/r/policydebate

Photograph via snooOG

A subreddit for the high school and college activity of Policy Debate/CX.

2022-2023 HS Topic: Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its security cooperation with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization in one or more of the following areas: artificial intelligence, biotechnology, cybersecurity.

2022-2023 NDT-CEDA Topic: Resolved: The United States should vest legal rights and/or duties in one or more of the following: artificial intelligence, nature, nonhuman animal species.

About

Policy debate is a form of debate competition practiced in high schools and colleges across the US in which teams of two advocate for and against a resolution that typically calls for policy change by the United States federal government. It is also referred to as cross-examination debate.

Read more here.


Rules

1. This is a subreddit for policy debate.

  • Please keep content relevant to policy debate or forensics generally. Off-topic content will be removed.

  • This is not a forum for arguing about random topics online. If you wish to do that, check /r/changemyview.

2. Follow site guidelines.

3. Be civil.

  • Please, remember to be civil and respectful to one another. /r/policydebate is an open community for anyone interested or involved in high school or collegiate policy. Any content that would seriously alienate a reasonable person will be removed.

Related resources

/r/Debate

/r/lincolndouglas

/r/DebateTrade

Debate Discord


/r/policydebate

11,345 Subscribers

8

University of West Georgia Debate Informational Meeting

Hello everyone!

Thought about debating in college? Questions about scholarships? Tuition?

This is a representative from the University of West Georgia's debate team!

On December 4th, 8PM EST, we are having an informational debate meeting, accessible via zoom!

We’d love to talk to you about opportunities on the UWG debate team, and also answer any general questions you have about college debate.

Please use this link to sign up and reach out if you have any questions!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1gsa2op8lqxW08Fn-mrgNX56O_Kqs5M3j4MBWGm0U4ME/edit?usp=sharing

https://preview.redd.it/sf0vvsk8ok4e1.png?width=807&format=png&auto=webp&s=9a6d446262309a24b23e9edb5b023c4dcb45ed98

2 Comments
2024/12/03
05:49 UTC

1

Aff Prep (blocks) this season.

First topical aff of the year - I’m a little lost on what 2AC blocks to cut.

What is the strategy this year? What are we doing on the case page? What about general Off case args?

Obviously this changes significantly on the aff, so for context it’s the plan text In the graffiti aff from DDI - modified to a soft left sole advantage.

It’s pretty basic, and topical AF.

Thoughts?

1 Comment
2024/12/03
03:35 UTC

8

TOC?

Im a sophomore atm and I wouldn't hate going to the TOC like most people BUT I want to be realistic. what do y'all think my chances are?--

Im from an underfunded public school in a state with like 3 tourneys a year but my team travels a lot for stuff-- my varsity record is 80%

we have only lost 2 neg rounds this year out of like 30ish rounds-- (The AFF kinda needs work lol)

I won grapevine JV in policy this year-- I break at all the tournaments I go to, Im going to UT, Newman, and Emory in the varsity division

I don't expect TOC this year but maybe next?? What are my chances at one bid this year?

11 Comments
2024/12/03
03:35 UTC

0

Coach Interference

So lets say a team in my district that we consonantly hit had their coach of speechdrop tell the debaters what to do, isn't that like super against the rules, along with this they debate on paper (my district is maj online), their coach also tracks cases via the speechdrop. What should I do? Or how should I like "attempt" to prevent this?

6 Comments
2024/12/03
02:31 UTC

5

help making an apocalyptic rhetoric K

I have a tournament coming up and I want to prep a K that links via basically any impact and criticizes the use of apocalyptic rhetoric in policy debate over rational meaningful discourse. What are good sources for framework cards and in general theory that talks about the role of the judge and analyzes rhetoric within speech and debate?

16 Comments
2024/12/03
02:06 UTC

2

Clash of Civilization - Survey

Should the 1AC have a plan text?

View Poll

27 Comments
2024/12/02
04:36 UTC

10

positional competition

ik func and textual but i swear i’ve heard “positional competition” before; does it even exist? what is or what was it?

3 Comments
2024/12/02
01:02 UTC

9

Free Online Policy Debate Camp

Dear Policy Debate Reddit Community, 

We are super excited to announce that EmpowerDebate will be hosting a free Winter Debate Camp called the Winter Debate Intensive in collaboration with the Pacific Northwest Debate Society from December 27-30. The camp will be in four different debate styles: Public Forum, Lincoln Douglas, Policy, and World Schools Debate. The benefits of attending the camp include: 

  • Built in practice rounds
  • Free topic prep (including free cases + blockfile)
  • Skills-based lectures 
  • Learning from top debaters

It will be everyday from 12PM - 3PM PST or 3PM - 6PM EST. 

Here are the links to sign up: 

Camper Sign-Up: https://forms.gle/1dkoChNcwLPv4koG6 

Instructor Application: https://forms.gle/j5EhqjkFaD6aULxz7 

Best, 

The EmpowerDebate Team

7 Comments
2024/12/01
22:21 UTC

11

Ban Intellectual Property CP

Hey there! I'm a second year debater in the Kansas circuit prepping for a Ban IP CP I will be seeing at regionals in a few weeks. I was taught to answer CP's in the POST form (Perm, Offense, Solvency, Theory)

I have every single answer to the CP down to a tee, except for a perm. Does anybody think a perm is feasible here? Any advice would be great!

8 Comments
2024/12/01
17:26 UTC

10

Flowing Question

This might sound kinda dumb but I feel like it’s easy to flow other people’s speeches in round, but when it comes to flowing my own speeches, what am I supposed to do specifically? Like for my 2NC’s when it’s 70% analytics how do I pre flow that or get time in the debate to right it down on my flow?

10 Comments
2024/12/01
00:09 UTC

6

Prepping against obscure laws

Lot of affs in my circuit run obscure laws with no opposing literature to them because they haven't passed the introduction stage in congress. It makes research really difficult because of just how complex and obscure it is so no one talks about it. Any tips for how to prep against them/what to run??

11 Comments
2024/11/30
20:58 UTC

7

Consult on the Affirmative?

Has anyone run a consult plan text on the aff?

Would that be topical? (T-Strengthen?) is this doable?

I love my consult CP on the negative, but I feel like I’m loosing it on the aff - can I?

9 Comments
2024/11/30
07:58 UTC

1

Universality K?!?

Hi I'm prepping against a K aff, and found the universality K as a good choice. Opinions anyone? It's in the CCFMP from UMich Camp! Thanks!

3 Comments
2024/11/30
03:32 UTC

2

diff between shopsafe and e commerce?

so basically my partner has been super indecisive about what we’re gonna run and i keep saying e commerce e commerce e commerce and im in middle school so at mmsdl tourneys we run shopsafe and at toc we plan to run e commerce. what’s the difference??

5 Comments
2024/11/29
18:27 UTC

4

COURTCLOG PLEASE HELP

Does anyone got hella recent courtclog non uq evidence? if so please post it down below, when im searching for courtclog non uq, im only getting immigration courts clogged, i need ipr related courts. thanks yall!

8 Comments
2024/11/28
23:42 UTC

13

biggest surprises of the season so far?

16 Comments
2024/11/28
18:00 UTC

5

Can anyone help me figure out V-Tub and other Verbatim Tricks

hey guys I'm from a small circuit and half of my team doesn't know how to use verbatim even to cut cards. could someone teach me some tricks on how to use things like the V-tub and quick cards? maybe even some custom macros?

6 Comments
2024/11/27
01:25 UTC

15

How to organize 1NC v K aff

Hi everyone, there's some K affs that have been popular in my area lately, and so I'm prepping for them. I've never debated K affs before but am familiar with some arguments against them. I'm just kinda confused how I should organize my 1NC. I have like a few questions

  1. Is T-USFG separate from framework?
  2. Also is theory part of the case debate or is it on framework? Like where would I put a Cede the Political/Switch Side Debate/Presumption?
  3. Can I run a counterplan to solve the aff's impacts or is that generally not a thing?
  4. How good are ballot PIKs, generally?
  5. How do people generally structure the neg block if they just run T-USFG? Is the 2NC the T and the 1NR just case? How do you get case cards if each K aff is so different?
  6. Do I just resort to generic links for Ks vs the K aff? Cause again each K aff is so different I don't know how I would find a specific link. Also would the lack of a specific K link be an independent reason for fairness/education in the T?
  7. Also I heard to not read a TVA in the 1NC or 2NC but instead read a TVA in the 1NR so the aff can't CX it. Isn't that kinda abusive tho? Edit: wait i'm dumb I thought TVA stood for topicality violation for some reason idk wyh.

Thanks!!!

10 Comments
2024/11/26
07:29 UTC

4

Explanation for Ks

Can someone explain either the anthropocentism K or the cap K? I'm gonna try to run one of them at nat quals.

3 Comments
2024/11/24
21:38 UTC

4

Who’s the best in the Oklahoma circuit

7 Comments
2024/11/24
21:30 UTC

3

Wipeout

Planning on running wipeout at my first tournament tommorow. Does anyone have any tips or tricks on running it effectively? (or args that are good against it so I can prep those out)

10 Comments
2024/11/24
03:47 UTC

33

Can we all just use speechdrop?

Email chain is ass and doesn’t even work 90% of the time because school district email are cancer to deal with

Speechdrop is so much more convenient. It’s literally just a room code on a board and you get all of the evidence. It’s so much faster than email chain.

Kansas debaters can agree with me on this

21 Comments
2024/11/24
03:26 UTC

8

Who's the best on the minnesota circuit?

I'm a jv debater in minnesota, and I was curious who's the best.

5 Comments
2024/11/24
01:17 UTC

8

What to say in 1NR if opponent dropped disads

I'm in novice policy. Recently I was in a tournament where our opponents dropped our disads. In the negative block, my partner took care of on case and one of our das, and I took care of the other later in the 1NR. I mentioned that they conceded our disad, but continued explaining to the judges on why our disad outweighs.

The judges at the end just told us to tell them why our disad is important and why the AFF shouldn't drop the disad, and also do a little bit of impact calc on our two das, but I don't think I'll be able to do impact calc on court clog for the entirety of 5 minutes. What else should I say in the 1NR if our opponents conceded with our das? Thank you 🙏

9 Comments
2024/11/23
01:08 UTC

7

Going for the Ballot PIK

Ok first off, I kinda suck against k affs but I’ve been trying to work on it. I have a good grasp on topicality and how framework debating works so I wanted to expand on my potential 2NR’s. First, as I understand it, a claim to a ballot turns the aff by deenergizing movements and a call for the ballot is bad. What would an ideal 2NR on that look like?

8 Comments
2024/11/22
03:55 UTC

7

Heg turns the K

I heard that a lot of people can go for heg turning the k (particularly race k's). How does this work?

25 Comments
2024/11/21
16:11 UTC

22

Is this not literally policy debate?

15 Comments
2024/11/21
03:11 UTC

1

1nc against green tech help

How do you against a green tech case since they’re trying to help climate change: anything we say is like we’re trying to say climate change doesn’t exist, we’re novice

7 Comments
2024/11/21
02:51 UTC

9

How do you guys cite in cards?

In cite creator I have %last% %y%%linebreak%[%author%, %quals%, "%title%", %publication% (%date%), %url%, accessed %accessed%]

I also use docs instead of word because chromebook. I'm transitioning into policy so I'm trying to learn the format of everything especially cards relatively quickly, as our school's LD team taught none of that.

6 Comments
2024/11/21
02:11 UTC

2

Eastmo policy debate laws on novice counterplan

In EastMO can novices run counterplans? Because my vp said not to do it but we can’t see any other way to win a neg round. So are counterplans like banned or what? Thank you!

3 Comments
2024/11/19
12:52 UTC

Back To Top