/r/AskBaking

Photograph via snooOG

Welcome to /r/AskBaking! This subreddit is devoted to the discussion of baking, the questions that arise during the process, and requests for help on your results!

Rules

1. Baking-Related Questions Only First and foremost this is a baking related ask and discussion sub! We are here to help you with your woes, questions, or concerns. Please limit your posts to this area. We will allow critiques as long as there is obvious concern/question. This is not your platform for showcasing finished products. See /r/baking for that!

2. No Self-Promotion It's great you run a business or a blog, but this isn't the place to promote it or ask for people to check you out.

3. Recipes. Recipes are not required, but if something went wrong we'll need the recipe to figure it out! Please consider posting a recipe with all your posts.

4. Kindness Everyone comes with their own level and experience. No question is "stupid" and disrespect will not be tolerated. DOWNVOTES ARE NOT DISLIKES. Do not downvote a post simply because you do not agree with it.

5. Use The Search Feature. While we certainly don't mind answering questions, you can often receive immediate help by utilizing the search bar and using keywords that relate to your issue. If we feel that you have not properly utilized the search bar, we may remove your post and encourage you to do so.

6. We Are Not Google. AskBaking is designed to help bakers who are struggling with perfecting their science and craft. It was not designed to become a substitute for Google. If you're looking for recipes try using Google, Pintrest, or any number of other subreddits.


Check out our affiliates and other baking/cooking related subs!
/r/AskCulinary
/r/Baking
/r/CAKEWIN
/r/FoodPorn
/r/Cooking

/r/AskBaking

226,104 Subscribers

2

How to I make my pound cake more condensed

I made pound cake previously and it came out great I used the cold oven method but it had risen a lot and that’s not what I wanted to happen how do I correct this to make a more condensed cake. I did use baking flower I did use Vanilla Ice cream as milk I used a mixer then after whisked everything

1 Comment
2024/04/21
04:49 UTC

5

Corn Syrup Substitute

I'm trying to make marshmallow buttercream frosting from scratch with homemade marshmallow fluff base but I can't get my hands on corn syrup. I found a recipie for glucose syrup that claims to be a substitute. Would that work? Or does corn syrup have any special properties that cannot be replaced when it comes to marshmallow

2 Comments
2024/04/21
03:31 UTC

0

Added steam to make the crust of my bread buns crackle...

3 Comments
2024/04/21
01:16 UTC

2

Would these type of cookies be okay to send internationally? (2-3 weeks/70% humidity/vacuum sealed)

7 Comments
2024/04/21
00:35 UTC

3

will whipped cream frosting melt at room temp?

Hi, I am planning to make cupcakes to bring to my boyfriend this weekend, but my concern is that they may melt since it is a 2 hour drive. The frosting recipe uses both cream cheese & heavy cream, if I just add gelatin will it be fine? or should i use a freezer bag?

4 Comments
2024/04/20
22:15 UTC

6

Trouble with shortbread cookies - dough came out whipped, is there any way I can salvage it?

I followed this recipe except that I subbed the vanilla chai leaves for Vermont maple ginger tea leaves, added a 1/4 tsp vanilla extract, and some maple syrup. At no point was my dough crumbly but was, in fact, very soft and whipped in texture the entire way through. I added a few extra spoonfuls of flour but it didn't do much and to a small degree, there's a taste of chewing on flour, though it doesn't taste terrible. There's no way I'll be able to roll this out and use cookie cutters on it.

I was going to scrap it and start over but I don't have enough flour to a new batch of anything. Is there anything I can do to work with what I've got?

https://preview.redd.it/dlmmnoiq9pvc1.jpg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7e32bc3e866f48d5008a783f2f8336873674eb39

5 Comments
2024/04/20
21:11 UTC

1

Can I turn a muffin recipe into a cake?

I have this amazing muffin recipe but I no longer own a muffin tin. While I do want to buy one, I can’t afford that right now, and I really wanna make these muffins lol Can I just use the same recipe, all measurements, and just throw it in a bigger baking pan?

6 Comments
2024/04/20
20:46 UTC

1

What I need to know about the airbrush gun? How I should pick the best?

I want to buy an airbrush gun but I don’t know anything about it. What to look for before I buy it?

1 Comment
2024/04/20
20:22 UTC

1

Cookie crumbs/dust

I packed a big bag of snickerdoodles for a conference, and they did not survive the trip very well.

What would bakers here do with a large amount of snickerdoodle crumbs/pieces?

7 Comments
2024/04/20
14:15 UTC

14

How to get sugar crust on muffins?

Sometimes when you buy store bought muffins they come with a few of these thin "plates" of sugar on top of them, usually an inch or so across with a rough surface, they have an amazing texture and would be perfect for a recipe I have been trying to experiment with, but I have absolutely no idea how to recreate that effect or even what to call it. I've looked everywhere and can't seem to find anything. 🥲 I would be super happy if anyone could point me in the right direction.

32 Comments
2024/04/20
14:09 UTC

279

Is this ermine buttercream ruined?

I made ermine buttercream and at the end I added raspberry jam as per the recipe, and then refrigerated it over night. The recipe said to beat on medium-high for 5 mins to bring it back to workable consistency. It started breaking down into this mess at about 3 mins. Should I have waited to add the jam until right before icing the cake? Maybe my jam had too much liquid? It looked fine last night!

21 Comments
2024/04/20
14:02 UTC

1

How to store burnaway cake overnight?

Need to have it delivered but the next day . Since the cake uses wafer paper , i’m scared it’ll damage the cake before the customer gets to light it. I know wafer paper doesn’t do well with moisture.

Is there a store and freeze method you guys recommend for this specific type of cake?

2 Comments
2024/04/20
11:52 UTC

17

Why does this happen?

Just baked these cupcakes from a cake recipe. Some of them have sunken and some haven’t? It’s still salvageable but I was wondering what makes this happen :)

12 Comments
2024/04/20
10:03 UTC

4

Do cake tiers need to be the same height!?

I'm making a cake for my friends baby shower which will be two tiers (usually I just do single tier but she has a lot of guests).

I have baked 3X8inch layers approx 1.5inch each and 2X6inch layers also approx 1.5inch each.

My question is, does it matter if the top tier isn't as high as the bottom tier? Will it look weird or should I bake another 6inch layer?

6 Comments
2024/04/20
09:55 UTC

2

How to choose the right butter?

I’m planning on starting a brownies business and there are quiet a few options of unsalted butter in the market.

Is there any way to know which one would be the best for making brownies?

6 Comments
2024/04/20
09:33 UTC

8

Milk Bread Rolls

The rolls have great flavor, but they're too dense. The dough didn't rise to my liking, and I'm not sure why… Any tips or suggestions?

Source: https://www.tiktok.com/find/milk-bread-rolls-recipe-tini

2 Comments
2024/04/20
03:53 UTC

13

Buttercream

I recently got into baking cakes and one thing that always drives me nuts is the buttercream has a weird flavor after being out. Usually it's the next day but this cake I made today (which isn't great looking) the buttercream almost tastes like butter thats been out too many days. Idk if that makes sense but no one else who eats my cakes notices it so maybe i'm crazy. Anyone else have this issue? Any tips? I use salted butter and let it sit out to soften for a few hours before using. Thanks!

11 Comments
2024/04/20
02:48 UTC

2

Home made cake “expiration” date?

I am trying to start a home based cake business and one requirement for my state is labels with an expiration date. How exactly do I calculate the expiration date of a cake? How long do I know it’s good for?

0 Comments
2024/04/20
01:57 UTC

1

How can I bake a cheesecake in a fancy toaster oven? (My oven is broken)

I was thinking of using an 8 inch springform pan to hold the cheesecake, which is 1 inch smaller than my 9 inch spring form pan. Which was what i was going to use to hold hot water to help bake.

Since my oven is not working, I was tempted to use my toaster oven. That toaster oven has proven to be such a great underutilized tool. (mostly because of the convection option, as well as it's space)

Bad idea?

4 Comments
2024/04/20
01:27 UTC

532

Wth does this frosting need from me???

Recipe: https://iambaker.net/chocolate-ermine-frosting/

I'm trying to make chocolate ermine frosting. Based on other posts I've read, I've tried whipping it more and putting it in the fridge for about 45 mins. Still looks like this. Please help :(

53 Comments
2024/04/20
00:21 UTC

1

Messed up diplomat cream?

https://youtu.be/fLBmWIcFFrg?si=2FzRKxH4quGVxtCN

Using this recipe here and I definitely made the pastry cream portion thicker than what was originally shown in the video. It’s not separated, but it’s not as loose as the video shows. Would it still be good to use or do I just toss it out?

5 Comments
2024/04/19
23:09 UTC

2

Prepare ahead of time

Hello,

I am making my niece's birthday cake this week, and I have had a slight scheduling issue.

Originally I planned to bake it before I go to work on Wednesday Afternoon, so it'll be sufficiently cold enough to ice on Thursday morning.

However, I forgot to factor in that I have to be at work 3 hours early for a staff training.

I can't pick up the cake tin I hired until Wednesday morning at 930am, and I need to leave for work by 1130

My question is, if I make the batter for the cake on Tuesday night when I get home, will it hold up in the fridge until after I get home with the cake tin to bake? It would be about 7-8 hours Or should I get up early and make the batter before going to pick up the tin so it's only sitting for at most an hour?

12 Comments
2024/04/19
22:09 UTC

9

Green cookies

OK so I am an amateur baker and baked these white chocolate/raspberry cookies and it's green ! I've never seen this it's so strange!

13 Comments
2024/04/19
21:07 UTC

1

can i sub double cream for greek yogurt?

i want to make 2-ingredient air fryer doughnuts but i dont have any greek yogurt left

6 Comments
2024/04/19
20:00 UTC

1

Carving a cake?

My friend’s 30th is next week, so we’re doing a Death to her 20s party. I want to make her a tombstone cake to go on theme that says “here lies her 20s”, and while I have experience decorating, I have no idea what kind of cake to use to carve it into the shape without disintegrating on me. Please help 😭

3 Comments
2024/04/19
18:52 UTC

987

Swiss Meringue frosting

I'm making a double batch of Swiss Meringue Frosting (Sally's Baking Addiction) I have been whipping for nearly 30 mins and I'm at soft peaks. Is it possible to whip in batches at this point or should I keep going and hope my KA motor doesn't die on me lol I'm thinking maybe I have too many egg whites whipping at once. I'm whipping 12 egg whites with about 900grams of sugar.

42 Comments
2024/04/19
18:29 UTC

1

dense vanilla cake

(reposting this got removed the first time) hello everyone! im baking my brothers birthday cake this year & he wants a dense vanilla cake. i've only ever used one recipe that i'll link below but he says it's not moist or dense enough. if anyone has any tips on making it more dense i'd appreciate it. thank you in advance!

https://cakesbymk.com/recipe/soft-vanilla-cake/

5 Comments
2024/04/19
18:10 UTC

Back To Top