Just noticed it watching through Season 1 on my 3rd rewatch. Towards the end of episode 7, Papania and Gilbough approach Errol while he's mowing a cemetary. This is almost the exact same circumstances when Rust approaches Errol at the school while he's mowing in episode 3.

Is this alluding to Rust being correct about Eternal Recurrence? Are Papania and Gilbough just repeating in time like Rust and Marty?

I never initially realized why over the course of his interview he kept carving out the figures until I zeroed in one it-

It represents the Tuttle videotape, one smaller figure in the middle (Marie Fontenot) surrounded by other figures, and Rust did this because he knew cult members would be watching the questioning film and he wanted to threaten that he knows about it

Another detail about the Tuttle tape that I saw on a YouTube comment, is that the Police Chief with white hair that shows up with Tuttle in the Police Station has the same exact posture and hand positioning as the leftmost figure in the last shot of the tape

It makes me wonder what other ridiculously niche foreshadowing was missed

So I just rewatched S1 after a decade or so...I kinda only remembered it vaguely, damn, what a show.

One thing I had in the back of my mind all along though, is how at some point Marty would find out that his own children were also abused, potentially by his father-in-law or some other family member being part of the cult. That obviously didn't happen though, so what other series or movie am I mixing it up with? Some cop (or just a guy) trying to solve a case of child abduction/sexual abuse and then based on some drawings, or whatever else he finds in the kids room, or something the kids might say to them would make them realize that they were also at least targeted, if not necessarily acted upon. I kinda remember this being like a plot twist near the end, just to turn things up to 11.

I tried ChatGPT and it gave suggestions like the movie Prisoners with Jackman and Gyllenhaal which yeah it sure does have a similar vibe and matches some parts of the idea but that's not it.

What did he mean by this? Reggie is obviously a white supremacist and I guess we can assume Dewall is probably one too, so I’m confused when they are referred to as “not being white enough to be white trash”? Was there any reference in the show to them being mixed? This line has me stumped because I’m working on a Tuttle family tree and I’m trying to figure out what this means.

A question about something I've never been able to understand.

The Tuttell cult has been killing for many years, but was it Errol Childress who started leaving bodies with symbols because he was basically crazy? Is it logical that the Tuttells didn't want that because they could be discovered? Was Errol acting alone?

The Ledoux were in charge of recruiting victims for the rituals, but what would be the point of leaving bodies in plain sight for everyone to see?

CASE FILES: https://youtu.be/rHR4LjtjLko https://youtube.com/shorts/iqYh1NTWehc https://youtu.be/FDI7X5NwbpM

S1, E3: Marty saying to his partner Rust, “You see that? Your fucking attitute. Not everyone wants to sit alone in an empty room beating off to murder manuals.” Priceless.

My cast choice would be Josh Brolin and Josh Hartnett as both been great in Sin City

Its been about a year since my obsession with S1 ended but im back!! Will watch all 8 episodes tn with some beer. Feel free to reply ill be updating thoughts on season as night goes on. Starting it now!

I've been meaning to order a copy. By Robert Chambers. Published 1895.

I just finished season 1 and thought it was fantastic and I've seen kind of conflicting reports on how much season 4 connects to season 1. My question is, does season 4 provide any more story to season 1? I assume this has been covered on this sub a lot, but I don't want to accidentally read spoilers, so I didn't search. Thanks.

I'm so late to this but finally watched it and it is one of the best TV show I've ever seen. So now to erase this memories ( so I can watch it again and again) can anyone suggest any similar series like true detective.

Have you noticed that rust is always in training but he's always drinking. This is especially in the part when he comes back to Louisiana. He says that he was drinking all the time and funkcional but drunk. He doesn't have any belly fat with his age and he's always in top shape. I call total BS on that. So what do you think?

Everytime i see this still i think of sam rockwell

Watching for the 10th time and just noticed this shot. They fade/blur the shot for Cohle's reflection to resemble Jesus, with Angelic music at the background. Found the whole saviour link with this shot very interesting.

Every time I watch this series I like it even more.

In season one episode one, Rust explains to Marty the motivation behind the crime. "An attachment of physical lust to practices forbidden by society". He confirms that he got that idea from a book. Do you by any chance know what book this might be? Sounds intriguing.