering a bus to Sarajevo, which is 7hrs+.

Does anyone know what my rights are in the situation and what I should do next? I am still in Zagreb airport.

8 Comments
2024/01/07
16:40 UTC

1

EU background check - Danish Public and Private criminal record.

I have been living in Denmark for the last 6 years and I am applying for a job in another EU country. I work for the financial and insurance sector. Often they hire third parties such as Sterling Talent to conduct background and criminal checks.

Often, I am required to sign a consent but it doesn’t specify from where they will pull the data.

The Danish Politi site explains that the Private record is the one you can get yourself as a citizen and the Public is only for government and other specific cases.

Q1 - Where do these companies such as Sterling get the criminal record in Denmark?

Q2 - Can Sterling Talent or similar companies access the Public record?

5 Comments
2023/12/31
03:15 UTC

2

Scholarly Journals

I'm seeking recommendations for scholarly journals specializing in International Armed Conflict, International Humanitarian Law, and International Conflict Studies, with a preference for accessible and comprehensible content suitable for a deeper understanding and reading of these topics. Thanks in advance.

0 Comments
2023/12/30
07:22 UTC

Back To Top