/r/Logo_Critique

Photograph via snooOG

A growing community of new and veteran logo designers. Learn and get feedback on your designs!

Ask for critique of your own logos or critique other people's logos. Be polite and constructive with your criticism!

  • For Submissions – Include a description of the company to enable other redditors to provide a critique in context and read this.

  • For Comments – Don't be a jerk, and read this

  • For EveryoneReddiquette


Looking for more feedback or logo discussion?

Check out /r/LogoDesign!


Other reddits:

/r/LogoDesign

/r/design

/r/design_critique

/r/crappydesign

Reddit logos:

/r/logo

/r/logos

/r/Logo_Critique

15,302 Subscribers

1

Please critique my logo

My name is Christian Baloga; I'm a visual artist and author; this is my logo: https://cbaloga.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/cropped-43dae-siteicon-1.png

Thank you for taking the time to critique my logo!

2 Comments
2024/03/05
21:28 UTC

1

Please help me with my quest to find a good logo

Here is what im working on: https://imgur.com/a/lv7FQii. At the heart of it, its for an internet company. Software development and geeky shit like that.

DETAILS Im having trouble deciding what path to go down. Im considering a "JollyRobot" pirate + robot mashup. Originally I was really set on this, and hadnt really considered anything else.

However as time has gone on. Im really thinking maybe this isnt the best option...

Ive tried to comment on each photo the logic behind it / what im going for. I think they are pretty straightforward but maybe that because i've been staring at them.

FEEDBACK What are your guys thoughts? Keep the robot? Work on the digital fingerprint?

2 Comments
2024/03/04
21:03 UTC

1

Visionnaire Art Gallery | Logo Design & Brand Identity

Hello guys, this is my first brand identity project! Let me know if you like it!🍀

https://www.behance.net/gallery/191974657/Visionnaire-Art-Gallery-Brand-Identity

1 Comment
2024/03/02
09:58 UTC

0

Hello! Can somebody make me one.

Hello everybody! Im here today to request help by making me a logo. It would be nice if it was like 2019 onlyfans logo but it reads OnlyVozols and inside O has to be okie looking smoke or just smoke emoji. Sorry for wasting ur all time and thanks to these that help me. ✌️ Yolo ✌️

1 Comment
2024/02/26
18:29 UTC

1

Help me add an idea please!

https://imgur.com/a/lDvNRN6
Logo design for walls of attraction. Walls of attraction creates magnetic wall sticker and sticker cut-outs that can be moved around by kids. So it's an interactive product. Help me please. I am stuck as to how I can make the w looks magnet, my client wants to retain the loopy 'w' with gradient but wanted to add something that, when you look at it, you'll say, 'oh it's something to do with walls, magnet, and interaction.'

Any feedback is highly appreciated thank you in advance!

4 Comments
2024/02/24
05:48 UTC

2

Help me choose a logo for my business

UPDATE: Fixed an issue with the voting being disabled and an issue where users couldn't change their vote if they wanted to. I also added a little more context to my business description below. Sorry for the confusion.

I am starting up a small business that does laser cutting and engraving. In the future I'd like to make other sorts of decor/art. The name of my business is Emberglow. While I will be creating some rustic-looking and personalized items that you see on platforms like Etsy, I have a goal of working with businesses creating engraved promotional materials an such. So my goal is to not portray my business as overly "crafty" or homespun, including the logo.

I'm trying to create a logo that's relatively simple and clean. I'm satisfied with the color scheme, I just can't find a shape that I really like. So I've decided to just take what I have and create a poll and let others decide what they think is the best option.

I would really appreciate your feedback if you have a moment and would like to vote in the poll: https://www.opinionstage.com/page/5a603630-2dd3-4fcb-8f3c-5e5f8dc8f306

I'd also appreciate any additional feedback and I look forward to reading your comments.

5 Comments
2024/02/24
05:32 UTC

0

Now that I’ve used Canva to create my rough draft of my logo, how do I go about making it so it can be trademarked?

My logo is quite simple but I used a few things in canva to bring it to life. Namely, an element design, a picture (of a bright star) and obviously used Canva’s font.

I know I can not use it as is as my logo. Is there a somewhat simple way to make it my own?

Adobe illustrator is quite expensive and I could get it but know it is essentially its own language and would not need it once I’m done with my logo

8 Comments
2024/02/22
20:32 UTC

1

Logo and brand redesign for regional radio station

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/zs4je2f7ovw9o53gqktf9/guidelines.pdf?rlkey=adypt716hl2o04l55gz32vskg&dl=0

High-energy dance music station based in the North East of England.

Would love to hear your thoughts to pass on to our designer, no matter how critical.

4 Comments
2024/02/22
19:11 UTC

5

What is the best software to create my own logo from stretch (that I can trademark)

Hello! I am creative a small clothing business. I am working on registering a trademark for the name soon and will be sewing patches with my logo on my clothes.

I am an artist but not too familiar with softwares I can use for my logo.

I keep getting conflicting results on if I can use certain softwares to create a logo if I want to sell my brand with it (IE Canva and adobe illustrator)

I have the logo design ready and would prefer to just make it myself but what software can I use to make my from scratch logo that will be safe to use once I start selling?

Preferably one that wont break the bank and i am only going to be using that software very briefly(for now at least)

thanks for the help!

5 Comments
2024/02/21
20:29 UTC

5

Logo for a custom furniture brand

First of all, thank you for taking the time to look at my logo designs!

https://imgur.com/a/0FS4G6r

This logo is for my custom furniture brand - Naomi Furniture & Design. We specialize in high quality modern and contemporary inspired designs, and mainly focus on custom media consoles, vinyl record collections, and custom high fidelity equipment storage.

This logo will not only be used in graphics on our social and website, but will also be laser etched/engraved on our products. We will be using the logo with and without the "furniture & design" tagline.

I'm trying to go for a slightly vintage, yet simple and modern feel. My inspiration was mostly from synthesizer logos like Moog, Korg, Nord, and Roland.

Please let me know your thoughts on the direction I'm taking and which one is your favorite!

6 Comments
2024/02/21
14:40 UTC

1

Need help with logo design

https://imgur.com/a/JOB0QZK

I'm designing a logo for a remote working blog called remote prosper. The main vision for the brand was "not just survive, thrive' essentially helping the target audience ( entrepreneurs and remote workers) in balancing their professional and personal life. There is some emphasis on being mindful and leading a fulfilling balanced life. The blog will focus on helping the reader achieve prosperity professionally and also as a remote worker and the qualms one might face in work-life balance in one's personal life.

The concept was of a "toggle" a switch essentially. That creates symbolic distinction between being 'on the job mode' and 'off the job mode' and having the ability or mindful practice of "switching/toggling" between the two.

I need your help and expertise to kind of 'peer review' the logo and how it looks. What changes you'd suggest and even if the concept doesn't click I'd love your opinions on why and how to better it.

I've attached a logo 'evolution' below. The first looks too simple and the second look was scratched because it kind of looked like a pacifier rather than a toggle. So you can tell me whether it looks like a pacifier to you or not and whether you like version1, 2 or 3. 3 being the current reigning option. I've attached a link to the gif of the logo animation. If someone here has some experience on making a animated or interactive logo ( knowledge about the coding end) please comment I'd love to pick your brain on this.

Thank you !

15 Comments
2024/02/15
20:16 UTC

2

Help deciding app icon and logo

This icon is for an app made to discover local businesses like restaurants and museums on your area, do you think it’s good enough for a first version?

https://imgur.com/a/lASckwf

3 Comments
2024/02/08
14:58 UTC

1

Logo Options for a Private Club Network for Wellness, Habits, and Professional Development in London. Which is best?

1 Comment
2024/02/08
14:20 UTC

6

I try to explain my friend that this is not a logo that resonates with his "brand"

Logo

Can someone say what is wrong with my friend's logo.

I am not in the design field and I can't articulate it, but having lines on a brand that is supposed to be Jolly Dots makes no sense to me

And also the colors are on the opposite side of being anything jolly about them

10 Comments
2024/02/07
19:09 UTC

2

Road block on rebranding logo

So I’m in the mix of starting up a “retreat/sactuary” on my 20 acres. It started off as just foraging/wildcrafting classes and now I want to add in yoga classes, weekend farmers market, reiki sessions, spiritual ceremonies/ and a coffee shop lol. Anyways it’ll be awhile before my dream is complete and everything is in order but I wanted “Groovy GroundsS.” (The s is short for sanctuary) to be the main branding and then I’ll have little names for the classes or whatever. Anyways I’ve been working on a damn logo for too long and I just don’t want something that’s going to be completely unrelated but I can’t figure something out that isn’t too complex or corny. Any thoughts?

2 Comments
2024/02/05
01:49 UTC

1

Logo Critique Please

Hello! Which of the two logos here do you prefer?

https://imgur.com/a/nEANK8y

or

https://imgur.com/iDN0sW8

6 Comments
2024/02/04
02:02 UTC

3

Help critique old non-profit logo on what’s good and bad about it

Hi I’m helping a non-profit change their visual identity. Pls note I’m not a designer but have experience in marketing.

The founder of the org had this designed 14 years ago and is fond of the logo. Most of the other people are not. No designer was used back then

IMHO it is a nice piece of art but doesn’t work well for a logo. It has low reductive value, is very busy and may have too many colors, amongst things)

Questions for the designers here:

  1. What is working for you in this logo ?
  2. What is not working for you?
  3. What do you think the visual is trying to imply
  4. What types of changes would you require.

I’m trying to make a case for logo redesign.

Thanks!!

https://i.imgur.com/AznTnmb.jpg

1 Comment
2024/01/29
12:57 UTC

3

Logo for a ‘done for you’ website builder platform

1 Comment
2024/01/26
15:13 UTC

0

Hello. I paid someone to make a logo and I am not happy with it. Is there a place on Reddit where I can post said logo, have people improve it, pick the one I like best and pay for that one?

6 Comments
2024/01/16
21:36 UTC

1

Feedback appreciated on my exercise

Hello everyone, I did some practice makeing a couple of logos for "Creative Perpetuum" collective for sewing novices and people who want to learn, variety of in classroom courses on sewing and alike.

Link: https://ibb.co/X4r76yN

0 Comments
2024/01/15
17:39 UTC

1

Tips on my business logo

For context I'm planning to start a 3D print farm in the future, i still need to work a lot of things out and such but I already started working on branding and such. I made this logo myself with some variations. I want it to be simple so it can be placed on 3D prints as a small cut out or a protrusion (basically bevel or emboss in photoshop terms).

I like it but I still feel like it doesn't have that charm of more professional simple logos (Think of Twitter, Telegram, Android, Python and such). Any tips or feedback appreciated.

A bit more info about the whole thing: the name of the business is Snowflake 3D, referencing the fact that 3D printing can be the solution to many different problems. No two snowflakes are alike, just like the customers needs, if that makes sense.

https://imgur.com/a/sI2Qr6R

8 Comments
2024/01/08
12:16 UTC

1

Looking for Ice Cream Logo Feedback

https://i.imgur.com/oOfMhCx.png

Does this logo look like the money sign ($) in a cone? We wanted to incorporate the "S" in our name into the ice cream cone but not sure how it looks to people.

3 Comments
2024/01/04
19:34 UTC

1

I am looking for feedback regarding a possible rebranding of this logo

Hi everyone, I need suggestions regarding possible interventions that can be made on this logo. There is no meaning linked to the three letters, except for M, whose dot also serves to indicate an exclamation point. I don't understand exactly what's wrong with this logo, but I have a lot of difficulty working with it to create accompanying material

https://imgur.com/a/zCAayFD

4 Comments
2024/01/02
17:29 UTC

1

Feedback Needed on a Rebranding Project

I am thrilled to announce the completion of my rebranding project of Enthrall IT on Behance! 🎉✨

🚀 Throughout this transformative journey, I discovered that Enthrall's previous brand design was not aligned with their core values, and as a result, they were not effectively reaching my exact target audience. 🎯

The new design elements have been carefully chosen to resonate with their target audience and create an instant connection. From the typography that exudes professionalism and credibility to the imagery that evokes emotions and tells a story, every detail has been thoughtfully considered to enhance brand perception

6 Comments
2023/12/15
22:03 UTC

2

Feedback needed for Business Consulting startup

Link: https://imgur.com/a/acl67us

Can you guys please review the logo which is for a business consulting startup company? They'll be dealing into service based industry and here is the design. Suggest me if there are any major red flags or anything that would lead a bad impression especially while reaching out to potential clients into b2b

8 Comments
2023/12/13
02:52 UTC

2

Dimitalize

Logo for personal/amateur use. My nickname is Dimi, so I wanted to try playing with that. I want to have something that I can stamp on my work. Very minimal.

Tell me what you think :D
https://drive.filen.io/d/4c6820d9-6107-4dd7-ba83-4cafc3104ae2#dZVeyRfuSph2i2ZxwTDvPRoZ0cXpnLsu

1 Comment
2023/12/12
22:01 UTC

2

Logo feedback for basketball tournament

https://ibb.co/rZ20cKx

Created this for a local basketball tournament, was told to give it a " streetwear vibe" - hence the handwritten stars & tournament wording. Inspired by the original Space Jam logo as well.

I'm a big fan of the logo but feel like something about it looks slightly off, any feedback at all is appreciated!

3 Comments
2023/12/10
18:40 UTC

4

Logo Feedback for Luxury Cannabis company

Hi there! I have been in graphic design and more recently focused on UX and UI design since August of '22. I have been attempting some logo designs recently, and I would appreciate any feedback on this.

The client was a luxury cannabis company called "Jov-e". They wanted to be exclusive, be sophisticated, and to bring a touch of luxury to everyday enjoyment. The personality is a mi of brightness, modern, friendly, class, playfulness, a bit of rebellion, natural, and easy strength. The client emphasized that this was meant for those seeking a lifestyle not just looking for a product. They are targeting wholesale and retail customer markets and requested a Lettermark type of logo. When using adjectives to further describe what they were looking for was elegant, modern, between personable and professional, neutral gender, colorful, and upmarket. I got the color scheme from an image that the client provided using magenta, purple, and blue hues.

I always get the feeling that there is something very obvious like a design principle or rule or something that I do not remember or do not know when I make logos, so I am very curious to know what you all think and have to say about them. I am only looking for constructive feedback so if you don't provide some sort of reason please don't bother commenting lol

I went ahead and quickly put them in a Google doc for you to check out here.

4 Comments
2023/12/06
21:09 UTC

1

All feedback is appreciated!

I've never actually designed a logo before, but as I'm about to start my own business, I finally found justification for all the logo design content I've consumed on Youtube over the years :D

The company will offer services and products related to NFC tags how to utilize them in the customers own business.

https://gyazo.com/3856f77ce873af11dad11761e798aea0

  1. Whatever comes to your mind as you look at the designs
  2. Which logo and font style would you prefer? Why?
  3. What colorway would you suggest? I'd like it to have high contrast. White parts as a light or bright color, and blacks as something dark.
  4. Any specific ideas or tips?
4 Comments
2023/12/04
13:54 UTC

Back To Top