/r/comic_crits
The mission of /r/Comic_Crits is to provide holistic feedback to comic creators based on the understanding that a comic is not just 'writing plus art', but rather a unique combination of both, bound together with elements of graphic design, layout, timing, 'cinematography,' and more.
Remember: Don't downvote "bad" comics (they need feedback the most)
SUBREDDIT DESCRIPTION
The mission of /r/Comic_Crits is to provide holistic feedback to comic creators based on the understanding that a comic is not just 'writing plus art', but rather a unique combination of both, bound together with elements of graphic design, layout, timing, 'cinematography,' and more.
APPROPRIATE SUBMISSION
Original sequential art that you would like feedback on (i.e. more than one panel unless that is the entire comic)
Original scripts for sequential art
Comic art with appropriate context (see rules)
Anything else related to making comics will be accepted in proportion to original work (e.g. tools, tutorials, blogs or discussion about making comics, etc.)
RULES
Be civil
Mark NSFW submissions and comments
Site-wide rules apply. This includes
- the Reddit Content Policy,
- the Reddit Spam Policy,
- and in most cases the Reddiquette.
Context is required for anything other than sequential art. This includes, but is not limited to: single panels, covers, character designs, pin-ups, etc. At minimum, 'Context' should include some information about the setting and genre of your story, and what role your character/technology/landscape/etc plays in the story. More information.
No spam-like behavior. Some posts tread the line between content and spam. For example, Kickstarters can be part of a legitimate comic project, but if you don't participate in the community, and you're just doing a drive-by to ask for money, that looks like spam. To prevent your post from getting removed, indicate in your post title that you are looking for feedback on your work.
Avoid aggressive posting. It is helpful to remember that this sub is populated by your peers. Although they may organically become your fans or followers, their role here is to provide constructive criticism as a fellow comic-creator. This is not the appropriate place to ask for "likes" or "follows", or to provide page-by-page updates to your fans. In general, please try to limit your posts to approximately once every two weeks. Reasonable exceptions, such as a second post to show a revised page based on feedback, are fine. More information.
TIPS FOR GIVING FEEDBACK
Please don't downvote "bad" comics. They need feedback the most.
Remember that the purpose of this subreddit is to give constructive criticism, not just blind praise (or insults). Please endeavor to write top-level comments with at least 50-100 characters of content. More information.
TIPS FOR CREATORS
Link directly to your comic. As opposed to your blog homepage or other site sections.
Link to what you want feedback on. The most recent page if you're most concerned with art, or the first page or start of the chapter if you want feedback on the whole story arc.
Respond to questions and comments. Even if you don't agree with the feedback you receive. It's an important courtesy to acknowledge the individuals who take time to review your work.
Provide feedback to other creators! Responding to feedback in your own thread is the bare minimum of effort expected. This community only functions if people are willing to give as well as receive feedback.
USER & LINK FLAIR
You can self-assign link flair after making your post.
You can self-assign basic user flair from the sidebar.
Use modmail to request custom creator flair.
IF YOU DON'T SEE YOUR POST
- You may be caught in the spam filter. Use modmail to get rescued from the filter.
/R/COMIC_CRITS WIKI
Visit the Wiki for resources on making and publishing comics. Pages include:
Books and Articles: includes links to resources on how to make comics, how to draw, how to publish online, how to print DIY, where to find fonts, etc.
Website Design Tips: includes advice on how to design your own website or customize a pre-packaged solution.
Writing Tips: includes advice on how to assess your own writing, punch up your jokes, and find your "voice."
Comic Design & Layout: includes advice on how to layout your scenes so that the reader can follow them clearly.
Publishing and Business Plans: includes advice on how to decide on web vs. print and whether to run a Kickstarter.
Understanding of "Comics": includes definitions of "Comics" by Scott McCloud & Will Eisner.
How to Critique: includes tips on how to develop and write a critique (mainly focused on critiquing writing).
FILTER BY FLAIR
RELATED REDDITS
Related subreddits:
BANNER ART
By /u/Redfoxyboy (www.winstongambro.com)
/r/comic_crits
10,581 Subscribers
Does bad art make a bad comic?
Hey guys, so I've got a webcomic I've been working on since the beginning of the year. I love it, and it's brought a lot of joy to my life, but I'm struggling with knowing if the lack of attention it gets is due to the writing, the art, or maybe I'm just really bad at advertising, idk.
So what I'd like to know is where the story turns people away and why you think it does so. The art is objectively bad, especially at the beginning, but even with my improvements I don't think anyone would call it, "good." I'm getting better, and I can only do as well as my skill level in the moment, but is the art so distracting that it actively discourages readers? Is the writing the problem? Is it the concept?
There are lots of things that can be improved upon, and many areas I know I'm weak in, but I'm specifically looking for what makes people go, "nope, not worth my time." and click away. Thank you so much in advance!! https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/outcast-odyssey/welcome-to-purgatory-/viewer?title_no=933154&episode_no=1
03:04 UTC
(Spoilers for mild blood but nothing too serious just a panel or two) First page of Planetbound! Critiques wanted so I know what to change for future pages!
20:41 UTC
Xander the Demon, 60+ page fantasy, traditional comic CH.1
01:19 UTC
Should I post my 60 page one-shot or split it into smaller episodes?
title. it's a shonen sci fi script in the webtoon vertical scroll format. I have written the full 60 page script and currently looking for an artist to get it drawn. the plan is to use kickstarter to crowdfund money for more episodes after the first one is out. is it smarter to post it as one 60-page unit after hyping it up on social media for months, or should I split it up into smaller weekly episodes and buils up an audience that way? I'm just not sure the story works as well when split up into smaller chunks since it wasnt written with that in mind. I'll appreciate any answers. thank you.
12:42 UTC
Looking for some feedback on my comic. Link below.
16:46 UTC
dimension size for printing
hello, i'm looking to soon begin drawing my comic digitally. eventually, i want to print it physically. im leaning towards the self-publishing route for my comic. i envisioned my comic being the size of a typical manga (5 inches x 7.5 inches) but im very flexible with that. i just need help finding a template/size that's suitable for self-publishing so i dont waste weeks drawing something that wont work w/ printing.
12:20 UTC
Haunted - Critique and feedback greatly appreciated!
23:30 UTC
Showing of my cover for my own comic,
Plz give me criticism if needed i want to hear everything give your opinion freely
15:39 UTC
01:14 UTC
If anyone wants to make this a comic strip this idea can be yours
I have an idea for a comic panel of an over the shoulder shot of a guy on his phone posting an ig post of his dog who pooped in the house and the guy says to himself as he posts it some thing like “that’ll show him” or “now he’ll regret it” and then the next panel is an over the shoulder of the dog posted up, browsing his phone seeing the post saying to himself something like “that’s so embarrassing, I can’t believe he posted that, what a dick”
08:22 UTC
MY MINISERIES DRIFTED(what do y’all think)
I’ve been posting this gag manga series recently and was hoping if you guys could critique or even enjoy my yonkoma
04:46 UTC
Would appreciate any thoughts on this page and the art style over all!
00:58 UTC
I finished a comic page upon request for someone on tumblr
10:13 UTC