/r/SubredditReviews

Photograph via snooOG

This subreddit is now private. Click here to find out why we have gone dark: https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/5/23749188/reddit-subreddit-private-protest-api-changes-apollo-charges

This is a subreddit designed for critiquing and criticizing subreddits. You can submit a review of your own, or you can submit a subreddit you want to be reviewed!

We are a community designed to help users and their subreddits.

There are two acceptable types of post

  • Your own review of another subreddit

This is fairly straightforward. You can review any subreddit for any reason, there is no criteria (x amount of subs, active, etc.). If you want to review a subreddit you can do it, as long as it abides by the submission guidelines.

  • A request for an honest and constructive review of a subreddit you moderate

Everyone on Reddit wants to spearhead a successful subreddit that they started from nothing. This is extremely difficult to do, and sometimes a little outside help is required. Feel free to submit your subreddit here (see posting guidelines) and you will get honest and constructive feedback. We encourage people who are struggling to incite participation, have stagnated subscriber growth, or any number of other problems to post here, but any sub can be submitted for any reason.


Posting Guidelines

All reviews should be, first and foremost, constructive criticisms. Posts and comments will be removed if they

  • Are full of flame and hate

  • Provide no constructive feedback

  • Are too short to be meaningful.

  • Don't give positives and negatives

Reviews should be well formatted, but formatting will not cause the removal of a good piece, it is just highly recommended and preferred.

If you are submitted your subreddit for review, the title of the post must be "/r/YourSub Request". Submissions that don't follow this format will be removed.

The body of your submission should include the basics of your sub. This includes, but is not limited to, subscriber count, purpose of the sub, feedback you are looking for. Submissions without additional information in the text box will be removed.


This community first and foremost is a serious forum for discussion and growth. Memes, jokes, trolls, and other low effort or harassing entities will not be welcome. Meta posts about the subreddit are allowed, but discouraged. We recommend you message the mods first and foremost before making a post. If your issue is not resolved with modmail we promise your post will not be removed.


Other Subreddit Help Zones

  • Need a Mod? - Do you want to help, or need help? Either way this is the place to look

  • Adopt A Reddit - Not everyone has time to mod, take a great idea and make it yours

  • Request a Reddit - Is there a sweet sub that the mods have abandoned? Try to get it back here

/r/SubredditReviews

551 Subscribers

1

Plan to review every subreddit

Hi everyone,

I think that this is a good place to post this, I'm planning to review every subreddit, starting with the popular ones. First up, r/funny: https://youtu.be/Wn-Ya0Jwp7g.

Thanks!

Po

2 Comments
2022/09/04
17:59 UTC

0

real free talk Is A Safe Place To Chat! It’s Not Got Many Members & There’s No Posts Yet It Just Needs Some Posts & More Member That’s All.

r/realfreetalk

0 Comments
2022/08/02
02:36 UTC

2

Find lost online friends

r/lostfriends

0 Comments
2022/08/01
04:18 UTC

1

r/TreeRageMusic2

Come To The Metal Woodlands Of Reddit & Listen To The Falling Leaves & hear The Call Of METAL! All Types Of Metal or It’s Subgenres Are Aloud r/TreeRageMusic2

0 Comments
2022/07/28
22:41 UTC

1

r/JustUnsubbed - a lot of people can't take edgy jokes from subs that are made for edgy jokes

Your average post there:

"Just unsubbed from r/shitposting because they post shit there"

"Just unsubbed from r/darkjokes because they make fucked up jokes"

Why did you sub again?

1 Comment
2022/06/01
23:06 UTC

1

/r/TheGreatOnesReborn - A sub for almost anything as long as it's chill. Please review!

0 Comments
2022/01/21
23:46 UTC

9

Turbocourses - My Positive experience with this website.

I sign up to reddit just to say few good words on turbocourses. I had great experience buying courses from them.

Subscription:

it costs only $30 lifetime experience(never expire)

Courses

Have more than 3k courses is forever useful ad they update more courses every month

Value

really good value saved me money and I am happy from them.

Link: turbocourses.net

69 Comments
2021/12/26
23:05 UTC

3

r/CarsandbikesIndia is corrupt.

r/carsandbikesIndia has a very corrupt mod team. I was just posting and the moderators ban me and tell me to get some help. Here are some links to help you.

Invalid bans be like

the only doctor here is your mum?

Cheers, u/Stroov. You've just lost your subreddit.

10 Comments
2021/12/05
16:07 UTC

1

r/NFTheaven

r/NFTheaven is a gathering & the hot spot for those interested in NFTs, Metaverse, Tokens, Projects, Marketplaces...Here where you can discuss & learn more about NFTs, buy, sell, promote and Share your work and ideas, tell your story, but most importantly, interact with others.💲

https://www.reddit.com/r/NFTheaven

0 Comments
2021/12/01
16:13 UTC

1

New Sub r/ToiletMotivation - Any feedback would be great?

Hi, I've not long created:

r/ToiletMotivation - The Community that's Rooting For Your Every Success in Your Toilet Endeavours. Get Words of Encouragement to Help You Push Through Those Hard Times. Motivational Quotes/Images That Sound Like They Were Written Just to Support You Through Your Toilet Visit.

Any feedback would be great?

0 Comments
2021/09/13
03:09 UTC

1

r/ASICMinersTalk - Everything related to crypto mining

Hello fellow redditors,

I created a sub for ASIC miners and crypto mining in general.

I would be glad if you check it out and join if you wish. The sub is still small, but I plan to take care of it.

Here is the link: https://www.reddit.com/r/ASICMinersTalk/

0 Comments
2021/08/31
14:04 UTC

1

r/ASICMinersTalk - everything related to crypto mining

Hello fellow redditors,

I created a sub for ASIC miners and crypto mining in general.

I would be glad if you check it out and join if you wish. The sub is still small, but I plan to take care of it.

Here is the link: https://www.reddit.com/r/ASICMinersTalk/

0 Comments
2021/08/25
09:08 UTC

1

r/ASICMinersTalk - everything related to crypto mining

Hello fellow redditors,

I created a sub for ASIC miners and crypto mining in general.

I would be glad if you check it out and join if you wish. The sub is still small, but I plan to take care of it.

Here is the link: https://www.reddit.com/r/ASICMinersTalk/

0 Comments
2021/06/10
12:54 UTC

1

r/audiotranscription - a place to talk about speech recognition and audio transcription

0 Comments
2021/06/07
11:22 UTC

0

Questions about this Sub

  1. Can we review any Sub here? Is this one included?
  2. Why don't we have flairs?
0 Comments
2021/05/27
11:08 UTC

3

Please Review my Subreddit!

r/FunMathProblems

0 Comments
2021/05/12
04:01 UTC

4

SR: r/Reddit_Island

Hello everybody, I am u/Kerviearon25 of Reddit and today we're going to review one of the most up-and-coming subreddits: r/Reddit_Island.

But first off, what is r/Reddit_Island**?**

r/Reddit_Island is a movement established on May 1, 2021 because of a meme explaining how Redditors could buy an island if they wanted to.

r/Reddit_Island can also be considered the modern successor to r/redditisland, a similar attempt in 2011 which failed due to inactivity.

Alright, now what are the positive aspects of the subreddit?

First off, it manages to unite Redditors together on one goal: an island/town.

The subreddit shows that Reddit could unite to ultimately reach a goal they want, whether it's crashing the stock market or getting a pedophile enabler admin fired, Reddit can do that.

Emphasis on COULD.

Okay, there's the positives, what about the negatives?

There is negative aspects about Reddit_Island. And that is Reddit itself.

You see, when r/redditisland came into birth, Reddit was different back then. There was a sense of community and that would result in a far more serious project.. if it hadn't been inactive.

Unfortunately, when you come to r/Reddit_Island, you see memes and conflicting ideas, people supporting a town, people supporting an island.

There is no sign of actual planning or suggestions; it's all just memes.

And it's also filled with the usual "Reddit" circlejerk: "tiktok bad. keanu reeves good", etc.

And there's also a problem with organization and centralization; the moderators ("board members") are not really organized and don't really communicate to the public well.

And one of the moderators are as toxic as can be: a former subreddit moderator was described as a toxic no-lifer troll constantly hindering progress and silencing those who think the project will fall.

As of now, they have been resigned/retired/fired from the team and is currently trying to make their own separate movement akin to the goals of Reddit Island... but I don't think I can see any progress other than trying to contact Elon Musk. I will not mention the movement here.

So what's the final conclusion?

r/Reddit_Island has a lot of potential, but it is hindered by the current Reddit community's circlejerks and the lack of organization within the moderators as well.

Will it succeed? No one knows.

-- u/Kerviearon25

0 Comments
2021/05/11
07:56 UTC

1

please review my subreddit r/HornyArmory, don't worry it's not a nsfw sub or anything

so we make weapons and armor for r/hornyresistance currently, but are hoping to expand to more anti bonk patrol subreddits. in order for us to expand, we need to make our subreddit as appealing as possible. also if you don't mind, please consider joining our subreddit so that we can hit our goal of 52 members (that's twice as many as r/BONKcrusaders).

0 Comments
2021/04/07
07:06 UTC

0

reddit banned me from posting on their ebay subreddit because I said that ebay moderates it!

reddit banned me from posting on their ebay subreddit because I said that ebay moderates it!

If Reddiit tolerates that deception I am done with reddit!

3 Comments
2021/04/07
00:20 UTC

0

great subreddit! horrible moderation r/gamemusic

So as some of you may know im a musician, a rapper to be exact. ill try to keep this short. i posted in their community 2 different post of my music work. (im new to reddit btw) i attempted to abide by their rules and apparently i messed up somewhere. With out any warning i was permanently banned. I sent the moderators a message trying to ask why i was banned and explained that i basically felt it was blasphemy. ( i was not profane in anyway) without a reply they muted me for 3 days. I think its very ironic and hypocritical that they run a community about game music but aren't in favor of supporting any independent music artist. Even if you felt i had broken your rules. You could have explained to me how they were broken. They may not see the immediate effects of this situation on their community but if you look at the larger scale they are doing nothing but destroying the very community they are trying to run.

0 Comments
2021/02/13
11:42 UTC

0

0 Comments
2021/01/05
15:25 UTC

1

Please review my sub • r/embracemonkey

First and foremost this is a sub about monkey memes that also tends to dabble in some anprim political memes.

I was able to grow it up to 3,000 members fairly quickly but despite that, barely any of my members consistently post.

I’d really appreciate you guys to honesty review it and possibly give ideas for ways to make it more inviting for new posters, thanks!

0 Comments
2021/01/02
23:26 UTC

2

please review the sub r/artoilpainting

0 Comments
2020/11/05
16:22 UTC

3

Please review my new subreddit /r/hybristophilia

Looking for proactive advice, especially on promotion and getting more user activity, since I just took over this subreddit:

https://www.reddit.com/r/hybristophilia/

0 Comments
2020/07/29
07:17 UTC

2

What do you guys think of my sub for hanging out and making friends, /r/TheGreatOnesReborn ?

/r/TheGreatOnesReborn is an 18+ sub for people to make friends and get to know each other. We talk about and post almost anything, though lately it's mostly just music or weird videos we find on YouTube.

The sub is just basically a place to hang out with buddies when you have nothing better to do. I've been promoting today and could use some of your thoughts to make things better and hopefully do better the next time I promote.

Thanks!

2 Comments
2020/07/22
09:22 UTC

7

I want to know how the world sees r/hobbydrama!

r/hobbydrama seems to be bit of a hidden gem to me! It's a subreddit where people detail the crazy, specific dramas going on in their hobby - ones that the rest of the world are likely blind to. What do you think of the stories on there?

1 Comment
2020/07/07
22:44 UTC

3

r/DannyBoyle is a subreddit dedicated to the director of Trainspotting, The Beach, 28 Days Later, Slumdog Millionaire, 127 Hours, Steve Jobs and Yesterday fame.

Brand new. New to modding and creating subs. Huge movie need. Tell me what to do better

1 Comment
2020/05/28
19:55 UTC

2

Please give your hoñnnNNnÑest opinñion of /r/SurrealEntropy

Looking to make improvements/see what's working. Thanks!

0 Comments
2020/05/11
14:38 UTC

0

r/HowSexy is a new sub to rate sexy women

0 Comments
2020/05/10
23:13 UTC

2

r/SexySquats is a brand new sub to watch GIFs and videos of women squatting

0 Comments
2020/04/07
01:53 UTC

Back To Top