/r/ArtCrit

Photograph via snooOG

A place for artists of all abilities to give and receive constructive feedback.

  • Welcome to r/ArtCrit!

  • A reddit for artists to get feedback on their work, all forms welcome. Traditional, digital, anything goes.

  • All art forms welcome


    • Subreddit Rules

    • Please be civil

    • Do not slander "bad" work, these artists stand to benefit the most from even simple suggestions and critiques

    • Keep critique focused on technique and craftsmanship

    • Please refrain from downvoting submissions you do not like. These people are looking for help improving, just like everybody else.

    • Posted work must be submitted by the artist, or someone close to them, posts to sites discussing art or other artists will be removed

    • NSFW Artwork is allowed, but must be tagged [NSFW]


    • Critique Tips

    • Above all, be honest and forthcoming

    • Be specific, don't say "I like it!" say, "I like the way you...." and likewise for negative comments

    • Be Helpful, link to books, tutorials, or offer exercises for the artist

    • Don't refer to things as "good" or "bad," try to talk in terms of skill sets that can be worked on

    • A lot of us are visual thinkers, if you have a tablet copy+paste and make some notes

    • When receiving a critique, don't be too defensive, you can't explain away other peoples opinions of your art, try and listen to what they are saying

    • Follow this link for a great post by Huisme on asking for critique




    Flair Legend

    Flair should guide other users to understand where you want to go, or where you are coming from, enjoy

    Student Flair

    Use student flair to show what level you are, feel free to write in a genre or medium

    Beginner

    Intermediate

    Skilled

    Skill Flair

    Skill flair shows off what you're good at, feel free to include genre, technique, or discipline you like to work in, you can be a beginner and still use skill flair if you like

    Drawing

    Painting

    Acrylic

    Oil

    Digital

    Watercolor

    Marker

    Pen

    Sculpture

    Abstract

    Other

    Foundations Flair

    Got a really great critique? Message the Mod to recommend that user for Foundations Flair, special flair for those who are particularly helpful to users

    Foundations

    /r/ArtCrit

    97,562 Subscribers

    1

    Backgrounds and colors?

    Something I stopped working on about a month ago but I might come back to it if I knew how to make a better background. I didnt try on the background or lighting

    1 Comment
    2024/11/19
    05:59 UTC

    2

    Thoughts?

    4 Comments
    2024/11/19
    05:24 UTC

    6

    Sketch from Today

    Colored pencil on medium surface paper. Just know what you think — whether you like it, what I can improve on, what you would change

    1 Comment
    2024/11/19
    04:27 UTC

    51

    Wip - any feedback is appreciated!

    Looking for gut reactions!

    9 Comments
    2024/11/19
    04:00 UTC

    2

    Still can't get shading right

    A sketch I did to practice shadows. Still have no idea how people do/ understand them so I tried a hatching technique. Any advice for improvement is appreciated

    5 Comments
    2024/11/18
    23:29 UTC

    5

    opinions and suggestions?

    I need to learn how improve my skills as an artist, so I’m asking strangers on the internet lol

    2 Comments
    2024/11/18
    23:24 UTC

    2

    Everyone else is so good kind of embarrassed to post my trash drawing

    1 Comment
    2024/11/18
    22:51 UTC

    2

    Wild Robot

    2 Comments
    2024/11/18
    22:49 UTC

    7

    2h sketch

    Graphite

    5 Comments
    2024/11/18
    22:01 UTC

    79

    My latest. All gouache. What do you think I can improve on.

    8 Comments
    2024/11/18
    21:49 UTC

    7

    Critique the design!

    Please help me with my design for the king of swords! This is just a rough sketch of my idea for a character representation the king of swords. Each card is a magical girl based off a crystal/ metal representing the card! She is based off yellow gold with a sub theme of hawks. Let me know what you think of the design!

    And if you have any ideas for backgrounds for the final piece or characteristics, that’s would be great too!!

    1 Comment
    2024/11/18
    19:27 UTC

    76

    I've been practicing cartooning, but they still don't feel "complete" to me

    9 Comments
    2024/11/18
    19:22 UTC

    4

    Need advice about hands,feet and face please

    I posted this yesterday but didn’t get any responses I used a dip pen and pencil

    4 Comments
    2024/11/18
    18:54 UTC

    2

    Perspective Drawing Feedback

    Recently did a perspective course which at end gave me assignment to create an environment scene! I would love some feedback on it, thanks!

    1 Comment
    2024/11/18
    18:11 UTC

    3

    I'm practicing to draw my own webtoon/manga, any advice on simple shading that looks decent is appreciated cuz this makes me grind my teeth

    8 Comments
    2024/11/18
    16:49 UTC

    2

    How to make it more dramatic

    Hi all! Recently finished this and I’m super proud of my shading. The only thing is it didn’t end up as dramatic as I wanted and I don’t quite think it pops. I’m still brainstorming a simple background, but if there anything I could have done better on her please let me know

    11 Comments
    2024/11/18
    15:34 UTC

    11

    Help please, how do I fix this hand? I redrew it over and over but it still looks very off to me.

    10 Comments
    2024/11/18
    15:25 UTC

    44

    Cheap mechanical pencil on left. Mid range 3B pencil on right. Where does that grainy texture come from? Is it my technique or the paper?

    Any advice is appreciated. I’m drawing in a 110lb sketchbook

    18 Comments
    2024/11/18
    15:11 UTC

    10

    What do you think?

    Playing with oil pastels

    10 Comments
    2024/11/18
    11:43 UTC

    61

    Add more details or stop here

    Acrylic painting. Looking for crit on the portrait itself, as the piece isn't done. There won't be so much white empty space when its finished.

    9 Comments
    2024/11/18
    07:45 UTC

    4

    Please help! How do I fix this face

    3 Comments
    2024/11/18
    07:34 UTC

    0

    Crit is much appreciated

    3 Comments
    2024/11/18
    06:56 UTC

    Back To Top