/r/open_news

Photograph via snooOG

With the recent events of mods in popular news subreddits censoring what they believe personally to be worthy/unworthy of discussion, this a place to speak freely.

The only rule that will get your comment removed and/or possibly get you banned is direct hate towards another user.

General


If you have any concerns, feel free to PM our modteam!


 

Rules

News Only
Submissions must be actual news or opinions on news. If news article is posted, headline of article should be used as title of post. Personal posts or personal news aren't allowed.


Do not insult other users
Comments should be related to the topic at hand. Any insult or hate directed towards a specific user will be removed.


Post title must be same as article title Quite self-explanatory. Please refrain from misleading users (i.e. "clickbaiting") with article titles.


Spam is strictly forbidden Spam has no place among the news. In addition, accounts tied to news publications are forbidden and directly go against the site-wide "1/10 rule".


  • New Comments
  • /r/open_news

    2,530 Subscribers

    3

    The Russian government has stopped the Blitzkrieg

    Strategic Mind: Blitzkrieg was banned in Russia by the Roskomnadzor decision effective today. We apologize to all the players from Russia, who no longer can purchase the game or open our Store page.

    Yesterday, we got a letter from Valve informing us of the formal Roskomnadzor’s (a Russian government body charged with legislative power to ban any content without the court decision or public hearings) request to stop the distribution of Strategic Mind: Blitzkrieg in Russia. As we understood, by Russian law the Roskomnadzor decision is enough to ban any game or other content in Russian segment of the Internet.

    As lawful entities, both we and Valve had to comply with the Roskomnadzor’s decision.

    So, now the game is not available in Russia in the Steam store. However, it is still available in the GOG.com store, creating unequal competition. Additionally, the number of illegal downloads in Russia (i.e. torrent etc.) has surged dramatically. So, what was the purpose of ROSCOMNADZOR’s actions, and did they succeed in their efforts? That is open to debate.

    We want to be fully transparent about the situation, so here are the charges that were filed against the game. (The exact law or its paragraphs that we supposedly infringed, was not specified)

    Here are the abstracts from the Roskomnadzor official request and our commentary on them:

    [the game] “has clear signs of the rehabilitation of Nazism” (c) Roskomnadzor letter

    “the game forms a loyal attitude towards Nazism and war criminals among the participants, belittles the exploits of the Soviet people in the struggle against Nazi invaders and is actually aimed at reviewing the results of the Second World War.” (c) Roskomnadzor letter

    First of all, regarding the alleged “Nazi propaganda”. All party members (Hitler and Goering) are presented as negative characters and they make progressively more criminal moves the longer the campaign goes, so we are sure that closer to the end of the game the player will most likely be fed up with them. The scene everyone is talking about is only 75% into the game (many mistakenly think this is the ending video, however, it is said in description to the said video on YouTube that it happens 75% into the game) Moreover, Hitler is killed by the Resistance just a couple of operations later, and Goering becomes your enemy at the end and you storm Berlin to get rid of his criminal rule. In the end, both Hitler and Goering are dead and the new non-nazi government is formed in Germany, and the main character announces “There will be democratic elections and all power will not be concentrated in one hands!” etc.

    The game has gone through the denazification process - all symbols that could violate the law were replaced or changed in such a way that they conform with the law.

    Secondly, regarding the “reviewing the results of the Second World War”. We did say in the game description from the very beginning that it had the alternate history elements and would allow the player to see the outcome of the war should the German army be more successful than it was historically:

    “While we strive for historical accuracy, we also allow you to explore various “what if’s” and see what could have happened should the German Armed forces be even more successful in their struggle for dominance over the European continent.” (c) Store page

    Consequently, we do not claim any of the following: “USSR did not win the war”, “German troops have taken Moscow” etc. We just make a fictional scenario to let the people see what could have happened if they did. We think that the negative reaction from some people is a clear indication that we succeeded in showing all the adversities that could befall us all if that were to happen. Which can actually be considered to have an “anti-nazi” effect and serve as a condemnation of their actions. Or at the very least regarded as a fictional scenario. There is a number of similar works of art and entertainment such as “The Man in High Castle”, “Red Alert”, and many more.

    We often get criticized that the game only presents the German side. However, we already did the US Pacific and Japanese Pacific campaigns in Strategic Mind: The Pacific and plan to make USSR and Allied perspectives in our future projects. So, we just need more time and resources to present the WW2 events both real and alternate history from every major participant perspective. Also, there were other games before, like Panzer Corps 2 where only the German campaign was available, with alternate history elements

    Thirdly, regarding the “the game forms a loyal attitude towards Nazism and war criminals” accusation. There is a wide-spread misconception in the Russian press, who obviously did not play the game nor examined the Store page, that “Hitler is the player character”. In fact, you play as Franz Halder - a German officer who was not tried by the Nuremberg tribunal, and who was imprisoned by Hitler’s regime on 23 July 1944. Moreover, “In 1961 he was awarded the Meritorious Civilian Service Award for this work. This award was bestowed by Major General Edgar C. Doleman on behalf of President John F. Kennedy. Halder thus became the only German to be decorated by both Adolf Hitler and an American president. (He had received the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross from Hitler in 1939.)” © In the actual game Halder often opposes Hitler and argues with him. At some point, Hitler even dismisses him from his position. The rest of the officers even get arrested, as Hitler doubts their loyalty.

    Thus, we think these accusations are completely unfounded.

    Lastly, we would like to point out that with accusations being so vague and open to multiple interpretations, the issue is left unclear both for us and any other developers and literary any new game can be banned with some rather vague and ill-informed accusations.

    To sum up, we would like you to know that we see no real substance to these accusations, and they seem very vague to us. We have let you know our perspective. Additionally, Steam user reviews are very positive, and we do not think that would have been the case had the game contain real nazi propaganda (unless the 83% of Steam users are nazi supporters, which would have been even more far-fetched). We want players all over the world, including the Russian Federation to enjoy our games. We stand firmly on the principles of freedom of speech and freedom of creation (to the point it conforms with the law, of course). We would not want to create a precedent of the case where the game can be prohibited without solid proof of it violating the law and without reasonable consideration. We are worried that games might get banned by mistake or by the willful actions of some government officials.

    By Russian law, both we and Valve had to comply with the Roskomnadzor’s decision.

    Still, it seems to us that the actions of the Roskomnadzor lack logic and consistency. There is no detailed explanation as to which law was broken and by what episode (the only thing they mentioned was “a parade of Nazi troops on Red Square in Moscow reviewed by Adolf Hitler, who was recognized as an international war criminal by the sentence of the International Nuremberg Tribunal.” (c) Roskomnadzor

    Secondly, the game is still available in the GOG.com store, so that creates an unfair market for the game in Russia.

    Thirdly, that decision makes players in Russia (who want to play the game but cannot do so legally) think about illegal methods of getting a copy, i.e. promote piracy.

    Finally, such actions, without solid consideration or investigation of the case, lead to the infringement of the customers’ rights in Russia.

    We regret that it has come to this, but this is what happens when an important decision (about the game with over 100 hours of gameplay) is being made after watching a 30-second-long video on YouTube.

    With best regards

    Ihor Tymoshenko

    The CEO of Starni Games

    0 Comments
    2020/06/05
    17:17 UTC

    0

    Starni Games studio is being attacked by the Russian media

    Hello,

    My name is Igor, I’m the studio head of Starni Games – an independent game development studio based in Kyiv, Ukraine. Our latest project Strategic Mind: Blitzkrieg has recently launched on PC. It is a WWII turn-based strategy that combines classic wargame mechanics with modern graphics. Currently, it has “very positive” reviews on Steam – 84% of Steam players like the game.

    But yesterday we found out that we can’t access our YouTube channel and one of our cinematics was deleted from Facebook. Turns out the game was featured on the Russian TV – and it was accused of glorifying nazis. Because of that, we’ve received a ton of complaints on YouTube and Facebook from Russian users. Moreover, it looks like the government there seeks legal action and threatens criminal prosecution. All because of this video – a story cutscene about Hitler on the Red Square.

    Starni Games has to clarify – in no way we’re trying to glorify the Nazi ideology, we strongly condemn their deeds. We’ve created a historical game with alternate history possibilities: if the player loses there are Soviet troops taking Reichstag and if he wins one of the battles German troops are taking Moscow. If you win the battle of Moscow you indeed can witness the alternate history moment with German parade on the Red Square. We have around 90 minutes of cinematics in the game and if you watch the whole story, you will clearly see that Hitler and Goering are portrayed as negative characters who give criminal orders. Other characters struggle between their oath and their reluctance to carrying out orders issued by the Fuhrer. Moreover, Hitler will be killed later on in the game by the resistance forces. Moreover, our game is denazified – all prohibited historical symbols banned by the law (like “swastika”) were replaced by the denazified symbols.

    We try to make games that will present the WW2 history from the perspective of different countries. We already did Strategic Mind: The Pacific featuring both the US and Japan campaigns. Now, we are telling the German story. Next we plan to move on to the USSR and Allies. Everyone can clearly see that we pursue entertainment combined with preserving historical knowledge of the events. We are not aiming to offend anyone or glorify anything, we aim to create great and immersive games. The game’s Steam user score indicates that the actual players enjoy the game. And the recent wave of negative comments on social media is instigated by Russian press agencies presenting the news in a very biased manner.

    A short video that caused the controversy:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MkgWJ2mzjGs

    Russian TV talk show:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O7_t65y8MuA

    Example of Russian news article:

    https://lenta.ru/news/2020/05/25/punish

    If you want to check everything out yourself – we can offer you a few keys, just let us know.

    Additional materials about the game:

    Press kit:

    https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1Z4Q0TZQG8pZIMdu-uAPGXHlQKvUi5AiL

    Gameplay trailer:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RzZmTZU_qrQ

    Cinematic trailer:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kVPImD_QKsE

    0 Comments
    2020/05/27
    17:06 UTC

    6

    100% Unbaised News Channel I put 10+ Hours in for Each Video - Please Take a Look!

    1 Comment
    2019/09/27
    03:56 UTC

    Back To Top