/r/whowouldwin

Photograph via snooOG

If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. You are indeed where you belong. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass!

Click here to choose a flair!

Visit /r/RespectThreads to look up character feats and abilities!

Find a flair you like, click it, and send the message it brings you to exactly as-is. Within a minute, /u/WWWtron will have assigned you your shiny new flair.



All posts must be flaired. Your post will get automatically removed if it is not flaired. For a guide on flairing and how to filter out flairs you don't like, click here.

If you do not properly flair your post, or reply incorrectly to a post because you didn't know the difference between 'Battle' and 'Scan-Battle', you agree to forfeit to us your soul in perpetuity or another soul of equal or greater value.



Unsure of a good way to make your fight more interesting than just "X Character vs. Y Character"? Check out our Official Submission Template for a few suggestions on how you can structure your battle with additional conditions and formatting to make it more interesting.



Rules - Wiki

  1. Be nice. Do not insult others, use derogatory terms, or resort to ad hominem arguments.
  2. Do not downvote. As this is a debate forum, we ask that you join the conversation, and not attempt to bury a point you don't like. If a post breaks the rules, please report it.
  3. Repost with moderation. We will remove posts that are duplicated in quick succession. We do not allow very similar posts on the same day, or an individual posting very similar posts every couple of days repeatedly. However, revisiting topics every once in a while is allowed.
  4. Do not make new posts more than 5 times a day.
  5. When making a claim about a character, be able to provide the source of that claim. A source can include the work of media that claim comes from, and the chapter, page, scene, ETC where it occurred. Refusal to provide details is considered posting in bad faith and can result in a warning or temporary ban.
  6. Do not post meta-topics without mod approval, except on "Meta Monday" when we open posts to general meta conversation. Meta-topics include conversation topics, tournaments, events, or other non-conventional posts. This rule will only be enforced Tuesday through Sunday.
  7. Do not use disruptive or gimmick accounts. Accounts posting with a gimmick or agenda in mind will be banned.
  8. Posts may not be overly broad. A post must identify at least one specific combatant and must include all combatants in the title. A post may not include "...in all of fiction" or "...in all of history."
  9. Posts must include sufficient details about the characters, the situation and the win conditions. Posts with low effort descriptions will be removed.
  10. Do not use disallowed combatants and modifiers. Topics not allowed in posts include "you vs...", "your favorite character vs...", "a specific subreddit or online community vs..." or "character with a [color] lantern ring vs..."
  11. Posts and comments may not be deliberately distasteful, edgy, intended to bait drama, directly insulting, or clearly written to evoke shock value.
  12. Posts and comments may not push a specific political agenda. Posts involving any real-life political figure will be removed.
  13. Posts and comments may not simply be jokes, memes, circlejerk or copy-pasta topics. Posts that are funny are allowed, so long as they are also a topic that can effectively be discussed.
  14. Posts and comments that target a group of people (including but not limited to race, sex, gender identity, religion, political affiliation) are considered abuse and will be removed and the poster may be banned.
  15. Comments must add to the conversation. Short comments like "Goku stomps," or a single image as a non-responsive reply will be removed.

Additional Guidelines:

  1. Include detail when posting. Try outlining arenas, special conditions, multiple rounds and specifying the universe/version of characters if you're looking for a good discussion. Again, please see the suggested template above for more details.

  2. Admit when you don't know. No one expects you to be a genius when it comes to every aspect of every character. Always admit it up front if you're unfamiliar with a character.

The penalty for breaking the rules of this sub, contributing to spam, trolling, or purposefully making things more difficult for the mods may include being banned. We issue warnings if we believe the user means well but we are not obligated to do so. You can be banned for a first offense. Report rule breaking and leave rule enforcement to the mods

Remember, the mods are humans, and we realize you're human, too. Be nice and we'll respond in kind. Apologies go a long way if you mess up.



Spoiler Tag

Spoilers - : [Text Text Text](#spoil "Hidden text")

  • How it shows up: Text Text Text - Mouse over the black bar to see the spoiler text.

Mobile-Friendly Spoilers - How to input: [Spoil](/s "text")

  • How it shows up: Spoil < Mouse over to see spoiler text.


W

Check out the WhoWouldWin Wiki!

L

/r/whowouldwin

542,909 Subscribers

1

The Sanderson Sisters (Hocus Pocus) vs T-800 Terminator (Judgement Day)

Forgive my fever dream matchup. Have at it

1 Comment
2024/11/03
16:17 UTC

1

1 Grizzly Bear vs 200 Raccoons

The fight takes place at the edge of a forest in an open field

0 Comments
2024/11/03
16:12 UTC

1

Weakest fantasy nation that could defeat the Monarchs (Cradle)

The Monarchs are transported to the world of the fantasy nation

Members for the Monarchs: Seshethkunaaz the Dragon King, Akura Malice, Northstrider, Emriss Silentborn, Reigan Shen, The Eightman Empire and Queen Sha Miara, and Ninecloud Court.

Everybody involved will act in character, with the one exception being that the people in charge of said fantasy nation will want to kill the Monarchs

Other than that, they can do so by any means they could/would

Assume any magic systems will be equalized

The fantasy side wins if they either destroy the Monarchs outright

The Monarchs wins if they either destroy the fantasy side outright or successfully defend against the fantasy side's efforts for 10 years

0 Comments
2024/11/03
16:11 UTC

1

Juggernaut (Marvel) vs Regulus (Re:Zero)

Morals off for both. Both start 20 meters apart. Both have all of their gear. Fight is won through the last man standing by either the death, incapacitation or BFR of all other opponents.

1 Comment
2024/11/03
16:11 UTC

1

Krang and Shredder (Rise of the TMNT) vs Invincible (Invincible)

Morals off for both. Both start 20 meters apart. Both have all of their gear. Fight is won through the last man standing by either the death, incapacitation or BFR of all other opponents.

1 Comment
2024/11/03
16:10 UTC

1

Gregor Clegane (GOT) vs Logan 9 Finger (First Law)

This is Zombie Gregor. Both start 20 meters apart. Both have all of their gear. Fight is won through the last man standing by either the death, incapacitation or BFR of all other opponents.

1 Comment
2024/11/03
16:10 UTC

1

A team of fantasy characters invade the Great Tomb of Nazarick

An alliance of characters with fantasy characters take on the Great Tomb
They win if they defeat the Guardians and Ainz and/or conquer the tomb as their own
Everyone is in character, but team is willing to not kill each other
The team shows up 100 feet from the Tomb's entrance, other than that Ainz is given no warning about this attack
Round 1: Speed equal
Round 2: Speed unequal
The team: Rand Al'Thor (Wheel of Time), Anomander Rake (Malazan), Eragon (Inheritance Cycle), Percy Jackson (Percy Jackson and the Olympians), Lord Ruler (Mistborn), and Catherine (Practical Guide to Evil). All of them are at their peak with all of their gear except Rand and Lord Ruler. Rand is before the Final Battle and Lord Ruler is his normal self

1 Comment
2024/11/03
16:10 UTC

1

Albert wesker (Resident evil 5) vs Samantha maxis (cod Cold War)

Both of them at their full power, who would win?

2 Comments
2024/11/03
16:02 UTC

1

How many Necrons to totally exterminate the entire population of the United States

I’m sure my opinion on this one will probably be more in line with you guys for once

Rules notes and win condition

  • All of the Necrons initially emerge in New York city(it’s the most populated by both sheer numbers and even density so showing up in it gives them a head start)

  • The US can and will use all means necessary to stave off extinction as long as possible including nukes(again this is another survival challenge like with guard

  • When I say only necron warriors I mean only necron warriors, (Assume it’s like the empire of the severed where they’re programming and memories got screwed and they all fall under the command of tomb world master programs rather than actually having a character lead them)

  • The Necrons have infinite time, if the last US citizen dies of old age while in hiding after evading the Necrons for years on end then that’s a wrap

  • I already stated how things are gonna go in the title no need for a win condition just how many of the disgusting non-organic freaks does it take?

0 Comments
2024/11/03
15:55 UTC

1

Witcher vs Vampire Lord (Elder Scrolls)

Round 1 : Geralt at his max vs Vampire Lord with all perks unlocked and powers vampires have shown in ESO in their base.

Round 2 : Higher Vampire vs Vampire Lord

2 Comments
2024/11/03
15:46 UTC

3

The console wars, but video games come to life.

Rules are over complicated

No powers or weapons that can wipe out Towns instantly.

All Vehicles must be created (including ones that could kill everyone given enough time and resources)

The companies are involved in this war.

Consoles, hand held devices and other accessories have become weapons.

Let the 7th corporate wars BEGIN!

0 Comments
2024/11/03
15:43 UTC

0

Could the Theropods of the Mesozoic Era survive the Bible?

Context: I am a man of faith who believes in intelligent design but I read certain parts of the Book of Genesis figuratively, as opposed to literally like the Young Earth Creationists.

According to Young Earth Creationist readings of the Book of Genesis, dinosaurs and modern mammals, as well as human beings, lived alongside each other (They reject the idea that Earth is billions of years old and take the days of creation in Genesis to be literal 24-hour days, and they take any metaphorical interpretation to be an attack on the authority of God as revealed in the Bible).

Let us entertain this mindset for the sake of this post and see what would happen if every single extinct theropod dinosaur from the Mesozoic Era lived alongside humans in Bible times. So, imagine Spinosaurus in Egypt during the Ten Plagues of Exodus, or a Velociraptor making a nest in a cave near Sodom and Gomorrah, a Tyrannosaurus having a run-in with Jesus Christ Himself, Joseph from the concluding books of Genesis running into a Compsognathus, Noah's sons, Shem, Ham, and Japeth, interacting with a Dilophosaurus, the Apostle Paul racing with a Deinonychus, etc.

For this hypothetical, we'll start after Noah and the Great Global Flood (Genesis 7:19-23) and we'll end the hypothetical with the Roman takeover of Jerusalem in 70 AD. How long would the carnivorous theropods last if they lived alongside the characters of the Holy Bible as the literal readers of Genesis would have us believing?

1 Comment
2024/11/03
15:40 UTC

3

How would the Wizarding World deal with a Zombie Apocalypse?

The Harry Potter world is hit with a zombie apocalypse 2 years before the Deathly Hallows. How does the wizarding world handle it? Will they be forced to break the Statute of secrecy in this kind of global disaster? For some reason magic can't cure the zombies.

Round 1: Walking Dead

Round 2: Dawn of the Dead (Remake)

Round 3: Last of Us

Bonus: Can Harry, Hermione, and Ron survive them?

8 Comments
2024/11/03
15:22 UTC

2

A walled of Berlin vs Attack on Titan

A walled off Berlin gets teleported to AoT E1, all their infrastructure (think pipes, electricity) continues to work and the geography around Berlin molds so it can fit the newly appeared city (for example, a river spawns so the Oder can continue flowing through the middle of Berlin.

How does the series change? Can East-Berlin survive against the titan threat?

R1: Berlin is alone and gets no outside help.

R2: Raisin bombers are able to provide east Berlin with additional weaponry / resources but can't attack themselves.

0 Comments
2024/11/03
15:09 UTC

3

The Culture vs Coalition of Authoritarian states

The Culture (just after the Idiran-Culture War) is set to face off against a large coalition of authoritarian sci-fi regimes. Can they overcome the coalition? Or will the commies(/j) meet their demise?

The Coalition (Peak Strength):

  • The Imperium of Man

  • The Necrons

  • The Galactic Empire (SW)

  • The Terran Dominion (SC)

  • The Terran Empire (ST)

  • The Cardassians

  • The Dominion (ST)

  • Principality of Zeon

  • The Empire (Dune)

  • The Empire under Leto II (Dune)

  • Goa’uld Empire

  • Helghan Empire

  • The Galactic Empire (Foundation)

  • The Ori

1 Comment
2024/11/03
15:08 UTC

2

Strongest superpower you can give to someone in real life but would still lose to a swat team?

Imagine this scenario, a random person suddenly wakes up to find themself with a superpower. After finding this out, this person decides to become a supervillain and goes out to commit a big crime(for example: robbing a bank). A swat team comes in, their only goal is to stop them dead or alive. The real life supervillain has whatever superpower of your choosing, can the swat team stop them?

1 Comment
2024/11/03
15:07 UTC

1

Cosmere battle

A mistborn, a windrunner, and a feruchemist battle in an all out battle royale. All of them are of similar skill levels and experience.

The mistborn starts with two full vials, but only enough Atium for maybe 1 second of use.

The Feruchemist has all his metalminds decently full. He can choose to bring a weapon with him but only 1.

The windrunner has sworn enough ideals to have both blade and plate.

R1: location is a street in Luthadel R2: out in the open on the Shattered Plains. R3: Interior of a building

0 Comments
2024/11/03
15:00 UTC

2

In honor of Godzilla day: Darth Vader on the Executor vs Space Godzilla

Who would Win?

4 Comments
2024/11/03
14:45 UTC

1

Gabriel (Malignant) vs Karl Ruprecht Kroenen (Hellboy)

For whatever reason, Gabriel and Kroenen have been thrown into a fighting pit and must fight.

Gabriel has his knife fashioned from the trophy, and Kroenen has his two bladed tonfas.

Gabriel is in complete control of Madison’s body.

Who wins and who dies?

1 Comment
2024/11/03
14:43 UTC

1

Naruto-DemonSlayer crossover battle

Could a team consisting of Itachi, Obito and Madara (alive, healthy & in prime) take out the entirety of the Demon Slayer universe?

3 Comments
2024/11/03
14:40 UTC

1

Who would win GFLs Griffin & Kryuger or Napoleon's Grand Armee pre 1812

For context Griffin and Kryuger is.a PMC fighting he enemies KCCO and Sangavis ferri right after ww3 ended Sangavis ferri is a rouge AI that wants to destroy humanity KCCO I don't remember much the grand armee at its height is 600'000 including bavariand badens Westphalians prussians Spaniards poles etc including artillery imperial guard navy etc So round 1 13 Vendarmiarie 2 the Bastille 3 streets of Paris the grand armee side gets 10'000 men including 3 arty 100 old guardsmen 1000 Westphalians poles bavarians and Spaniards the rest regular french line infantry while G&K uhh hm K98K Negev AK,15 and AK,12 and screw it give them defy team and Anti Rain team

0 Comments
2024/11/03
14:37 UTC

1

Black Templars(Warhammer 40k) vs US military

First of all I’d like to say I disagree with what most people were saying in the last part of this….series? But the whole point of making the post was to ask what other people thought so I’m not gonna throw a fit by I am gonna explain my reasoning, feel free to skip if your not interested.(My personal estimate is 50 mechanized guard regiments, and 5 air all high balled to the max even then I don’t see the guard actually winning air superiority ever just not letting the US have air supremacy long enough for the ground units to knock out all its airfields since 40k aircraft don’t typically have stealth capabilities like modern fighter jets do vastly evening the playing field even if imperial radars can no doubt detect stealth planes at a far longer distance than modern radars which is the only reason the air regiments could actually fight fifth generation US planes at all, link here to that post to formulate your own opinion on the matter: https://www.reddit.com/r/whowouldwin/comments/1gieosp/how_many_mechanized_imperial_guard/)

This episode of “Warhammer vs the USA”’s rules notes and win conditions are:

  • Tactical ineptitude: As cool as the black Templars are their melee focused combat doctrine is really only effective because 1 their super soldiers who are equivalent to 100(though specifically for the level tactical ineptitude we’re discussing here it’s probably more like 60-80)guardsmen in terms of power when high balled to the max(Which we will be doing here because 10-40 doesn’t really make sense even in universe for 40k and if that’s all their worth then they ain’t doing jack to the US) and 2. 40k is a fictional universe that operates solely on the rule of cool(and that’s why we love it) but in this instance they’re invading a real world location and their lack of practical tactics is huge mark against them no matter how much they scream “The emperor protects” while only wielding a chainsword and charging 8 tanks all firing at them. (Honestly despite the ultramarines having 6 times less forces I think they’d actually secure more success than the black Templars against the US and that’s precisely why they weren’t chosen for this cause asking if the most strategically, tactically and logistically sound space marine chapter wins against the USA in this same scenario, is like asking if a grenade can vaporize the leaf right next to it)

  • That being said 6,000 soldiers and a couple hundred vehicles no matter how powerful, is 6000 soldiers and a couple hundred vehicles having all the power condensed into a small unit has both benefits and drawbacks, there is strength in numbers after all

  • No orbital bombardment for the black Templars(given the aforementioned tactical ineptitude they probably wouldn’t even think to do such a thing until all their forces are dead anyway) and no nukes for the United States(Unlike the last 2 times since it’s an instant win button against only a little over 6,000 targets)

  • The US military can’t recruit any new troops or manufacture any new weapons or vehicles, what they got is what they got for the entire fight(though they can bring out mothballed old equipment if need be) and that’s solely based on the black Templars win condition

  • In a similar vain the Black Templars aren’t getting any reinforcements their entire chapter is already here and none of the rest of imperium is coming to help they probably have enough supplies on their ships person anyway so for once someone is actually on par with the US in terms of logistics

  • The US gets about one week to prepare for the invasion(which is absolutely enough time to mobilize all active duty forces since the US military is a logistics organization that only dabbles in warfare) but the black Templars get to drop anywhere and of course can use air and space craft to rapidly redeploy to the next war zone

  • Win condition: The black Templars must wipe out atleast 95% of US military personnel(including reserves and national guard), vehicles and bases(Yes 95% of each) if they don’t then it’s a win for the US(Heck killing a single full company of 100 spaces marines is a win in its own right for anyone I’m pretty sure the US would be able to pull something like that off with its classic infinite missile, drone and artillery spam) also unlike the Guard the Templars don’t need to occupy anything since 6,000 marines +A couple hundred vehicles, no matter how powerful couldn’t possibly hold 3.8 million square miles of land alone (even in lore the space marines purpose is to wipe out armies so the guard can occupy worlds with little resistance if I remember correctly)

  • Also depending on who you think wins, how much damage do you think the losing side does to them, how many Templars does the US take down with it, who percentage of US military assets do the Templars destroy if they don’t meet the win condition?

26 Comments
2024/11/03
14:36 UTC

2

How long could the Rabbids survive in Warhammer 40k

I know it might sound silly but the Rabbids got some good feats.

Rules: Rabbids get everything across every game, TV series, Movie, etc. and the Rabbids start on 5 random planets that aren’t controlled by any faction.

1 Comment
2024/11/03
14:29 UTC

1

Venom From Insomniac’s Spider-Man 2 Is Suddenly Teleported To The World Of Middle Earth (Right Around The Time Of The Death Of Smaug), Could He Achieve His Goal Of Taking Control Of The World? If Not, How Long Would He Survive?

Take Note, This Version Of Venom Is Fire-Proof And Can Sprout Giant Wings. (The Host Is Harry Osborn And He Has Already Come Into Contact With The Meteorite.).

1 Comment
2024/11/03
14:20 UTC

4

Tony Soprano (The Sopranos) vs. Uncle Phil (The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air)

One of the NJ mob's legal troubles reaches the office of federal judge Philip Banks. Tony sends Chrissy and Paulie to intimidate him, but they get lost in Pine Barrens again, so Tony has to do it personally.

Both in-character. Both unarmed. Victory by knock out.

5 Comments
2024/11/03
14:09 UTC

3

Kakine Teitoku (Toaru) VS Goku (Dragon Ball) - Who Would Win?

Both will fight in their strongest form.

8 Comments
2024/11/03
13:44 UTC

2

Andy (undead unluck) vs perfect kars (jojo's bizarre adventure)

Both at the current peak of their power in either the manga or anime, excluding novel kars

4 Comments
2024/11/03
13:37 UTC

6

The Suicide Squad (Suicide Squad Isekai), after their success, are sent into other settings to accrue resources for Amanda Waller. How do they fair?

Members are as they appear within the anime. They start the fight in their normal (but armed) states, but if it's too out of their league, they are allowed to utilize their magic gear powerups. They also don't have strict time limits this time, so they can stay for as long as necessary to plan until they're ready to strike.

MEMBERS:

  • Harley Quinn w/Arthur (her dragon).
  • Peacemaker.
  • Deadshot.
  • King Shark.
  • Clayface.
  • Rick Flag.
  • Enchantress.

ROUNDS:

  1. Jujutsu Kaisen. Goals:
    1. Obtaining cursed tools.
    2. Learning how Cursed Techniques function.
    3. Establishing a relationship with the Jujutsu Clans.
  2. Demon Slayer. Goals:
    1. Obtaining Demon DNA samples.
    2. Seeking to understand Breathing Techniques.
    3. Establishing a relationship with the Demon Slayer corps.
  3. MCU - Pre Infinity War. Goals:
    1. Obtain Hydra tech.
    2. Establish a relationship with Stark Industries to obtain Stark Tech.
    3. Discover and obtain the various types of Super-Soldier serums, and schematics for other means of creating super soldiers. Whether they use them or not is optional.
2 Comments
2024/11/03
13:17 UTC

2

If there are Batman-like teams and individuals in various universes, can they defeat the robot programmed to terminate every Batman?

Characters

Batman (Failsafe)

VS

Nemesis (Mark Millar's Nemesis)

Ghost-Maker

Owlman

Batman Who Laughs (Dark Multiverse)

Flashpoint Batman (Thomas Wayne)

Murder Machine (Dark Multiverse)

Situation

Failsafe gets a taste of his own medicine and gets warped through different universes. His programming identifies multiple targets who fit the nature of "Batman." Each of these "Batman clones" has no idea what this machine is, but are forced to defend themselves.

Win Conditions

Would any of these Batman-esque villains be able to disable or destroy Failsafe?

Can Failsafe defeat each of them?

1 Comment
2024/11/03
13:15 UTC

1

Baki (Baki The Grappler) Vs Ranma Saotome (Ranma 1/2)

Scenario 1: Let's assume this is current Baki vs Final Chapter Ranma and they know nothing about each other

Scenario 1: Let's assume this is current Baki vs Final Chapter Ranma and they do have intel about the other.

1 Comment
2024/11/03
13:12 UTC

Back To Top