/r/historyofmedicine

Photograph via snooOG

A place to discuss the history of medicine, the fascinating evolution of medical science, the anecdotes of the people who have made medicine what it is today. Topics of discussion may include (but is not limited to!) the history of medical procedures, treatments, and devices, historical persons of interest, the history of epidemiology and public health, and other related areas of interest.

A History Network Member

Welcome

This subreddit is dedicated to the discussion of the history of medicine, as well as the histories of epidemiology and public health. Submissions and comments should be on topics related to these subjects except when otherwise permitted.

Also check out our wiki (Note: wiki is in development. Have a suggestion? Message the moderators).

The Rules

  1. This is a subreddit for civil and informed discussion. No hate material or open hostility is acceptable. Those users found to be in violation of this rule will have their comments removed and will be warned. Any subsequent violations of this rule will result in a ban.

  2. Please follow the twenty-year rule: only post and comment about topics prior to 1993. This is to avoid the discussion of current events, which is more appropriate for other subreddits.

  3. When posting, find the most relevant source. All controversial or possibly insensitive materials should include a thorough bibliography of sources. Blogspam is not acceptable. If you would like to post a link to a blog, that is fine, but multiple postings of singular blog entries by a single user will be considered spam, and that user will be banned.

  4. Joke answers, memes, pun threads, reaction .gifs, MFWs and anything of the sort are strictly forbidden.

  5. Downvote for irrelevancy, low content, or unhelpful content. Upvote for rich and interesting content.

  6. If you have any questions, concerns or comments about the subreddit, please message the moderators directly.

Flair

Users are allowed to create their own flair.

You may include whatever you like as the text - either a primary area of interest or an area in which you consider yourself and expert.

In order to further distinguish novices and experts - if your flair represents an area of interest please select the color blue; if you consider yourself an expert on a topic, please select the color red.

Expert defined as either: extensive knowledge of a subject usually obtained through the completion of an undergraduate degree, or extensive self-study - please be willing and ready to expand on an issue or provide good sources, if asked.

/r/historyofmedicine

8,133 Subscribers

2

AAA - Antique anatomic tables wanted

Hi everybody,

I hope this post reaches the right community, otherwise please redirect me to a more appropriate subreddit.

A friend of mine just graduated in physiotherapy and we want to gift her antique anatomical tables (DaVinci/Vesalio style). Do you have any suggestion on where to look to find somein high quality?

Thanks a lot in advance

0 Comments
2024/11/20
13:56 UTC

1

Looking for contemporaneous accounts of lobotomies

Is there anywhere I can read old medical journals that contain contemporaneous accounts of lobotomies or perhaps articles that explore the justifications for these procedures. I'm interested in learning more about what doctors did and thought during them. Why they were thought to be successful, etc.

6 Comments
2024/11/11
18:29 UTC

6

What would have happened if someone broke their hip in the late 1960s?

I'm working on a writing project set in the late 1960s. I've been doing some research and asking around, but it is difficult to find an answer that is appropriate for the time period I'm looking for.

Assuming a healthy man in his 20s broke his hip, what would surgery have been like? (Traumatic, invasive, big/small scars). How long would recovery take? (Hospital stay, rehab, physical therapy, etc. Would he have been in a brace of some kind or a cast? How long afterwards would he be in pain or limp?)

I found some scholarly articles that mentioned a 3-week hospital stay and particular hip replacement options that would have not bonded correctly to the hip socket, and a lot of other technical stuff, but these articles get quite "scholarly" lol.

I know a woman who broke her hip when she was a teenager or early 20s, maybe in the 1960s (?) and now, as an elderly person, she limps quite extremely, and according to my parents, she always has. Is that common for a hip injury prior to our modern hip replacement technologies?

Anyways, I'd appreciated any insight or if you have a source I could read to help me understand it better!

0 Comments
2024/11/09
03:45 UTC

5

Lobotomies were not fringe science

In this post we review the rise and popularity of lobotomies as an intervention to cure mental illness and eradicate undesired behaviors.

https://open.substack.com/pub/curingcrime/p/mad-doctors-ice-picks-lobotomized-children-the-lessons-behind-dullys-tragedy-684b0f356d17?r=2bk4r1&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

4 Comments
2024/10/29
09:36 UTC

4

Why was jaundice seemingly much more common for adults in the Western world up through WW2, but not currently?

In doing a lot of historical research for certain times and places for my work, such as Edwardian-era Britain or 1920s United States, in many documents and diary entries I've come across it seemed relatively normal or even common for adults to get jaundice. In the current era in the developed world, though, this seems relatively unusual- infant jaundice remains very common, but not for adults. Why was this the case? Was it dietary/lifestyle related?

5 Comments
2024/10/25
09:49 UTC

8

Does anybody know what this says?

Found this record in absolutely terrible condition and have been trying to figure out what it says the cause of death was for this individual in 1962 was. Can anybody figure it out? I think I see “haemorrhage” but that’s all I got 🤕

14 Comments
2024/10/21
08:15 UTC

1

Torn ACL question

I hope this is okay to ask here. I'm working on a story, a historical, where I need a child to NOT get somewhere quickly. But she needs to be reasonable mobile later in the story and needs to not have too major of an injury, where she wouldn't be too immobile (such as a broken leg). So, I'm thinking about taring a seven-year-old's ACL. The setting is late Victorian England, but she's a poor rural kid.

Anybody know? My google-fu has failed me, it keeps giving me things about modern braces. Also, what would the longterm affects be? I've had her using a rigged up leather knee brace and a crutch and later a cane. Reading has suggested that (since I need her moderately mobile later) that it wasn't an incomplete tare?

Thanks in advance.

2 Comments
2024/10/19
07:19 UTC

2

The UCSF-JHU Opioid Industry Documents Archive (OIDA) has collected millions of documents exposing the inner workings of industries that have fueled the worst overdose epidemic in US history. Today is #AskAnArchivist Day—ask me anything about this trove of corporate communications.

0 Comments
2024/10/16
14:56 UTC

2

Who are some key advocates, organizations or cases behind legitimizing "nervous breakdowns" (MHC) and bringing it to the national conversation?

I'm looking to learn more about the history of mental health crisises and how people took their perception from a personal failing of the patient to a real medical condition deserving sympathy.

0 Comments
2024/10/02
13:58 UTC

2

How many puffs or individual oral doses in a 1958 Medihaler?

I am still researching the material for a screenplay I posted another inquiry about a couple of weeks ago that is set in Los Angeles in 1958. In the story, a young 13 year old girl has asthma and treats it with an emergency Medihaler inhaler. How many puffs would be in the inhaler?

Thank you for any assistance you could provide.

1 Comment
2024/09/24
00:58 UTC

7

medical apparatus in the mid-1950s for a leg injury

I am researching the material for a screenplay set in Los Angeles in 1958. In the story, an actress in her mid 30s is injured on a film set and is left mostly or partially immobile. It is very difficult for her to walk. Would she wear a leg brace? What sort of apparatus would she use? She could often be confined to a wheelchair, but I would like her to be able to attempt to walk with a great deal of difficulty. A visual representation highlighting her injury is definitely a bonus.  That’s why I’d like to use a leg brace or something similar. Any ideas for a medical apparatus in the mid-1950s?

8 Comments
2024/09/11
06:06 UTC

12

Can you identify the handwritten chief cause of death?

8 Comments
2024/09/01
16:45 UTC

1

Writing question: Early Victorian patent medicines (England, 1840s/50s)

0 Comments
2024/08/31
02:05 UTC

2

Seeking info on this Brandkompreffe WW2 German burn bandage

I know this isn't the perfect subreddit for this question, but it's the most fitting one I can find. I'm looking for any information I can get regarding this WW2 German burn bandage branded Brandkompreffe

These bandages came from my German Grandfather's WW2 issue medical kit. What's interesting is that even despite roughly 80 years worth of degradation they still work incredibly well - a little too well - so well that it has me questioning what the hell is in these things.

The burn they were recently applied to was very severe and very large. As soon as the bandage was applied there was an abrupt reduction in pain which remained even after the bandage was removed. The burn did not blister at all. One day later the burn does not hurt at all even when touched.

These bandages are genuinely incredible. I'm nearly positive that no product like this exists today and I'm wondering why that is. What is the likelihood of this product containing some type of banned/potentially harmful substance?

2 Comments
2024/08/29
14:10 UTC

9

Recommendations for reading about birth control methods throughout history please.

4 Comments
2024/08/25
20:40 UTC

3

Plausibility of 1880s French doctor misdiagnosing yellow fever as mushroom poisoning?

Hello r/historyofmedicine,

I'm working on a historical novel set in 1880s Le Havre, France, and I need some expert opinions on the plausibility of one of my plot points. I've written an "expert conclusion" by a fictional doctor who misdiagnoses a case of yellow fever as death cap mushroom poisoning. I'm wondering about the historical accuracy of this scenario.

Here are some key points from the "expert conclusion":

  1. The doctor examines a deceased sailor with symptoms including jaundice, liver damage, gastrointestinal bleeding, kidney damage, and fever prior to death.
  2. He concludes it's a case of Amanita phalloides (death cap mushroom) poisoning.
  3. The doctor notes similar symptoms in three other recent deaths and suggests they're connected.
  4. This takes place in Normandy, where yellow fever would have been highly uncommon.

My questions:

  1. Given the state of medical knowledge in the 1880s, especially in a port city like Le Havre, is it plausible that a doctor could misdiagnose yellow fever as mushroom poisoning?
  2. Is death cap a good candidate for this misdiagnose?
  3. Would a doctor in 1880s France be familiar with the symptoms of death cap mushroom poisoning? Was this a well-known threat at the time?
  4. How familiar would French doctors of this era be with yellow fever? From what i found, it was not discovered yet, that it is transmitted by mosquitoes. Would its rarity in Normandy make misdiagnosis more likely?
  5. Are there any glaring anachronisms or errors in the medical knowledge or procedures I've depicted?

I'd be grateful for any insights that could help me improve the historical accuracy of this scene. If anyone's interested, here is a fictional "expert conclusion" that I wrote for the book https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ihHnpB9ncbmKjnpf_wN9uIwOqH2Mgv2uMR4Z9x5vTJw/edit?usp=sharing for more detailed feedback.

Thank you in advance for your expertise!

0 Comments
2024/08/21
17:08 UTC

6

Buffalo Red Cross Nurse during the Polish Soviet War

Praxeda Fronczak was a Red Cross Nurse from Buffalo who went to Poland after World War One during the Polish-Soviet War (1919-1921) to help combat a typhus epidemic, teach nursing, and evacuate and treat refugees. She did amazing work in Poland and kept an extensive diary and scrapbook of her time there.

https://library.buffalo.edu/news/2023/12/21/praxeda-fronczak-a-red-cross-nurse-in-poland-1919-1921/

https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/973910e6aa854000bb62895199933b1

0 Comments
2024/08/02
19:19 UTC

6

Who first used the term ‘lub-dub’ to describe heart sounds?

I know the steth was invented by Laennec, but curious as to who first used the phrase lub-dub to describe the sound of the heart

0 Comments
2024/07/10
01:32 UTC

8

Louis Pasteur succesfully administers the anti rabies vaccine to 9 yr old Joseph Meister on this date in 1885, after the boy was bitten by a rabid dog. He produced it by growing the virus in rabbits, and then weakening it. It laid foundation for other vaccines too.

1 Comment
2024/07/06
04:32 UTC

3

Lf books or papers about history of case studies

Hello, I'm looking to see if there are any books or papers that deal with the history of case studies especially things wrestling with the positive medical benefits but potential ethically concerns. This is a really broad topic so any thoughts or suggestions are greatly appreciated.

2 Comments
2024/06/24
17:21 UTC

9

Looking for books and authors on the history of anxiety

Hi team! Anyone read any good books (or chapters in books) about how anxiety has been treated as a symptom or diagnosis across time? Podcast tips also welcome!

4 Comments
2024/06/22
13:11 UTC

6

Michel Foucault’s Archaeology of Scientific Reason: Science and the History of Reason — An online reading group starting Sunday June 23 (12 meetings in total), open to everyone

0 Comments
2024/06/21
20:15 UTC

Back To Top