/r/LessCredibleDefence

Photograph via snooOG

Welcome to LessCredibleDefence - the home of links which have failed to pass the quality requirement of r/CredibleDefense. This community exists for sharing & discussing anecdotes, tidbits, historical events, current news/events, weapon sales/developments, and more

Welcome to LessCredibleDefence - the home of links which have failed to pass the quality requirement of r/CredibleDefense. This community exists for sharing & discussing anecdotes, tidbits, historical events, current news/events, weapon sales/developments, and more

Pay attention to the rules or your time here will be shortlived.

  1. No Ad-Hominem attacks No attacking the character, motive, or some other attribute of the person making an argument rather than addressing the substance of the argument itself. Simply put, keep it civil.

  2. Do not violate OPSEC, COMSEC, INFOSEC, PERSEC Do not post any content which violates OPSEC, COMSEC, INFOSEC, PERSEC (or PII), and do not post or ask about anything classified. Direct links to detailed transcripts, images, or files of leaked material will result in a no warning ban. Failure to follow the rules could result in a ban.

  3. No asking for money No asking for money or advertising. We can make exceptions for non-profit organizations but please send us a message before posting. This includes asking for help with homework or research projects. Failure to follow the rules could result in a ban.

  4. Moderators have the final say The /r/lesscredibledefence moderators reserve the right to moderate the subreddit how we see fit for the good of the community. Just because a #Rule is not listed does not mean we cannot enforce it (i.e. promoting terrorism, racist comments, etc). Do not try to debate the mod on your interpretation of the #Rules

  5. Posting Moratoriums On occasion there may be a spate of posting about international events that more properly belong in /r/geopolitics or one of the other international news subs. Moratoriums about the subject may be implemented by moderators in this case.

Looking for a place with even less credibility? /r/NonCredibleDefense might be for you.

Looking for a place that's strictly procurement related? Check out /r/MilitaryProcurement

/r/LessCredibleDefence

27,315 Subscribers

14

Logistical issues with ACE versus China

One of the largest vulnerabilities the US has vis a vis China is that in the western pacific most of its eggs are in a few vulnerable baskets like Guam Kadena etc. The idea is that if China saturates these places the US can be massively hampered in terms of sorties, attrition to their equipment etc.

The solution the US military has come up with (from my research) seems to be "agile combat employment " aka ACE which says the US will distribute bases across the region so they aren't as concentrated. The logistical issue with this is

  1. How does the US plan to get fuel to these distributed air strips? Will they pre position lots of fuel and how long will these fuel depots last for?
  2. Will there be enough spare parts?
  3. Will there be enough ammo stored?
  4. Will there be the required number of technical maintenance and repair specialists on these various islands? I can imagine demand would be high for these skills so can the US afford to distribute them. If these crews on dispersed islands are small they can be very vulnerable to attrition. You can have 99% of your crew working but if you don't have the guy who can look after engines the plane won't sortie.
  5. How vulnerable will individual units be to attrition of certain key assets? To quote WOTR "what if losing that logistics aircraft results in the flameout of a dozen other aircraft expecting to rendezvous with the tanker on their precarious return from a distant strike?". Basically, if planes are distributed and a certain squadron relies on one tanker, of that one tanker disappears will that squadron essentially become inoperable?

Am I missing something or does this plan seem to be a little bit logistically shaky. When you take into account China will be targeting every single tanker, UNREP etc won't ACE run into issues?

16 Comments
2024/10/30
13:30 UTC

5

Canada defense strategy and issues- Procurement disasters and the arctic & alliances.

2 Comments
2024/10/28
06:33 UTC

Back To Top