/r/StarcraftFeedback

Photograph via snooOG

This is a Subreddit for anyone looking to get Analysis Requests on replays, or for anyone looking to review player games.

  • Please use This to share replays.

Related Subreddits

/r/AllThingsTerran
/r/starcraft_strategy
/r/starcraft2_class

/r/StarcraftFeedback

493 Subscribers

1

r/StarcraftFeedback needs moderators and is currently available for request

If you're interested and willing to moderate and grow this community, please go to r/redditrequest, where you can submit a request to take over the community. Be sure to read through the faq for r/redditrequest before submitting.

0 Comments
2019/11/21
02:42 UTC

1

Lambo vs Zanster | Game 2 | ROUND 1 | WCS Montreal | Starcraft 2

1 Comment
2018/12/15
13:13 UTC

2

2vs2 Casual Match Replay [Humor/Spanish]

0 Comments
2016/10/05
09:06 UTC

1

Complete noob here, looking for some pointers

So, I got into StarCraft about a month ago, and I am basically terrible. I play terran.

So anyways, I have three replays I would like feedback on. I mainly just want some general feedback. I also have a few specific questions.

First off, I know you're supposed to be pretty much constantly producing SCVs, and I am bad at this. Are there any specific pointers for this? I mean I put my CCs on hotkeys, but I get distracted by other things going on. Second, I got LotV two days ago, so I'm not used to the timings. What should I be doing here?

Here are the replays: http://ggtracker.com/matches/6400701

http://ggtracker.com/matches/6400703 On this one, I feel like I had a better army and economy than the other player, but I just got absolutely wrecked by his lurkers. What should I have done differently?

http://ggtracker.com/matches/6400706 On this one, I knew the canon rush was happening, but I wasn't able to effectively prevent it. How should I have handled that situation?

0 Comments
2016/01/14
17:22 UTC

2

TvZ | Defended early baneling aggro, never got game back..

Bronze league.. I'm the terran. I think I defended off the banelings pretty decently, but I never got back, which i should have. Few mistakes I noticed was that i didn't mine with 3 mules after pulling, so no income.. then it prolly went hell from there.

http://drop.sc/379400

0 Comments
2014/04/26
23:51 UTC

2

Need help in my Zerg play. I have no idea how to improve. Any help would be nice, thanks!

Like the title says, I have no idea how to improve my Zerg play. I'm not sure if anyone actually uses this subreddit anymore but I figured it's worth a try. Here's a replay:Replay!

Thanks in advance!

2 Comments
2013/11/13
05:53 UTC

1

Accidentally joined a game that wasn't Co-Op VS AI, went up against a Platinum Zerg player. Feedback appreciated!

I was wondering if you guys wouldn't mind watching the replay and tell me what I SHOULD have done differently. It was my first game against a real person, and I feel like there's a lot to learn from it. Thank you for your time!

http://drop.sc/337827

25 minute long replay.

4 Comments
2013/05/26
02:21 UTC

1

PVP, gold league. What to do against voids/archon?

Replay: http://drop.sc/326599 Everytime I try to understand PVP I'm always left confused.

In hindsight, I might have needed to harass a bit with the blink stalkers :/, improve engagement micro (esp with blink) and work on macro.. but I cant think of anything else.

Any help/criticism would be appreciated, thanks.

4 Comments
2013/04/22
14:52 UTC

3

Bronze PvT; Can I get some advice on how to play better in general?

http://drop.sc/316523

I know I did many things wrong, but any advice would be appreciated!

1 Comment
2013/04/01
00:31 UTC

1

ZvP What could I have done better? (replay included)

http://drop.sc/315891

Played a ZvP and not quite sure what I could have done better. Some things I picked up myself is that my overlord on his third was positioned wrong (could have hit his 3rd maybe if I saw it on time). And my army wasn't together when I defended, but not sure if that would have made enough difference.

2 Comments
2013/03/30
19:04 UTC

1

2 replays both ZvP

http://drop.sc/312618 (game1) and http://drop.sc/312615 (game2). Out of the 9 games I played so for these are my only 2 losses. Both ZvP but both very different.

In game1 I think I know what went wrong mechanically. I saw one base P but didn't react accordingly, I should have gone either roaches/banelings or spines I guess. But other stuff might have held me down too.

In game2, well he was diamond which I am clearly not. Don't think I was even suppose to win this but it was somewhat close. Any ideas what I could better here are greatly appreciated.

0 Comments
2013/03/23
20:01 UTC

1

ZvP HotS First ranked game (plat? see description)

My first HotS ranked game, as zerg. In WoL I went from plat to bronze all the way back to plat near the end. So I am probably plat but not sure. I would love some feedback on what needs my attention to improve upon.

http://drop.sc/311720

0 Comments
2013/03/20
21:47 UTC

2

SC1 sounds in SC

Hello, i dont know where else to post this questions so sorry if this is a little OT. I wanted to ask if there is still an option to insert the SC1 sounds into SC2. The way i was using (editing mpq) was terminated with the 1.5 patch. I would be glad for any method, thank you very much! :)

0 Comments
2013/02/11
00:58 UTC

1

(Gold PvT EU) How do I improve on my below average PvT? - Replay inside. (Crosspost from AllThingsProtoss)

0 Comments
2013/02/01
07:31 UTC

2

[Bronze P] Getting Silly Now... Can't win anything. Help Please :)

Ok so I'm playing in the HOTS beta, I've yet to win any games.

2 Replays below.

  • Short game PvP - Was planning FFE my standard play. I noticed he was already dropping gates so I correctly assumed 4 gate. Binned the expo and started defensive 4 gate play. Still got stomped.
  • Zerg Macrogame, Pretty even all the way then got crushed. No idea how :<

http://cl0ne.co.uk/~cl0ne/Starcraft/PvP%20-%20Failed%20Defensive%204%20gate.SC2Replay http://cl0ne.co.uk/~cl0ne/Starcraft/PvZ%20-%20Loose.SC2Replay

Please watch and help, Its starting to get annoying im not sure what im doing wrong :(

Thanks.

1 Comment
2013/01/18
16:37 UTC

1

[Plat - US - ZvZ] need help with my zvz!

I lose almost every ZvZ. Which doesn't help since there are a million Zerg players. I have 4 replays, all of which I did 15/15/15 opening. If anyone can help me ingame as well, that would be great. ID : ZmB char code: 691

Thank you!

http://drop.sc/286753 http://drop.sc/286751 http://drop.sc/286752 http://drop.sc/286750

3 Comments
2012/12/22
07:37 UTC

3

Gold [TvP] I don't know what I could have done more

This replay pretty much sums up my experience trying to play macro vs protoss.

http://drop.sc/282296

I'm only gold but I seem to be always ahead macro and upgrades wise and against the toss but I just seem to always lose.

Sorry about the slight bm from me at the end as I was pretty mad.

3 Comments
2012/12/06
23:35 UTC

2

PvZ Platinum, need help!

http://drop.sc/274719

The only two things that i can see that i did wrong were:

  1. Totally failed at my timing attack on his third with +1 zealots..
  2. Stayed on blink stalker too long by the time he got Broodlord Infestor, So maybe i need to transition into late game sooner?

Any help or tips or anything would be awesome, thanks!

Oh, I'm the Protoss btw...

2 Comments
2012/11/12
12:24 UTC

8

[Bronze P] 10 Games, 1 win.

From newest to oldest, all ladder unless stated otherwise:

Notice that while in one of those games I "win" (the PvZ in Ohana), I think the other player either had a DC or was just giving me points.

So... I'm trying, I practice, I watched dApollo's tutorials, I watch my replays, I watch the streamers, I watch the Day[9] Dailies, I tried to learn a few Build Orders, but I have no idea what to do and what I'm doing wrong. Please take a look at some of my replays, if someone can help me, I really want to improve...

8 Comments
2012/11/06
03:22 UTC

3

(Plat PvP) A late game PvP on Antiga Shipyard, One of my better games any tips on my play would be great

2 Comments
2012/10/25
00:05 UTC

2

[Gold, NA, ZvZ] I felt like I let a victory slip away from me, but I don't know where it went wrong.

Replay Here.

I've been doing nothing but FilterSC's 2 base mass roach style ever since I started playing SC2 about 50 days ago.

So I was going 14 pool/15 hatch. My opponent was apparently going zergling/baneling off one base.

I hold off several offensive waves with minimal drone loss, by the time he decides that he wouldn't be able to finish soon, I've banked a lot of mineral. So as soon as he eases off, I take 2 expansions.

He does the same, but I was able to snipe off his 3rd.

So I'm up on drone count and I thought my macro was so far ahead that I was going to be able to flood him with units.

I thought I would push the advantage even more by getting mutalisks (and this is maybe where I may have gone horribly wrong).

He went with hydra + roach.

I lost soon after.


Well, I'm Gold. I know that at lower leagues, the compositions don't matter as much as solid macro. But I thought I was ahead in that front.

This was the first game that really had me perplexed about how I lost.

Some feedback would be greatly appreciated.

1 Comment
2012/10/01
11:09 UTC

0

What's a computer good enough to allow me to play starcraft without lag? (sorry if this is the wrong subreddit)

I just moved back home and all I have is this crappy laptop to play SC2 on and when it gets late into games it begins to lag extremely bad. Playing 2v2 and 3v3 isn't even really optional at this point. I was wondering if you guys knew of any good computers that I could buy for a decent price. Would it be better to build one? (I've never built a fucking computer before). I just wanna game again :( Thanks dudes. glhfgg

4 Comments
2012/08/22
08:01 UTC

Back To Top