/r/GMOMyths

Photograph via snooOG

Every mods of /r/GMOMyths are either shills or highly mentally disturbed - u/They_Wont

"What is this place?"

Welcome to /r/GMOMyths! This is where anyone can point out how uninformed the average interweb denzian is about biotechnology, farming, Bayer or other basic science facts. Sit back, relax, cook yourself a batch of GMO popcorn and enjoy the ramblings of the misinformed!

Submit glaring inaccuracies of GMOs, Biotechnology, Bayer, farming/agriculture from either Reddit or any website. Remember that no matter what you actually know accusations will be made that you work for an agribusiness giant.

“Every mods of /r/GMOMyths are either shills or highly mentally disturbed” - u/They_Wont


Rules
  1. All links posted from Reddit must contain the "np" in the URL. e.g. np.reddit.com/r/AskReddit
  2. Under no circumstances will personally identifiable information will be allowed. e.g., facebook profiles of non-celebrities
  3. Please take a screenshot and host to imgur whenever possible. This decreases traffic going to sites which make money off of misinformation such as NaturalNews.
  4. No vote brigading or calls to "vote brigade".
  5. No doxxing. i.e., don't attempt to find personal information about the moderators of this subreddit. You will be reported to the administrators.
  6. All shill accusations must have evidence the accused works for a corporate PR firm.
  7. Any attempt to defend Bayer in /r/socialism results in a ban because a true comrade loves his echo chamber

  8. Follow Rediquette. We enforce good faith commenting and have little patience for trolling.

  9. We are not your personal army. Do not link to comments you're engaged with.

GMO FAQs

Hover to see answers

  • What are GMOs?

  • Genetically modified organisms (GMOs) can be defined as organisms in which the genetic material (DNA) has been altered in a way that does not occur in nature. The technology is often called “recombinant DNA technology” or “genetic engineering”. It allows selected individual genes to be transferred from one organism into another, also between non-related species.
  • Why? Why do we need them?!

    • Because they offer advantages over traditional breeding processes. Ultimately, both consumers and producers benefit from GMOs. Genetically engineered plants benefit the producer/farmer by offering traits that a.) decrease costs b.) increase efficiency/productivity. Ultimately, this results in lower food costs for the consumer by eliminating negative production factors. In addition to providing benefits to producers and consumers, biotechnology can benefit the planet, too. This is accomplished through bioremediation. There is exciting potential for the use of GMOs to clean-up polluted water and land streams through engineering remediation traits into them. In addition to bioremediation, engineering resistance traits into the plants reduces the costly and overuse of pesticides.
  • Are there health risks associated with GMOs?

    • No - they are just as safe as any other "conventional" counterpart. There are much more important things to worry about health-wise.
    Common GMO Myths
    • Monsanto sues farmers who have GM seed/pollen/whatever contamination on their farmers, thereby making them go into bankruptcy - like Percy Schmeiser
  • GMOs are not safe and cause liver/kidney/brain/stomach/intestinal/whatever damage.

    • There is no scholarly sources from reputable journals that back-up any claim of detrimental health effects from GMOs. In addition, on a biochemical level it doesn't make sense how GMOs could harm any of your physiological systems.
  • Bayer has a monopoly on the seed market.

    • No, they kinda don't. There are hundreds of producers of conventional, hybrid seed out there. There are several other major companies that also make GMO seed, too.
  • RoundUp is Agent Orange

    • No. Look up the active ingredients. 10 seconds on Google and you would realize this is factually incorrect.
  • RoundUp is super toxic

    • In comparison to herbicides used in the past, it is actually very safe for animals and the environment. Unless you have chlorophyll, you will be fine.
  • Patenting seed is bad

    • Why? It is necessary to protect investment into R&D. It is nothing new as a result of GMOs. In fact, it has been going on since the 1950's with the development of hybridization with the development of Plant Patent Act (1930) - long before Monsanto was ever in the seed business.

    Check out the Myths Network™:


    Helpful Links

    /r/GMOMyths

    3,296 Subscribers

    2

    Epicyte patent

    I just watched an eleven year old Youtube video entitled GMO Foods: Safe to Eat? Playing God? It was almost entirely favorable to genetic engineering in agriculture, and it knocks down a few of the myths.

    There was one myth I had never heard of before, about a startup company called Epicyte, which was said to have patented a gene that lets a plant or animal produce an antibody to human sperm, and which was developing a drug to make human beings sterile, and that Monsanto and Dupont had formed a partnership to purchase Epicyte and promote that drug. It was supposedly put into corn.

    It shows up very close to the end of the video, at 35:40.

    0 Comments
    2024/10/29
    17:53 UTC

    4

    The Biblical Nutritionist

    I came upon a YouTube video by Annette Reeder, about two years ago, and another just a few days ago. Both were about GMO food, both described very negatively, but as you might expect, her objections were mixed with religious beliefs about what God meant for us to be eating.

    But in both videos, and in a third that I found afterward, she claims that there is a genetically modified salmon which was given a gene from a mosquito, so that it could live in ponds. I was pretty sure that there was no such salmon, but I used the comment section of YouTube to ask if she could tell me where that claim came from. And she was nice enough to answer, giving me the name of her source, Dr. Richard Brouse, a biochemical wellness coach and a retired chiropractic physician. She said she would ask him, but she never got back to me. I emailed Dr. Brouse and never got an answer. To skip right to the mosquito salmon, go to 1:47. Right after the salmon, there's the obligatory hypodermic syringe injecting an apple.

    www.youtube.com/watch?v=v1BRVNqyOiw&t=3s

    1 Comment
    2024/09/30
    23:16 UTC

    51

    A surprisingly decent amount of rational GMO discussion, though a lot of stupidity in there as well.

    16 Comments
    2024/09/25
    04:23 UTC

    15

    Baker Creek "rare Seeds" was selling a GMO tomato and claiming it wasn't GMO....

    Is NHP's Purple Tomato related to the "Purple Galaxy"?

    We have received many questions about the purple tomato marketed by Baker Creek as “Purple Galaxy” in their 2024 catalogs. We understand from Baker Creek that they will not be selling seeds of this variety. Given its remarkable similarity to our purple tomato, we prompted Baker Creek to investigate their claim that Purple Galaxy was non-GMO. We are told that laboratory testing determined that it is, in fact, bioengineered (GMO). This result supports the fact that the only reported way to produce a purple-fleshed tomato rich in anthocyanin antioxidants is with Norfolk’s patented technology. We appreciate that Baker Creek tested their material, and after discovering it was a GMO, removed it from their website.

    https://www.norfolkhealthyproduce.com/faqs

    11 Comments
    2024/02/17
    04:44 UTC

    4

    EU Parliament | ENVI Committee back NGTs in historic vote [CRISPR]

    1 Comment
    2024/01/24
    13:12 UTC

    2

    Survey on the Public's Perception of Genetically Modified Organisms

    Hello, I am a high school student in need of responses for my google form for capstone research, please, if you have time, take part in my survey. Your response is anonymous and there is always an answer to not respond to an answer you are uncomfortable with.

    Your support is greatly appreciated.

    Link: https://forms.gle/xpS3DZZ5mUVY4Q9w7

    3 Comments
    2024/01/09
    01:55 UTC

    4

    Confusing one myth with another.

    This account poses as educational, but the presenter, Barbara Swanson (Nutrition Consultant and Author) is so confused that she mixes one myth with another as if they are the same thing. Example - the tomato with a fish gene and the Flavr Savr tomato are treated as one GMO event. A gene gun is mixed up with CRISPR, she mixes up herbicide resistance with Bt, and thinks that GMO rice is a Bt crop, etc.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Nvz_vcpKCo&t=265s

    0 Comments
    2023/10/14
    21:20 UTC

    4

    GO warning, 8 reasons why GMOs are bad --- in another universe

    www.youtube.com/watch?v=RDVyGg-83d4&t=135s

    At 2:15 she actually says that high fructose corn syrup is made from GMO sugar beets.

    2 Comments
    2023/08/24
    11:49 UTC

    5

    Worst GMO for diabetics, a special case of the hypodermic syringes.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7M2eq4FTofA

    I saw this youtube video with the whole anti-GMO rhetoric squeezed in. The teaser was that if you watched enough of the video you would be told which GMO food is the worst, they all being bad, for diabetics.

    I skipped ahead and it was sugar beets. Now how hard would a diabetic have to work to avoid sugar beets. Nobody eats sugar beets. They are used only by sugar companies to extract sugar, which is identical to sugar from non-GMO sugar beets, or GMO or non GMO sugar cane. I think every diabetic person knows how to manage his sugar intake, but should know that all kinds of sucrose are the same.

    It was also intriguing to see the endless arrays of hypodermic syringes, which must be very familiar to many diabetic patients, but not injecting fruits.

    0 Comments
    2023/07/28
    18:38 UTC

    4

    GMOs and diabetes. Also, syringes are now animated!

    2 Comments
    2023/06/27
    19:56 UTC

    8

    Robert Kennedy, Jr. On Suing Monsanto and The Dangers of Round-Up

    8 Comments
    2023/06/20
    01:54 UTC

    22

    Going Black

    This subreddit will go dark July 12th if this gets five upvoted

    4 Comments
    2023/06/08
    23:40 UTC

    6

    Dogs and chickens won't eat GMO corn

    2 Comments
    2023/05/27
    17:07 UTC

    23

    That darned GMO wheat

    8 Comments
    2023/04/19
    15:18 UTC

    Back To Top