/r/mormonscholar

Photograph via snooOG

A community dedicated to evenhanded, thoughtful, empirical-based discussion of Mormonism.

What is Mormon Scholar?

Mormon Scholar is a community dedicated to evenhanded, thoughtful, empirical-based discussion of Mormonism.


Expectations

We expect the following from all users:

1) Be courteous. Demeaning language, sarcasm, rudeness or hostility towards another user may get your comment removed. Repeated violations may result in a ban.

2) Source your facts. If you're claiming something to be true, you should back it up with a qualified source.

3) Put thought into it. Explain the reasoning behind what you're saying. Bare statements of opinion, off-topic comments, memes, and one-line replies may be removed. Argue your position with logic and evidence.

4) Address the arguments, not the person. The subject of your sentence should be "the evidence" or "this source" or some other noun directly related to the topic of conversation. "You" statements are suspect.

5) Acronyms and verbiage. Please avoid polarizing acronyms like "TSCC" (use "LDS Church") or calling leaders by a diminutive nickname (e.g., calling Joseph Smith "Joe"). Well-known acronyms like BoM, JS, TSM, are all acceptable.

Topics

Posts should generally be focused on scholarly approaches and information related to Mormonism. Posts may be formal (e.g., links to the academic literature on a particular topic) or informal (a well-thought out analysis on a particular topic or data presented in a new way).

Discussion on all Mormon branches (e.g., CoC) is welcome but it's assumed that the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is being referred to in the absence of clarifying identification.

Information or data related to any Church claim or aspect is fair game. Relevant topics might include:

  • Parallels in the Book of Mormon to modern or ancient sources
  • Analysis of historical documents related to Joseph Smith's polygamy
  • Medical studies related to the Word of Wisdom
  • Survey data on sexuality among Church members

note: some of the verbiage for this sidebar was copied verbatim from neutral politics

/r/mormonscholar

1,577 Subscribers

4

Evangelical Steven Pynakker's Appreciation of The Book of Mormon

Stephen Murphy host of the program Mormonism with the Murph recently sat down with Evangelical Steven Pynakker to discuss Apologetic defenses of the Book of Mormon.

Link: https://youtu.be/ril622_FACI?si=IAG8qqx-roWjoyF6

0 Comments
2024/11/26
23:03 UTC

2

Greg Prince and Patrick Mason join Maven and Gene to discuss the life, work, and legacy of Leonard J. Arrington.

0 Comments
2024/11/23
12:01 UTC

6

WidowsMite comments on a FAIR presentation on Church finances

1 Comment
2024/11/21
22:53 UTC

8

The push for purity as the early Saints face growing pressure to conform. LDS leaders drive their community toward extreme obedience and emphasize Blood Atonement • Plural Marriage • Bathing and Physical Cleanliness • Public Confessions. Sunstone Mormon History Podcast - Mormon Reformation, Part 2.

0 Comments
2024/11/17
15:29 UTC

10

Lindsay Hansen Park speaking for the opposition at yesterday's Cambridge Union debate. The house became unruly and had to be called to order at the mention of "Feminist Mormon Housewives".

1 Comment
2024/11/15
12:58 UTC

1

Latter Day Accountant Talks Tithing Misconceptions w/ Aaron Brewster

Accountant and member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints Aaron Brewster talks about innovative approaches to Tithing!

Link: https://youtu.be/tsIucdMP8y0?si=b49bjb8PhdOordZj

0 Comments
2024/11/14
23:03 UTC

6

John Vance Journal

John Vance was an early member and pioneer west. He arrived in one of the first waggon trains (but not with Brigham Young). His journal is bland at times, but does include entries talking about the crickets eating crops the first year, the birds coming to eat the crickets, how this helped somewhat (but they still came back later), and preaching from the early summer telling the saints that if they wanted to get rid of the crickets they had to be better at sharing their cows. It's an interesting perspective and a little more complex than traditional narriative.

I have uploaded it digitally here for anyone who is interested.

Here is the transcription which is easier to read.

Some entries:

Su 5th [June] Parley preached encouraging the people to hold on - we will make grain notwithstanding crickets. This is the place for the Saints at present. Father Smith

said “You who have many cows lend to those who have none, till harvest & then crickets will quit & we shall have plenty.

Th 20th [July] Finished planting peas therein and everywhere else. Snipes have cleared off crickets much...

0 Comments
2024/11/08
17:55 UTC

8

Bishop Koyle's Dream Mine & Ogden Kraut w/ Kevin Kraut

Kevin Kraut son of Mormon Fundamentalist scholar Ogden Kraut talks about the history of Bishop Koyle's Dream Mine and his father's involvement.

Link: https://youtu.be/yhiTvCInYSs?si=cvtvtLezhEijqpvn

0 Comments
2024/11/07
23:04 UTC

8

Recommending Krohn's "Mormon Hermeneutics"

I’m offering a recommendation for Jeffrey Krohn’s “Mormon Hermeneutics.” Any serious scholarship on LDS theology, doxy, or interpretive praxes ought to be familiar with this book. While he does restrict his focus on LDS interpretive practices to those of the Bible, it is well researched - the bibliography subsection titled “LDS Books and Articles” alone fills 21 pages.

Krohn states, “My intention is not to offer the LDSC a set of rules for interpretation, but rather, a critically well-founded assessment of the potential alignment between LDSC hermeneutics and mainstream theological and hermeneutical scholarship.” His use of the research framework critical realism allows an evaluative, rather than a strictly interpretivist, stance. Krohn and one reviewer discussed the legitimacy of critical realism for this subject matter. 

The five hermeneutics he identifies are literal, allegorical, sociological, emendatory, and “re-authoring.” He ultimately argues that a Gadamerian hermeneutic framework would best suit church scholars who seek dialogue with the “mainstream hermeneutical academy.” 

A repository on the university website contains a pdf of Krohn’s thesis that predates the paperback publication by two years.

0 Comments
2024/11/04
22:33 UTC

1

The Dream Mine & End of Days? #churchofjesuschristoflatterdaysaints #mor...

0 Comments
2024/10/23
20:02 UTC

6

Looking for a good home for an early pioneer journal (1847-1850)

My father spent a lot of time transcribing a pioneer journal of an ancestor. The result is a nicely bound book with photographs of all of the pages along with his transcription. It has some interesting first-hand and second-hand accounts of things like arguments along the path to SLC between church leaders and the problems with insects and late planting of crops after they arrived.

I have a limited number of copies. The church has already received the original (historial journal) and copies of the transcription. I would like to place a few copies in places where researchers can have access. I was thinking the Univesity of Utah(?). Possibly Yale? Any suggestions as to where I should put these so that people researching mormon history can find them? Should I post this digitally online?

3 Comments
2024/10/16
14:39 UTC

0

The math maths out.

Everyone has there views on polygamy, and this is not that debate, for nor against it.

But... Math checks out at least.

The narrative is that a third of all heaven was cast out. And those cast out were all men.

This means that 1/6 of the original total in heaven is men with the remainder half being only women.

And because 1/2÷1/6 is 3, this would mean that for everything to be as even as possible, every man would need to have three wives.

This doesn't take into account variables like people's opinions and desires. Plenty want to be gay, plenty are fine with being single, plenty just want 1 spouse, and yes, some will have more than three.

So if the polygamist doctrine is true, it at least got the math right.

23 Comments
2024/10/07
18:18 UTC

9

What is The Mormon Polygamy Journal All About?

Mormon Scholar Cherly Bruno and Michelle Brady Stone join Steven Pynakker to talk about a new Mormon History resource called "The Journal of Mormon Polygamy". We also discuss an upcoming conference that will occur next March in Utah! Here is a link to the Journal's site: https://journalofmormonpolygamy.org/

Link: https://youtu.be/m-v-BCOujf0?si=Vop0ufAYa1xWsY7h

0 Comments
2024/09/26
22:04 UTC

13

New Book of Mormon About To be Canonized? w/ Paul Durham

Robert Messick of Book of Mormon Editions joins Steven Pynakker as a special co-host to interview Paul Durham an editor of a remarkable edition of the Book of Mormon that is a Modern English version called Covenant of Christ!

#bookofmormon #holybook #bible #churchofjesuschristoflatterdaysaints #thebookofmormon #denversnuffer #restoration #josephsmith #evangelical #stevenpynakker #mormonbookreviews

Link: https://youtu.be/7K4RJk8s3zw?si=LLljW1X4ukyRwnJo

0 Comments
2024/09/24
22:04 UTC

7

Polygamist Shares His Faith! w/ Benjamin Shaffer

Mormon Fundamentalist Benjamin Shaffer returns to Mormon Book Reviews to discuss with Evangelical Steven Pynakker the important role that Covenants play in Mormon theology!

Link: https://youtu.be/PFv9gATyMSk?si=KH1PIdWy_Q0BMHJG

0 Comments
2024/09/17
22:02 UTC

6

Cheryl Bruno Paints Mormon History!

On today's episode of Mormon Book Reviews, I am excited to have on my friend Cheryl L. Bruno to discuss her art exhibit she showcased at Sunstone. The exhibit was water color portraits of some of the more prominent characters in the Mormon Studies community! Here is Cheryl's email to contact her about her artwork: clbruno@gmail.com

Interview Link: https://youtube.com/watch?v=FPRLAVJm9Zs&si=P2wQIEqqx9s587VN

0 Comments
2024/09/05
21:32 UTC

5

CES Letters podcast on YouTube: Book of Mormon Translation with Richard Lyman Bushman

0 Comments
2024/09/02
04:45 UTC

Back To Top