/r/poetry_critics

Photograph via snooOG

This is a subreddit for constructive criticism and feedback on all types of poetry. Our primary goal with this sub is to ensure that every poem that is submitted gets a good amount of quality feedback.

Please sort by 'new' to see posts that have little or no feedback.

Welcome! We are taking mod applications!

This is a subreddit for constructive criticism and feedback on all types of poetry. Our primary goal with this sub is to ensure that every poem that is submitted gets a good amount of quality feedback.

Please sort by 'new' and comment on posts that have little or no feedback.

If you have any questions, concerns, or feedback in making this sub a better place, feel free to message the moderators. (We're not scary. Most of the time.)

Formatting Help

Guides and Useful Information

Wall of Fame


Rules

  • Before posting a new poem, users must critique at least two other poems. Every new poem you post must be accompanied by two more critiques.

Please do your best to make your critiques substantive. Critiques that only say "Nice," or "I like it" will not be counted. We have a bot that helps us identify users who are not contributing critiques but we still have human mods double-checking, so please do not think you can fool the bot by doing the bare minimum. Please see this post for basic critique guidelines. To learn how to master giving feedback, check out this post.

  • All users must select a flair indicating their skill level.

  • See this post for more information. Beginners have 0-5 years experience, Intermediates have 5-10 years experience, and Experts have 10+ years experience. Professionals derive some income from writing. If you cannot figure out how to set your flair, please message the moderators for help and indicate what flair you need.

  • Be Nice.

  • This subreddit is for constructive criticism and feedback; overly negative comments will be removed and may result in a temporary ban. Racism, homophobia, transphobia, sexism, harassment, and other similar behavior will result in an immediate permanent ban.

    Tips for Success

    • The more feedback you give, the more you are likely to recieve.

    • Please include ONLY the title of your poem in your post title; further context may be added in the post itself, but is not needed in the title.

    • Regarding revisions: Posters who have submitted their poem here, taken the given critique into consideration and revised it are encouraged to repost the edited version of the poem. If you do so, please include a link to the original thread. The mods are currently considering a system of link flairs to add to posts such as these.

    • Each posted poem should only contain ONE poem.

    Contests and Writing Prompts

    Sister Subreddits

    /r/poetry_critics

    63,810 Subscribers

    1

    Honest

    A weapon for the sly

    Relief for the soft

    Scary and pretty

    A heart on display

    Brutal and quant

    With no shortcuts

    Once lost

    And never found again

    Hidden where it's safe

    Away from the hungry

    Till the growls sound softer

    Intention no longer ugly

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    05:59 UTC

    2

    Advice On How To Better This Poem

    Did you mean to kill me when you threw the knife?

    Did you mean to break me when you left my life?

    Did you know how sad I was, laying on the bathroom floor?

    I gave you everything, what do you mean you wanted more?

    The chandelier went crashing and my tears were streaming

    Watching all my love vanish as you were leaving

    Strangled by your ignorance, I couldn’t breathe

    Tortured by your carelessness, melting in our tension’s heat

    Fighting all day, but I still wanted you to stay

    Looking for something you never had anyway

    You took the ring off my finger and threw it in the lake

    You stayed hours at work, trying to push me away

    Hugs were forbidden, kisses were restrained

    Still need to unlearn the way I was tamed

    I was obedient, sat in the bedroom alone

    Taken from all my friends, kidnapped from my home

    You cut the phone line and I stopped seeing family

    Somehow convinced me that it would make me happy

    Only your wisdom to follow, I fell in the well

    Jack and Jill fell down the hill into Hell

    Tell me again everything that you promised

    Now let me list everything I’ve not gotten

    Followed you to the end, jumped off the cliff

    Only to look back and see you had not done the same

    When forever really meant never and help never came

    I started to realize that your kind of love was pain

    And hurt isn’t a kind of healing, it’s plain brutal

    My heart crashed, my trust forever totaled

    My scars will cover, but they’ll never be healed

    I can’t believe all of the things you told me were real

    Every overreaction was me sinking to my demise

    Your heart was never true, you were one big lie

    I lay here alone, but it’s for the best

    Rather die living than live dying

    ---

    Would appreciate advice about my poetry, specifically my rhyme scheme :D

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    05:41 UTC

    2

    Goodbye

    You may go, But not in the velvet cloak of midnight.

    You may go, But leave behind whispers of your grace.

    You may go, Yet let it not strike like lightning's shock.

    You may go, For the world unfurls its welcoming embrace. But pause, just once, in this moment's glow, Let my arms weave a tapestry of our shared space.

    How is it? :)

    2 Comments
    2024/12/01
    05:23 UTC

    2

    Alone In A Crowd

    In a room full of voices
    I stand in the crowd
    Laughter and chatter
    Yet silence feels loud

    Eyes meet and pass
    But none really see
    The quietest longing
    That lives inside me

    I smile when they smile
    I nod when they speak
    But inside it’s distance
    I can't seem to breach

    I’m surrounded by faces
    Yet lost in the haze
    A shadow, a ripple
    In all of their gaze

    The air hums with warmth
    But it's cold where I am
    A fleeting connection
    That slips through my hand

    I reach out for meaning
    But grasp only space
    Alone in a crowd
    Where I can't find my place

    How can you feel lonely
    When you’re never alone
    When voices are plenty
    But none truly known

    A paradox strange
    Yet so sharply real
    To be with them all
    Yet with no one, I feel

    1 Comment
    2024/12/01
    05:14 UTC

    2

    Dream

    It's a silly dream It's only a dream And I fear that's all it will be All in my head Filling my mind Her and this dream Maybe we could be More than we are But it's all in my mind And I fear i'm not in hers And it's forever to be Just a silly dream That's all it will be But like a dream She's in my head Constantly reminding of what it could be Haunting me No longer a silly dream But a nightmare Eating away at my mind Where she stays It pushes me to be better But im not enough Not for her But i want to be I wish I Dream

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    05:13 UTC

    1

    Dream

    It's a silly dream It's only a dream And I fear that's all it will be All in my head Filling my mind Her and this dream Maybe we could be More than we are But it's all in my mind And I fear i'm not in hers And it's forever to be Just a silly dream That's all it will be But like a dream She's in my head Constantly reminding of what it could be Haunting me No longer a silly dream But a nightmare Eating away at my mind Where she stays It pushes me to be better But i'm not enough Not for her But i want to be I wish I Dream

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    05:04 UTC

    1

    I Have never written or attempted poetry. My grandmother died when I was a teen and My family fell apart afterwards. Things happened and nearly the entire family became estranged. I was dragged as a boy into the turmoil and lost most of my family… (Any feedback is welcomed)

    Innocence, a child’s perceived reality, crashed at last breath with failed vitality.

    A family once knit, undone like a knot unfit.

    Silent Yells full of passion, with stubbornness all the new fashion.

    A young teen caught in-between, the throes of things said but not seen.

    Backs turned and bridges burned, the bonds of brotherhood all but unlearned.

    But what of the boy, stuck silent in the crosshairs, Yearning for what was, realizing, it can no longer be. A family torn, he can only adorn, what was, for it is now no longer.

    In the mind, Memories dance like a hallowed flame, feelings of warmth flicker and shine, but it’s nothing but the ghost of the past stuck on rewind.

    Years gone by and it’s Time to sleep, here we carry, yet another to bury. With pride the child strides, grandpa by his side, carrying him to where he shall finally reside.

    With Hopeful optimism, 10 years gone by, we all finally reunite, eye to eye. With Gazes averted, the final blow, it is a punishment just for show.

    I Yearn for the days when we would go, to sit beside each-other row by row. Christmas dinners and birthday bash, family laughs, and grandpas crafts.

    I was a boy but now I’m grown, but to you all, that’s unknown. The choice was made, but not by me, I wish everyone could just see. You are all petty to a T.

    I was a boy who watched family grow, I was a boy who watched family go. 15 years is all I got, and it did not feel like a lot. Now I’m grown and I see, that the next time I see you, will be in your sleep. But I will not stand aside, stubborn and cowardly like you all.

    With a head held high, I will carry you too, to where you shall finally reside.

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    04:50 UTC

    1

    Pile Of Heart

    My boy is being taken,
    to tussle with men.
    He will drink from silver cups,
    once sipped by the dead.
    He will swear oaths,
    oaths forsaken by gods.
    A old man will give him a sword,
    bright as the moon.
    And he will swing, and swing,
    so that another may not swing at him first.
    His first will be etched into his memory.
    His tenth will be just a pile of meat.
    The pile will grow, and grow,
    and sink into the depths of his heart.
    Instead of cleaning the pile,
    he will simply get rid of the heart.

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    04:45 UTC

    1

    Content

    my world burned to ashes. everything. through the fire I walked. I screamed in anguish until It passed content with the aftermath.

    look in my eyes. tell the truth. share with me. the mountains you've moved

    I knew my voice more than special. finally free. to be me

    lift every voice and sing. let every dreamer dream.

    skimming your poem, I want to feel it. trigger my emotions I'm healing. Gratuity.

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    04:43 UTC

    1

    Buzz

    Here I sit, with a buzzing in my brain.

    Irritating itch of the shining emerald grass,

    Sweltering shine of the gorgeous sun above,

    Song of the Thrush only to harras.

     

    Despite the brilliance of its stream,

    The trickle of the fall; only to annoy,

    The dragonflies danced around like steam,

    Dancing; dancing like sticky kids drunk on Lacroix,

     

    Swooping and rushing, all the while buzzing;

    There wings aglow to spite me, inspite of me.

    They are the mob of people humming,

    Humming because they hate me.

     

    They humm because they know or want to know

    The latest they or he said, she or we said.

    The latest how do you do. Why do they do?

    And it serves nothing more then to hurt my head.

     

    Maybe my sights would move me if I let it,

    Maybe the peace would ease my pain.

    And yet I sit with a hot coal in my pocket,

    Sitting; sitting with the buzzing in my brain,

    Pretending the problem is them and not I.

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    04:40 UTC

    1

    a swirling sieve

    Blots of ink on the ceiling shapeshifting, Fluid shadows, unseen, persist. They sing both dirges and hymns of praise, Waging war in unseen haze— In the heavens, below Heaven.
    Flesh and soul, spear and tongue, An endless battle, old yet young. Demons scatter, flail, and scream, Writhing in pain—a fractured dream, Just beyond our reach, our sight.
    The air thickens, heavy with fright— Then, stillness. It turns to white.

    1   2  

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    03:38 UTC

    2

    Maroon

    Every once an idle mind,

    Silence avows in wisps,

    how I end up debted,

    at this crisp arm length,

    with The One I want;

    Burgundy skies sightsee

    the palms I once fit,

    in search for lies maroon,

    I haggle for you,

    with a poet once dauntless;

    I reach for conondrum arcane

    That once was only mine;

    Every once a heart flicker,

    weighting down the dark

    Forthright I rushed into alive,

    I forget about you.

    1 Comment
    2024/12/01
    02:53 UTC

    1

    When my time comes

    When my time comes, I want to leave quietly, softly, wrapped in warm, fuzzy blankets, the scent of my favorite vanilla perfume and cookies filling the air,

    fingers intertwined with a loved one’s, beneath their gentle gaze—our silent goodbye.

    I want to slip away with my lips curled slightly upwards, neck turned towards the window, raindrops mirrored in my eyes, slipping down my cheeks.

    My regrets will linger unspoken, bitter as my desire to hold that hand in mine just a little tighter,

    but it’s okay, because my eyes will close, the rain will stop, and their hand will lift away from mine.

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    01:50 UTC

    3

    Saturday Night and I’m Mad

    It’s Saturday night, and I just crashed after a cardio session. I’ve been a loner for over a year, Which feels strange, knowing I have great connections. Maybe I’m just a little depressed.

    It’s Saturday night, and I can’t make it to a friend’s party. It’s too far, and I don’t have a ride. So I’ll sleep early under the daring moonlight, And wake up early to keep writing.

    It’s Saturday night, and my mom’s away. She’s always out on weekends, I wish I were like her. She said she’d drop me off when she got home, But she’s not back yet.

    It’s Saturday night, and I secretly wanted to cancel. Big parties overwhelm me when I barely know anyone. I freeze as if someone dropped a question To which I didn’t know the answer.

    It’s Saturday night, and I’m crying. It’s the second birthday party from the same friend that I canceled. How will I ever make more friends If I can’t even show up for once? I’m mad at my mom. I’m so mad it’s painful.

    I wanted this, but I’m drowning myself. I’m tangled. Gold-haired angel, The sound of nature. My thoughts and feelings will fade, Even if it feels like forever.

    —Melissa Ulloa

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    01:34 UTC

    2

    That witch Monday

    Hocus pocus toil and focus
    Monday decends upon us;
    Mounted gloom
    On a flying broom,

    Schedules out the sun.
    We have to get it done.
    We nod and smile,
    Go an extra mile.

    We spin the gold;
    We fit the mold;
    We do the work;
    We never shirk.

    We work each day
    To pay our way,
    To buy and sell-
    There is no spell...

    Two of five we thrive,
    The rest we survive
    With tv and drinking
    and magical thinking.

    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    01:02 UTC

    3

    Effortless Futility

    I tried to continue, to keep on going
    But eventually you begin the slowing;
    
    I try, I fail,
    I believe I'll prevail.
    Yet all I do, is get jailed:
    Not behind bars of metal,
    Not in a room alone
    Not anything that can be shown.
    
    I'm locked in the cycle of life:
    To resit, to continue;
    Reject internal strife.
    To accept, to view;
    To see life as is true.
    
    I walk, I stumble;
    I try, I fumble.
    Whenever will I succeed, 
    when those unworthy gain victory?
    0 Comments
    2024/12/01
    00:39 UTC

    1

    December Looks Different this Year

    December Looks Different this Year

    December looks different this year
    My sweet baby sleeps behind metal bars
    A crib not fit for an infant so small
    Trapped within these hospital walls

    Alarms replace the bells of cheer
    Angels rush in, thank God he’s still here
    The murmur is goes on, blood passes so quick
    Whooshing snowstorms, turmoil within

    He’s starting to smile at lights strung above
    We decorate his room so he’s not alone
    A baby so tender it’s hard to believe
    He’s only known needles and surgeries.

    Maybe he knows that Santa is near
    Will he stop by if my baby is here?
    Bring him the heart he so desperately needs
    Wrapped with a bow underneath the tree

    My baby whose fought since the day he was born
    Who doesn’t deserve the cross he has worn
    Full of poking and prodding, worry and fear
    My baby I pray on Christmas is here

    Yes, December looks different this year
    Born with a heart that’s half of its size
    Outshone by the courage he carries inside
    My mother heart swells with gratitude
    Sweet baby, I’m blessed that I still have you.

    2 Comments
    2024/12/01
    00:13 UTC

    1

    Stop Trying (You'll Never Get It Right)

    It was over before I started

    I will never reach catharsis

    My bones aching with my head

    All I see, a sea of red

    If I could bend my back more

    I could contort my body

    It May be not meant to be

    I would sacrifice the rest if

    You let me only just have this

    I would give five pounds of flesh

    I would drive myself to debt

    Everything is just dumb noise

    Why can't I find my one voice?

    Confusing screen of static

    Burn it all, burn to ashes

    Walls begin to close in

    Hope is close to ruin

    This is it, so end it

    https://www.reddit.com/r/poetry_critics/s/m1Yaj4gnEW

    https://www.reddit.com/r/poetry_critics/s/CPMwE7BfBM

    1 Comment
    2024/11/30
    23:47 UTC

    6

    If I had known

    If I had known it way back then That I’d forget your taste

    That all I had to offer Was too little and too late

    I don’t think I would undo All the love to come

    Walk away from all the pain Of losing all your love

    I’d choose you in every life time Welcome all the déjà vu

    Let my heart break ten times over For the sake of knowing you

    And if I’m not enough to love now If it will never be the same

    I’ll wait until my next life I’ll love you from the grave

    8 Comments
    2024/11/30
    23:22 UTC

    6

    sort of a criptic biography of how i was created (IVF) called cell no.2 / what was She made for

    Cell number 2. Hand selected, cultivated, a swimmer, tied at the finishing line..

    Blue gloves determine the womb deserved. 

    9 months later removed, dissected out,

    2nd to the first, male.

    No tears, no fuss,

    waiting for the next order

    Measured. Legs long,

    circumference small,

    hair red, eyes blue

    Milestones completed, all is well

    Does he know?

    Cell no.2 has grown

    Cell no.2 is flawed, conscious of self. 

    Can he know?

    Tower Hamlets homes Creator 1. A former poet, comedian…

    Was no.2 one of his jokes?

    Does she know?

    Park view homes cell no.2. Does she know?

    What was she made for?

    0 Comments
    2024/11/30
    22:28 UTC

    13

    AI Girlfriend

    You can’t have sex with your AI girlfriend

    Sit on your ass just watching the world end

    Hand on your cock in the cold of your bed

    So fucking dumb, can’t get out of your head

    Zeroes and ones can not give or feel love

    You can’t imagine a replica of

    The warmth of a touch, a kiss, or a fuck

    You’re so fucking lonely, down on your luck

    Needing some kind of emotional bond

    Coming to see that it’s actually gone

    Wish I could be there to witness the fall

    The realization of losing it all

    Hope you die old spend forever alone

    Never leave VR and never leave home

    8 Comments
    2024/11/30
    22:05 UTC

    3

    Poem

    summer left without a note, just your shadow cast in blue. we whispered what we felt was safe, afraid of what was true.

    1 Comment
    2024/11/30
    21:22 UTC

    12

    The shape of lust

    When I was young and fairly dumb
    A maidens hand I asked
    To my surprise, a yes she said
    For her it seemed a laugh

    So off we went into the night
    For love we were to make
    But once in bed I heard her say
    'Its only cash I take'

    And then the truth washed over me
    My maiden she had lied
    She handed me a business card
    'You're a prostitute I cried!'

    So at the door I stand alone
    For back outside she went
    I shut the door and slumped in bed
    And chuckled, 'cash well spent'

    12 Comments
    2024/11/30
    20:51 UTC

    1

    Awaiting my Azure

    Somewhere in my psyche

    It lingers, a place that's debilitated

    That's suffering unmedicated

    Or perhaps it is the whole.

    Thin like the sheath which bled crimson

    Torn and infected

    Or perhaps it was just recovering

    And it was I that misunderstood

    The situation as a whole.

    Diluting down it's worth into my insecurities

    And quaffing down uncongealed embitterment

    Or perhaps it emerged from within me

    And consumed me whole.

    Constructing my own delirium

    With my flayed, exsanginuated hands

    Pleading for someone that understands

    Or perhaps I wish I was dead and

    Swallowed whole.

    I wish to rise from the decay of my thoughts and my dreams

    But not of my hatred, I seek vengeance

    For everyone who has ever wronged me should endure excruciating agony

    But the one who will suffer most shall be me, as always.

    -PR

    0 Comments
    2024/11/30
    19:10 UTC

    1

    Fluid Hopelessness

    My mental illness has been an affliction since birth

    I must take pills daily to regulate my mood I get irritated

    just from another human being breathing some nights i'm in so much

    physical pain and so mentally restless that I wish for the forever sleep

    but I'm such a coward that I'm incapable of checking out of my own misery

    well on a good note for support I do have my best friend who just happens to be a poodle her name is Betty Boop she is always elated to see me constantly playful , warm hearted , so radiant I'm so fascinated by how free she is

    she's also without worry and so energetic I must say today I live through Betty Boop

    2 Comments
    2024/11/30
    15:10 UTC

    3

    What if I told you I liked you.

    What if I told you I liked you that day? Would it change our story?

    Would we two children? Living in a remote town?

    Would we have the German shepherd we dreamed of? The one we promised we'd  name Reily?

    Would I wake up in your arms? Drink morning coffee together?

    I can't help but wonder if I didn't hesitate.

    Didn't think twice. Didn't know why. Didn't get to try.

    What if I told you i liked you that day?

    Would you liked me too?

    2 Comments
    2024/11/30
    14:22 UTC

    1

    Where The Heart Is

    There's no place

    Like an abandon home

    That gets burn down

    And bulldoze over

    For a prison block,

    I mean an apartment complex

    That's overpriced and mismanaged

    With a landlord that haunts you

    For paying the rent

    Which takes up half your paycheck

    While the other half's spent

    Scrounging around for scraps of food

    Leaving you with little to do

    Except eat, work, and sleep.

    0 Comments
    2024/11/30
    14:00 UTC

    2

    Before The Breakdown

    I'm the silence between two noises, The silent tone before the breakdown. My life's not the fast climb, Im fast only in my desire.

    Im a straw in the field. The voice in the crowd fading away, The noise of death threatening me, Fear it will overpower me.

    They can kill me, but they can not kill my sadness. The can cut my hands, I'll grasp her with my teeth. They can cut my ears, I'll listen her with my soul. They can take my heart out, I'll pump her with my bones.

    She is in every corner of my soul, The flame burning in my core. The only emotion i explored, A stone dragging me down to the bottom, and lifting me closer to my dreams at the same time.

    I see people with cold faces, and Cruel eyes, and i can't confront them. God didn't make me that wise. A child's smile becomes the face of evil, Two persons that are not equal.

    This Earth is spinning too fast for me, I still can't figure out what I'm supposed to be. The world is rushing, throwing away The weak and indecisive like me.

    If somebody is crying out there , it feels like i am guilty. If somebody laughing, it always feels like they are laughing at me.

    0 Comments
    2024/11/30
    13:49 UTC

    3

    thoughts

    are we inherently bad,

    does the way we speak determine our character,

    or do thoughts carry heavier than the weight of bones,

    how do we unveil emotions,

    that cannot be seen,

    but are felt deeper than skin,

    a glimmer of hope,

    and once again we are reborn,

    can we be changed?

    do we deserve a chance to seek retribution,

    or are our sins engrained so very deeply in our hearts,

    may we only be the words spoken of us,

    spat out with wickedness,

    in a moment of our weakness and pain,

    everything will turn,

    morphing into a true colour,

    is the loneliness a blanket of comfort,

    or a twisted monster under our beds,

    gnawing away at the remains of our souls, identity rotting, mouth smiling, teeth snarling.

    2 Comments
    2024/11/30
    13:43 UTC

    2

    Photo Book - ...

    I opened a photo book the other day,

    And I saw glimpses of a past

    so far in the back of my head

    That i felt as though I shouldn’t be watching,

    Private moments 

    with a family I see as often as a UFO

    They’re all grown up now

    And what do you know

    I’m still here.

    Waiting, for nothing

    For them to pause their lives

    And come back to my grandma’s house

    Where we’d ride bikes on the roof

    And drink juice on her velvet couch

    It feels empty now

    she told me she felt lonely

    since everyone has a life to live

    they don’t need her affection anymore

    When it’s all she can give

    Now all she could do is

    fall asleep until she can’t anymore 

    Cook, knit and sweep the floor

    Telling herself we’d all be back one day

    And thats for sure

    To her at least

    I’m afraid of loss

    I’m afraid I’ll open a photo book one day

    Only to see her holding me in her loving arms

    Telling myself I should have stayed

    Right there, in her heart

    Shrouded by the aroma of omelettes

    Watching wacky Saturday cartoons

    But now the sun has set

    And i’m afraid she’ll be gone soon

    Like everyone else

    in that little house,

    Where we all grew 

    1 Comment
    2024/11/30
    11:51 UTC

    Back To Top