Hey everyone, I've been rewatching Supernatural and with watching the earlier seasons as well as seeing some discussion on this subreddit it seems to me that there are multiple hypothesises about Sam's ability and desire to want to go back to a normal life, I was wondering about everyone's thoughts on it and more specifically, what episode was his 'point of no return [to the normal life]' if you think there was one (or multiple).

I think my opinion on the subject has kind of shifted with this rewatch as where I first thought the point of no return was in one of the later seasons I now really thought of the season 1 episode 'scarecrow' as his moment, as here it shows not only him choosing Dean over his desire for revenge (which I originally thought to be his primary motive for all of season 1 and 2 to stay in the life) and finding his dad, but it also literally sees him picking Dean over running away in general, in the beginning of the episode he's still pretty much 'i need revenge and we need to find dad and after that I'm gone' but in the end he helps save Dean and joins him again. Basically I think this moment shows that Sam would not want to leave hunting if it meant not being around Dean. Fitting to another topic but I think this going back to Dean in scarecrow is also the moment he starts being afraid of losing Dean, that something might genuinely happen to him if he isn't there (which then gets shown even more clearly in the episode faith)

Imagine the boys doing the Dukes of Hazzard hood slide on Baby🤣

i posted just a few minutes ago about season 2 ep 10 bc of a song that i love that appeared and ten minutes later supermassive black hole by muse plays in the background, music wise this ep has been amazing for me, also if u didn’t know that song appears in twilight, ik some of y’all don’t like twilight but give the music a chance it’s amazing

the music is amazing on this show, i can’t believe there are songs that i love but i didn’t notice on my first watch, im on season 2 episode 10 and at the beginning white rabbit by jefferson airplane starts playing and i love that song! last time i watched it i was like 14 so honestly it was such a pleasing surprise, i first heard of the song in the movie sucker punch a couple years ago idk if anyone knows it but i find it really cool, tbh i thought the song was a bit more underground than i thought 😆 apparently it’s a classic since i’ve heard it now in like three different projects

So I just finished the finale of season 2 and I was obviously sad, but prepared to keep watching UNTIL I stupidly but accidentally spoiled the series ending for myself. I am SO MAD that Dean and Sam don’t get to live a mortal life together. I know that Sam comes to heaven fast (for Deans perspective) but I can’t deal with the fact that Sam had to deal with Dean dying permanently and the two of them never getting a normal life. Sooo, if I keep watching, when would be a good season to stop? I hear that after the first several seasons, it goes downhill anyways, so is there a season finale in the meantime that kinda gives a happy ending and I can ignore the rest of the show? (This was also just a vent bc I am so mad at that ending) ty!

i was never really a fan of Leviathans

which is weird considering they did the most damage to the Winchesters

I see a lot of people really into the Dean/Castiel romance thing, and I was stoked for it- because I thought it would be such a fun thing to add to the show…

But I don’t see it. The ‘romantic things’ people mention, really look just like Dean being a bro, and Castiel not getting anything. I was expecting way more fun and tension-like things.

I’m only at season 7, so I get that there might be more… but most of the moment people point out seem to be behind me.

—— I do get that in season 15 or something Castiel talks about his love for Dean and I even forwarded to that, and it still feels totally lacking in romantic vibes.

It really feels like people are reaching so intensely! But I’m open to being wrong.

What happened to the shapeshifters body? Like did it stay there for the police to find and close the case or...?

If you had the chance to go to a con what would you ask them? And who do you wanna ask a question to?

I’ve rewatched too many times. Would love suggestions (books, shows, movies, whatever) to help fill the void 💔

https://preview.redd.it/z26bwwvumdge1.jpg?width=448&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5f5697b3123962fa9dcda89b59427afc70f641cc

https://preview.redd.it/njtdzvwvmdge1.jpg?width=622&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=83fa77b322500aaec0aa7e0882567101247066e1

I love them both and I can see both being fun things to do as a person who enjoys quality time LOL

I have so many but I would say their conversation at the end of Sacrifice (8x23).

When Virgil is "clearing up" the set, Gopher dodges 2 gunshots then steps back behind the set without freaking out or anything, almost as if he has powers. Is this explained anywhere why that is? Time stamp: 37m50s. Apologies for the bad English

2ep left for the end of supernatural, i feel like my heart has been ribbed out of my chest, my poor castiel… my sweet angel… and dean, I’m in awe.

I’m never recovering from this, this is it I can’t anymore

God! Why why why

Omfgg, please no tell me it’s a joke that it’s not ending this way… it gets worse before it gets better right? Right??? :<

So please correct me if I'm wrong, but I just kind of had an epiphany of sorts during my last lunch. I kept thinking about a theory video I watched about Crowley's smoke being red, and now I kind of seemed to connect some dots for what I imagine to be a nice head canon.

So, Dean was offered to torture souls instead of enduring such moments himself by Alistair, right? My idea was: what if new crossroads demons do go through that torture as expected, but someone else (king of the crossroads?) makes them a different offer, that to work for hell and gather new souls, to spare further torture whilst still ensuring it is efficient? Now, I do realise I might just be confused and have somehow forgotten a key element about them in the main show or some other lore source, but I don't know. That could explain why especially their eyes are different, as they are literally born out a mostly different path than the regular black eyed demons.

I just finished and started s11 but noticed there was no season summary w/ the season-ending song, no “The Road So Far”. it was just immediately right into the episode. made me a bit sad for a moment that it’s suddenly changed in s10

How do you think SpringTrap would handle himself in supernatural purgatory??

https://preview.redd.it/ddoalxs43bge1.png?width=414&format=png&auto=webp&s=774214254e6d7d3e0dc8a7775d181992ccba1724

I know nothing about maintaining cars. Is it actually possible to drive a classic car for 30 years? How realistic is the show when it comes to that?

Is it one of those things where you can maintain the outside body of the car and you just have to replace parts (engine, carburetor, etc) over time? I've never known anyone that had the same car for more than 5 years. People always say to buy cars with low mileage. What happens when the mileage reaches the maximum??? I bet Baby has driven for millions of miles.

Any insight is appreciated. Thanks!

https://preview.redd.it/ipfrrgso4dge1.png?width=501&format=png&auto=webp&s=8fcf52db86b60eadf33c76f214066b1e1384cd6f

I get that Dean was bummed out after everything happened but his constant whining about Jack really gets me. Like stfu dude give it some rest. He always treats everyone around him as punching bag. First Sam, then Cass, then Crowley and the Mary he always has to pick up fights.

Just watched the episode in which Hannah(the angel) leaves Caroline‘s body and I’ve got a question…

In season 9 Gadreel makes it very clear that because Sam was his vessel he could eject him at any time/if he wanted to. Doesn’t that mean that in the earlier seasons Jimmy Novak could have ejected Cas anytime he wanted? I mean he didn’t seem happy about being Cas‘ vessel and he had wanted out of the whole ordeal while Cas was using him…couldn’t he just have done that?

Idk am I missing something 😭

I totally think it was a missed opportunity on the writers and in universe on Lucifer’s part to not dress up as a clown one time to really torture Sam. “Hi Sammy it’s Lucifer the Clown!!!” He already dressed up as Santa in Rowena’s Dream

And there have been a lot of them, with all kinds of magic and powers. Rowena clearly takes the cake for being the queen she is, but who would be your top five without her included?

Were the Horseman’s “steeds” perfect for them? Or would you replace any/all of them?

Imagine a video game for supernatural in the format of a game like Red Dead 2. An open world game with a main story line and tons of side quests and paths you can take while you hunt, explore, learn magic, and etc. Two main characters are Sam and Dean and you can decide who to play as and the path each takes. A game on that level of good like read dead but implemented with all the lore and story of supernatural would be absolutely unreal and amazing. Imagine playing and there being side missions with NPCs and lore where u can check up on them and depending on how you handle the situation/mission the npc will align with that. A game of that caliber with that many options, paths, monsters, and things to do as a hunter would generate millions and satisfy millions. I know it will probably never happen but the thought of it just seems so cool. Literally exactly how read dead is in terms of open world, so so many options, great npcs/ side tasks, and etc but tweaked to where it fits perfectly within the realm of supernatural.

As a quick recap, near the end of the episode, Lucifer and Gabriel are both armed with angel blades and are fighting with the intention to kill each other. Then Lucifer stabbed a fake Gabriel and believed he had really died. But wouldn't they both know that those blades aren't able to kill an archangel? I can get behind the pagan gods not knowing that from when they "killed" Gabriel earlier in the episode. But not the Archangels themselves.

in creating supernatural scrapbooking 😭🙏