/r/reddeadredemption

Photograph via //r/reddeadredemption

/r/RedDeadRedemption - A subreddit dedicated to Red Dead Redemption & Red Dead Redemption 2, developed by Rockstar Games, the creators behind the Grand Theft Auto series.

Question and Answer ThreadsFAQRules and Policies ExplainedSubmit Online feedback to R*

/r/RedDeadRedemption - A subreddit dedicated to Red Dead Redemption & Red Dead Redemption 2, developed by Rockstar Games, the creators behind the Grand Theft Auto series.

Red Dead Redemption 2 is a harsh tale of life in America’s unforgiving heartland. The game’s vast and atmospheric world also provides the base for a new online multiplayer experience.

Join our Discord server to find your posse, share screenshots, or to talk about the game.

You can also follow the r/RedDeadRedemption account on Twitter for regular Hot, Trending ad Official posts delivered right to your feed.

Helpful Links

r/RedDeadRedemption Discord

Red Dead Online Collector's Map


Filter by Flair

Discussion 🛇 Issue 🛇

Lore 🛇 Media 🛇

Meme 🛇 PSA 🛇

Question 🛇 Online 🛇

Speculation 🛇 Spoiler 🛇

Official 🛇 Rant 🛇


Reminders

All posts with spoilers INSIDE them must have [SPOILER] OR [SPOILERS] in the title.

Memes are ONLY to be posted on Mondays, and should be a genuine fresh attempt at humor.

  • Overused meme formats/macros, unoriginal or memes that cannot stand on their own in reference to RDR will be removed.

Current banned memes:


Rules (Detailed Rules)

1. Comments and discussions must remain civil or they will be removed.

  • Follow proper reddiquette.
  • This subreddit is about a video game; keep political discussion to other, more appropriate subreddits. This is not the place for heated console debates.
  • Due to the nature of Red Dead Redemption and its M-rating, M-rated language and content is allowed, within reason. However, this does not mean things like insults and personal attacks are allowed.
  • PC/Console elitism is not welcome in this subreddit. Discussion is perfectly fine as long as it stays civil.

2. Rule 2: Spoilers in our community.

  • NO SPOILING RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 WITHOUT THE USE OF THE SPOILER TAG.
  • Use spoiler syntax:>!RDR is a great game!< will become RDR is a great game
  • Absolutely no spoilers, intentional or otherwise for any game in the title of your post.
  • If the body of your post contains a spoiler it must be marked as a spoiler. To do this put [Spoiler] or [Spoilers] in the title. You can also press the "Mark as spoiler" button or similar.
  • Intentionally spoiling RDR2 or any other game to ruin other's enjoyment will result in a permanent removal from this community.
  • Unsure whether it's a story spoiler? Mark it as one to be safe. (Or ask the mods)
  • Spoiler tags for RDR1 are strongly recommended, but not required.

3. All content must be directly related to Red Dead Redemption.

  • They must be related by more than just the title.
  • If you are submitting a meme: unless the image is directly related to Red Dead Redemption, it must be separable from your title and still remain funny.
  • Other memes can be posted on /r/RedDeadMemes
  • LFG Posts belong in /r/RedDeadCrews.

4. Low-effort & low-quality content may be removed.

  • All meme content will be removed on every day of the week EXCEPT MONDAY
  • Videos or spam, intrusive or obvious fluff content will be removed.
  • Misleading titles, trying to trick user into clicking your posts will be removed.
  • Image macros, overused generic meme formats and low effort/common in game screenshots will be removed. Memes must be submitted only on Mondays and make a genuine attempt at humor. Consider posting to /r/RedDeadMemes.
  • Duplicate content will be removed.
  • Overdone or low effort/quality art maybe removed.
  • Reaction type images or similar falls under the category of a meme and maybe removed if not properly posted during the corresponding period of Meme Monday.
  • In-game screenshots being posted here must not be crappy cellphone pictures.

5. Link to high-quality websites & official sources.

  • Well-written articles with sources are preferred over fluff articles and evidence-less news/speculation posts.
  • Websites with excessive ads, bias, misleading content or links, etc. may be removed at the discretion of the moderators.
  • Link to official sources such as R*'s official website or social medias.

6. Choose the most relevant link flair.

  • Incorrect link flair can often be corrected but may result in the removal of your post.
  • Contact the mod team if you make a mistake.

7. Minimize self-promotion.

  • Sharing OC is strongly encouraged, and with OC often comes self-promotion.
  • We ask that you take care to participate in the community beyond self-promotion.
  • Users who actively engage themselves in the subreddit and make the occasional self-promotional post will be approved.
  • However, treating our subreddit solely as a platform for advertisement is not allowed.

8. Simple questions should be asked or answered in the scheduled Question Threads.

  • Simple questions that can be asked or answered in a few short sentences should be submitted as a comment in the daily question thread pinned to the front page of the subreddit.
  • If you believe a question relating to RDR will take a more detailed explanation that cannot be asked or answered in a short comment, then submitting such a question is allowed.
  • Moderation discretion applies.

Related subreddits

Red Dead Redemption

Rockstar Games

Gaming


Official links


Mod note

Failure to follow these rules will result in posts or comments being removed, and may result in bans, the length of which to be determined by the nature of the infraction.

Posts and comments from new users will automatically be removed. Don't ask us the specifics, we won't tell you. However, we will be happy to manually approve your comments if you send us a message

Message the moderators

/r/reddeadredemption

2,071,647 Subscribers

1

What was the most despicable, dishonorable deed you've ever done as Arthur and why? How did you feel after?

I've had my share of shootin' up the whole town and committing mass murder just for kicks, but they seem way too tame compared to the madman that is Edmund Lowry. I don't think my Arthur could ever surpass his dark deeds.

Have you ever done anything you found so personally despicable and horrendous in the game as Arthur? Care to share what, why, and what you felt after, you heartless monster? 😂🤣

0 Comments
2024/12/01
17:17 UTC

4

The real life RDR2 map

These are in the Xbox disk containers for RDR2

0 Comments
2024/12/01
17:10 UTC

6

Anyone else wish we saw more of colm?

Like we saw him what in like 3 missions?.When i first saw him i thought we were gonna have gang wars and stuff with him but no they just forget about him until chapter 6,wasted villain.

0 Comments
2024/12/01
17:09 UTC

3

What in your option is the best money maker is red dead 2 epilogue?

I would say without glitches….black jack or robbing people 😆

1 Comment
2024/12/01
16:57 UTC

2

undead nightmare chupacabra

okay idk where to find this thing ive finished the story ive got to the challenge to find and kill it and i even finished all other challenges what am i doing wrong

0 Comments
2024/12/01
16:55 UTC

1

My idea for storyline for red dead redemption 3

So i just replayed rdr2. Spectacular game. Really took my time with it. What if in 3, you play as Jack mariston. And through his days as a gunslinger, you come to find out about your fathers best friend, arthur morgan. You inherited all his belongings when john was killed. You search through arthurs journals over the years to get to know the man who saved your fathers life, as well as yourself. You stumble upon a curious note, mentioning arthurs drunken one time fling with abigail, and discover the truth. Arthur morgan is your true father.

That’s how the 2 games can tie together perfectly. You play as the biological son of arthur, who was raised by john.

2 Comments
2024/12/01
16:50 UTC

2

why did arthur still help dutch after my last boy?

why did arthur still help dutch Rob the train after dutch left him to die in my last boy?

1 Comment
2024/12/01
16:49 UTC

2

What horse is this?

The horse I'm trying to find is the one where we get it in the beginningof the bear hunting mission. It was a big black one. Sorry I don't have a picture.

1 Comment
2024/12/01
16:45 UTC

2

Chased this convict to clemens point camp. No one reacted to him, and hosea remarked that the place gives him the creeps as we ran past. And then he dissappeared. Ghost?! /s

0 Comments
2024/12/01
16:20 UTC

1

Verification issue for RDR2 and GTA5

When I launch these two rockstar games I get an issue related to verification. For red dead it's "Verifying game ownership failed and your offline activation data could not be loaded when launching Red Dead Redemption 2 on PC. Verifying game ownership failed and your offline activation data could not be loaded when launching Red Dead Redemption 2 on PC" and for GTA it says that my game key has already been used. I tried all the fixes on the Rockstar support page and in a couple different subreddits, none of them worked. Can someone help me? (Both my games have single-player mods installed)

0 Comments
2024/12/01
16:17 UTC

7

How well would you do on Blackjack?

I would get lucky but sometimes when I lose I just kill the dealer out of frustration.

4 Comments
2024/12/01
16:12 UTC

1

Can’t find certain legendary animals

I’ve tried to find both the white bison and the alligator but they haven’t come up on my map and when I go to their locations it always says that there is too much activity even when there isn’t any. I know that I have to wait until I complete a certain mission for the alligator but is this the case with all of them? Do u have to complete missions to unlock the chance to hunt them. (I’m on chapter 6 and have hunted the coyote, buck, moose, boar and beaver and somehow a lion but that was part of the Margret missions I think)

Edit: I just fell into lake Isabella and now a fish has appeared on the map. Does there need to be this on the map to be able to hunt the animal?

2 Comments
2024/12/01
16:05 UTC

3

Why dont we have the navy revolver in story mode?

In story mode i even customed the lemat revolver to look like a navy revolver. And then a friend of mine said to play red dead online, and fooling around i found the navy revolver in the gunsmith. WHY DA FUCK IS IT NOT AVAILABLE IN THE STORY MODE?!

And before you say "use mods" or something, im playing in console so that's out of the question

3 Comments
2024/12/01
16:03 UTC

1

My friend just started playing.

A good friend of mine finally picked up this game and has been absolutely loving it. He’s managed to avoid story spoilers all these years but there one problem. He keeps telling me how much he likes this “Micah guy”. Says he’s a real wild card and his missions are always exciting. I’m going along with it to not spoil anything for him but it’s been killing me to hype Micah up like that. He’s only on chapter 2 and really takes his time exploring and doing stranger missions so it’ll be a while before he learns the truth.

2 Comments
2024/12/01
15:59 UTC

1

sunday gaming fun

Sunday gaming fun

0 Comments
2024/12/01
15:58 UTC

23

Nothing here folks.... just My boi arthur chilling with this view

4 Comments
2024/12/01
15:44 UTC

1

Just beat the first game

Wow, wasn’t expecting that ending 😭😭 Poor John- poor Abigail!! What the heck happened to her? 😢 Thankful I still have the second game to play! Loved the first so I’m looking forward to it. Need to emotionally recover a bit first 😅

2 Comments
2024/12/01
15:37 UTC

0

Cringe micah hate

https://www.gamingbible.com/news/red-dead-redemption-2-kills-micah-405730-20241127. What is this? Posted December of 2024? Jesus guys get a grip.

Its so weird, the only clips I see anymore on yt of Red Dead Redemption is usually someone being a pyscho brutalizing npcs. Which i think is really fking weird and if you defend it with the “it just a video game” that’s equally as weird. Besides the point its like half the fanbase is obsessed with making Arthur this fucking serial killer. But god forbid some random hillbilly throughs a wrench in the gangs plan. Like get a grip

4 Comments
2024/12/01
15:33 UTC

1

Jamie Gillis

I did a Google search for Jamie Gillis hoping to hop onto a Wiki or whatever and see if there was any additional information on him, Mary Linton, and Arthur that I may have missed during the game. I was a little surprised to find that when you search just Jamie Gillis the primary links that came up are for AVN Hall of Fame Performer Jamie Gillis, the P*rnstar. This guy's career was prolific and he probably starred in some of those films back when they were shown primarily in theaters. I was a bit mindblown.

Maybe in an alternate universe Jamie Gillis had a kid after what happened with the Chelonians?

https://preview.redd.it/r8atav77994e1.png?width=1107&format=png&auto=webp&s=7789cf99a19b9f74046a365ad044722a55bfe0fb

0 Comments
2024/12/01
15:25 UTC

2

what's you're favorite missions do to but playing as Arthur Morgan?

4 Comments
2024/12/01
15:13 UTC

11

This rotten POS is rottenly black to the inside, and had the audacity to call our Arthur black lung.

8 Comments
2024/12/01
15:03 UTC

1

Need help - Accidentally killing my horse.

I have a serious skill issue and and just wanted to vent.

Playing undead nightmare for the first time and am trying to get the tomahawk mastery by killing a bat with a tomahawk. I have a bat close by, flying low, go into dead eye but can’t tag it. I think that’s fine and aim a little above the bat and hit throw. Pow! Right in the back of Pestilence’s skull.

Later I find war and break him. Then I see a low flying bat, whip out my tomahawk and blamo! My new horse collapses beneath me with a tomahawk sticking out of his head.

I know I get them back later but I’ve killed 2! Horses of the apocalypse. How can I throw tomahawks without killing my horses? And how in the west dickens do I kill a bat if deadeye won’t tag them??

2 Comments
2024/12/01
14:39 UTC

0

Is there a way to change hair at certain length to one of WhyEm's Hairdos?

Came back to RDR2 a week ago after almost a year from finishing it, to finally try a low honor run. This time, I installed mods to spice things up.

One mod I came across was WhyEm's DLC which brought the game a lot of new things to enjoy, one of which are new hairdos.

The thing is, as much as I love the hairdos in WhyEm's, it kinda bugs my immersion that these hairdos don't get longer like the default hairstyles. One thing I really enjoy about the game is customizing Arthur's appearance and I find it really fun when his hair grows long and I have to cut it back to the hair length I want.

As such, I wonder if there is a way so that you can change a default hairstyle at certain length (let's say "Middle Parted Fade" Hairstyle at Length 6) to one of the hairdos included in WhyEm's (like "The Cowpoke" hairstyle which imo makes our BOAH much more of a trouser-dropper - I'm sporting the same look as this post) such that when Middle Parted Fade reaches Length 6 - Arthur would sport The Cowpoke hairstyle.

I thought it might be possible since I saw another mod (a tutorial really) that changed Arthur's beard at Length 5 to Bill's beard at Length 5, so I'm thinking maybe the same process could be done with one of WhyEm's hairdos, I just don't know what line to edit in which file.

Thanks in advance to anyone who helps!

3 Comments
2024/12/01
14:39 UTC

Back To Top