/r/wildanimalsuffering
Content and discussion for the evaluation and optimization of wild-animal welfare.
We believe that the well-being and interests of nonhuman animals in the wild should be of great moral concern to humanity.
In sober truth, nearly all the things which men are hanged or imprisoned for doing to one another, are nature's every day performances. [...] The phrases which ascribe perfection to the course of nature can only be considered as the exaggerations of poetic or devotional feeling, not intended to stand the test of a sober examination. No one, either religious or irreligious, believes that the hurtful agencies of nature, considered as a whole, promote good purposes, in any other way than by inciting human rational creatures to rise up and struggle against them.
— John Stuart Mill, “On Nature”
Found a wild animal that you think needs help? Please refer to this post on /r/WildlifeRehab.
Recommended reading:
Support research into wild animal suffering and stewardship of nature by donating to:
Related subreddits:
Our comment policy is “Victorian Sufi Buddha Lite”: comments should be at least two of {true, necessary, kind}.
/r/wildanimalsuffering
Once we are done shutting down the human run animal concentration camps, I believe we just need a bit of technology to end predation in the wild. In fact, I would argue that we could already do so for some species.
Step 1: experiment in a park, so that you can study the effects and practical implications of your plan.
Step 2: sterilize predator species one at a time.
Step 3: sterilize some members of herbivore species selectively. If one animal has more babies than the average, sterilize it. Rince and repeat until you end up with animals that don't breed much.
I believe that one of the main obstacles to the idea of eliminating wild predators is that we humans currently abuse animals by consuming their corpse. This creates a conflict of interest: humans do not tend to be able to understand why their actions are wrong if they benefit from them. However, once lab meat, climate change make veganism a reality, the cognitive dissonance will stop. It is entirely possible that we are witnessing the end of predation, beggining with humans, to be followed by other species.
Launching Screwworm-Free Future – Funding and Support Request https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/d2HJ3eysBdPoiZBnJ/launching-screwworm-free-future-funding-and-support-request
TL;DR
Screwworm Free Future is a new group seeking support to advance work on eradicating the New World Screwworm in South America. The New World Screwworm (C. hominivorax - literally "man-eater") causes extreme suffering to hundreds of millions of wild and domestic animals every year. To date we’ve held private meetings with government officials, experts from the private sector, academics, and animal advocates. We believe that work on the NWS is valuable and we want to continue our research and begin lobbying. Our analysis suggests we could prevent about 100 animals from experiencing an excruciating death per dollar donated, though this estimate has extreme uncertainty. The screwworm “wall” in Panama has recently been breached, creating both an urgent need and an opportunity to address this problem. We are seeking $15,000 to fund a part-time lead and could absorb up to $100,000 to build a full-time team, which would include a team lead and another full-time equivalent (FTE) role We're also excited to speak to people who have a background in veterinary science/medicine, entomology, gene drives, as well as policy experts in Latin America. - please reach out if you know someone who fits this description!
I've been attending today's Animal Liberation March in Poland's capital, Warsaw. From what I heard there were never so many people, so a record was set, and it really looked to be so! Animal Liberation March is the biggest vegan march in Poland, and I feel so happy I could take part in it for another year. Seeing all those people caring about animal suffering is great and makes me feel hopeful. As usually, I try to spread awareness about Wild Animal Suffering on such events, because many vegans are not familiar with the concept and the importance of it. I share my sign from the march. Let's hope the promoting ethics and empathy will eventually make place for a constructive discussion about the problem of wild animal suffering and the position of it in a coherent moral ideology. Thank You all the people who alk about it, read about it, and think about it, as You are at the forefront of the future.
Biodiversitätsinitiative dilemma
Hello
I'm facing a bit of a dilemma & would love to hear your opinion on this. Faced with the alarming decline of animal species, plants & ecosystems, I have always voted green & supported initiatives to increase biodiversity. Recently, however, I've been reflecting on my values & realised that I don't see intrinsic value in nature itself. Instead, I value the well-being of sentient creatures within it. So of course we're all heavily reliant on nature.
This brings me to the upcoming biodiversity initiative. Whilst it aims to protect & enhance biodiversity, I'm actually & seriously concerned about the potential increase in animal suffering. According to the concepts of r- and k-selection in ecology, species can be categorised based on their reproductive strategies:
R-selected species produce many offspring with little parental care, resulting in high mortality rates & often harsh living conditions.
K-selected species have fewer offspring but invest more in their care, resulting in a higher survival rate.
In nature, many animals, especially R-selected species, suffer significant suffering due to predation, disease & starvation. Negative utilitarians, who focus on reducing suffering, argue that in the natural world there is often more suffering than well-being or happiness. There are more R-selective species.
In view of this perspective, I'm torn. On the one hand, I would like to support biodiversity & the protection of natural habitats. On the other hand, I'm worried that increasing biodiversity could inadvertently lead to more animal suffering.
I'm aware that I've an extremely controversial stance here (especially as a vegan). I would therefore like to have these concerns challenged.
I recently saw this interesting video (in Dutch, but you can autotranslate in YouTube) which describes the re-introducing of the wild cat (a seperate species from the housecat) back into the Netherlands. In the video they describe how the wild cat returning actually helps wildlife by scaring away housecats who go in groups. Are there other such examples where relatively little work can be done to have such an impact in reducing animal suffering, even by something so seemingly contradictory as reintroducing a predator?
Parasitism is an unmitigated evil-an evil that cuts two ways. It results in the degeneracy of the parasite; and in the host species it causes immense destruction while contributing little or nothing to the evolutionary development of that species-perhaps even causing retrogression if the parasitism is heavy.
Among plants, I am familiar with no important structural modifications that might with confidence be attributed to the selective influence of parasites.
Among animals, parasites appear to have had strangely little effect in modifying either structure or habits.
We may lament the tremendous loss of life, even up to the extermination of whole species, brought about by the competition between individual and individual in a crowded world, and by the habit of one living thing preying upon another. But at least this competition and this predation have been fruitful in the progressive development of organisms in myriad diverse ways. Parasitism has taken its tremendous toll of life with scarcely any return that we can see; it has led to retrogression rather than to progress. Hence, we may call it the greatest evil of life.
The parasites among men are those who exist through the efforts of other men, producing nothing themselves. They include the idle rich who live in sloth on inherited fortunes, the shiftless poor who live on charity or such windfalls as they can find, the thief, the swindler, the forger, the smuggler, and the panderer to the vices and follies of men.
Among men, as among all other organ- isms, parasitism is the absolute and unmixed evil-the evil that cuts two ways. For the parasite it results in moral and often, too, in intellectual and physical degeneration; for the hosts-the rest of society-it causes tremendous losses with no compensating gains.
We got a young cat because my wife really wanted another one & always had at least one. I'm now thinking about how we can make sure that we avoid any additional suffering caused by keeping this cat. He has an enormous urge to go outside (which we currently only do with a lead). She occasionally tries to snap at insects. We currently play with her often & regularly. I have heard that a small bell could warn birds early enough sometimes. Does anyone have any recommended reading and/or tips & tricks?
Also what's best to feed her?