/r/Simracingstewards
A subreddit for answering the age old question: "Who's at fault?!"
Rules:
- Racing Sporting Code Questions & Incidents Only - This subreddit is specifically for answering questions of fault for racing incidents or for questions related to racing rules / sporting code. All other content should be posted elsewhere.
- Ask a Legitimate Question - This is not the subreddit to show off accidents where fault is obvious or rant about another driver. Posts must pose a legitimate question for the stewards.
- Show Adequate Angles & Views - Posts must include reasonable camera views that allow stewards to form an opinions about the incident or racing question. Posts with inadequate camera views may be removed.
- Sim Racing Games Only - Only clips of sim-racing titles should be included, not arcade racers or real-life racing clips.
- Show Respect and Keep it Civil - Show kindness to all users on the subreddit and racers alike. Use civility in all interactions on the subreddit. Because discussions and disagreements can quickly turn ugly, incivility will not be tolerated. This includes name calling, hostility, flaming, baiting, etc..
- Be Open to Criticism and Differing Opinions - Submitters must approach responses with an open mind and be accepting of constructive criticism. Don’t approach this subreddit simply looking for validation, but rather to gain an understanding of race conduct and craft. Discussion is fine, obstinance isn’t.
/r/Simracingstewards
92,145 Subscribers
My Friend (Aston) an i raced and he says its my fault... Is it?
20:12 UTC
Could i have done anything better? Pretty sure it was my fault but i just want a second opinion, im in the 31 car
19:19 UTC
Who was in the wrong? (Pls help)
My friend and I have been arguing for an hr abt whose fault is the crash at Interlagos T1. I’ve attached a video
16:54 UTC
LMP3 at VIR
First lap, I am the red and yellow car. I feel I was entitled to space as my front wheel was along side his rear wheel.
Who is at fault?
16:51 UTC
Is this reportable? I didnt think so but i was just making sure bc it was a pretty d!ck move. we ended up catching him anyways but I still want to know if this is illegal or just silly.
15:58 UTC
Who's at fault? I'm the white Silvia, I feel like we were alongside by the turn but I'm really not sure and I kinda feel bad for the lambo
15:26 UTC
What are your thoughts? (I’m the McLaren)
I feel like I was pitted but looking at it again I have no clue who’s a fault.
14:23 UTC
Green/yellow (manthey) Porsche blamed me for crashing im blue (calsonic) gtr. Am i at fault here?
Im in the clasonic gtr (blue) i felt like inwas squeezed and had no where to go. Manthey porsche (yellow/green) blames me for the crash. Am i at fault here? And feedback is appreciated thanks!
12:05 UTC
I’m the red bull did I deserve space
10:35 UTC
Partly think this is my fault but also look how much room he has on the inside, ended up lapping him and was around 3 seconds a lap faster regardless but dropped me from P5 to P7
11:00 UTC
Sardegna T1 - Should I gave him room or was this a fair squeeze?
I feel I was okay to squeeze him but should I have given him more room with regards to him having the lead prior to the corner?
09:12 UTC
Battling for 2nd on the last lap. I’m in pink. Anything I could have done differently or just racing?
Battling for
07:33 UTC
I (Teal) gave him plenty of space and he still understeers into me (at least from my view)
05:08 UTC
Apparently I’m at fault for running a different line than last lap, white flag for the win, btw (I’m black car)
04:28 UTC
This was in practice so it doesn't really matter, but who's at fault here? I'm in the goodsmile car
03:34 UTC
I was the one behind all of this mess. Do you think this guy should get a penalty or a nuke sent to his house?
02:46 UTC
Can i report someone for this? or this just racing?
02:34 UTC
I am in the white and blue and he is in the blue, tried to say he left me room and I was in the wrong, could I have done anything differently.
02:32 UTC
What should I have done differently?
I was getting some practice laps in the formula F3 and I got into the situation. What should I have done differently or is it even my fault?
02:28 UTC
Am I in the wrong for either one of these crashes i think im not but idk(Im the 95 orange mclaren)
23:54 UTC
Is this moving under braking?
22:36 UTC
should i have reacted differently
I don’t know if i should have left more room or not. is anyone at fault or is it a racing incident.
21:14 UTC
I'm the yellow and red car. At first, I thought it was entirely the Marlboro car's fault, but after watching the replay, I started to wonder if maybe I could have been at fault as well. Was my overtake too aggressive/reckless? (Note in comments)
19:51 UTC
Who‘s at fault
I don‘t think it was malicious from either side but still.
19:23 UTC
Who is at fault here/how would you have handled the situation differently? I am the McLaren in front. Last lap for context
19:02 UTC
18:15 UTC
This is not my fault, am i right?
(i am the red and blue car) just did a ff1600 race in iRacing and had a dude say i didnt give him enough space (even though that was my corner). He then proceeded to slam into me when the race was over. So ive got 2 questions, 1) is it really my fault? and 2) Is the incident at the end protestable?
17:42 UTC
I (NSX) was blamed for this incident but I personally disagree
I knew I had a bad line off of the corner which is why I didn’t attempt a block or anything and I felt like I gave enough space on the inside but they claim it’s my fault
13:47 UTC
Who is at fault ?
13:00 UTC
hard but fair? or penalty worthy
11:37 UTC
Back To Top