/r/academiceconomics

Photograph via snooOG

Unofficial discord: https://discord.gg/4qEc2yp

A subreddit to discuss models, techniques, econometric methods, and general academic discourse.

HOMEWORK/TERM PAPER POSTS NOW BELONG IN r/econhw

For more general economic discussion, recent economic news, etc, please visit r/Economics.

If you're looking for advice on how or where to apply for grad school, you're welcome to ask; however, there are many well maintained and helpful sites dedicated to grad school applications.

A few to get you started:

Test Magic Forums

Profile analysis by university, and school rankings by flyout

If you would like "Flair" to represent your field of interest, PM BorderedHessian.

IRC If you are bored enough irc.snoonet.org #academiceconomics

Links for critics of economics: (Credits to SpaceToad)

Micro consistencies and biases in Capuchin monkeys

Microeconomics and experimental evidence

Progress in empirical economics

Progress in financial economics

Economics and rationality

Criticism of Steven Keen's criticism of economics

Experimental evidence consistent with rational choice theory

Is economics a science?

Chris Sims on DSGE

Kocherlakota on the state of macroeconomics

Mankiw's advice for first time lecturers

DATA LINKS

Panel Study of Income Dynamics

Census Data- Factfinder

/r/academiceconomics

22,907 Subscribers

0

Economics and statistics tutor here.

Other services: spss, rstudio

Contact me if you need help. Whats app: +1 843 965 2594

0 Comments
2024/11/10
15:42 UTC

7

How do you get A’s?

I’m finishing up my bachelor in economics and I do not have the best grades. I’d say I have a C average, we don’t do GPA in Sweden so not sure how to calculate it.

Starting master in the fall and since I want to aim for a PhD I know I need better grades. I have had a real though time the last few years with my mental health. Got my adhd diagnosis this year and my grades are better; B and A in all courses I’ve taken and two of the exams I got a 98/100 on both.

So it’s looking better but I could still use some tips and tricks how yall managed perfect grades. Any input is appreciated :)

12 Comments
2024/11/10
13:02 UTC

0

year 11 for econ

I live in india- and I'm not so sure if I'll do my undergrad from India or uk, so I'm sorta confused if i should take isc (y11 and 12 of the current board I'm in rn- cisce) or a levels!?

2 Comments
2024/11/10
11:14 UTC

5

Will an F affect my phd application?

Hi everyone,

I’m a first-year master’s student planning to apply for econ PhD programs next year. My master’s grades are strong (top of my project cohort), and my undergrad GPA was around 3.7/4. However, I had a bit of a mishap during an exchange program in my senior year. I attended a prestigious UK school and, unfortunately, ended up with an “F” in my econometrics final, though I did get an A+ in class participation.

The “F” appears on my exchange transcript, which is a bit worrying since I otherwise have solid grades in math and econometrics. I’m wondering if I still have a shot at being admitted to a top-30 econ PhD program. Also, are there any strategies to help minimize the impact of this on my application?

Any advice would be appreciated!

0 Comments
2024/11/10
10:22 UTC

1

PSE Eiffel Decision 2025

Hey guys!

Recently the Eiffel deadline for PSE APE has passed (6th November). I wanted to know if the dates mentioned for the results (week of 27th November) are accurate and whether we do get a decision by that week.

Also, if anyone here has applied for it and wants to connect, do dm or message here :)

2 Comments
2024/11/10
09:46 UTC

1

Is it possible to get published in economics if I work in a totally different field?

I am a newbie grad student in Canada, studying computer science (namely, computer vision). With that being said, I do have an interest in economics, and I study the subject in my spare time. If I become competent enough in economics to eventually submit a paper to a journal, will the people there care that I'm a computer scientist by trade?

5 Comments
2024/11/10
03:34 UTC

4

Renewable Energy Transition - Paper Recommendations

Someone mentioned on this subreddit that a lot of academic economics right now is about just transition and renewable energy. I am struggling to find papers on renewable energy transition, particularly in a developing country context. If someone has any pointers (either a JEL, JEP, or a paper you think is relevant), could you please name them or send them here?

Not necessary, but I would prefer papers from top journal papers. I am particularly keen to see how top academics are thinking through these challenges.

0 Comments
2024/11/10
02:27 UTC

4

PhD targets

I have an A in the calc sequence, A in linear algebra, A in mathematical economics and statistics, A in real analysis, and 4.0 from a US econ masters program where I took adv micro and macro. I have done 3 years of a pre-doc/RA role with extensive research experience; currently 1 co-authored article (not quite a paper yet) and another working paper being written, hopefully done before application deadlines. I plan to apply to Econ and finance PhDs. 1 VERY strong letter and 2 strong letters but relatively less well known researchers than my first letter. I have a 328 GRE (165 Q, 163V) and am re taking in a few weeks to try and boost the quant.

Given my GRE I think T10 are out the window and probably not worth the fee. But what ranks would be best to target across econ and finance given my current profile, assuming my quant does not improve in a few weeks.

2 Comments
2024/11/10
02:17 UTC

5

predoc worth it?

I'm doing a funded 1.5-year (can be 2 year) MS now to maintain my student status as an international student on F-1 visa after completing my OPT. I recently got an offer from Northwestern for a predoc. Though I'd love to be in a top 5 or top 10 PhD Economics program, I do miss working in the industry. If I drop out of my MS program for the predoc, I'll have to go back home and apply for J-1 visa. I'm not sure if that is too risky or not. I have a few thoughts:

  • I'm in final rounds of internship at some econ consulting and MAANG firms though none is secured. If I get an internship offer, I don't want to miss the opportunity to do it and hopefully get a return offer. HOWEVER, I really hate my program (not Econ but related) and out of 3 classes I'm taking (all PhD level classes), I only do good in 2. I'm scared of not getting a 3.0 to be qualified for an internship. I hate going to school and just want a job.
  • If I accept the predoc offers, I'll have to go back home and apply for J-1. Is it too risky to drop out of a MS program and change your visa from F-1 to J-1? Predoc is a job but the pay is so low (only 50k/year).

What should I do?

16 Comments
2024/11/09
16:12 UTC

2

Duke Pre-Graduate fellowship

Anyone else apply to the pre graduate fellowship at Duke? I’m waiting to hear back and so nervous lol

0 Comments
2024/11/08
18:04 UTC

27

at what point did you realize you wanted to pursue economics at the phd level

just curious as a current math/likely econ undergrad who really enjoys reading papers & also books on econ thought. i plan to try and do research soon in my school's econ dept, but i was wondering at what point you all realized you actually wanted to pursue grad school/an academic career in economics. thanks!

12 Comments
2024/11/08
16:43 UTC

115

Do i need a phd to enter in a phd in economics?

Seriously wtf is becoming this field? ra, predoc, experience, paper during your master, math graduate level…too much competition for not too many jobs…

47 Comments
2024/11/08
13:55 UTC

0

Looking for Advice from Economists

0 Comments
2024/11/08
11:58 UTC

5

Seeking Calculus online course recommendation

I got B in my undergraduate Econometrics and Mathmatical Economics courses and so i am not good at math. Currently i am employed and i want to pursue a phd in future so i was thinking of strenghening my math skills so that i can take the pressure of enrolling in economics phd program. I was thinking of doing some online course during the weekends in tendem with my current job. I know that Intergral and Differencial calculus are used in Economics and i saw some course in EDX but i am unsure of which course to choose. Can you please give me a recommendation? It would be really a great help. Thank you.

[If this is not the right community to post this let me know and i will withdraw the post. Thanks]

10 Comments
2024/11/08
11:57 UTC

15

MS in Applied Economics as a career change path

My undergrad was in 2013 and I meet the requirements to get into most MS in Applied Economics programs. I have done 10 years of political/community/labor organizing work, which I've enjoyed, but feel like it's not setting me up for long-term career success.

I am considering either Boston College's or U of Maryland's program. Would an MS in applied econ from one of those schools help me as a career change plan? Would I be able to make $80-$100k upon graduation with limited experience in the field outside of the MS?

8 Comments
2024/11/07
22:15 UTC

8

Is a co-authored paper required for top econ PhD programs?

I've seen a bunch of recent applicants to top PhD programs have a coauthored working or published paper with economists. How vital is this for getting into the best PhD programs? Does it make a huge difference?

18 Comments
2024/11/07
21:48 UTC

2

Which path is better?

I’m on an Erasmus and have a lot of free time, so I want to dig deeper into economics, especially the math/computational side, but I’m not sure which path to take. I’ve thought of two options:

  1. Go through all of QuantEcon’s Economics with Python courses (intro, intermediate, and advanced) + Microeconomic Theory by Mas-Colell.
  2. Study Dynamic Programming by T. Sargent + Econometrics by Wooldridge + Kaggle courses + Microeconomic Theory by Mas-Colell.

My goal is to finish one of these by June 2025, and ideally be able to do some research/programming on my own by then. Which path should I choose to make the best use of my time and build both solid and applicable knowledge? Or if you have a better idea, please let me know!

15 Comments
2024/11/07
16:13 UTC

42

How will a second Trump term impact graduate education & public-sector economists’ employment in the US?

Given that so many people here want to work with the Govt, the Fed or IGOs and we now have yet at least another few years of a Federal Govt that will almost definitely fill public service positions in these institutions with MAGA loyalists rather than experts

And additionally a govt that doesn’t believe in science, is incredibly hostile to academia & places of research, and doesn’t value scientific rigour at all

20 Comments
2024/11/07
08:37 UTC

6

Economics Podcast Idea

Hello all!

Would you be interested in an economics podcast that gives you access to economics professors at a top state university?

Fill out the survey below and if I start this podcast you will be one of the first people to know!

https://umassamherst.co1.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_ezWL6HVEDkREbky

1 Comment
2024/11/06
20:33 UTC

0

can someone help me understand ASAD

I've got my macro midterm on Thursday and would love some help working through the ASAD model. Message me plzzzzz

1 Comment
2024/11/06
18:02 UTC

0

Fascism Wins

1 Comment
2024/11/06
15:59 UTC

0

I am searching for a minor (1 year) in Economics (Europe)

I'm a philosophy student (25M), and I would like to pursue a career as an art curator. I would like to enter a prestigious master's program in this field, but I am also looking for a plan B in case I am not selected. That’s why I’m seeking a Minor in Economics taught in English in Europe. In the future I would like to manage my own independent gallery and know that I have to implement skills and knowledge in the economic field. The best thing would be a specially designed program that combines business and art, but often such programs are offered by very expensive private universities. Do you generally know of any one-year minor in economics?

3 Comments
2024/11/06
14:28 UTC

1

How to prepare for Intermediate Macroeconomics

Hello Everyone! I’m taking Intermediate Macro in the spring, and while I don’t think my math skills are lacking, I don’t remember a ton from my macroeconomics class. Any advice as to how to prepare for the upcoming semester? Thank you all!

6 Comments
2024/11/06
13:31 UTC

9

How do economists use marginal propensity to consume?

Hello, so I’ve always been interested in concepts similar to lifestyle creep. How do economists use marginal propensity to consume for public policies or just general research?

I know it has something to do with GDP because I took an Econ class a while ago and the professor showed us this huge formula with it.

2 Comments
2024/11/06
03:52 UTC

4

Stanford SIEPR coding/statistics task

Hi everyone! I’ve got an email regarding the coding task at Stanford SIEPR. Any experience regarding what to expect?

0 Comments
2024/11/06
00:59 UTC

7

FED Reserve board interview

Hey yall! I was wondering if any of you guys have gone through the fed reserve board, especially board of goveners, interview process is like! I was offered nearly 4 hours of interview, how long could they possibly ask me about myself? What should I prepare?

2 Comments
2024/11/06
00:13 UTC

1

Chicago Booth PREDOC

Does anyone know how many rounds of interview Booth conducts before extending an offer? Anyone received any offer yet this intake? this waiting period is killing me 😓

0 Comments
2024/11/05
19:24 UTC

7

Opinions on Thomas Sargent's books?

Hey, I recently asked about important CS concepts for economics, and the top answer mentioned matching, dynamic programming, ML theory and networks. I saw that Thomas Sargent has a book on dynamic programming (including matching and search) and another on networks. How good are they? Are they worth it, or are there better books out there? Any recommended book or source for ML theory and algorithms? I’m a third-year undergrad, if that helps.

1 Comment
2024/11/05
12:54 UTC

12

math classes to do well in the first PhD sequence

Other than the standard math classes listed on the AEA math requirements for PhD prep, I’ve heard the math class that’ll help you succeed in first sequence macro phd class are dynamic programming

For micro phd: topology, functional analysis, measure theory

Any important math classes I didn’t mention?

10 Comments
2024/11/05
12:34 UTC

Back To Top