/r/cogsci

Photograph via snooOG

The interdisciplinary study of the mind and intelligence, embracing philosophy, psychology, artificial intelligence, neuroscience, linguistics, and anthropology.

A community for those who are interested in the mind, brain, language and artificial intelligence.

Posting rules:

  • This is not a self-help sub. Posts must be about cognitive science. Occasional threads of general interest (discussion of careers in Cog Sci, for example) may be allowed.

  • Currently, calls for participation in scientific studies are allowed. See our policy on that here.

  • All posts must be about cognitive science. Pseudoscience, claims not backed by peer-reviewed science, and the like are not allowed.

  • All decisions on posts, bans, etc. are at the discretion of the moderators. All such decisions are final, and appeals (and especially complaints) will likely be ignored.


Want to know more? Take a look at our reading list here. If you have any suggestions for further inclusions, post them here.


AskScience Science ScienceNet
Psych CogSci Neuro
CogLing IOPsych PsychSci
BehEcon Music Cog NooTropics
NeuroPsych MathPsych Psychopharm
Linguistics PsychoPath Academic Psych
NeuroPhilosophy CogNeuro Multilink

/r/cogsci

122,105 Subscribers

0

I want to know what you call the lobotomy of a species. Laboticide. Mass prefrontal tissue displacement. The c.i.a. has a word for it.

Has anyone studied the mind? The two systems that are easily manipulated. Anyone? What is known for hijacking these systems? What is the per capita of the nation affected? Can it be lethal. How many people are dying due to this molestation a year. All the answers are in reading format. And digitally as well as o.g. Oh, please don't leave comments. Unless you are increasing my life quality. Just move along.

0 Comments
2024/11/10
05:19 UTC

7

Should I major in Math or Philosophy to prepare for a Masters In Cogsci

(My school doesn't offer CogSci)
I originally planned to go to a school that offered a bachelors in cogsci but my current university gave me a full-ride. So instead I decided to major in computer science. Fast-forward a year and half and I want to leave this major so badly. I just no longer have any interested in coding classes, not to mention how tanked my GPA is because of that.
I am going to take a CS minor, but now I am wondering which major to choose. Philosophy or Math? I know I'll probably hear "just do the one that interests you the most". But I would love to hear from some of you who might've majored in math or philosophy and then went on this field. Thank you.

7 Comments
2024/11/09
07:46 UTC

0

Anthropology proves that Psychology is not a science.

I've heard that 80% of psychological tested can not be replicated. Particularly when tried cross culturally. Should Psychologists really be programming our brains?

1 Comment
2024/11/08
13:19 UTC

3

Pursue CogSci Masters or keep going in my MIS Master ?

Background: I‘m a 27 year old german student. I have a bachelor in Business Psychology where the focus was mainly Psychology. Based on my work experience I decided to switch subjects to a more technical master. This is my first semester in MIS and I‘m a little Bit disspointed with the topics and lack of technical focus. Its been also somewhat of a career decision and less of pure interest. I look back at myself and at my bachelors and had the most fun and best Grades in Cognitive Psychology and Biological Psychology. Always been interested in the Human Mind, Cognition, Perception and AI. I recently also discovered that Neuroscience is damn interesting.

But I‘m not really interested in an academic career.

Anybody got some advice ?

Possible to land a job in e.g healthcare or industry with a CogSci Master ?

Pursue something that interests me more but has worse job outlooks or stay in MIS ?

Thanks in advance!

1 Comment
2024/11/08
12:39 UTC

11

Is there any open courses for CogSci self-learning?

Hello there! I’m currently learning CogSci on my own while doing my 9 to 5 jobs. I plan to pursue CogSci academically but not right now. Could you please recommend any free and open CogSci course you know?

3 Comments
2024/11/07
13:06 UTC

10

Cognitive science and or neuroscience

Hi everybody,

I have very recently decided to start a Bsc in Psychology (3 years online university degree). I already have an MSc in Political Science from the early 2000s.

I have been admitted to the second year i thanks to my first degree and a post diploma course in preventing gender violence I just recelty finished.

I don't have major working aspirations, I am kind of an older lady (50). My main goal would be to study what really interests me. I have always been passionated about sociology, and social psychology, but life is life plus my poor choices and judgment...

I had to work jobs that are not in any way related to my interests nor to my previous degree.

Recently I have discovered a few really strong passions: 2 years ago I started to learn how to play guitar and i am sticking to it, gender studies (i volonteer in a women shelter), cognitive science, neuroscience and the good old social psychology.

Music and guitar aside, I would like to persue at least some of my passions.

I think those studies can cross paths at some point, cultural, social, individual, cognitive and if i cannot find that path i would at least like to try and study a few of them individually.

I would like to do an MA or MSc after Psychology, maybe even two.

I live in Italy, could travel a bit but still have a small(ish) kid (10). The older one is 18 and is going to college next year. Online courses would be perfect (academic, not only coursera, edx..)

Do you have any suggestion or recommendation?

Of course I wouldn't refuse a new career opportunity if it came around, it is just not what my goal is right now.

Thanks and sorry for the messy post.

4 Comments
2024/11/04
15:35 UTC

4

Need help or advice on a mental or psychological problem

What can cause someone to feel that the world is confusing, have tics like shaking stuffs in his hands, walking around in circles, overthinking, overlap of ideas, moving his lips, talking with himself while thinking, and what are the best solutions?

4 Comments
2024/11/04
10:09 UTC

2

Question about a certain mental health problem that happens to children

What can cause 4.5-year-old to lose his speech for a few months, have tics like shaking stuff in his hands, feeling confused, and suffer from cognitive decline and some vision decline? That happened to me when I was a kid.

2 Comments
2024/11/04
10:07 UTC

0

Grandma's Fall thought experiment

Hey all! The other day, I came across an interesting thought experiment, so thought that I'd share it here.

Imagine this: you're sitting in a uni lecture, and suddenly receive a text message from your grandmother letting you know that she had a serious fall about an hour ago.

The reaction of most people in this scenario would be one of sadness / worry. Of course, we would all agree that your grandmother falling over is not a good thing.

However, let's think about how the "goodness" of the world has changed after you receiving the text message. Before receiving the message, your grandmother had already fallen. After receiving the message, your grandmother had still fallen, but we now have the benefit of you knowing about the fall, meaning that you may be able to provide help, etc. In actual fact, you receiving the message has improved the "goodness" of the world.

Now, sure, your perceived goodness of the world has decreased upon reading the text message - one minute, you were enjoying your uni lecture, and the next, you learn that your grandmother is injured.

However, that's just your perception of world "goodness". The actual "goodness" metric has increased. The fall happened an hour ago, and the fact that you received a text about it is a good thing.

So here's the question: should a truly rational agent actually be happy upon hearing that their grandmother has had a fall?

I first heard about this paradox the other day, when my mate brought it up on a podcast that we host named Recreational Overthinking. If you're keen on philosophy and/or rationality, then feel free to check us out on Spotify or Apple Podcasts. You can also follow us on Instagram at @ recreationaloverthinking.

Keen to hear people's thoughts on the thought experiment in the comments!

20 Comments
2024/11/01
20:03 UTC

0

Using My Brain To Its Full Potential

What strategies can I adopt to use my brain to its fullest potential and enhance my cognitive abilities?

4 Comments
2024/11/01
05:25 UTC

3

The Telepathy Tapes Podcast

Has anyone listed to this podcast? It's stil running but I just listened to the first 7 episodes after someone sent it to me. It discusses telepathy and related phenomena, particularly related to autism and savant syndrome.

It's very compelling but I can't get past my skepticism. Can anyone more intelligent and well versed in this subject than I am offer any sort of rebuttal?

17 Comments
2024/11/01
04:18 UTC

2

Is getting into a CogSci masters program realistic for a screenwriting MFA/philosophy minor without lab or psych experience?

Sorry if posts like these are considered pollution in this sub, but would be very grateful for a little guidance.

Graduated magna cum laude from a top five film school—I’m sure I could get some nice recs from professors, but other than that I’m not sure I have much to offer. I’d be lying if I said my resume was particularly impressive, especially this last year (graduated in 23)

I took and thoroughly enjoyed a neuroscience course as well as a couple of psych ones while I was at school. I’ve always been fascinated by the brain, and I’m sure much has already been made here about future prospects for cogsci professionals as AI becomes increasingly relevant (unless I’m missing the mark here. Please don’t hesitate to tear me apart)

I’m a pretty smart dude, and confident I’d be able to put in the work were I to be admitted somewhere

In all honesty, though, this is a prospect that I came upon relatively recently—I’m a little unclear as to what exactly an admissions team would be looking for, and suspect the answer is not me

I’m not necessarily asking for a “how to get into grad school” walkthrough, but if I have a snowball’s chance it couldn’t hurt to think about hedging my bets/looking elsewhere.

Thanks in advance

0 Comments
2024/11/01
00:35 UTC

15

What are some jobs I can get with a Cognitive Science degree?

Hey yall, I am currently a freshmen uni student studying software engineering right now and I was thinking of changing my major to Cognitive Science since it interests me more and I like how it blends psychology neuroscience and computer science together. I have always been fascinated by the mind and it's processes and I just found out that my school (UT Dallas) offers a degree in that so I feel pretty fortunate about it, though I'm still thinking if I want to switch or not, but I was wondering what are some of the careers I can get into after i graduate especially if I do concentrations in AI and human computer interaction? My school as 4 concentration areas but I need to choose 2. Any info is appreciated!!

13 Comments
2024/10/31
19:03 UTC

2

New LSAT w/out logic games

Does anyone know what specific areas of intelligence the LSAT Logic Games were testing? I'm curious about how the removal of the section will impact it's ability to measure IQ accurately.

2 Comments
2024/10/31
03:52 UTC

1

Course Program Master Degree

Hi guys,

I'm interested in the cognitive neuroscience field, especially related to computational simulation of perception.

I'm about to enter a master, but I'm unaware if it's more prone to the philosophical aspect, rather than a technical BCI oriented one. Here's the program breakdown:

  • ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
  • INTRODUCTION TO PYTHON
  • NEUROPSYCHOLOGY
  • PHENOMENOLOGY
  • PHILOSOPHY OF MIND
  • DEEP LEARNING
  • LINGUISTICS IN COGNITIVE SCIENCE
  • ETHNOLOGY AND ETHNOPSYCHIATRY6
  • PSYCHOPATHOLOGY OF LANGUAGE
  • HUMAN COMPUTER INTERACTION
  • SOCIAL SEMIOTICS
  • THINKING AND SOCIAL COGNITION
  • PHILOSOPHY OF COMPUTING
  • PHILOSOPHY OF PERCEPTION
  • INTRODUCTION TO PYTHON
  • MEDIA THEORY
  • MEDICAL ANTHROPOLOGY

Would such subjects allow me a to pivot in a technical position or is too much "humanities"?

1 Comment
2024/10/30
14:09 UTC

11

Is a Master’s in Cognitive Science worth it if I don’t want to go into research?

Hey everyone,

I’m currently studying Psychology in Germany and considering switching to Cognitive Science for my Master’s. However, I’m not sure if it’s the right choice because I’m not really interested in pursuing a career in research. The working conditions in research aren’t very appealing to me—especially the idea of having to move every 3–5 years for temporary contracts. I’d like to build a stable future and eventually start a family without constantly having to relocate.

Are there any people here who have experience with a Cognitive Science Master’s and ended up outside of research? What kind of career options are there? I’d be particularly interested to know if it’s possible to work in areas like consulting, technology, or even science communication.

Thanks a lot for any advice or experiences you can share!

6 Comments
2024/10/30
09:28 UTC

2

Eating Behaviour Study

Looking for 300 people to participate in my eating behaviour study. You get the chance to win one of three £20 Amazon vouchers ! https://bbk.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_2fYxTHmgjQN1hZk

1 Comment
2024/10/29
07:57 UTC

5

How ‘Human’ Are NLP Models in Conceptual Transfer and Reasoning? Seeking Research on Cognitive Plausibility!

Hello folks, I'm doing research on few-shot learning, conceptual transfer, and analogical reasoning in NLP models, particularly large language models. There’s been significant work on how models achieve few-shot or zero-shot capabilities, adapt to new contexts, and even demonstrate some form of analogical reasoning. However, I’m interested in exploring these phenomena from a different perspective:

How cognitively plausible are these techniques?

That is, how closely do the mechanisms underlying few-shot learning and analogical reasoning in NLP models mirror (or diverge from) human cognitive processes? I haven’t found much literature on this.

If anyone here is familiar with:

  • Research that touches on the cognitive or neuroscientific perspective of few-shot or analogical learning in LLMs
  • Work that evaluates how similar LLM methods are to human reasoning or creative thought processes
  • Any pointers on experimental setups, papers, or even theoretical discussions that address human-computer analogies in transfer learning

I’d love to hear from you! I’m hoping to evaluate the current state of literature on the nuanced interplay between computational approaches and human-like cognitive traits in NLP.

4 Comments
2024/10/28
21:13 UTC

3

Seeking Participants for DClinPsy Thesis: Investigating Patterns of Online Dating Apps, Self Image, and Self Perception

Hi everyone, My name is Amber and I am in my final year of study of the Doctorate in Clinical Psychology at UCL. I am currently recruiting participants for my thesis investigating patterns of online dating app use and its impact on self-image and self-perception. I am hoping to recruit around 400 participants to complete my survey, it takes 10 minutes and is completely anonymous. If anyone would be interested in participating, please follow the link below!

Understanding Patterns of Online Dating App Use (ucl.ac.uk)

This study has been approved by the UCL Ethics Committee: Ethical approval no. 26999/001

If you have any questions please do not hesitate to contact me!

Thank you, your help is greatly appreciated! :)

0 Comments
2024/10/28
20:42 UTC

3

Simple explanation of the default mode network?

Hi. Forgive my ignorant question but I watched dr. K’s video on this topic and I got interested. So here goes: The default mode network activates when we are not focused on a particular task… and does what exactly? I mean I know that the brain is not well understood but to our knowledge (as humans) what is its function? Or rather if you used electrodes to ‘turn it off’ what would be missing from that person? The video mentioned that overactivity of the DMN is connected to things like anxiety and depression. Is this true/proven? Are there mental disorders that are related to the DMN’s over/under-activity?

2 Comments
2024/10/28
12:10 UTC

3

Attention, multitasking and coordination/motor control

Hello everyone,

I am currently looking for possible topics for my master's thesis and I recently had a very interesting idea:

From what I know about exercise science, coordination as a whole cannot be trained and transfer effects are very small or non-existent (only when the tasks are very similar can a transfer effect be observed). From what I know about cognitive psychology, it is controversial whether attention can be trained or impaired by multitasking (MT). Currently, there are two conflicting theories: the trained-attention hypothesis (MT improves attention because parallel processing of information gets better) and the scattered-attention hypothesis (MT worsens attentional control because attention is too scattered). The way attention is measured can vary, and this seems to me to be the crux of the matter. If switching between tasks/redirecting attention is required, you will see improvements/positive effects with more and more training. If focusing on a single task/object is required, reallocation of attention is seen as a negative effect.

In addition, studies have shown that playing action video games improves spatial and temporal attention, as well as top-down attention, vigilance, and visual working memory. Some studies also suggest that they can improve verbal working memory in older people.

Now to my main idea. Since coordination and attention training follow the same pattern (what is trained gets better, transfer effects are rare) and have the same underlying mechanism (systematic activation of neurons), identifying transfer effects in attention tasks may indicate that these cognitions are similar/related. So I want to find out which cognitions can be improved by different types of video games (e.g. action, strategy) and how big these transfer effects are, if there are any. Furthermore, it might be possible that training attention/MT and coordination together could yield even greater results through synergetc effects.

Okay, this is as far as I have thought about it for now. I know there are still some links missing and I need to improve my argumentation. I also don't know if this is even a plausible research topic, since this is not exactly my scientific domain. So I would like to hear your opinion and thoughts on this. Thanks in advance!!

2 Comments
2024/10/27
21:24 UTC

1

One EMNLP has plagiarized my work

One recently accepted EMNLP paper titled "Towards a Semantically-aware Surprisal Theory"  (Meister et al., 2024)(https://arxiv.org/pdf/2410.17676),  in which the authors introduce the concept of similarity-adjusted surprisal. Although surprisal is a well-established concept, this paper presents a weighting algorithm, z(w<t,wt,w′), which adjusts surprisal based on the (semantic) similarity between wt and other words w′ in the vocabulary. This approach allows the model to account for both the probability of a word and its similarity to other contextually appropriate words.

I would like to bring to your attention that the algorithm for similarity-based weighting was first proposed in my preprint series from last year (my work titled "Optimizing Predictive Metrics for Human Reading Behavior" https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.09.03.556078v2arXiv:2403.15822;  arXiv:2403.18542). In these preprints, I also detailed the integration of semantic similarity with surprisal to generate more effective metrics, including the methodology and theoretical foundation. Additionally, I’d like to provide my other related research using such metrics. My earlier work on contextual semantic similarity for predicting English reading patterns was published in Psychonomic Bulletin & Review (https://doi.org/10.3758/s13423-022-02240-8). Recent work on predicting human reading across other languages will appear in Linguistics, Cognition. Moreover, more preprints expand on using these metrics in modeling human neural activity during language comprehension and visual processing:

https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2410.09921
https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2404.14052

Despite clear overlap, the accepted paper (Meister et al., 2024) has not cited my work, and its primary contributions and methods (including research objective) closely mirror my algorithms and ideas released earlier than this accepted paper.

Additionally, I observed that multiple papers on surprisal at major conferences (EMNLP) originate from the same research group. In contrast, my paper submission to EMNLP 2024 (based on arXiv:2403.15822 and available at OpenReview) received unusually low ratings, despite the originality of my approach involved with upgrading surprisal algorithms. These patterns raise concerns about potential biases in the panel of cognitive modeling research in EMNLP that may hinder the fair evaluation and acknowledgment of novel contributions.

In light of these overlaps and broader implications, I respectfully request a formal review of the aforementioned paper’s originality and citation practices, and I ask that the paper be withdrawn pending this review. EMNLP holds a strong reputation in NLP and computational linguistics, plagiarism or breaches of academic ethics are not tolerated.

1 Comment
2024/10/27
11:20 UTC

13

Best cognitive science schools California

Thinking about transferring back to California cause my college doesn’t have cognitive science, I know ucsd has good cognitive science what other Cali schools have good cognitive science?

7 Comments
2024/10/27
03:52 UTC

7

Weirdly Good memories

I just wanted to know what is up with my mom and I.

My mom has a really good memory for remembering faces, doesn't even have to get close to someone or talk to them, she just remembers them if she comes across them and can tell you where she saw them first.

I have a strangely good memory for conversations. I can recall all conversations and I can even tell them word for word. I usually creep people out just from the fact I can remember conversations from over 10+ years ago. I could even repeat conversations told to me word for word, as if I lived that experience and was telling the story. I don't even know I have those memories, they just pop up when l'm having a conversation with that person. Suddenly it's like I have a whole archive of conversations with said person at my disposal.

Is this something that's inherited?

5 Comments
2024/10/25
03:47 UTC

6

Cognitive words/expressions yet to be defined

Hey, I'm a 2nd year CogSci student and have been given a task to translate a specific Cognitive word/expression into my language which doesn't have a clear translation yet. Do you know any rather difficult Cognitive expressions to translate from English?

5 Comments
2024/10/24
21:54 UTC

5

Future direction and career insight

Im a university student, and im interested in studying cognitive. Im not yet sure what stream specifically and need help because i dont know what would be a good fit for me.

I enjoy computer science and the logic of problem solving so i am looking into doing a minor in cs as well. However, i also like the deep thinking aspect of cognitive science. I can sit and ponder on a thought for a long time and I like to always try and problem solve and enjoy that process. I love solving puzzles and love to challenge my brain. I like philosophy and psychology, and linguistics maybe the a little less. Im interested in ai and the way we think and how our brain works.

Im also not sure what kind of career paths are related to what specific stream you study in cognitive science. Will it matter since you focus on different aspects of cognitive science?

Any advice or general knowledge would be appreciated as i dont really know much about cogs and what it has to offer

1 Comment
2024/10/24
10:56 UTC

18

Are humans 'hardwired' to be religious, spiritual, belief in God etc

19 Comments
2024/10/23
06:30 UTC

8

Donuts and psychedelics: Homological scaffolds of brain functional networks

0 Comments
2024/10/20
21:20 UTC

Back To Top