On their way to save Uncle, Charles and John talk about the Skinners and how they are just angry man and then Charles says “just like we were” I just find it really weird because the Van Der Linde gang, while not saints, were much more moral than any other gang we see and especially the skinners who seem to scalp and roast people just for shits and giggles. Felt really jarring hearing them talk that way about themselves.

Just look how insanely detailed this game is

Wrong way to Tahiti my dude

Main offices in Armadillo.

so I haven't played RDR2 in about a month or so and i pulled out my knife to skin an animal and noticed it looked strange. I'm not sure if it's because of a mod I have or some side mission I've completed but I am completely baffled. Help would be appreciated

or is this just another npc with the same name?

https://preview.redd.it/1govji62rmyd1.png?width=2559&format=png&auto=webp&s=ee29c63b9941dc4d77f32bc29a21f941a16914eb

I'd rather have an additional chore to empty the troughs than have my animals drinking this...

Is it a mod? if it is ima be pissed. hes fine asfuck i gotta see

I’m doing the mission to steal the tribes horses back from the army, and for some reason I can’t paddle this dang canoe so I can get to them. I’m playing steamdeck and I’m guessing there’s a trick I forgot? Thanks.

Has this happened to anyone else? It didn't fall off my horse. I didn't camp out or sleep. Killed it, skinned it, stowed it, rode straight to camp and it had changed to poor. What gives?

Fair warning of a major spoiler for the story mode. . . . . . . . . . . . . I just completed my very first playthrough and I’m very curious as to what other people’s opinions are as to why >Dutch shoots micah< at the end? Why he doesn’t >shoot John, or both of them? He didn’t seem to take the “correct” side when Arthur dies, so what changes now?< It’s been years since I played rdr1, so I can’t remember if this is addressed in the first game.

Every mission leaves 40 or so bodies dead.

I was trying to buy a new horse but it said it was to expensive, even though I have enough

I don't think this one has been uploaded yet...

Is there away to get rid of all the stars with out going through every thing it doesn't realy bother me bit I'm sick of seeing them

I’m In chapter 5 I believe. I finished the mission where I crashed the air ballon. Do I need to catch the famous animals yet or can I do that with John? Thank you.

Im trying to get a trapper hat accesory that req some feathers from the pheasent sparrow and robin. all 3 are pretty small birds and i can't skin them so how can i get the feathers?

https://vm.tiktok.com/ZMhX1rxuN/

So I'm going through the game again for the second time and I just noticed that chapter 4 is named saint Denis, which I find strange because

Chapter 1 : colter

Chapter 2 : horseshoe overlook

Chapter 3 : I don't remember the name

Chapter 4 : saint Denis

Why is chapter 4 called saint Denis instead of shady bell it doesn't really fit in