/r/USHistory

Photograph via snooOG

Premier subreddit for the history and historiography of the United States of America

The premier subreddit for the history and historiography of the United States of America. We welcome discussions, debates, questions, articles, videos, discoveries, etc.

Rules:

  • No submissions on events that occurred less than 20 years ago.

  • We have a zero tolerance policy for racism, sexism, homophobia, using "retard" as an insult and other derogatory remarks.

  • No memes, screencaps, or other "meme-like" content.

  • No homework questions.

  • Blog-spamming and self promotion is discouraged.

  • Submit all book related inquiries to /r/USHistoryBookClub

Upvote

Good posts that constructively add to the conversation, people citing sources, and helpful answers

Downvote

Unhelpful or antagonistic replies

Report

Blogspam, self promotion, flaming, insults, memes, or anything else that breaks our rules.

Sister Subreddits:

/r/USHistoryBookClub - for the discussion of non-fiction books

/r/AmericanHistory - for the history of the Western Hemisphere

/r/PanAmerica - for the issues and commonalities of the citizens of the Western Hemisphere

/r/USHistory

99,303 Subscribers

3

Is history different from propaganda?

You only hear one side of the story and the winners write with their bias.

I once tried to reach out an indigenous tribe near me for their side of the story and they said because I'm not a member they can't share their history perspective with me.

18 Comments
2024/12/01
16:43 UTC

6

Worth anything?

5 Comments
2024/12/01
15:49 UTC

1

What woman in the 1800s was closest to being president?

I know Victoria Woodhull technically ran for president in 1872, but I'm more so talking about any woman who had enough political power/influence that they could run in an election and win?

16 Comments
2024/12/01
14:26 UTC

219

Was James Buchanan the worst ever U.S. president?

After looking at him, he seems very indecisive, and he didn't do much about the South seceding.

382 Comments
2024/12/01
07:38 UTC

10

Historic tour of the US?

If you could go on a tour of the United States to learn about its history, what would your stops be? Gettysburg, etc.

18 Comments
2024/12/01
04:04 UTC

127

Pfc. Edward J. Foley of the 143rd Infantry, 36th Division, cleaning his M1903 Springfield sniper rifle before moving out to the front lines near Velletri in Italy. May 1944.

13 Comments
2024/12/01
01:17 UTC

0

Does anyone have that old video of the guy calling Huey long a dictator and saying many people now regret the Louisiana purchase?

0 Comments
2024/11/30
23:09 UTC

0

How and why did the original Republican and Democratic parties flip ideologies beginning in the 1800s?

54 Comments
2024/11/30
22:27 UTC

76

If you could get rid of one Constitutional amendment or alternate, what would it be?

If you could get rid of one Constitutional amendment or alternate, what would it be?

705 Comments
2024/11/30
19:52 UTC

0

US History Hagiography

When did we really start to move away from hagiography for US history for the common people? It seems to me as a child raised in the 90s that adults around me (myself as a young teenager included) started to be surprised when more accurate, or at least more controversial, stories of the founding fathers started coming out. I'm wondering if this was just me, or if most of the histories that the masses read or believed up until the mid-1990s were hagiographic. Any insights?

8 Comments
2024/11/30
17:41 UTC

1

Why do people say Stagflation was out of Carter's control even thought Carter actually inherited an economy in recovery?

https://preview.redd.it/mgna95nb904e1.jpg?width=330&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=098a15d00c2311574a175a253b4566ba1f7bcbc3

The economy was quite poor through out the 70s but by 1976 it had actually started to recover under Ford which was the reason why the election became as close as it was, well that and Carter's campaign which was as poor as the economy under him.

13 Comments
2024/11/30
09:14 UTC

0

Why is America the greatest country?

All Americans say it. History people probably have the best idea. Why do you think it’s the best country in the world?

59 Comments
2024/11/30
03:34 UTC

15

any background behind this pocket watch or is it not rare at all?

my boyfriends cousin got this from her teacher just wondering if anyone knows anything about it? the outside says “200th US constitution anniversary” , just curious 😊

8 Comments
2024/11/30
03:28 UTC

387

Was Andrew Jackson a good president?

705 Comments
2024/11/30
02:59 UTC

371

Senator Peter Gerry of Rhode Island is the only Senator to date to lose re-election but return to defeat the same person that defeated him for re-election.

24 Comments
2024/11/29
23:22 UTC

17

Why did Lyndon B. Johnson fire Robert McNamara?

16 Comments
2024/11/29
16:41 UTC

102

Why was George Wallace so angry?

122 Comments
2024/11/29
15:47 UTC

0

Why did the US intentionally deprive occupied western Germany of food?

I recently read that after Germany surrendered, German prisoners were designated as disarmed enemy forces, rather than prisoner of war status. Due to this, they were not entitled to the same quantities of food as U.S troops. There was often starvation in camps and the international redcross was prevented from involving itself and over 16,500 German prisoners died in French camps alone.

US soliders were also under orders not to share food with the German poulation. Women were not allowed to share any leftovers with German maids.

Here's information I found on the wiki -

"According to a U.S. intelligence survey a German university professor reportedly said: "Your soldiers are good-natured, good ambassadors; but they create unnecessary ill will to pour 20 liters [5 U.S. gallons] of leftover cocoa in the gutter when it is badly needed in our clinics. It makes it hard for me to defend American democracy among my countrymen."

Why did the US donate food resources to occupied Japan, but withhold food from the Germans?

21 Comments
2024/11/29
14:15 UTC

438

Why was the 1876 election close in the first place?

81 Comments
2024/11/29
13:34 UTC

53

“A child can run it” and “All speeds 1-25 Miles per Hour”- The Sears Motor Buggy for $395. (1909)

15 Comments
2024/11/29
13:11 UTC

21

Was slavery in South really threatened by 1860s?

I don't live in the US so I am a total layman and outsider but the Confederate States of America was formed by Southern slave states to protect the institution of slavery as part of their speeches and documents.

However I am curious how was slavery as an in the South threatened by the Northern free states? From my research the Northern states outnumbered the South so theoretically they would have more power over the federal government but was not very fully abolitionist or interested in outlawing slavery in the South so how did the South feel that slavery was threatened?

PS: As an outsider I am not fully informed on how the US government works and want people to clarify

76 Comments
2024/11/29
06:38 UTC

16

The Soiling of Old Glory

Taken during the Boston Busing Crisis of 1976. Joseph Rakes swang an American flag on a pole at Civil rights activist Tim Landsmark. Jim Kelly, Boston city Councilman who was anti busing is seen trying to pull Landsmark out of the way. Rakes was charged with assault with a deadly weapon and would be known as the "flag kid" from then on.

16 Comments
2024/11/29
05:28 UTC

6

Did this happen?

I heard a story about an englishman wanting to meet the president and so he just turned up at the white house and waited outside the oval office. This would have been in the distant past before security measures were brought in to stop this sort of thing. Does anyone know if this happened and if so, which president was it? and what was the name of the english guy? I have tried googling this but all of the results are about modern meetings with other heads of state.

5 Comments
2024/11/29
02:53 UTC

357

Superman in the Macy's Thanksgiving Parade. New York City, November 21, 1940

9 Comments
2024/11/29
00:55 UTC

172

Three American infantrymen eat K Rations on Thanksgiving day in a dugout near Fauquermont, France. They will be relieved later and will have Thanksgiving dinner in the evening with their unit. The soldiers are left to right: Sgt. Albert E. Burns, PFC John K. Smith, and Pvt. Robert H. Seymour.

4 Comments
2024/11/28
20:40 UTC

33

Your thoughts on Burr

Burr is one of (honestly THE) those historical figures who I feel like has never has been pinned down. Jackson, Jefferson, Adams, you name 'em, I feel like I understand where they were coming from. But not Burr. No matter what angle I come at him from, and I've read about the man in a variety of contexts (academically speaking), I just never feel like I understand his motives.

So what, fellow history buffs, do you make of the man?

75 Comments
2024/11/28
17:06 UTC

619

Thanksgiving in Vietnam 1967

10 Comments
2024/11/28
16:58 UTC

0

What caused the US Civil War?

I'm being told what my teacher said was wrong (from the South).

I was told the cause was Lincoln. Lincoln became president, South Carolina seceded and then other Southern states followed to form the Confederate States.

So Lincoln attacked with the North to show states they weren't allowed to secede. Then, he abolished slavery because he realized slaves fighting for him would turn the tide of the battle in the North's favor. But, he never wanted to abolish slavery until he saw he couldn't win without them.

125 Comments
2024/11/28
15:49 UTC

Back To Top