Does anyone agree that Josh Holloway would make an outstanding impression of FDR, with his accent and such?

One of my absolute favorite scenes was the hamburger helper scene…

Obviously I had seen a lot of the buzz from this show at launch and along the way, but the wife and I decided to hold off watching until the series finished so we could just binge everything with no waiting in between.

I'd seen people raving about this show on social media, avoided spoilers but couldn't avoid the annoying "I'm like Beth Dutton" type posts. From what I was seeing, I was expecting something like Breaking Bad or Ozark. It was entertaining in parts, but overall very underwhelming. All I kept thinking while watching was "do people really find this horse spinning that entertaining?", "Why do we have to keep seeing this boring Texas ranch?" (Wasn't following production at the time so I didn't know Taylor Sheridan was a self insert), and "WTF is with these corny ass lines like 'we know what it takes to put steaks on a plate".

The only real news I caught along the way was that Kevin Costner didn't sign on for the last season, so I was prepared for a crappy ending. Based on the opinions I saw on social media leading up to now, I was expecting similar from Reddit. I've never been happier to be completely wrong. Seeing every other post be about horse spinning, all the cringy quotes, all of Sheridan criticism has been incredibly refreshing. I really was starting to think I was the crazy one, the only one with these thoughts.

Glad to see it's a common opinion and I'm not alone

After binging 1923 (still haven’t finished it but im enjoying it) and I will admit I’ve only seen clips of 1883 (still want to watch that one) John seems to be the worst out of the Duttons we’ve come across. From the clips I’ve seen of 1883 Tim McGraw character seems like a honorable man, Jacob from 1923 was rough but he also seems to care about the other ranchers and takes his role as livestock commissioner seriously not just as a form of power to mention Jacob took in his nephews and raised them and ACTUALLY seems to care about them and love them, sure John took in Jamie but that seems more like Evelyn twisted his arm over it and John never seemed to love Jamie (hell he fucked up his other kids as well). But I will admit we don’t know how bad John’s father was (and he started the Prison/branding thing) but out of the ones we did see John Dutton the 3rd seems to be the worst out of the Dutton patriarchs.

No specific spoilers please BUT just started watching Yellowstone because it started showing on Netflix, I'm 3 episodes in and Kaycee has managed to kill 3 people already and you can just tell this is going to be a thing later. Like honestly how does one manage this? I know he says he is good at it but I never thought there would be so many opportunities or situations. No one else finds themselves in them in these. Does his unfortunate knack for getting himself and his family into hot water get any better because I'm starting to find him quite annoying.

Hey guys we just started Yellowstone and pretty into it. But I have a question - we are halfway through Season 2 and I did read Tate will be kidnapped at the tail end and rescued but with physical and emotional scars. Now since becoming the mama of a youngin I find it really really hard watching scenes of violence with children and I’m wondering if I should just skip a few episodes? So my question is does it get super heavy and how many episodes does that arc go for? Thanks so much 🙏🏻

Who was the short-lived lawyer for rainwater in season 3 episode 4? The male actor looks super familiar and I can't find him anywhere online

Is this show like Succession but with cowboys instead of meeting rooms? (I loved succession). On ep 3 so far.

i remember him being on parole and not being able to leave the state was a huge issue. checking in every week was the reason he stayed in montana. at that point did he just not care?

Watching old CSIs and this guy showed up. Ha

Maybe it is because I'm from Texas, but ever since we were introduced to the character Teeter I understood every word she was saying no problem. Anyone else the same way? lol

So Beth brought land surrounding Yellowstone and she listed Yellowstone (or herself not sure) as a co owner of the land? Then when she gets fired from Schwartz and hired by Market Equities, she gets the controlling stake in Schwartz and Meyer. Then she gives the controlling stake to a competitor. So what happened to the land around Yellowstone that she originally brought in earlier seasons, who ends up owning that?

Hello. I just watched the first episode in a very noisy area and missed alot. Can anyone explain ONLY the first episode to me?

Hello. I just watched the first episode and I've been confused cuz kayce's wife said Lee was her brother. But isn't Lee kayce's brother and son of jhon. Then how can Lee be brother to Kayce's wife. I might have misheard since I had bad subtitles and was in a noisy place when watching.

My wife and I made this list prior to watching the finale as a drinking game, needless to say we were completely sloshed by the end. 🥃 what else should we have included?

Does he now have over 300M? Or did the money from selling everything on the ranch(not the ranch itself, that was sold to Rainwater for over 1 M).

They were cowboys. They had beans. Potatoes too. They had a professional cook who made things from scratch. Summer was there for a long time and she was boss's girlfriend. I'm sure the cook could have prepared batches of beans, potatoes, and other vegetables without animal products in them.

Just saying...

I’m desperately trying to find where I can watch the second part of season 5 without signing up for services like fubo. If anyone has streamed the second half of the season and could please let me know, I’d be grateful :)

Those guys should've had more screen time

Can any superfan help me identify the brand of the Vest?

He wore the jacket a lot during the first season, and I’ve been trying to find it ever since – but without success.

https://preview.redd.it/pfvnktnxiqfe1.jpg?width=3360&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=13a7feb79ceb5654a227dc3c5bfc5bbe24d20d74

https://preview.redd.it/gboxben4jqfe1.jpg?width=600&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7fa8f4b7245680f80a71900c5e59f75822e75402

Just started Yellowstone for the first time in the US on peacock, and watching with a friend in Canada on paramount who has watched the entire series dozens of times. We discovered by watching on a video call that the US version has extra scenes that her Canadian version does not, and she had no idea existed.

In season 1 episode 2, kill the messenger, the entire church scene with John is missing for her as is the short scene of Kacey driving down the highway after the tribal get together and watching the wolf get plastered by the semi.

Anyone ever noticed this before? Just wondering why entire scenes are missing based on your region/streaming service, seems odd.

Wife and I just finished season 2 of the show and we're just kinda baffled by how many scenes feel like complete filler and things that just don't pay off.

What was with the dinosaur bones?

Why was Tate at a second house and not at the first when he got kidnapped?

What was the point of the Chinese couple falling off the cliff?

Why did they send a park ranger out to inspect the bear, only to have her injured?

What was the point of Cowboy?

I don't know, it just feels like they keep writing these scenes where they feel really important and it's only 5 episodes later that you realize that it didn't matter at all.

Is there a lot of payoff in later seasons?

In the season where Jamie finds his birth father, he purchases a "ranch" style property. What happened to it? In the 5th season we see Jamie in a suburban neighborhood, and no mention of his "ranch"!

Did the show cover Jamie getting rid of that property? Is this another forgotten storyline/plot hole to add to the growing list?