/r/design_critiques

Photograph via snooOG

Help new and amateur designers improve their designs through reviews and critiques. If you are an experienced designer, please review a submission and share your constructive suggestions!

WELCOME

Are you looking for a critique on your design? Post it here!
YOUR TITLE

To attract the proper critique helpers, explain what design you're requesting critique for. Apparel? User Interface?
TEXT BODY

Directly link your design at the top of your text body.
TIPS

Constructive criticism only. Keep in mind, downvoting is not critiquing.

/r/design_critiques

102,124 Subscribers

0

Portfolio feedback!

Hi, I'm a novice graphic designer trying to properly get into freelancing. I've posted my portfolio on another subreddit around 6 months ago and got a lot of constructive criticism which I tried to implement as much as I can. 6 months later with a little more experience, how is my portfolio, and what else can do to further improve it, any advice is welcome. (There is a lack of content atm, got a few things lined up, just haven't prepared them for the portfolio yet).

https://wawtamem.myportfolio.com/

CV is also on there in the about section if you want to have a look at that too. Cheers!

3 Comments
2024/11/15
16:02 UTC

1

Balancing a Web Design Business, Full-Time Job, and School—Am I Selling Myself Short?

Hi everyone, this is my first post.

Lately, I’ve been grappling with feelings of inadequacy about my work, yet, paradoxically, I also feel like I’m undervaluing myself. In July, I started a web design agency after diving deep into WordPress, graphic design, and several AI tools. I was determined to offer affordable, niche web design and hosting services for small businesses locally and beyond. My focus has been on creating custom WordPress sites, though I can handle e-commerce and Shopify projects too.

In addition to running my business, I work a full-time hospitality job, which gives me the chance to work on my web design during the night shift. I’m also a full-time software engineering student with aspirations to become a full-stack Web3 developer and eventually create DApps. Life right now feels like a balancing act where I can just about cover my necessities, bills, and business expenses (including tools like ChatGPT), but I can’t shake the feeling that I’m underselling my skills and hard work.

So, I’m reaching out for honest advice. My website is kinkoudesign.com, and I have about six portfolio sites listed there. I would deeply appreciate any feedback—am I truly selling myself short? Should I be charging more for my services? Where should I direct my energy design-wise? And, if I’m being honest, is there hope for me to grow?

Thank you in advance to anyone willing to offer insight—it means the world to me~

1 Comment
2024/11/15
12:37 UTC

2

Knight's Graph – A Puzzle Game Inspired by the Classic Knight's Tour Problem

Hi everyone! I’m excited to share a personal project I’ve been working on: Knight's Graph, a puzzle game inspired by the classic Knight’s Tour problem.

The idea for this app came from a memory that’s stuck with me since high school. My dad once showed me how to play Knight Tour on a piece of paper, and I was fascinated by the logic and strategy involved. Years later, I decided to bring this puzzle to life in the form of an iOS app.

What is Knight's Graph?

It’s an intellectual puzzle game based on the famous Knight's Tour challenge, which has roots dating back to the 18th century. The goal is simple: move the chess knight across the board, visiting each square exactly once.

What I’m Looking For:

Design & Usability: Does the UI feel intuitive? Any suggestions for improvement?

General Suggestions: Features you’d like to see? Anything missing?

Links:

App Store: Knight’s Graph

Website: knightsgraph.vercel.app

Thanks in advance for taking a look! Your feedback will be invaluable as I continue improving the app. Feel free to ask questions about the development process too—I’d be happy to share details!

6 Comments
2024/11/15
09:24 UTC

1

Wine Label

Hey!

I’m working on a wine label design (8x12 cm) and would appreciate your feedback. The idea was to keep it simple, without too many elements, just black and white. It’s meant to clearly highlight the poem and the number.

Does it make sense to you, or does it come across as completely grotesque? I genuinely need your opinion because i'm an amateur and have no one else to ask opinion.

Thank you in advance

https://preview.redd.it/pe0mie342z0e1.jpg?width=944&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f550d4fa63f3a1bef881d96643069e46100f9822

https://preview.redd.it/zko2s2j42z0e1.jpg?width=944&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=be0cd1350b76b5db32fca8afaaa9847790d14c0e

10 Comments
2024/11/15
01:53 UTC

0

Anti bullying poster

I made a poster for an anti bullying poster competition. Bullying tends to bring out very emotion laded design but I thought it might be fun making something more "reserved" and contemplative. You like..?

https://preview.redd.it/fp59cfcpkv0e1.png?width=594&format=png&auto=webp&s=aefaa110083a5c927fce649c2d2a76b35d7abe37

4 Comments
2024/11/14
14:15 UTC

1

Graphic Designer Portfolio Critique Help

Hi everyone! I’ve been lurking on this sub for ages, but I figured it’s time to put myself out there. For context, I’ve been employed as a graphic designer at a small-time athletic apparel company for almost 3 years now, but I’m ready to land something even better—preferably better pay, benefits, etc. I’ve been applying to jobs all year, but so far, no luck. My dream job would be to work at a bigger sports apparel company like Under Armour, or a designer for a collegiate athletics program like the University of Maryland.

That being said, here’s my portfolio: https://jailadesperee6a.myportfolio.com

I understand there’s a lot of work to be done on the front-end (I’m not a web designer, so I struggled hard to get the format of the website to where it is now). Feel free to tear it down, so I can build it up better. Any and all feedback is appreciated, as well as any potential connections, contacts, or personal experiences as a designer. Thanks :)

9 Comments
2024/11/13
13:25 UTC

0

This movie/show search is insanely detailed. How can the design/UX be improved?

10 Comments
2024/11/13
08:13 UTC

1

[Feedback] Mini APP feedback, which one will trigger your curiosity?

Hi, we are a team of developers dedicated to creating mini apps and would appreciate your feedback on which app interests you the most.

Here are 3 ideas for our first app.

1. Mood Tracker

Log your daily mood and activities to receive valuable insights you may have overlooked.

https://preview.redd.it/kw4wrpgqdm0e1.png?width=996&format=png&auto=webp&s=fb627180cd2464fc4cb36b437efcc42958772405

2. Digital creature: Tamagochi
Nurture and develop your digital creature with daily surprises and challenges.

https://preview.redd.it/c352368tdm0e1.png?width=1080&format=png&auto=webp&s=e685f6d6557c0878f0edb1de72cfb59a131941d2

3. Customized quotes
Answer three simple questions, and the app will generate a quote tailored to empower you in the moment.

https://preview.redd.it/hpdlk2jydm0e1.png?width=1078&format=png&auto=webp&s=dc9974d71826d4b3702d8678c967dc958b4f97eb

View Poll

0 Comments
2024/11/13
07:19 UTC

2

ux/app feedback request

Hi! I'm in a UX program and am working on my first app. I would like to add this to my portfolio as a case study and would appreciate any and all feedback that a potential employer would look for This is literally my first app, so while I want all the feedback, please be nice about it, haha

Looking for feedback on:

  1. ux flow, useability, the app overall
  2. figma prototyping, anything you want to see that I didn't prototype?
  3. case study (I'm not finished)
  4. ui/design

prototype

case study (ignore "notes slide", I only got to slide 29 so far)

2 Comments
2024/11/12
17:25 UTC

1

Looking to figure out what settings to use for a shot like this. Which is your favorite?

0 Comments
2024/11/12
11:28 UTC

0

Feedback On Graphic Tee Design

I’m working on a new T-shirt design for my streetwear brand and could really use some input. I’ve attached an image of the design in progress – it features a skull wearing a crown, with two rifles crossed behind it. I’m aiming for a bold, rebellious vibe that resonates with street culture, while also keeping it clean and impactful.

Here's the design – let me know what you think!

https://ibb.co/JH6dH5m

I’d appreciate any feedback on:

  • The design concept: Does it come across as strong and eye-catching?
  • Details: Should I add or remove any elements, or modify the style of the crown or skull?
  • Color scheme suggestions: Right now, it’s mostly grayscale with red accents, but I’m open to ideas to make it pop more.
  • Any general improvements: Anything that could make it look more professional or aligned with streetwear aesthetics?

Thanks in advance for any feedback or suggestions! Looking forward to hearing your thoughts.

11 Comments
2024/11/11
12:47 UTC

Back To Top