/r/ArtCrit

Photograph via snooOG

A place for artists of all abilities to give and receive constructive feedback.

  • Welcome to r/ArtCrit!

  • A reddit for artists to get feedback on their work, all forms welcome. Traditional, digital, anything goes.

  • All art forms welcome


    • Subreddit Rules

    • Please be civil

    • Do not slander "bad" work, these artists stand to benefit the most from even simple suggestions and critiques

    • Keep critique focused on technique and craftsmanship

    • Please refrain from downvoting submissions you do not like. These people are looking for help improving, just like everybody else.

    • Posted work must be submitted by the artist, or someone close to them, posts to sites discussing art or other artists will be removed

    • NSFW Artwork is allowed, but must be tagged [NSFW]


    • Critique Tips

    • Above all, be honest and forthcoming

    • Be specific, don't say "I like it!" say, "I like the way you...." and likewise for negative comments

    • Be Helpful, link to books, tutorials, or offer exercises for the artist

    • Don't refer to things as "good" or "bad," try to talk in terms of skill sets that can be worked on

    • A lot of us are visual thinkers, if you have a tablet copy+paste and make some notes

    • When receiving a critique, don't be too defensive, you can't explain away other peoples opinions of your art, try and listen to what they are saying

    • Follow this link for a great post by Huisme on asking for critique




    Flair Legend

    Flair should guide other users to understand where you want to go, or where you are coming from, enjoy

    Student Flair

    Use student flair to show what level you are, feel free to write in a genre or medium

    Beginner

    Intermediate

    Skilled

    Skill Flair

    Skill flair shows off what you're good at, feel free to include genre, technique, or discipline you like to work in, you can be a beginner and still use skill flair if you like

    Drawing

    Painting

    Acrylic

    Oil

    Digital

    Watercolor

    Marker

    Pen

    Sculpture

    Abstract

    Other

    Foundations Flair

    Got a really great critique? Message the Mod to recommend that user for Foundations Flair, special flair for those who are particularly helpful to users

    Foundations

    /r/ArtCrit

    98,757 Subscribers

    1

    I just finished this draft and I want to know if I'm on the right track

    I'm going to use this drawing to make a new advertisement to sell my art commissions.

    1 Comment
    2024/12/03
    20:58 UTC

    1

    Hi, whats wrong with it and how to correct it?

    4 Comments
    2024/12/03
    20:51 UTC

    2

    Looking for feedback on this piece, particularly micro things as I'm nearly done with it!

    2 Comments
    2024/12/03
    19:20 UTC

    12

    How do i make the character more like he's genuinely debating if to jump, and less like a generic anime villain being edgy? (The 🧍🏻 pose is part of his character though,,,)

    11 Comments
    2024/12/03
    19:00 UTC

    7

    How can I improve this painting?

    Want to make it feel more finished and professional.

    I feel feel like it’s still in the “ugly” phase of painting. Especially the flowers and leaves. Would adding more highlights and shadows (maybe bluish shadows) to the leaves help, or detract from the portrait?

    Also, how can I make the flowers pop more, while keeping the same background color?

    Thanks so much. :)

    3 Comments
    2024/12/03
    17:23 UTC

    4

    Critique

    I want to take my painting to the next level. I think maybe what’s holding me back is that I paint very rigid, not very confident brush strokes, and I end up getting lost in details that maybe don’t need too much attention. How do I paint more “naturally” so to say?

    1 Comment
    2024/12/03
    16:53 UTC

    4

    Can i have advice on dijital colouring please? I'm struggling sm with hair, though any advice is appreciated!!! (Also i know the chin is so wrong, I just noticed😞)

    1 Comment
    2024/12/03
    16:38 UTC

    1

    Best work so far. How do I beat it?

    Composition and color palette feel strong to me. Some of the details feel a little muddy, particularly as it relates to anatomy. Also, any production tips for oil painting? I no the basic stuff, fat over thin and all that, but this painting took months so I know there's something I can do more efficiently.

    1 Comment
    2024/12/03
    14:41 UTC

    0

    Advice on improving digital colouring

    6 Comments
    2024/12/03
    11:59 UTC

    3

    I’d like some input on what I need to work on.

    I’m loo

    2 Comments
    2024/12/03
    10:08 UTC

    2

    How can I made it more detail?

    3 Comments
    2024/12/03
    08:27 UTC

    6

    Hey guys, can I have some constructive criticism?

    5 Comments
    2024/12/03
    06:16 UTC

    9

    There are many things wrong with this

    This was my first time painting and I found it pretty hard

    I think my main issues are color variety and hard/soft edges.

    Idk if this is a result of the software I’m using(clip studio paint) or I just need to practice more but blending is really hard for me. Especially putting down a new color and blending it into what I previously blended. It just ends up looking muddy/has that airbrush effect.

    Also idk if it matters but here is my process:

    1. Lay down a tone color for the background

    2. Sketch all the details

    3. Paint a base color for skin

    4. Paint shadows

    5. Paint warm tones for skin

    6. Paint highlights

    6 Comments
    2024/12/03
    06:06 UTC

    1

    Intrusive- Assemblage Box

    I didn’t get much feedback on this during critique. any thoughts ?

    1 Comment
    2024/12/03
    05:50 UTC

    1

    Hey guys, how can I make this pose look less… stiff ?

    8 Comments
    2024/12/03
    05:29 UTC

    2

    Crit please.

    Hey everyone, I've been re watching Fairy Tale and I decided to draw Igneel.

    I was following a how to guide just to get the shaping down as I haven't drawn any full body dragons before, as I've only been drawing since late September.

    Im also having trouble with paper size? This is a larger artist pad and I still didn't have the room to fit the wings correctly.

    I'm finding that if I use a smaller pad or a larger one I always run out of space.

    I know there are bigger sheets but I spend 95% of my time drawing in my car between Uber orders.

    Any tips?

    This was done in pencil and then lined with a micron pen.

    1 Comment
    2024/12/03
    05:18 UTC

    8

    Except for the line quality, what could improve this drawing?

    (I know the line quality is terrible and I need to refine these hands lol) but except that which constructive criticism can you give on this? Thank you!

    5 Comments
    2024/12/03
    02:46 UTC

    6

    Need help!

    I don’t hate or love this piece so far. Newish to digital art and using color/ rendering so any advice would be much appreciated. I think I have been staring at it too long and am missing its flaws. Do I need to keep rendering?

    This is about 7hrs in, is that typical this stage?

    4 Comments
    2024/12/03
    01:58 UTC

    Back To Top