/r/BethMidrash

Photograph via //r/BethMidrash

Dedicated to the academic study of Torah, Tanach, Mishnah, Talmud, Midrashim, Halacha, and other Jewish literary works.

About

Dedicated to the academic study of Torah, Tanach, Mishnah, Talmud, Midrashim, Halacha, and other Jewish literary works.

Rules

Will be decided by the community...

Related Subreddits

/r/AskTheologists

/r/AcademicBiblical

/r/CriticalBiblical

/r/AcademicQuran

/r/AskBibleScholars

/r/HistoricalJesus

/r/BethMidrash

838 Subscribers

1

Does nashim refer to women as in 'adult and minor females'

I'm specifically talking about yevamot 35a

10 Comments
2024/11/10
16:13 UTC

5

Does Judaism have its own equivalent of the Rosary?

A quick googling earlier led me to discovering that Buddhism, Hinduism, and even Islam have used prayer beads in a fashion similar to the Catholic Rosary. So I ask, does Judaism using a similar device?

2 Comments
2024/10/21
03:12 UTC

1

Come join my new subreddit if you are interested in more Jewish study!

2 Comments
2024/10/08
12:21 UTC

6

Unlocking the 1000-Year-Old Secrets of the Leningrad Hebrew Bible

0 Comments
2024/06/27
16:42 UTC

3

Mug for the Chevrusas

1 Comment
2024/06/04
19:40 UTC

4

What's inside this old pair of Tefillin?

2 Comments
2024/03/26
16:30 UTC

3

Are All Torah Scrolls the Same? [OC]

0 Comments
2024/01/31
17:02 UTC

2

The Story of Ruth in Vintage Photographs [OC]

1 Comment
2023/12/21
18:14 UTC

7

3D Walkthrough of Bayit Sheini [OC]

2 Comments
2023/07/25
17:57 UTC

8

I made a tutorial for looking up verbs in Biblical Hebrew dictionaries

0 Comments
2023/06/29
15:21 UTC

5

What position does Judaism traditionally have on self-torture to test faith? Specifically something as directly harmful as self-flagellation?

Since a post I read pretty much sums up the details of my question and is why I'm asking this, I'm quoting it.

I am curious of the Calvinist and Reformed Christianity on mortification of the flesh through painful physical torture such as fasting, self-flagellation, tatooing, cutting one's wrist, waterboarding oneself in blessed water, and carrying very heavy objects such as cross replication for miles with no rest or water? And other methods of self-harm so common among Catholic fundamentalists done to test their faith and give devotion to Jesus?

As someone baptised Roman Catholic, I know people who flagellate themselves and go through months have fasting with no food along with a day or two without drinking water. So I am wondering what is Judaism's position on corporal mortification acts especially like cutting yourself with a knife and fasting?

7 Comments
2023/06/09
11:37 UTC

5

Sources on development of Rabbinic Judaism

Anyone have recommendations for academic books or articles on the history of the development of Rabbinic Judaism?

Specifically, I'm looking for sources that don't take at face value the history given in traditional sources like the chain of traditions at the beginning of Pirkei Avot or Iggeret Rav Sherira Gaon.

1 Comment
2023/06/04
19:52 UTC

1

What Is Orthodox Jewish Interpretation For The Fall of Man?

6 Comments
2023/06/01
01:51 UTC

1

Was Jonah afraid of the whale? A study in art and text

0 Comments
2023/05/23
16:32 UTC

3

Why this תנ״ך just sold for $33.5 Million USD in NYC

2 Comments
2023/05/17
18:18 UTC

3

Interesting Introductions

For tikkun leil shavuot this year, I decided to study some "introductions", so I'm looking for any recommendations. So far I'm thinking:

  • Ramban and Shadal's introductions to their peirushim on Torah

  • Introduction to David Zvi Hoffmann's מלמד להועיל

If I'm feeling really brave, might try to start R. Halivni's introduction to מקורות ומסורות, but not sure I'll be able to handle that at 3am.

Thanks for any more suggestions!

0 Comments
2023/04/10
18:51 UTC

3

Audiobooks for getting started

Someone from /r/askbiblescholars/ recommended I bring my inquiry here. I'm sorry if this isn't the place for this sort of thing.

Do y'all have any audiobook recommendations for learning about how Jewish texts influenced Christianity? I know an audiobook may limit the recommendations, but that's how I tend to read these days. If you have a dynamite paper book recommendation, I can try to get through it.

Specifically, I want to learn more about the Mishnah, Midrash, etc. I keep reading references to these from prominent theologians (like, referencing stories with Elijah and the Messiah, for example), but I dont know how to get started learning about these, myself. I downloaded the Sefaria app, but there's a lot there and I don't know how to find what time looking for.

I'm a total newbie, so thank you for your grace with answering my perhaps ignorant question! I'm a Christian, and want to learn more about my own faith (I'm not sure if this sub is mostly for Jews), but I'm open-minded if you have something non-christian to recommend.

6 Comments
2023/04/03
20:52 UTC

5

During COVID I made two jumbo Biblical Hebrew reference cards. Here’s a video explaining what they are and how to use them.

0 Comments
2023/03/09
16:43 UTC

5

Why Does Ginzburg's Legends of the Jews cut off at the beginning of the second temple? Are there any works that seek to continue with the aggadot about the rabbinic age?

I have often heard that Ginzburg's "Legends of the Jews" is the definitive compilation of Aggadah. I was therefore very surprised to see that it ends with Esther given the wealth of Aggadot about figures in the AKH, Tannaic, and Ammoraic periods. Is there a reason for the omission of this material? Has there been a similar chronological collection for this material?

Thanks!

3 Comments
2023/03/06
08:43 UTC

1

Other than Sefer haYashar, are there any other sources that reference a baby speaking in Joseph's defense?

0 Comments
2023/02/03
06:28 UTC

5

Rabbi Angel's Introduction to Nakh

Here is a really good introduction to each of the books of Neviim and Kethuvim by a Hayyim Angel.

Check out the section "Rabbi Hayyim Angel's Survey of the Prophets and Writings in the Bible" here: https://www.jewishideas.org/online-learning/classes-lectures. These are recordings of a lecture series delivered by Rabbi Angel in English, with 1-3 lectures per book.

I think this is a good introduction to one type of Modern Orthodox Tanakh study methodology:

  • Pshat-oriented, based on careful reding of the text
  • Valuing classical commentaries, but open to differing views
  • Informed by archeology, philology, and other disciplines

If anyone checks this out, I'd be curious to hear your reviews.

2 Comments
2023/01/26
16:19 UTC

8

There's a website with recordings of Jews from around the world reading Biblical Hebrew. Some of the readers were born in the 1800s. I made a video explaining some of these unique pronunciations. [OC]

0 Comments
2022/10/25
15:47 UTC

1

How to translate אִישׁ אִישׁ, דֹּר דֹּר, יוֹם יוֹם, etc. [OC]

1 Comment
2022/09/28
15:32 UTC

3

Was Ruth a Canaanite slave?

Ruth refers to herself as a shifcha and an amah, names for a gentile amd Jewish slave respectively. Most commentaries I have seen assume this is just an obsequious nicety. I am wondering if it is more than that.

Specifically could it be that Ruth is portraying herself as a slave (perhaps to Naomi) such that Boaz can purchase her when he acquires Naomi's ancestral field. Furthermore a child of that union, once freed would have the halakhic status of a full fledged Jew, without recourse to the legal machinations differentiating between male amd female Moabites.

Following this reasoning the requested act of spreading his cloak over Ruth would have halakhic implications as well.

1 Comment
2022/09/25
20:06 UTC

2

Can Quran 7.157 be seen as a midrashic/Pardes interpretation of Isaiah 42?

0 Comments
2022/07/04
15:14 UTC

3

Mishnaic/Talmudic Views on Abortion?

0 Comments
2022/06/24
23:36 UTC

3

I made a video about the Biblia Hebraica Quinta, a new scholarly Bible

0 Comments
2022/06/23
17:23 UTC

Back To Top