So, I’m pregnant and trying to avoid TOOOO much sugar, but I decided I’m going to treat myself to a 3 mini cookie pack either this week or next week. I won’t do both, just one.

If I went this week, I’d do the dirt cake, Reece’s pieces, and the Halloween cake batter (I considered the chips ahoy cookie but it seems controversial lol! And I prefer warm cookies anyways).

If I go next week, I’d get the peanut butter blossom, strawberry cupcake, aaaand the NY Cheesecake.

So here are my questions as a newbie who has only been once before: Which is the better peanut butter cookie generally? Peanut butter blossom or Reece’s? Honestly this might be the deciding factor because I’m a peanut butter hoe. If I went next week, should I sub out a strawberry cupcake or NY cheesecake for something else to avoid having two cream cheese-y cookies? But which of my picks would probably be considered the better selection overall?

For the free cookie from the T-mobile app, can it only be the chocolate chunk or could I use it for any of the cookies this week?

Is there anyone who tries all of the new cookies every week?

Does this mean Crumbl decided to remove them permanently?

In honor of Halloween and for those have been consuming Crumbl since its inception, what is your favorite cookie that has since ended up being put into the graveyard (was discontinued)? For those who don’t know, you can find the graveyard list on the app under cookie journal. I would say mine was the coconut cake cookie.

View Poll

personally prefer the milk chocolate (although neither are something particularly spectacular imo)

View Poll

This sub is getting flooded with top 10s &’ drowning out any actual discussions 😞

Are people creating their own rankings or can you rank in the app?

Hey, so I kind of got unlucky when ordering crumbl and it so happens that I’m unable to pick up the cookies the day I ordered. Is there a way to change the day on which I can pick them up? If I called, can they change the date themselves since I’m unable to on my end?