/r/VietnamWar

Photograph via snooOG

A subreddit dedicated to the history of the conflict in Vietnam

WELCOME

This is an educational subreddit dedicated entirely to the wars and conflicts that occurred in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia between 1946 and 1979 (and beyond!).

Rules and Guidelines

  1. The Golden Rule: This subreddit is intended for civil and informed discussion of the Vietnam War and related issues. Engaging in bigotry or racism, and resorting to insults or hostility will result in a ban.
  2. While anyone is welcome to comment in /r/VietnamWar, comments about the history of the war should be offered in good faith and only when you, the commenter, are sure that what you say is true. That being said, opinion is also welcome -- just make sure you present it as such. If you are asked to provide a source then you will have to present one. Failure to do so will result in a removal of the post in question.
  3. The war and its historiography are contentious issues which are still debated to this day. The possibility of someone disagreeing with your take on things certainly exists, but both parties are required to engage the matter in a polite and charitable fashion. We here at /r/VietnamWar welcome both the orthodox and revisionist schools of study.
  4. Please have a detailed caption for any historical photograph and video you submit in this subreddit. This should include year, location, and a description of the subject shown in the photograph. Personal photographs and original content are excluded from this rule.
  5. No political soap-boxing or modern-day politics. Such posts will be removed, and repeat violations will result in a ban.
  6. No 'edits', modern music videos or other videos that are not from the time period in question. Furthermore, submissions and images of reenactment kits, replicas or reproductions, video games, or films are not allowed.
  7. Memes, pun threads, reaction .gifs, MFWs and anything of the sort are strictly forbidden. /r/VietnamWar is a venue for serious discussion of the conflict. That doesn't mean you can't inject humor into a post, but a joke should not be the entirety of a comment.
  8. Basically, if you wouldn't do it in /r/AskHistorians, don't do it here.
  9. If you have any questions, concerns or comments about the subreddit, please message the moderators directly.

/r/VietnamWar

19,545 Subscribers

5

Does anyone know how to visit a collection of Vietnam War photos featuring the USA Army and the South Vietnamese Army?

I've searched the entire internet and found only one person who has collected almost all of the photos. Link to the person's Flickr page

How did this person gain access to these photos? In the photo descriptions, the source is mentioned as Corbis, but when I searched for the company, it seems like Corbis was acquired by Getty Images.

I am a huge fan of the history of the Vietnam War, so I really want to take a deep look and understand it better.

8 Comments
2024/05/11
23:54 UTC

2

Why did pretty much all military of the West believed there was no way for the Vietnamese to bring up artillery into Dien Bien Phu?

Its pretty much a common meme mocking the arrogance of the French army for the cluster%@#! that is Dien Bien Phu in particular about the widespread belief in the military stationed in Indochina that there is no way for the VietMinh to bring up artillery over the top of the mountains of DBP. An assumption that would cost the battle and lead to the worst defeat any European colonial power has aver faced after World War 2. So much to the point the French are the only major empire that lost a major head-on conventional pitch battle in the style of Clausewitz against the colonized rebels during the downfall of colonialism.

But as I read more into the whole war, it becomes apparent the French weren't alone in believing that it'd be impossible to transport artillery to Dien Bien Phu. Bernard Fall mentions that Americans who were involved in French affairs actually believed the uphill mountains would be extremely difficult even for the US army to transport any equipment with noteworthy firepower like AA guns and tanks never mind large tall heavy cannons that made up the bulk of Vietnamese far ranged weapons in the battle. At least one American intel officer ultimately agreed with the French conclusion that there's no way the stationed division there could lose as the VietMinh wouldn't have the weapons to obliterate the flimsy trenches and bunkers built on the location esp with French counter-battery. And even if they brought big guns, American analysts sincerely believed no way would they be brought in large enough numbrs with enough shells to pose a threat.

I seen British statements to the French also saying that while they warned the place would be a death trap if a Western equipped army is able to cross over, the artillery equipment would be a gigantic pain to bring up. Even the Soviets were treating the whole thing as a side show where if the VietMinh lost, its no big deal and a minor liability and if they win, well great investment for the communist PR withe little money thrown which is why the bulk of equipment came through Chinese direct aid rather than Soviets directly doing the supply chains. Basically plenty of the goods where Chinese-purchased if not even made in China and the Soviets while hoping for a victory, where not throwing big investments because they thought it'd more likely be another typical defeat in the war.

I have to ask why did the West practically believe that the VietMinh would unlikely to have transport mass artillery into Dien Bien Phu? I mean I'm just flabbergasted reading from not just Bernard Fall but from other books of how its not just the French but the Americans equally believed as well that artillery (or at least enough of it) would be impossible to transport across the hills over the summit of the highest mountains into the valley and the Brits and Soviet pessimism in the situation for the Vietnamese side. Why was this believe so rife among first world nations? instead DBP would be the greatest single victory in a traditional Western style mass battle ever won by the anti-colonialist revolutionaries and this is due to the fact they did the impossible task of transporting howitzers and other heavy firepower into the place despite large hills and even a mountain or two alone the way!

4 Comments
2024/05/11
22:29 UTC

5

Vietnam -Then & now Huê (Saigon, Street without joy)

0 Comments
2024/05/11
22:14 UTC

33

Bath time

Closest thing we had to bathing - a quick run down the road from our firebase. 4/60th Dusters - West of Bong Son, 1970.

6 Comments
2024/05/11
04:33 UTC

26

Can anyone help identify what the thing in the middle is? I assume it’s a rank of some sort but I’m just trying to learn I guess

Was my grandpas but was passed down to me

12 Comments
2024/05/10
02:19 UTC

5

HELP w/ Dads DD214

My father passed this year and I'm building a shadowbox. He served two tours in Vietnam. I don't have all of the details but he was enlisted guard in NY during this period and then went active and retired after 22 years or so. i have his final 214 which is crisp and clear but I'm really interested in knowing what these awards are on his 214 from 1972. Can you all help me decode the acronyms here? NDSM -national defense service memo, RVNCM - republic of Vietnam campaign medal, VSM?, MUC - meritorious service medal, RVN? osf gallantry?, CCMD(1st award)? thanks!

https://preview.redd.it/l9cbevcd9izc1.png?width=1072&format=png&auto=webp&s=5dabcf6a4d09f65714a1fa0254bd1fba823b9175

1 Comment
2024/05/10
01:56 UTC

3

U.S. AIR FORCE AIR STRIKES IN NORTH VIETNAM in 1966 BOMBING OF HANOI 23384

0 Comments
2024/05/09
19:38 UTC

1

Looking for a photo

I’m going crazy trying to find this photo that I’m beginning to think I made it up. It was a soldier or marine taking a knee and firing an m60 one handed while feeding the belt with his other hand. He had no helmet on and some sunglasses on. Been trying to find it for the last hour and feel like I’m going crazy as I thought it was a pretty popular picture. Cheers

5 Comments
2024/05/09
13:43 UTC

1

Any memoirs from vets of the U.S. 1st, 4th or 25th IDs?

I’ve always mainly read about the 1st cavalry and 23rd ID when it comes to the books I’ve read about Vietnam. As such most of my knowledge about the war is from them mainly we were soldiers, If I die in A combat zone, and When I turned 19. I’m looking to see if there’s any books/ memoirs from vets of the 1st, 4th or 25th IDs since I’ve been trying to look into their history since idk much other than the 4th fought at Dak To and my uncle served in a maintenance unit with them near plekiue. Any suggestions are appreciated thank you.

0 Comments
2024/05/09
09:08 UTC

24

This is a painting of my dad.

The painter was a friend of his in the service. We only have a photo of the painting. Is there any way we can find out who painted it? It is absolutely breathtaking, he was a fantastic painter.

Of course, like all soldiers, my Dad was very handsome in his uniform!

1 Comment
2024/05/09
00:18 UTC

0

Urban Legend? US pilots in the Vietnam War going blind in flight due to rotor resonance

I am trying to track down the source of a story I remember hearing about. The gist is that during the war there were reports of pilots experiencing bouts of sudden blindness while in flight, when looked into it was determined that the rotor vibration had been resonating with a part of the pilot's eyes (Specifically some part of the back of the eye if memory serves).

I am having trouble finding any references to this however, has anyone else heard of this occurrence or do you think this was more of an urban legend?

3 Comments
2024/05/08
18:44 UTC

34

These are my Dad’s.

Other than the rank being upside down, what can you all tell me about them? My Dad is 92, served in Korea and Vietnam, and doesn’t like to talk about it.

6 Comments
2024/05/08
17:39 UTC

3

How frequent were traps in Vietnam?

24 Comments
2024/05/06
05:04 UTC

13

Our Year of War: Daniel Bolger writes an intimate and engrossing account of The Vietnam War in 1968 through the lens of two brothers fighting the war side by side.

Bolger's descriptions and poetic style of writing stopped me in my tracks a few times with its wide lens of reflection. He goes deep into details on weapons, the lingo of war, the battles within Mini-Tet, the 1968 assassinations of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Bobby Kennedy, and the growing chasm that was the anti-war movement back home. He also spends considerable time explaining the metrics of victory and the problematic and typically outdated ways the war was fought. Using many examples in different situational contexts, he highlights the approach ordered by a WWII General to be carried out by "grunts" in the jungle, surrounded by unknown tripwires and an elusive enemy that never seems to show himself. Each example seems to showcase the vast difference in the war that was being fought slowly by a rifle platoon machete-hatching their way through the boggy jungle and how it was being fought by MVAC and the U.S. government back in Washington.

In Vietnam, Chuck and Tom Hagel served side by side in the same rifle platoon. Together, they fought in the Mekong Delta, battled snipers in Saigon, chased the enemy through the jungle, and saved each other's life under fire. However, when their one-year tour was over, these two brothers came home side by but no longer in step—one supporting the war, the other hating it.

Together, Chuck and Tom Hagel have five Purple Hearts, a Bronze Star with a V for Valor, the Army Commendation Medal, and the Combat Infantryman Badge. I am also currently reading Mark Bowden's Hue 1968 and Bolger's Our Year at War, which was a wonderful and more narrow exploration to accompany that. I highly recommend it to anyone interested in personal war stories that are usually too granular for military histories.

0 Comments
2024/05/04
21:16 UTC

4

Books about coming/being home after the war

Any recommendations for books detailing what it was like coming home after the war or adjusting to life in the 60s/70s afterward?

Can be historical fiction.

6 Comments
2024/05/03
16:15 UTC

3

We Were Soldiers - The "candle trail" scene.

I was watching We Were Soldiers last night and it came to the scene where Snake Shit flies over a trail clearly illuminated with hundreds of VC carrying candles in the dark.

Surely this did not happen...? I can't think of an easier target for an air strike.

11 Comments
2024/05/03
14:49 UTC

48

Ron Kovic with a group of dissident veterans encamped in the office of Sen. Alan Cranston (1974) ■ Tom Cruise in Born on the Fourth of July (1989) by Oliver Stone ● Tom Cruise, Ron Kovic and Oliver Stone at The 47th Annual Golden Globe Awards (1990)

19 Comments
2024/05/03
14:42 UTC

1

Information on RVN Police Field Force

Does anyone have any information on the RVN Police Field Force? Including but not limited to photos, websites, and or books? Any information would help.

0 Comments
2024/05/03
03:16 UTC

12

Why did Navy Seals Hunt for Soviet RPD-44 and Wear Blue Jeans in Vietnam

0 Comments
2024/05/02
20:43 UTC

6

Has anybody heard of The Community of Foreign Angels during the Vietnam War?

My grandfather passed away and left behind a series of autobiographical notes for a book he wanted to write. I was reading through them and there's a brief (1 page) passage about a group of 75 GI's that he was a part of that lived in Chau Doc in 1971/72. He said the group was called "The Community of Foreign Angels". They were cut off from the rest of the US Army and only got supplies via helicopter drop once a week. The notes mention that they traveled into Cambodia to get other supplies. I know enough about the Vietnam war to know they definitely weren't supposed to go into Cambodia and I also know he was a member of Army Intelligence, so I'm guessing this group was there for more than charity work. If it helps, he does mention they were working with a Catholic church run by a Chicago educated priest and three english speaking nuns. I can't find anything on google for The Community of Foreign Angels nor anything about US soldiers being in Chau Doc at that time. Does anyone know what this group could be or where I can start doing more research to uncover what he was doing there?

5 Comments
2024/05/02
13:31 UTC

20

My grandpa showed me this.

He also mentioned his call sign was Alpha Two Six.

4 Comments
2024/05/02
04:39 UTC

2

Info on CIA operations in Nakhon Phanom

Hello,

I'm looking for a source(s) of information on the CIA operations dealing with interrogation during the war in the 1964-68 timeframe.

1 Comment
2024/05/01
13:51 UTC

Back To Top