I just started Yellowstone last week! I am someone who relies heavily on captions due to near total deafness in both ears. I am now on season two and am getting frustrated with the captions on this show, or maybe it's just Peacock? I can clearly see them talking in scenes but no captions appear. It seems to have gaps in every episode where whole conversations or words from characters are missed. I even went back on a few sections to confirm with my wife that stuff was being said in parts where no captions were displayed.

Has anyone else noticed this?

I think Kayce finds out that he knows who killed his dad.

I saw this is at a Super Walmart last night in MA. We can't just worry about the vodka scenes anymore 😂 Maybe Gator will be adding this to the Texas chili.

!Everyone. John Dutton is dead. He’s not coming back. No twin brother, no “oh it was all dream”, no faking of his death, no whack ass theory. He’s dead. He was killed off in the first episode (without showing his face) because Kevin Costner left the show. He released personal video explaining this. He’s not coming back!<

!He is dead.!<

The only way they could possibly write KC back in the show is if they had some lame story line where we find out John's brother Chance was his twin and he's actually still alive. How incredibly funny and lame that would be... but with how sloppy the writing is going this season so far.. it wouldn't surprise me.

In the last episode Beth was learning Italian on her way home. Does anyone else think she has a plan for the ranch to bring in Italians, either selling beef to them or bringing them in for some kind of deal at the ranch?

I am watching the new episodes. I still Kevin’s name as actor and producer. Will Taylor and Kevin mend the fences? Will they say John Dutton faked his own death with him knowing they put a hit on him. I don’t see something surprising him

SPOILERS!!!!!!! What do you guys think about Taylor Sheridans way of >! Killing off John !< ? I really didn’t like how he was so tough the entire time and then suddenly he’s taken out so easily. No last words or anything. Ik he couldn’t do much else considering Kevin Costner didn’t return, but man it just feels like shit to me they brushed off his character so bad. Although I do respect how TS overcame this problem, and the writing he did after to make up for it and now the new scenarios and conflict that is happening, but considering the main character just gets erased so quickly is wild to me.

Am I the only one that feels like Sheridan is about to pull a game of thrones with this last season and kill everyone off to give some quick and shitty ending to the series? I guess we’ll see what happens the next episode but from the first few I’m getting a sense that he realized he screwed himself over with the plot from pt 1 and doesn’t really care to give the show a real ending.

Beth to Jamie:

Option 2.

I tell my husband what your father did and he will kill him. And then I'll tell my husband you had his child cut from me. And then you had me sterilized so he can never have a family of his own. And you, no matter where you hide, he will find you and tear you apart with his fucking hands.

Wouldn't you like to know which option I picked?

Jamie is cooked

I’m rewatching season 2 & the scene where Beth is attacked by 2 masked men is shot very similarly to the scene in True Romance between James Gandolfini & Patricia Arquette. Has anyone else talked about this? It seems like it was an intentional tribute. Thoughts?

If not Jamie, somebody involved with the ranch is a dead man (or woman) walking. What do you guys think?

I have just watched the making of 1883 and it’s become evidently clear to me why Kevin Costner couldn’t see eye to eye with Taylor Sheridan. It’s called an EGO and Sheridan has it in bucket loads. Hearing the way he speaks after watching him insert himself in these shows trying to “act” is just too much for me. He just gives you the feeling that he walks around like King Kong when he’s really just Bubbles the chimp. I know he has his supporters and that’s great but the current train wreck offering of season 5B of Yellowstone is enough to tell me the blokes ego got in the way again and he just doesn’t care how it ends.

I recently started the show and I’ve been binging it for a bit (I’m now on s4 e1) and idk if it’s just me but isn’t Beth’s anger for Jamie a little misplaced? Like ik he didn’t tell her about the fact that she would be sterilised but he was like 17 at the time he shouldn’t be responsible for a decision like that if anything it’s on John for not being a good enough father that Beth would want to open up to. And now Beth just treats him like shit for something he did when he was 17 like that’s kinda ridiculous lmaoo and you can tell John didn’t really love Jamie either. I don’t even remember what season and episode it was but Beth and Jamie got into their shit again and Beth starts hitting Jamie multiple times so Jamie hits her once and she goes crying to daddy and John is like “if you hit Beth again I’m gonna put your head through the wall” like huh?? I gotta be dreaming man this shit is so dumb. And as I said I just started s4 but there’s no way Jamie was responsible for that attack on the duttons in the s3 finale right? Beth blamed him out of the blue but I deadass can’t take this bitch seriously so idek fr. Anyway just lmk if I’m trippin cuz I don’t think I am fr

Just wondering what everyone’s thoughts are heading into tomorrow nights episode.

Do you hold Jamie responsible for John‘s death?

So I have been rewatching bits and pieces of the show on Paramount the last couple of days. One thing that has stood out for me is Kayce’s love for and belief in Jamie. I think Jamie genuinely loves and trusts him too.

With that in mind, I am thinking Jamie may call Kayce to meet with him. We see Kayce walking down the street with a weapon and with his hood up while someone waits in a car. I think it will be Jamie, who tells Kayce he is scared after what happened with Sarah. Kayce tells him he should be scared - he knows everything.

What do you think?

Fantasy wish: Keep the land whole with part of it in a conservation trust and the rest for Beth’s idea of raising the cattle to sell for meat.

It probably won’t end like this, but I wish it would.

Mo seems like a really financially smart guy and Lloyd has had minimal life costs besides clothes, cigarettes and booze. Both may have lots of cash socked away - they combine it and buy the ranch. Ridiculous I know but I like it. The Duttons can suck it.

why is everyone hating Jamie? I haven't finished the show but it seems like his family is just actively trying to hurt him or doesn't try to include him at every turn

Who is the target audience for these quips? What is the thematic significance?

John gave Rip a house on the ranch, just as he did Kayce. I doubt any kind of formal paperwork was done on either of them. Now that John is gone, do you suppose Rip wI’ll have to forfeit his house?

I’m trying to find a gold heart necklace very similar to the one Beth wears in Yellowstone but in real gold. Etsy has one I saw but unfortunately it’s not real, either gold plated or filled or whatever. The real one she’s wearing is like $700+. The diamonds don’t need to be real but I like the design of the heart and the letter initial. Any suggestions for similar styles?? Thank you!

And you mean to tell me that Rip can kick his ass on the show. I mean there are a lot of nutty things on this show that make no sense like Beth getting a controlling interest in Shwartz and Meyer from ME but this to me is probably the aspect that defies the most logic

1883 was legit great, 1923 was campy fun. Tulsa King is aight. His new show with Billy Bob Thornton also looks promising. On the other hand, s4 and s5 of Yellowstone are almost unwatchable with Hallmark movie tier writing, not to mention unbearable 6666 product placement. I know people are saying that he is spread too thin, but honestly, the quality drop off of those two season is too big to be only explained by that.

The episode where Beth gets pulled over and apparently the 6666’s is basically worshipped by everyone in Texas according the police officer. That is pure Hollywood haha. I’m from Texas, born and raised here. I partake in outdoor activities, hunting, fishing, hiking, I go to the Houston Rodeo every year, I’ve been invited onto cattle ranches to hunt, help, work, and to just give company. I’m very Texas proud and like to stay in the loop with what my state is up to and the like. And honestly, before Yellowstone, I have NEVER heard of the 6666’s. Idk if Sheridan is trying to market his new ranch or just trying to shed light on how big it may have already been.