/r/ComicWriting

Photograph via snooOG

PLEASE READ RULES BEFORE POSTING.

Welcome to the comic writing workshop! If you encounter a specific problem in your comic writing, post it here for advice and solutions. NO CRITIQUE REQUESTS.

RULE 1.

Only posts directly related to comic book writing that help everyone with their scripts.

This reddit has a very specific purpose. It's a place where writers can come to improve their ABILITY TO WRITE... which in turn, allows others to learn and improve their ability.

It is NOT a place to come for ideas to finish your story. That's YOUR job.

Whether your story takes place on Mars or Venus, doesn't help other folks with their story.

Posts should create discussions where everyone can learn something and apply it to their own script.

RULE 2. Unless exempt here, non-comic writing posts are spam.

Posts not related to comic book writing, unless noted otherwise here, are considered spam and not allowed.

RULE 3. All Promo Posts must stay up for 30 days.

Promotional posts are allowed if they follow the rules posted here. * ALL Promo posts MUST Contain "PROMO" in the post title. *

1) Promo posts may not be deleted before 30 days from posting.

RULE 4. 20 posts posted before you repost any promo.

2) 20 posts must go up after your promo before you can repost your previous or any new promo.

RULE 5. All employment posts must be paid. No free work here.

3) All employment posts must be paid positions under the following minimums; New writer $10/page (less than 1 year or first paid project) Experienced $20/page (1-2 years or around 10 paid projects at this rate) Published $40/page (3-5 years or around 15 paid projects at this rate) Professional $50/page and up. (more than 5 years and over 25 paid projects at this rate)

No posts offering writing rates less than $10/page. The new standard in comic writing starts here.

RULE 6. Product or Crowdfund Promos Must be Posted By Writer.

You can't post for a friend. This is a writing community. Only writers can push their products or crowdfunds. If you want to give your friend's project post time, get them to send their writer to join the community. It's easy enough and maybe they'll stick around and contribute.

RULE 7. Artists can post service promos.

If you're an artist, you can self promo for your services (following the promo guidelines here), but not for your books or crowdfunds, send your writers over to promo those!

RULE 8. Non comic script, but comic related writing min. .04/word

Minimum rate for comic related, but non-comic script writing work posted here is $.04/word.

RULE 9. No generic project updates allowed.

Personal project updates must contain talking points for the community. The goal is to learn and improve.

Posting "Hey I'm almost done with my latest script," OR "Just letting everyone know I finished another 5 pages last night," etc. doesn't belong in this forum.

RULE 10. No multiple cross posts.

Cross posting in 30 different groups is spammy. You can cross post from 1 other group in a 72 hour period. Crossposts in 2 or more groups within that time frame will be deleted.

RULE 11. NO Unpaid Collaborations

No post for collaborations are allowed here. If you want to do that, there is a specific reddit for it. r/ComicBookCollabs

If you want a writer for this group, you must pay them as per Rule#5 OR follow the group and make a friend, then contact that friend directly to collab.

RULE 12. General Critiques Require 2 or more specific questions

If you're going to dump some content and ask if people like it, you need to include 2 or more specific questions on problem or difficult areas.

Remember the goal of this subreddit is that EVERYONE can learn something from every post.

If you can't bother to identify at least 2 specific question to help you improve your writing, then the group shouldn't be bothered to read it.

RULE 13. NO Privacy Walls

Do not ask people to contact you to review your content. That defeats the purpose of this group.

If you are not comfortable sharing your work, consider sharing a portion of it.

If you're not comfortable sharing at least a portion of your work, this writer's reddit group is not for you.


Related Subreddits

r/MakeComics

r/Comicbookart

r/Comic_Crits

/r/ComicWriting

14,348 Subscribers

13

How does one write a comic script?

I'm beginning a new project and want to try fully scripting out a few chapters before I draw them to see if it will make the process easier for me. How do you all write your scripts, at least format-wise? I'm unsure of where to start and would love some help.

7 Comments
2024/10/29
15:57 UTC

5

when a character is speaking, how long or short should an individual speech bubble be?

for example: if a panel's dialogue runs for 20 words, should those 20 words be in the same bubble, or should I divide it? if the latter, by what criteria?

I'm unsure whether these details are relevant or not. firstly, I use the nine-panel grid; secondly, my limit for one panel is 20 words; thirdly, I don't use thought bubbles.

my thanks.

11 Comments
2024/10/29
08:27 UTC

1

I want to write a comic about a pop star, but I don't know how to write music. What's the best way to work around this?

I have written a short 6 page comic as part of a collection of stories, but I want to elaborate on it.

I'm a big fan of movies about fictional pop stars, such as Vox Lux, Velvet Goldmine, and most recently, Smile 2.

I'm looking forward to any advice you all may provide.

13 Comments
2024/10/28
15:09 UTC

6

Do you guys make money from comic ?

I don't understand, cause we read manga for free (literally) anime are free to watch too.

How can we make money with our indie short comic ? Or it's just hobby ?

16 Comments
2024/10/28
15:04 UTC

8

Converting existing story into a comic script

Hi all, a published short story writer here, with no scripting experience. I have a short story on my hands which I'm working on turning into a script.

The comic is inherently a different medium from creative writing, and I'm often stumped by the translation, even though readers found my story to be very visually evoking and cinematic.

For example, I'm floundering with the pace and matching paneling to content. I have 16 scenes (two of them are bookending small blips)—should I strive to convert every scene into a page? Or should it be a bit per page? Or there's no hard and fast rule here except trying to make every page end so the reader wants to see the next one? How many pages do you usually do per scene?

Another one: what is the content limit of one panel? Is it one action, one key thought, or something else?

Please dump all your thoughts and considerations on me.

16 Comments
2024/10/28
13:54 UTC

0

How much would it cost to produce a 20 panels short comic ?

I'm a write and the cost probably just about paying artist.

20 panels. Colored. Simple illustrations style. How much should i expect to pay ? I don't have a big budget so.....

6 Comments
2024/10/28
12:23 UTC

15

Published writers, how did you find your artists?

I've been looking around at submission guidelines at various publishers and I am finding that most publishers don't accept scripts or project proposals from writers only. I was wondering how folks have found the artists that they have worked alongside since I am from a small town that doesn't have much of an arts scene. Any and all advice is appreciated and thank you in advance!

9 Comments
2024/10/26
18:15 UTC

7

Tips for maintaining a longform Wecomic/ Webtoon/ Graphic Novel?

We all know that longform comics are a marathon, not a sprint....but they can devolve into agonizing slogs, too.

I've been struggling with creating a longform webtoon/ webcomic because of my limited attention span, so for the longest time I concentrated on shorts, portfolio samples, and pitch packets. None of them really landed.

Recently I reopened an abandoned graphic novel script from three years ago. It was like coming home. Suddenly the plot holes from three years ago were easily resolved; I could finally see the shape of the book, the grand pattern. Now I plan to draw the whole thing as a webtoon/ webcomic.

However, the thought of drawing 300+ pages is daunting, even though I've drawn my own short comics and 200+-page gn's already (but not gn's I've written). I'm envious of creators who seem to dash off work so easily, page after page, for years. They develop a following and community that I want, too.

Creators, how do you maintain your dedication and inspiration while working on something as lengthy, slow, and time-consuming as a longform comic?

Thanks!

9 Comments
2024/10/26
02:55 UTC

9

What do you do to make a "boring, normal day" intro interesting?

I'm working on a series of one off comics for practice. I've finished the first issue's rough/1st draft. But I'm trying to figure out how to make the into more interesting.

The series premise is a modern/fantasy city plagued by various apocalypse scenarios. The first one is zombies. In a retail store in a mall, it's a slow day, and then zombies happen.

So far I've got a 2 page intro that I'll do variations on for every issue. Where it's an eagle eye view of the city, that then zooms into where in the city shit's going down. Then it's each character getting a page introducing them through just showing what they're doing at the moment.

Manger is yelling for folks to get off their phones, while looking at weird or funny shit on his.

Two employees at the counter, one is telling a boring/bad story, the other is throwing out "that's crazy" and "oh dang"s.

Then the two friends shopping some records, giving each other shit.

And finally the District Manager shows up to kinda round out the group/collect them all at the front counter.

I'm just having trouble figuring out mundane dialogue, or interesting art stuff that won't make a reader lose interest. The entire point of the comic is just to practice art and writing. But I still want it to be the best I can do. And maybe turn it into something bigger by bringing the survivors from each one off together.

So how do you make something boring interesting?

9 Comments
2024/10/23
18:25 UTC

15

I think I have a really good idea but have no idea where to start

I am an artist first and a writer second, I decided to pick comics because I want to use my art to tell stories. I have a clear idea of the setting and protagonist but what I am struggling with is the actual writing. I am confused about how to start it; I know a bit about writing, mostly short stories and a bit about film, but I'm not sure about comics. It seems like it might be similar to film because a lot of it is visual, I'm just wondering what guidelines are there for writing comics? I've tried looking up different methods but most are far more vague than they would be for film or short story writing.

10 Comments
2024/10/21
20:13 UTC

2

PROMO] Dive into the wild world of Solu to the Rescue! This sci-fi young adult comic blends superhero adventures with relatable coming-of-age themes, featuring a character who’s on a journey to prove he’s more than his past. Link: https://linktr.ee/solutotherescue

0 Comments
2024/10/21
20:09 UTC

4

Advice on writing a plot for 20 panel comic

So, art school entrance tests in my country consists of drawing a short comic based on a prompt they give, and I'm having trouble coming up with a satisfying story that I can put in a 20 panel comic while practicing for that. Main piece of advice I've heard is to structure it like a joke; clear setup and then punchline - but while that sounds true, I can't quite grasp how to come up with an interesting 'punchline' with a clear message, and also make it surprising. Any help appreciated

15 Comments
2024/10/20
05:47 UTC

6

Any artists have experience hiring a writer?

To elaborate, I already have a full story outline with some pages of various scenes written. But I've been in the process of reworking my comic into a strict 22-24 page format and the scope of the project is getting too overwhelming to handle all by myself. So what I really need is a collaborator to write the issues; break down the outline into scenes in a full script by-the-issue, as well as be frank about what works & what doesn't, what should happen instead of this plot line etc. This is a lot of work and I'm not sure what rates typically are for this, so I'd like to know if anyone here has experience with hiring a writer/being hired as a writer and if you can share any advice.

14 Comments
2024/10/17
20:08 UTC

0

[Promo] Aces - Detailed Manga Comic Design. I designed this comic and it was a great experience.

1 Comment
2024/10/17
16:18 UTC

4

As a writer, how do I get an artists for a comic?

So its nothing very serious, but I'm currently writing my first chapter for a comic sort of like a pilot, just to get the idea out there since I'm back logged on other projects, but I've focused more of my life on the writing portion of comics rather on the drawing portion so I was wondering how I'm able to get a professional artists? I already have some sketches laid out for it that give out the main idea of what each panel would look like but where I would look for other artists?

15 Comments
2024/10/15
21:09 UTC

0

End on an even or odd number

Do the story or each act in the story end on an even or odd number? Also how many pages per act usually?

Thanks in advance

4 Comments
2024/10/15
02:16 UTC

20

Want to make an NSFW comic, but with actual characters and plot and stuff, not just p*rn.

Possibly my favorite part of story writing is the world, character arcs, plot arc, etc., and I like to incorporate that into everything I do. However, now that I want to make something NSFW, adding actual story seems to be uncharted territory. This personally really annoys me, just cause p*rn is thought of as shameful by society doesn't mean some of it can't have as much or more plot than a kid's cartoon. I'm going to try to stray away from harmful tropes and stuff obviously (such as lesbian sex targeted towards men rather than actual lesbians, which is gross and reprehensible) but any tips on how I can do this? So far, best allegory for what I'm trying to do is 50 Shades of Grey, and oh my god I do not want to end up anything like that awful book. Any advice? Thanks.

For context, it will be Sci-Fi, and probably targeted towards cis men and amab trans/nonbinary people for the most part, who like girls.

28 Comments
2024/10/14
23:01 UTC

7

Advice on creating a portfolio as a writer

Hi All,

I am a brand new comic writer who just completed my first script. I am currently working with an artist to bring the script to life, and am very excited to see the finished product.

As I was looking ahead towards the completion of this comic, I was contemplating the best way to document it in my portfolio. Do I just post the finished product as is? Do I include a few pages of my script along with the finished pages so viewers can compare the two? Would love to hear other people’s thoughts on this subject.

Also, if anyone has any recommendations on a portfolio website (Behance, DeviantArt, etc.) I would love to hear those as wells.

Thanks for taking the time to read my post!

8 Comments
2024/10/13
06:43 UTC

6

At what point in writing a script do you typically ask folks for peer review? Or ask for their opinions?

I am working on starting a..I guess series of one off stories that, story-wise, is about a city plagued by various apocalypse. So basically, a bunch of one off stories that has potential to tie together. If I want to make something out of it. Also one setting because it's easier.

Function-wise, is really only meant to be practice. So I can learn and get some practice in the art and writing sides of creating comics. And use what I learn to make the actual series I'd like to work on.

Well, I've finished the first draft of the scrip. And it absolutely needs re-working. It takes place over maybe 30 minutes. Employees of a retail store in a modern/fantasy shopping mall have to deal with zombies. Simple.

The dialogue needs a redo. The intro segment needs re-working to make it interesting. Lots to do.

But at what point do I ask friends (not a lot, just those i feel could give solid feedback) if they'd be willing to look at it?

5 Comments
2024/10/12
06:50 UTC

3

How do you approach promoting your work?

I have basically no social media following. I'll be honest, I don't really love mist social media or trying to chase clout, but it's an unfortunate reality of the world we live in.

I'm very far into a project right now. Somehwere between 1/2 and 2/3rds done with page art.(approximately 80 pages of story total)

At that point I want to try and release and print it but I don't really know how to go about that. I have some ideas but I would love some advice from people whove successfully managed to get a comic out there.

My general plan has been the following: Continue to post sketches/other art i produce aside from comic. This is difficult as I don't have tons of time to draw nonpaid work outside my comic. I'm working a full-time job as well.

Build out a Kickstarter with a small goal as the Kickstarter is only for printing costs. As I'm writing and drawing I don't have any costs associated with production. I would then try and get as much support as possible through my existing networks(handful of Twitter artists friends who would probably signal boost me a few times if I asked)

Try to identify different blogs or yt channels that review comics and give them free digital copies of the book.

Once I have physical books table at local cons if possible. Talk directly to local LCS shops to see if they might stock copies in their indie sections if they exist.

Submit to one of the publishers with open submissions. I don't think they'd help with printing costs, but I'm hopeful they could at least help me get listed in diamond or some distributor? I'm hoping that having the project completed in its entirety might help my odds getting picked up. Many only require a handful of completed pages. Is this assessment offense?

I could try uploading the comic page by page to a dedicated webcomic platform, but this really inst a webcomic. It's structured in pages and is intended to be read more like a traditional comic/manga

If anyone has any other ideas for promotion I'm not thinking of I'm all ears. If you know of specific reviewers or channels I should look to approach for potential reviews I'm all ears as well.

4 Comments
2024/10/09
06:51 UTC

6

What do you present an editor with, before you properly start?

So some background:

I'm an artist/writer and I want to show my work to an editor

I have an entire volume of a comic basically fully figured out, but before I storyboard/write an official script for the whole thing, I want to run my ideas by my editor, but I have no idea how to present them without just doing an entire script.

They suggested I give them an outline, but every time I try and write an outline of the bigger storybeats, i feel like its missing so much that any feedback given on it would be met with me saying "well this happens because of xyz but i left it out" Or another worry is it being so vague and watered down that it doesnt remotely give the feeling of how anything will actually play out, and now theyre giving feedback on something irrelevant

Is there any point in laboring over an outline like this?

Should I just write a full script and send them that??

I started doing something in between, like a very detailed outline, but now it just feels like I'm writing the script and leaving out all the flavor that makes it entertaining.

How do people present finished stories in a digestible way?

3 Comments
2024/10/08
14:22 UTC

16

[PROMO] My superhero/vigilante comic is now on Kickstarter!

https://preview.redd.it/ztmjvequ2dtd1.jpg?width=1748&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=73fcb14bef1954717d05144b16eb5252fac5ce8f

Hello everybody! After several months of hard work, I've finally taken the big leap into crowdfunding with the first issue of my creator owned comic EMERGENT: Retribution! 24 pages filled to the brim with action, masked vigilantes and good old-fashioned revenge, all of it written and drawn by yours truly!
It would mean a lot to me if you took a moment and checked out my campaign page, where you'll also find links to my previous comic EMERGENT #0 which is available for FREE, so don't miss out!

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/emergentcomic/emergent-retribution-1

0 Comments
2024/10/07
16:34 UTC

12

Advice for Script Writing

Hi folks, I'm new to here and new to the artform as well. I've written three or four scripts for fun, but I feel a little lost when it comes to format and content. I've done a little research on different styles of scriptwriting and I find myself gravitating to a more "DC Style" of detail in my script. I was wondering if anyone could point me towards some general guidelines to follow when writing and how to properly format a script. Thanks for any and all info!

4 Comments
2024/10/05
01:07 UTC

8

How much story to put in a Oneshot?

(Oneshot, meaning 25-30 pages with a standalone story from beginning to end with full closure.) Im currently trying a oneshot script but I dont like the "A day in the life of a character" type that people suggest for oneshots, I want to tell more than one day. I want to tell multiple small happenings and real charakter developments, but its so hard to get the pacing down. It feels everything is happening to fast... Any tipps out there?

(If u have suggestions for closed Oneshot titles out there that are telling over a period of time, that also would be super helpful)

15 Comments
2024/10/04
05:59 UTC

Back To Top