It's not bad..... I'm keeping the Olehendriksen facial oil & the Natasha Denona eyeshadow palette. Everything else will be gifted at Christmas if I get it before. If not it's for Birthdays or Mother's Day. I bought a few hair ties for $3.50 x2, eyeshadow brush set $3.50 for Christmas. Again hoping I get it before Christmas. 🙄..... .....I can't remember. Nothing too exciting. The hair ties are the only thing I'm keeping. Makes Christmas affordable. I think I'll be on a long pause starting January 2025.... Not sure how long. I'm getting it faster than I can use everything. Even gifting most of it isn't really helping. ...... Now I'm rambling. 😆

❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️

To be honest the only thing I’m looking forward to is the Amika hair mask, the first two were things I couldn’t choose and I’m not really excited for some random concealer and serum. The blush pallet looks like it could be nice as well. Idk haha maybe I’m just being picky because I loved my icon box last month

Excited for all the good brands!

Last box I got, I made all my choices in the correct timeframe and none of them are what I received. It was all a bunch of stuff I had no use for, and while annoyed… I took my loss and tried to find use for the products. I was told by support they “try to accommodate selections but it’s not guaranteed and I made mine late” so, ok do better next month. I actually DO need some stuff right now and can’t really afford to get nonsense items again this time of year. I checked my bank account and the auto draft just came out today but I’m entirely unable to select anything at all.

Is this the case for any of you as well? I already emailed support and told them to cancel my box and refund my money if I can’t select anything at all. There are plenty of subscription boxes that will send me items and products I actually want.

I haven't been a member of boxy charm since 2019 because I have so much makeup but I miss trying new things and I got introduced to a lot of great brands and products because of boxy charm. i was debating joining again but everything is so different?

one of my favorite things used to be the shop they had, is the shop they have now open to nonmembers?

how is the selection for the monthly boxes now? is it worth it?

My November 2024 Second Account BoxyCharm Choices and Add Ons.

Has anybody tried any of these before? Does the Dermalactives spray smell like apple cider? I am pretty sure I will like the Byroe, Ren, and add ons. I thought the Cinta London was a hair spray when I read the Super Hold part but now I realize it is actually for makeup. Has anyone tried it before?

I still haven’t received my October box?! The tracking update just says moving through network since 10/14. Has this happened to anyone else? What did you do?

I’m in Canada so the icon box with tax and conversion comes out to a bit over $100 for me, it’s my first time doing the icon box and I’m excited!

How do you guys feel about the products included in this months icon box?

I’m in Canada so the icon box with tax and conversion comes out to a bit over $100 for me, it’s my first time doing the icon box and I’m excited!

How do you guys feel about the products included in this months icon box?

I recently signed up for boxy charm last month. I got my October box a few days ago. I was under the impression that I would be able to “pick” some things for the next box (November) around the 1st of the month but it looks like they’re already working on it but I never got the option. Did I miss it or is that not a thing?

Hi guys! I used to be a member in 2020-2021 and I’m considering subscribing again but I see Ipsy has acquired boxy? Has quality improved? Are they still using white label products?

I mainly wanted to return for the pop up shops, is that still a thing?

If someone could give me a rundown of what it’s like now I would very much appreciate it ❤️

I go through my makeup every few months and toss anything that hasn't been used in X amount of time. These are all from past boxy's/shops. My personal fav is the makeup forever cream contour kit and I use it almost daily (a little goes a long way with it which is a plus). Anyone still sporting things from the old-school BC?

I got this eyeliner a while ago from my boxy charm and it’s almost gone :( it’s the best eyeliner I’ve ever had and I want to buy another one BUT I have no idea what brand it is anymore for obvious reasons lol , anyone wanna take a guess and what the brand could be??

I don't get the point of them upping their price and all that and having us choose if we don't even receive 5 items. This is the 3rd time this has happened to me. I only got 3 items. They didn't even give 2 replacements if they were out. Now I get to fight with them through emails again. Grrrr!! Anyone else keep having this issue?

Anyone else not received their September boxy?

Maybe I’m out of the loop but usually I think we see a clue for icon by now? Anyone see anything or have any guesses?

Pretty pleased with it!

I wasn't sure if I was going to like this month's box, but it turned out better than expected even though some of my choice options were awful. My power picks were the Seraphim's Diamante Highlighter, and the Clara's New York Vitamin C serum. I had wanted the Tula serum and the Luna highlighter pallette they showed up in choice but didn't want doubles. I ended getting mostly what I wanted. Super psyched about the Eloise Goddess eyeshadow, and the Kevin Aucoin lipstick. He was a legend and from my hometown. I was surprised to see a Dr.Brandt cleanser. I didn't want a lip liner I definitely jumped on that. The brand is fantastic. I'm actually it's been too long since I got any actual makeup. Especially eyeshadow and lip color

Oct 2024

Choice opened early for me, like around 10:40ish CT. I made sure to snag the Tula & First Aid Beauty since that’s what I really wanted. Idk how I feel about the makeup products lol. Other than that not to shabby.

I was under the impression I'd get to pick out my October picks since I got an email to "rejoin and build my box" and choose 3 products for October. But after re-enrolling it just said this. Do I not get to choose any items? Or does it become available later? Pretty disappointing if not.

https://preview.redd.it/y21p0qxm59rd1.png?width=1110&format=png&auto=webp&s=e10dfab9243367a84766df107dadc1962a3b34f2

Was able to snag 2 as add ons. Just started wearing it this week and the projection and longevity for me are great. 10hrs +. Loving it!

This may be just me but I feel like sometimes after I make my selections, they get changed after the fact? For example, this month I’m getting 3 different facial cleansers but I wouldn’t have selected two on my own. I feel like after I put my selections in and then check the app a few days later the my selections are different than what I picked!

I always forget to screen shot my selections but it’s happened a few months before and I was just curious if anyone else has experienced this before?

I used to be subscribed to boxycharm a few years ago and loved it. Around 2020/2021 and prior. Amazing brands, pretty much never had to buy skincare. I just resubscribed to a regular Boxycharm subscription and am waiting for my September box. I’ve noticed they are now offering all sorts of upgrades-Beauty Boost, Icon Box, something with Chrissy Teigan? They advertise exclusive brands and stuff with the upgrades. My concern is that some of the great brands I used to get with a normal subscription, will now be exclusive to an upgraded subscription. Can anyone whose been subscribed for awhile let me know if the quality of products is the same as it was a few years ago? I’m willing to upgrade to Beauty Boost if it’s worth it, not really interested in Chrissy teigan though

Hi, so I used to have boxycharm subscription about 3/4 years ago and I received this lip liner in one of the subscriptions. I still have this but I don’t know the brand of the liner. Could somebody tell which brand it is from. :)

I realize that I am a bit late sharing my August haul, but am dying to hear what everyone thought of the products that they received. Which is your favorite and why?

I have really enjoyed the 🌴Vacation🌴sunscreen, the Context shadow stick 🎨 (I have it in another color as well), and of course the Anastasia Brow Wiz eyebrow pencil ✏️ in medium brown. 🩷

Is anyone else experiencing delays in their August box? I still have not received mine. Kinda annoyed because By the time it eventually finds it's way here it will already be time to pay for September! I'm pretty sure it got lost and they gave me some one size fits all excuse.