/r/genetics

Photograph via //r/genetics

For discussion of genetics research, ethical and social issues arising from genetics and its applications, genetics career questions, etc.

Genetics, genes, and genomes

Frequently asked questions

If your post is not showing up or receiving any views, it may be caught in the automatic spam filter. Please use the modmail to ask for a manual review.

 

Rules:

  1. Be nice - No trolling, personal attacks, hate speech, bullying, harassment, etc.

  2. No promotions or advertisements without moderator approval - This includes crowdfunding, online courses, personal genetics testing services.

  3. No low effort posts - Posts which are directly addressed by the FAQs in the wiki may be removed. Posts and comments should generate or contribute to a discussion.

  4. No pseudoscience or misinformation

  5. No medical questions - We are not equipped to provide medical advice. Please see the pinned readme thread for details on this rule.

  6. No homework or study help posts outside of the megathread - Please see the pinned megathread for guidelines.

  7. No posts containing just personal ancestry/genetic testing results - Posts for help with interpreting such results should contain a specific question and will be removed if covered by the FAQ.

  8. Directly link to research studies - Videos, press summaries, or news articles discussing a specific study must be accompanied by a link to the study in question.

Please use the report feature to notify the moderators of rule violations so they can be dealt with quickly.

*Mods reserve the right to remove posts or comments at their discretion. Repeated or particularly egregious violations of these rules may result in temporary or permanent bans. If you have any questions or complaints, feel free to contact the mod team via modmail.

 

Helpful links
Please check out our wiki for FAQs and helpful resources in genetics.

/r/genetics

113,222 Subscribers

1

Can we extrapolate the impact of genes?

1: Assume we have a pair of identical twins. We magically switch out ONE specific gene sequence in the one twin, which results in them having orange eyes. Without any other information, what would the probability be that changing said gene in another random (unrelated) baby would cause the same effect? Would it be fair to presume that there is a high chance the same effect would occur? (Something like 'it's more likely than not...')?

An analogy to this would be me walking over and spilling a mysterious juice on someone's skin that causes their skin to turn green. I would presume that the same effect would occur on another unrelated random person, despite not yet running any additional tests.

The question, then, is basically: is there something fundamentally different about how genes work that would make these two circumstances non-analagous? To be clear, I understand that there's uncertainty regardless. The substance of this question is more about whether a logical induction can be made similarly between them.

2: Imagine they're twins, rather than identical twins. Does the answer change?

3: Let's assume that my brief Google research is right in that there are 150~ genes that determine skin color. Let's assume that we identify 150~ genes in one group of people like a country that seem to determine something like teeth size. Would it be reasonable to presume that these genes would also likely have the same effect on another group of people, like a different country? Or would it be just as likely that these genes have a completely different effect or no effect at all on teeth?

0 Comments
2024/11/10
03:13 UTC

47

Question: what kind of mutation would cause this? Or is this something like an octoploid?

12 Comments
2024/11/09
19:44 UTC

0

How can a random person be closer related to me than my dad, but not related to my maternal granddad?

I have dna tested myself, my dad and my maternal grandfather. After uploading these kits, I got a match with me, my father and another person on the website. However, the person who matched is closer related to me 0.8% (59.1‎ cM) than my father 0.2% (16.2‎ cM)? Also no match with my maternal grandfather? Is it an error or a relative of my maternal grandmother got together with a relative of my dad?

https://preview.redd.it/3r9fmmma5wzd1.png?width=1150&format=png&auto=webp&s=80dbb8e93c831a46f72026c510981996dbf3db94

19 Comments
2024/11/09
15:03 UTC

3

Looking for recommendations for high school or early college level books on genetics

My younger cousin has been super interested in genetics since his science class did a unit on it. He says he might want to go to college for it. What books would you all recommend for a 14 year old boy?

Edit:

over the last couple hours I've gone down a rabbit hole researching books. I've compiled a list from other threads but have no idea what I'm looking at. And as much as I love the kid, I don't want to break the bank with a couple dozen books (esp when I don't know what type of genetics he has an interest in). But I also want to be sure he has a strong foundation. Can you all help me cut it down some, maybe clear out overlapping books?

#Textbook-ish:

  • genetics: from genes to genomes
  • griffith's intro to genetic analysis
  • cartoon guide to genetics
  • genetics for dummies
  • thompson's genetics in medicine
  • the tangled bank by Zimmer

#Human Evolution:

  • the gene by mukherjee
  • the selfish gene by dawkins
  • genome by ridley
  • herding hemingway's cats by arney
  • the meaning of human existence by EO Wilson (on the fence)
  • blueprint by Christakis (seemed like it might be better than Wilson)
  • your inner fish by shubin
  • some assembly required by shubin
  • how the leopard changed its spots by goodman
  • making of the fittest by carroll
  • not in our genes by lewontin
  • she has her mother's laugh by Zimmer
  • the violinist's thumb by kean
  • 7 daughters of eve by sykes
  • a series of unfortunate events by carroll
  • history & geography of human genes by sforza
  • a brief history of everyone who ever lived by Rutherford
  • a short history of nearly everything by Bryson
  • a brief history of earth by knoll (not necessarily genetics but I enjoyed it when I read it)
  • hacking darwin by metzl
  • a crack in creation by doudna

#GMOs/not human focus

  • DNA demystified by mchughen
  • in mendel's footnotes by tudge
  • how to clone a Mammoth by shapiro

#History:

  • the double Helix by Watson
  • unraveling the double Helix by Williams
  • Neanderthal man by Pääbo
  • the chimp and the river by Quammen
  • the hot zone by preston
  • darwin's ghost by stout
  • symphony in C by Hazen
  • guns, germs, and steel by diamond (ik there's some sort of controversy there)
  • how to win a nobel prize by bishop
  • mutants by leroi

#Biography:

  • carrier by rough
  • the immortal life of Henrietta lacks
  • code breaker by isaacson

#Fiction:

  • my sister's keeper
  • science of discworld
  • next by chriton
  • jurassic park

#Ones I decided against:

  • letters to a young scientist
  • why evolution is true
  • Homo deus by Harare
  • regenesis by church
2 Comments
2024/11/09
03:59 UTC

0

Transitioning (🏳️‍⚧️) and X-linked traits

X linked traits and hormone replacement treatment correlation

I have seen trans men (afab taking testosterone) go through male pattern baldness once theyve taken hormones for some time. Obviously, male pattern baldness only affects males, and is a sex linked trait. Based on what i know an x/sex-linked trait is carried on the x chromosome and more often presents in males as only one copy is needed whereas a female would need two copies to be anything more than a carrier.

  1. would the trans man effected need two copies of the male pattern baldness gene in addition to the testosterone/hrt that “activated” it?

……or, like a biological male, would the trans man only need one copy in addition to the testosterone activator?

  1. would this specific balding gene be part of genetic linkage where you have to be biologically male in order for it to show? If so, would the simulated male levels of testosterone trick the body into putting the genes to work even though the trans man is not biologically male?

not sure if this made sense completely but i was just curious lol

3 Comments
2024/11/08
19:37 UTC

0

30x Genetic Sequencing UK

Hey. Looking for a 30x test kit available in the UK.

Have searched around to compare prices (>400% markup between some companies, wild) and came across mostly junk. DanteLabs appears cheap but the company is taking money but isn't processing requests due to being insolvent, Nebula initally seemed cheap but then try to charge for a year subscription to junk that isn't needed at checkout, etc.

Was just wondering if there are any suppliers of good quality genetic tests that are generally recommended by the subreddit.

Thanks.

0 Comments
2024/11/08
18:36 UTC

4

Regulating the height of grasses via genetic engineering

Mammals have complex genetic systems to regulate ideal hair lengths. Would it be possible to genetically modify grasses to enter a resting phase once they've reached a certain length? There would need to be a selective pressure against wild type grasses otherwise they'd just outcompete these engineered grasses. And I know grass is a huge water suck with little payoff, but if people insist on keeping their lawns, then significant labor and energy could be saved by no longer requiring mowing.

If we can make spider silk in goats and make bacterial pesticides in crops, this doesn't seem so farfetch'd.

7 Comments
2024/11/08
02:31 UTC

0

WholeTruth: [Truth Never Hurts For a Doctor]

In this article your going to learn about heredity & where genes reveal themselves with neither rhyme nor reason to the untrained eye, there lies the baffling case of Lucy and Maria Aylmer. Fraternal twins born in 1997, their appearance defies assumptions: Lucy with fair skin, red hair, and blue eyes, and Maria with darker skin, brown eyes, and curls. It is a case of astounding genetic variance within one household—an occurrence so ordinary in biology yet so unsettling to common sense that it seems to unnerve even those supposedly schooled in science.

These doctors, self-proclaimed arbiters of knowledge, seem unable or unwilling to communicate the astonishing nuances of genetic inheritance. As if the public should be shielded from such truths, they let families wander with questions left unaddressed, assumptions unsatisfied, because perhaps these professionals are haunted by their own unspoken prejudices. In a field meant to illuminate, why do they hesitate, allowing society’s rigid views of race and identity to cloud the realities of human variation?

There is more to the story: Donna Aylmer, mother of these twins, had a previous husband before Vince, the twins’ father. From that union came three children—George, Chynna, and Jordan—who sit chromatically between Lucy and Maria. They stand as testaments to the fluidity of genetics, a tangible bridge linking diverse ancestries within a single bloodline.

And yet, the doctor’s passivity persists—a reluctance to pull families aside, look them in the eye, and say: “Your story is a marvel of human biology, not a puzzling mistake.” For these twins, like all fraternal twins, are a product of separate eggs fertilized by different sperm, resulting in natural genetic variation. But the medical mind, so formalized, prefers silence, sparing itself the task of recalibrating societal understanding.

Then, there is a sobering thought: what if, one day, Lucy or Maria finds herself in need of a kidney, a liver, or a transfusion? To discover in that moment that they aren’t compatible, that their biology does not align as they’d believed, would only deepen the rupture. Wouldn’t their lives be better served by knowing now rather than later? By being empowered with a true understanding of their genetic landscape, they could face such crises prepared, with knowledge as their shield.

In moments like these, one must insist that doctors rise to the occasion—to refresh their minds, break free of staleness, and help families embrace their own narratives with certainty. What else is their purpose if not to reveal, to teach, to cast light upon the shadowed halls of genetic heritage, so that lives may be lived with truth as a companion?

I ask, then: isn’t it time for these professionals to forsake the bounds of convention, to share the truth.

0 Comments
2024/11/07
22:36 UTC

0

Undergrad looking for some advice

I'm a UC Davis undergrad majoring in genetics and genomics wanting to pursue a PHD in genetics with the hopes of doing research. However, I am running into an issue of my gpa might not meet the minimum requirement for application this cycle, my bioinformatics class is kicking my ass. I'm a transfer student so all the classes I had left were upper division and the transition between CC and UC has been tough.

I wanted to apply for a PhD at UC Davis but my mentor recommended I look into Merced as well. Do you guys think that makes sense? They don't have a genetics PhD from my understanding so would I still be able to pursue research in genetics?

I'm also wondering if my GPA doesn't meet the minimum requirement what should I do to help with that? I will have a few more quarters after this application cycle to get my GPA up before I graduate, but in the off chance I am not able to do that what should I do in a "gap year" to make me a viable candidate?

Thanks to anyone who responds your advice is much appreciated!

3 Comments
2024/11/07
22:14 UTC

1

Why are animals like cats, dogs, and goats likely to share certain phenotypic traits with us?

Some possible examples:

-Hair changing color in response to sunlight

-Experiencing the same benefits (or some of the same benefits) from being in "nature" (around plants, soil, natural bodies of water, and sunlight)

-Sunlight-related needs or benefits

-Personality-related phenotypic traits

-An instinctive sense of "Yes" and "No"?

-Understanding when a question is being asked based on inflection

-Instinctively fasting during an upset stomach

-Showing affection via hugging

-Health negatively impacted by ultra processed food (not sure if that's due to phenotypic traits or due to the food or both)

-Tendency to nap around noon

-A need for companionship

-A need for affection

5 Comments
2024/11/07
18:48 UTC

0

Snp risk allele

How can we identify the risk allele associated with the rs id, as dbSNP and GWAS seem to have less information about the risk allele when searching for a rs id? Does anybody have worked on this?

3 Comments
2024/11/07
12:31 UTC

6

Jobs for genetics major student

Hello everyone,

I am aware that there is a fair bit of posts that pop up here and there about jobs in genetics field but I wanted to get some information for my perspective.

I am a genetics major student in Canada and I am in my last year of studies (hopefully). For the past couple of years I have been volunteering in research labs that is not really related to genetics. However, in my opinion rather than the research topics, the experiences I have gained is far more important. I have gained experiences in many different lab techniques, such as immunostaining, PCR, microscopy techniques, animal care, behavioral experiments and many more. These are all on top of what I already learned from lab courses and I am currently working on my own final project to end with a "bang" lets say.

I would like to continue my masters over a job but I need some funds because of the high international student fees.

Now since I am in my last year I started peeking at the job market. However, I could not see anything that is related to genetics. Usually, there are lab assistant or lab tech positions but they all require CSMLS certificate which genetics program is not eligible as far as I can see.

I was hoping you guys can give me some insights what can I do or how can I proceed with my career.

Thank you for reading my post everyone :)

2 Comments
2024/11/06
17:26 UTC

1

Genetic Markings and Chromosome Banding(?)

When I was studying genetic markers and the bandings on chromosomes, I had myself partially lost.

Though I am familiar with the nomenclature of genetic markers, I am unfamiliar with what the decimal points refer to. For instance, -q25.2 or -q23.3 attached to the numeral (autosome chromosome) or character (sex chromosome) of the chromosome. I am just not understanding the .#.

To ask another question, what do each of the band marks refer to or represent? Do these band marks refer to a certain trait or gene?

3 Comments
2024/11/05
02:01 UTC

3

Wright’s Fstats

Is it possible to calculate the Fst of a population dataset containing subpopulations when all that is given is the observed heterozygosity?

2 Comments
2024/11/04
21:15 UTC

0

Why are we so focused on which supplements to take or how our epigenetic look when we haven’t even understood our basic biology?

If your car's is broken and wont drive, would you spend time polishing the windows or fixing the doors? Of course; Neither. You’d go straight for the engine, right? Some things simply have more impact than others — especially when it comes to longevity.

Trends in health range from eating algae with some even suggesting you should eat Ashwagandha all the way to decoding our DNA. Think about it this way: not smoking will probably add more years to your life than taking a daily Ashwaganda or algae. Now of course these are not mutually exclusive, you can both not smoke and eat the right supplements. But following this argument there are billions of things we have to do to increase our longevity, supplements, treatments, therapies and so forth.

Let’s shift the conversation to what is high impact, and therefore genetic conditions. If you look at the statistics, it is crazy. For example, familial hypercholesterolemia affects 1 in 250 people, over 90% are undiagnosed and unfourtnantly the first symptom may very well be a heart attack at your 40s. There are more heart conditions that have the same statistic all the way to hereditary cancer?

My question is, why are we so focused on so much small things and not our own stepping stones of life, DNA? I am working with monogenic diseases, ask me anything.

29 Comments
2024/11/04
09:47 UTC

0

Can genetics influence one’s memory capacity or power or whatever you call it you get it what i mean

Basically the title

2 Comments
2024/11/04
08:33 UTC

1

Can genetics influence personality traits?

I've never met my uncle before, but I often feel energetic and have the need to just jump around the house like an idiot just because I can. (espescially if there's music) Apparently my uncle used to love jumping and running everywhere when he was younger, too.

My brother used to rest in the womb the same way my grandma slept. I wonder if it's correlated or just coincidences?

11 Comments
2024/11/04
05:08 UTC

4

Blood Type

I am O- My parents were O+ and O- so all good. My kids dad is A+, now not one of 3 of my kids is exactly same as either of us but a mix. Eldest A- then middle and last O+ is that normal they all got mixed up? The A- caused most issues for him, cannot explain why something to do with my blood. Lost 4 pregnancies after 3rd I would think they would have given RH needle though.

7 Comments
2024/11/04
01:56 UTC

3

Should i use 3rd partypartner to analyze my gene sequence?

Hi, is my privacy actually safe when I use 3rd party apps to analyze my genome? I had my DNA sequenced on Sequencing and have only used them to ananlyze my genome. Thinking about using one of their partners. What should I do?

11 Comments
2024/11/03
18:56 UTC

0

Could my child look like my father if I have more of my mother’s DNA?

if I look more like and have more characteristics of my mother then I have more of her DNA? But if I where to have a child with a man him having more of his fathers DNA, could there be a possibility that our child comes out looking like more of (the mothers) fathers side even tho I’m more made up like my mother? Correct me if I’m wrong in anyway and the science behind it I’m very interested

8 Comments
2024/11/03
16:37 UTC

3

ASHG2024

Just wondering if trainees would like to meet informally in groups and go around Denver!

Not sure why these groups don’t exist, but I would love to meet more genetic enthusiasts!

0 Comments
2024/11/03
00:05 UTC

0

Genetics

"Does exome sequencing offer consistent coverage and depth across both coding and non-coding regions?

14 Comments
2024/11/02
14:40 UTC

1

Can anyone recommend any resources/books?

Hi, I'm a master student in bioinformatics and I have a strong computer science background but a really poor biological background (i.e. I've never studied microbiology, embryology, histology...). I have a good bases in genetics, could anyone recommend me some resources/books on genetics (not just human) and immune genetics? Thanks so much in advance

3 Comments
2024/11/02
10:41 UTC

0

Is there a website or service that reads your DNA and provides recommendations for antidepressants? (I have raw 23&Me data) Thank you

7 Comments
2024/11/02
03:24 UTC

4

Complex diagnosis : targeted gene tests, or buy one off full genome sequencing?

It can get pretty expensive to keep getting small segments of my genome tested while not necessarily offering new direction to consider subsequent other sorts of testing, or treatment that might help.

My question is if 30x full genome sequencing would capture all the snp I want, so that if a Dr wonders if I have a variant of CYP21A2 that is associated with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (cah), that can be looked up readily, or even to actively scan through in case there are any strong genetic associations like having HLA-DQB1*06:02 ?

Or is this flexibility of a full genome sequencing unreasonable or impractical?

13 Comments
2024/11/01
23:08 UTC

1

Ability to speak is acquired or inherited?

I

5 Comments
2024/11/01
21:46 UTC

9

I DNA tested my male orange and white cat and it said he inherited two copies of the gene for black coat color. How is this possible?

Hello! I have a male cat that is orange with white on his face, paws, and belly. I did a basepaws DNA test for him and everything made sense except for his coat color. The report said that he inherited two copies of a CA deletion in the ASIP gene, from my understanding a mutation of that type would lead to a solid coat color that is likely black. I am not super familiar with cat genetics but from my understanding it is not possible for a male cat to have two copies of that mutation and not be solid or black. So I was just wondering how this was possible? If it helps i originally fostered him with his mother and brothers, so I know what they looked like. His mother was a dilute tortie (grey and beige), one of his brothers was solid gray with white patches, one was a gray tabby, and one was identical to him beige and white. Thank you!

12 Comments
2024/11/01
17:10 UTC

0

Free Genetic data analyzer

Hello, I recently got my DNA data from ancestry and was wondering if there are any free tools for analyzing the data for genetic health risks. I’ve seen a couple options but it’s hard to know which ones are valid.

6 Comments
2024/11/01
16:53 UTC

Back To Top