/r/NationalDivorce

Photograph via snooOG

A place for discussion of national divorce, the idea that the USA should peacefully split up into multiple different countries.

/r/NationalDivorce

492 Subscribers

3

Some concrete national divorce policy suggestions that try to take all sides into account

Imo i think it’s time for both red and blue states to really sit down and discuss this - like nuts and bolts. It’s not even polarization anymore, it’s outright hate. It’s irreconcilable differences.

1.) I kind of imagine this looking like the north american version of what should’ve been a two-state solution with the Israelis and Palestinians. Completely separate political and economic systems that govern specifically those willing to be governed by it down to the local (county) level. Hopefully there’s a divorce attorney that can give input on asset division - there would need to either be some sort of reasonable split of military and economic assets.

2.) county by county referendums to decide how they wish to be governed. As a native californian I’m well aware that outside of the biggest cities it’s mostly deep red and expecting all of california to stay together is unrealistic. Imo this is the fairest idea since it takes in consideration red pockets in blue states and vice versa like the rural parts of oregon and washington etc

3.) free travel, trade, and visitation. Let people move not policies. Let’s be free to govern ourselves the way we want but restricting travel would harm interstate commerce, cause grocery store shortages and does neither side any benefit. When it comes down to it - both red and blue use costco and amazon.

Without this, a split america would be a mess of increasingly hostile checkpoints, the mostly blue biggest cities in red states would basically be besieged and cut off islands and creating such potential flashpoints increases the very real possibility of war if say for hypothetical instance the red parts of Georgia decide no food water etc will be allowed into Atlanta.

Free travel is also needed because such a split would invariably result in many opting to move somewhere they prefer and both sides would be doing this. Even deep blue counties have trump supporters and vice versa.

That’s the ideas i have…if others have suggestions I’m willing to discuss/help put together some sort of proposal. As weird as this sounds coming from a LA liberal…maybe MTG could get the ball rolling on this since it was originally her idea but at this point i think she’d agree with me that she doesn’t want to be countrymen with me any more than I do with her- but both sides need to work together one last time…if only to split.

1 Comment
2024/11/13
06:26 UTC

14

“Evangelism”

For a long time, talk of separation has come largely from the right. Now that the left is all grumpy with Trump’s victory, we need to be actively promoting national divorce to them as well. The whole thing goes much smoother when both sides are convinced that separation is in their best interest.

Buckley’s book American Secession takes a leftist approach. My book National Divorce: A Plan for Peace takes a somewhat libertarian and non-partisan approach, arguing that it’s in everyone’s best interest to divide.

Www.national-divorce.com is where you can find my book. I’m also happy to podcast, etc. with just about anybody.

15 Comments
2024/11/07
18:39 UTC

6

Analysis of Census

The census went as expected:

https://www.reddit.com/r/NationalDivorce/comments/1g7z4u2/a_census/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

1 Democrat

4 Republican

17 Libertarian

1 Socialist

6 Anarchist

There needs to be a case for the Democrats and Socialists to allow secession. I'll try and everyone else should add what else might interest them:

  1. A smaller military.

  2. Smaller lobby groups. I'm thinking the American Medical Association which has huge influence over nationwide drug prices.

  3. Majority minority countries including the possible Atlanta and West Mississippi.

  4. You don't have to be in the same country as Alabama and you can get rid of most of the strict Mormons.

  5. The EU allows secession.

  6. No federal laws for drugs.

  7. You can add in a hard border so that you can prohibit guns.

  8. There would be no January 6 extremists.

2 Comments
2024/10/30
21:10 UTC

24

Once you decide to secede from the 'Union," your Supreme Court ruling no longer applies.

2 Comments
2024/10/30
16:31 UTC

6

A Census

Who are we? Who should we be talking to?

Pick which group you best identify with. Don't say that you identify with none of them because one of them is close enough for you to choose it:

If you are truly a special snowflake then describe yourself in the comments.

View Poll

2 Comments
2024/10/20
13:49 UTC

10

Bob Murphy and I talk national divorce

2 Comments
2024/10/08
15:29 UTC

8

Other ND forums

Hi. Are there any more active ND forums out there?

1 Comment
2024/09/29
05:53 UTC

25

Hot take: The Constitution of 1787 is a red herring. What in the Constitution authorizes gun control, the FBI, the ATF, three letter agencies and economic and foreign intervention?

2 Comments
2024/09/26
11:30 UTC

4

It is possible to be insured against theft without having to pay protection rackets. E.g. your TV is stolen, so you are indemnified and then your insurance agency goes to retrieve your TV along with restitution from the thief, all the while not forcing payment.

0 Comments
2024/09/20
18:45 UTC

17

I guess that the meme pertains to the post-Southern War of Independence Union flag. Do you agree?

2 Comments
2024/09/19
23:23 UTC

3

Live on the Heartland Liberty show

Spent an hour tonight with Dan Meredith and the Heartland Liberty show talking about national divorce.

https://rumble.com/v5fhc31-09-18-24-heartland-liberty-live-wednesday-8-9pm-l-jason-fry.html

0 Comments
2024/09/19
02:42 UTC

54

As a libertarian, how do you feel about secession?

10 Comments
2024/09/18
12:26 UTC

11

Heartland Liberty

I’ll be on the Heartland Liberty show Wednesday on rumble.

If we’re gonna have any chance at peace when it comes to the national divorce, we’re gonna have to get the word out better than we currently do. I wrote a book on the subject, and I am hitting the podcast circuit. What are you doing?

1 Comment
2024/09/17
00:30 UTC

9

The Ethics of Secession in the Star Wars Galaxy: A Libertarian Critique of Jedi Politics

0 Comments
2024/09/13
15:37 UTC

3

Porcupine Report #28: "Liberty-For-Real Societies @ NH Liberty Forum" with Dennis Pratt

0 Comments
2024/09/09
22:03 UTC

12

Your favorite book on secession?

I'll start, my favorite is Breaking Away by Ryan McMaken

4 Comments
2024/09/06
14:41 UTC

16

Libertarian Carla Gericke of the Free State Project interviewed by Dr. Phil on secession

2 Comments
2024/09/04
12:05 UTC

7

Whenever one proposes political decentralization, a common retort is: "But what if criminals or China fill the power vacuum?!". A crucial insight is that political centralization can be accompanied with legal, economic and military integration which fixes that, without political centralization.

0 Comments
2024/08/28
22:56 UTC

5

Anyone familiar with the movements for secession in Northern Mexico?

0 Comments
2024/08/25
13:29 UTC

7

An innovative way of proving that taxation is theft: show the interlocutor this map and ask them "What would Kamla Harris have to do to the City of Dallas here in order to ensure that they paid for her public programmes?". The State is just that, but realized.

13 Comments
2024/08/24
09:52 UTC

11

A glaring question the one who argues that 1865 settled the secession question: "would you have executed the treasonous secessionists Benjamin Franklin and George Washington?"

5 Comments
2024/08/22
16:26 UTC

10

New National Divorce book

Hello fellow secessionists. I’m happy to announce that my new book, National Divorce: A Plan for Peace will be out very soon soon. It’ll be on Amazon next week, and I have autographed copies available for pre-order with delivery by the end of September.

I have two kids in the military, so any separation option that involves Civil War I’m not interested in. Since America is divided already and the break up seems inevitable, it makes sense to me that we could just lean in and negotiate a deal instead of waiting until circumstances beyond our control lead to violence.

I look at the idea of division and smaller nations from quite a few different perspectives, including economic, social, global, etc. I talk about intentional sorting into more homogenous groups as the answer, sprinkling in a dose of libertarian live and let live.

I cite over 60 sources, including scholarly works from well known economist and writers.

Www.national-divorce.com is the website. Sign up for the mailing list, and even order a book if you’d like.

6 Comments
2024/08/21
22:37 UTC

10

Secession: Good, Legal, Inevitable

1 Comment
2024/08/17
12:44 UTC

Back To Top