/r/moviecritic

Photograph via snooOG

A subreddit for movie reviews and discussions

A subreddit for movie reviews and discussions

Rules

  1. Clearly state the movie name in your post title.
  2. No spam, or you will get you banned!

Related subreddits


See our previous top scoring links.


spoiler tags: Spoiler stuff

 code:  [spoiler stuff](/spoiler)

/r/moviecritic

438,237 Subscribers

1

Mank (2020) is my favorite David Fincher picture. Though, I acknowledge that’s it might be his least accessible. Gary Oldman chews the scenery and it’s a visual and technical delight. What did you think of it?

1 Comment
2025/01/18
16:03 UTC

3

The Ultimate Comedy Classic: The 40-Year-Old Virgin

0 Comments
2025/01/18
15:47 UTC

5

In Tim Robbins’s “Bob Roberts” (1992) he portrays a clownish far-right entertainer taking power. It felt over the top and hyperbolic at the time

Trailer: https://youtu.be/yRpWaJRyVQo?si=rxzoD7QZygIHuXbt

He gets so many details right. The Miss America pageant, the conspiracy-driven bro culture, the grifting and fraud. Astonishingly prescient.

0 Comments
2025/01/18
15:39 UTC

37

Worst character and worst actor? Here's mine: Megan Boone in the Blacklist.

52 Comments
2025/01/18
15:27 UTC

2

Which director lost the sauce?

3 Comments
2025/01/18
15:26 UTC

0

Do Reddit communities have too many rules? Artificial intelligence bots keep deleting my posts and it’s pissing me off. What do you think?

Does this happen to you? We’re already letting artificial intelligence rule our lives. Before you know it it will be T2.

1 Comment
2025/01/18
15:16 UTC

61

What Scene Makes You Cry Everytime? I Know People Say Titanic is Overrated, and I Kinda Agree, But This Scene Always Makes Me Cry.

32 Comments
2025/01/18
15:10 UTC

2

The Edge (1997) is criminally underrated and you should see it

0 Comments
2025/01/18
14:36 UTC

298

What’s your favorite film that beautifully captures the essence of friendship?

170 Comments
2025/01/18
14:17 UTC

19

Movie... the next parts of which are only better?

For me it's 'Men in Black &'. I can't even say which part of the three is better, they are all self-sufficient and great.

Your opinions?

10 Comments
2025/01/18
14:06 UTC

127

You have no call to get snippy with her. She's just trying to do her job.

46 Comments
2025/01/18
13:13 UTC

5

Movies that are outshined by their soundtracks.

Sometimes the soundtrack goes harder than the actual movie they were part of. Sometimes the soundtrack is just better than the movie. What are some stand outs to you?

To this day I still play a lot of tracks from the Suicide Squad Soundtrack, movie was meh to me. I think I know every word to heathens.

https://preview.redd.it/bxczzhx74qde1.png?width=400&format=png&auto=webp&s=42fede8a9a544b6e0ba11018d20285485809347d

6 Comments
2025/01/18
09:47 UTC

13

Which movies did you really enjoy but left you disappointed with how the story ended?

19 Comments
2025/01/18
09:40 UTC

171

What’s your favorite scene where a character is lying, with the audience knowingly aware of it?

My favorite is the scene from Fargo where Jerry and Marge have their final conversation in his office. It’s so fun to watch him getting nervous, great dialogue and acting as well.

88 Comments
2025/01/18
09:37 UTC

0

How would you feel about Adam Sandler and the 'Grown Ups' crew in a new Harry Potter

0 Comments
2025/01/18
09:24 UTC

2

Best Acting Performance in Speed Racer (2008)

Who gave the best / your favorite acting performance in Speed Racer (2008)?

View Poll

0 Comments
2025/01/18
08:30 UTC

77

What movies do you feel are over-hated

108 Comments
2025/01/18
07:47 UTC

8

Worst accents in film?

The Temu-Tier Australian accents in Pacific Rim are wild. What accents have been so egregious that they have stopped you suspension of disbelief in its tracks?

35 Comments
2025/01/18
05:34 UTC

49

Sin City (2005) oozes with style and atmosphere. An ensemble cast that is top notch catapulted into some hypnotic noir. Have you seen it?

13 Comments
2025/01/18
05:28 UTC

4

Writers really said, "Yeah, try scrolling through your phones while watching this. We DARE you, WE DOUBLE DARE YOU!"

4 Comments
2025/01/18
05:14 UTC

0

Need to find a movie with a middle aged man that's widowed, preferably by Cancer, left with not, if autistic or challenging all the better and with a vibe of hope and new love

0 Comments
2025/01/18
04:28 UTC

58

Me: “- Must be so nice to watch films at the Cinema in 80’s, without people checking their smartphones around.”

People at the Cinema in 80’s:

9 Comments
2025/01/18
03:42 UTC

10

Never played the games, nor followed Blizzard, but I thought this movie was pretty entertaining… what do you guys think about it?

11 Comments
2025/01/18
03:34 UTC

1

Civil War by Alex Garland - MUST SEE

https://preview.redd.it/f1yy0uq69ode1.jpg?width=586&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=85a66f2980a637a8239f1ada0bbee98ee2bf3a49

Civil War Poster: https://amzn.to/3ChsGkd

Review: Civil War by Alex Garland

Rating: 91/100

  • Performances: 35/35 Jesse Plemons delivers a career-best performance, balancing quiet intensity with emotional depth, while Kirsten Dunst brings raw vulnerability to her role. Their real-life chemistry translates beautifully on screen, creating some of the film’s most powerful moments.
  • Direction & Visuals: 30/35 Alex Garland’s signature style is on full display, blending stark realism with surreal, dreamlike sequences. His haunting vision of America’s Civil War era is both visceral and thought-provoking, making the film as much a psychological exploration as a historical one.
  • Story & Themes: 26/30 While the pacing may challenge some viewers, the film’s exploration of survival, division, and redemption is deeply impactful, offering an intimate perspective on war’s emotional toll.

Alex Garland’s Civil War, backed by A24’s unwavering commitment to bold storytelling, is a harrowing and unforgettable depiction of America’s most fractured era. Jesse Plemons shines as Silas, a Union deserter tormented by his choices, delivering one of his most nuanced performances to date. Kirsten Dunst’s portrayal of a Confederate widow is equally captivating, her quiet strength anchoring the film’s emotional core.

Their on-screen chemistry, informed by their real-life marriage, adds an authenticity that elevates the film’s stakes. Every scene between them feels intimate, raw, and heartbreakingly human.

Garland’s direction masterfully balances the brutality of war with moments of surreal introspection, making the Civil War-era South feel both grounded and otherworldly. Rob Hardy’s cinematography paints the battlefields and forests as haunting characters in their own right, while the score amplifies the tension and dread.

While its deliberate pacing and philosophical focus may not be for everyone, Civil War is an ambitious, thought-provoking triumph that cements Garland’s place as one of modern cinema’s boldest voices.

Recommendation: If you’re a fan of A24’s daring approach to storytelling or admire Garland’s visionary style, Civil War is a must-see. Jesse Plemons’ performance alone is worth the stream.

1 Comment
2025/01/18
03:31 UTC

600

Saddest death in a movie? Nothing will change mine but curious about what everyone else thinks (Picture is from I Am Legend)

510 Comments
2025/01/18
03:18 UTC

0

Robert Eggers’ Nosferatu: A Gothic Masterpiece That Haunts Your Soul

Nosferatu

https://preview.redd.it/54jhsx4i6ode1.jpg?width=593&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0f1f82e69d0fc2110c4904a12451f985958f061d

Nosferatu Poster: https://amzn.to/3Q17ORL

Robert Eggers’ Nosferatu**: A Gothic Masterpiece That Haunts Your Soul**

Robert Eggers has done it again. With Nosferatu, the visionary director reimagines the 1922 silent horror classic, blending his trademark atmospheric style with an emotionally rich and deeply unsettling narrative. This isn’t just a horror film—it’s a full sensory experience that cements Eggers’ reputation as a master of the macabre.

Rating Breakdown (Out of 100)

  • Atmosphere & Visuals: 40/40
  • Performances: 35/40
  • Pacing & Storytelling: 18/20

Overall Rating: 93/100

Lily-Rose Depp Shines as Ellen Hutter

While much of the buzz surrounds Bill Skarsgård’s haunting portrayal of Count Orlok, Lily-Rose Depp is the film’s true emotional anchor. As Ellen Hutter, she delivers a nuanced and heart-wrenching performance, balancing fragility with strength in the face of unspeakable horror. Depp’s Ellen is not merely a victim of Orlok’s predation—she’s a compelling character in her own right, one who draws you in with every glance and whispered word. Her chemistry with her co-stars, particularly Nicholas Hoult as her husband Thomas, adds depth to the human drama at the core of the film.

Eggers’ Gothic Vision

Eggers excels at crafting immersive, lived-in worlds, and Nosferatu might be his most visually stunning work yet. From crumbling castles to mist-shrouded forests, every frame is dripping with gothic dread. The naturalistic lighting, much of it provided by candles and moonlight, creates an otherworldly atmosphere that feels both intimate and vast. It’s the kind of film where you could pause any frame and hang it on your wall.

Skarsgård’s Unforgettable Count Orlok

Bill Skarsgård brings a raw, almost animalistic energy to the iconic role of the vampire. Unlike the romanticized versions we’ve seen in recent years, Skarsgård’s Orlok is grotesque yet oddly sympathetic. His interactions with Ellen are chilling, not only for their horror but for the tragic humanity he conveys in fleeting moments.

Pacing & Storytelling

Eggers takes his time building dread, and while the slow-burn approach won’t be for everyone, it pays off in a climactic finale that will leave you breathless. The story stays true to the essence of the original film while adding layers of complexity and emotional resonance. At 2 hours and 15 minutes, the pacing is deliberate, but never dull, thanks to the strength of the performances and the richness of the world Eggers has created.

Final Thoughts

Nosferatu is a triumph of gothic horror, a film that doesn’t just pay homage to the original but expands on it in thrilling ways. Eggers’ meticulous craftsmanship, combined with stellar performances—particularly from Lily-Rose Depp—makes this one of the most compelling films of the year. Whether you’re a fan of Eggers’ previous work or new to his style, this is a must-watch for anyone who loves intelligent, atmospheric horror.

Have you seen Nosferatu yet? What did you think of Lily-Rose Depp’s performance? Let’s discuss in the comments!

3 Comments
2025/01/18
03:12 UTC

464

Movies with the most stacked cast? Black Hawk Down has an insane number of big Hollywood names in it.

249 Comments
2025/01/18
03:10 UTC

0

Ruin A Movie Title By Switching 1 Letter.

I'll start.

"Suicide Squat" (Suicide Squad)

I put a NSFW tag for any names that aren't particularly tame but I don't mind as long as they're hilarious, got ingenuity and originality

38 Comments
2025/01/18
03:05 UTC

Back To Top