/r/askastronomy

Photograph via snooOG

For your astronomy-related questions and content!

"We make our world significant by the courage of our questions and by the depth of our answers." - Carl Sagan

/r/askastronomy

87,443 Subscribers

1

Just for fun.

Tired of all the "what is this" posts. So, I have a magic pole, and a magic telescope. The pole is light years long. The telescope can see clearly all the way down the pole no matter how far away it is, c regardless. If I extend the pole long enough, will it eventually follow the "curve" of the universe, so the pole appears curved from my perspective? And if so, how long would it have to be?

1 Comment
2024/12/01
16:36 UTC

2

Would you rather have 1000 JWST class telescopes or one telescope 1000 time more capable than JWST?

We appear to be at the dawn of an era of transformationally cheap launch capability. Casey Handmer is a former NASA engineer who likes to blog about this and his most recent post sketches out the feasability of a 1km space telescope: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2024/11/30/it-is-time-to-build-the-monster-scope/It's an interesting article, however what I'm curious to know is:

  1. Would astronomers be more interested in a single super-advanced instrument, or many, many adequate instruments?

  2. Follow-on question: What need would there be for ground-based telescopes if we could launch dozens of 10m space telescopes for the cost of a single ground based telescope of similar capability?

5 Comments
2024/12/01
16:35 UTC

2

Asteroid 2019 ok

So it's a bit late but I just remembered and I have to know: was "asteroid 2019 ok" visible to naked eyes in Egypt? Because I recall seeing something in late July 2019 when I was out at night, and I have been doubting myself since then.

Edit: I saw a greenish white light ball the size of a melon, going from North-west to South-east, could see it for about two seconds.

My location was in Al-Mahalla city, in the middle of Nile delta in Egypt, late July 2019

15 Comments
2024/12/01
16:06 UTC

3

Reading List on Supernovae

I am currently working on a research paper regarding Supernovae and am looking for materials to read on them to gain deeper understanding of how they are formed (from a physics standpoint). Do you have any recommendations for books, papers, publications? I am really struggling to find something interesting. :)

0 Comments
2024/12/01
10:04 UTC

1

Can Anything Be Completely Still?

Not sure how or where to research this so I figured I'd toss the question in here.

So I'm watching 2001: A Space Odyssey and at the part where Dave shoots himself into the ship airlock and I'm musing about physics in a vacuum.

One question that popped up tangentially is momentum. We talk about objects moving and at rest in physics but is there ever a situation where something in space is ever at 0 acceleration? Like, relatively speaking, something could match the momentum of a larger object e.g. a rock sitting on Earth and that would be considered at rest, but the Earth is moving. So in a bigger picture the rock is also moving. But say you took a spaceship into the vacuum with nothing nearby, could you balance out the momentum of the ship to 'stop' completely, or is momentum relative to other objects? If so, how is that measured is there a baseline to reference? Is there a gravitational component to it?

5 Comments
2024/12/01
03:56 UTC

2

Shooting Star outside of Hammonton, NJ around 6:30 PM EST

Hi all! Wanna start off by saying I know next to nothing about astronomy, including good terminology so I'm sorry if this is poorly worded and a dumb question.

My partner and I were driving on the expressway tonight and saw quite a large shooting star above us which went over the treeline before dissipating behind the treeline. It had a bit of a comet tail but apart from being somewhat large did not seem unusual. What us off was after it dissipated there was a hazy red-orange plume in that area that went from where the comet/asteroid first appeared that then went down in front of the tree line.

This is probably a very stupid question with a very obvious answer, but what was the plume and why did it's path appear somewhat different than the original shooting star?

I've spent the last hour trying to find more information but the only things that seemed to make sense with its appearance and timing were 1. a dust trail and 2. information on the likely makeup of the comet/asteroid. Any additional info would be greatly appreciated :)

2 Comments
2024/12/01
00:33 UTC

1

How long does sky take to get dark after moon set?

Hi, I’m gonna be roadtripping this winter. I’ll be at big bend national park either January 4th or January 5th. I’m looking to stargaze.

If I make it there by the 4th, the 23% ilium moon sets at 10:55pm. I’d assume this means by midnight the stars would look beautiful right? If I make it there the 5th, the 33% ilum moon sets at 11:59pm. So how long would it take for the starts to look nice then?

Getting there by the 4th would be a bit rushed but I really really wanna have my first cool star gazing experience.

I’m also young and don’t mind staying up all night if that would work for the 5th.

Any advice? Thanks!

1 Comment
2024/12/01
00:13 UTC

1

What was the southernmost constellation in 2000 and 3000 BC (from the Northern Hemisphere)?

So I notice that, today, the constellation Centaurus just peeks above the southern horizon at night and draws a slow circle across the sky. It wasn't like that anciently due to precession, as the earth's poles were pointed in different directions. So, I am curious which constellation in ancient times was closest to the Southern horizon?

Thanks!

4 Comments
2024/11/30
15:31 UTC

0

Buying a dobsonian telescope

Buying a used sky watcher 150p 6in dob. My first time buying a used scope. I've asked for a picture of the mirror and it looks clean. Was wondering if there is anything I should look out for or any red flags.

1 Comment
2024/11/30
04:48 UTC

61

Seeking someone who wants to meet in central Texas to do some astrophotography with my night vision and their telescope

GIF for attention. Taken on an L3 high fom night vision device. 7/7/24 flagstaff az

14 Comments
2024/11/30
01:25 UTC

3

View of planetary rings from shepherd moon

I'm trying to visualise what a planet's rings would look like in the sky from the surface of one of its shepherd moons.

So far I've been able to conclude that the rings and the moon would share their orbital tilt, so at the equator of the moon, it would look very similar to what it would look like from the planet's equator, a thin band across the sky of varying intensity depending on if you're looking "out" or "in".

Would latitude impact this? I understand how it impacts the view from the parent planet, but the shepherd moon is much smaller. If it were closer to Earth size, would one be able to gradually see the "surface" (for lack of a better term) of the rings, or would they simply fade from view the closer to the poles you got?

Say the moon is tidally locked to the planet (suspend your disbelief for me, please) and you were located on the hemisphere facing away from the planet, at 45° latitude, and the axial orbit is 22.5° to the ecliptic.

During the night, the rings would reflect some light to the surface, could it be enough to act as a Moon stand-in? I'm pretty sure it would be very bright if the rings were icy like Saturn's, but what if they were rocky?

Would the rings remain visible during a partial eclipse (or even just at high noon), or would the star's light be too overpowering? Would they gradually fade out closer in the sky to the sun?

What about if you were on the side facing the planet? would the rings be visible at all, at least at night?

0 Comments
2024/11/29
15:19 UTC

2

Question about taking pictures of black holes

So, I just saw a picture of the sombrero galaxy, 30 million light years away from earth taken on jwst. How can we have a clear picture of that whole galaxy with the black hole in the center of it, but our own black hole at the center of the Milky Way galaxy, our only picture of it is super blurry and can barely see anything?

10 Comments
2024/11/29
10:34 UTC

0

How can I take picture of Andromeda Galaxy?

Next week I'm gonna visit my grandparents and I want to take some pictures of Andromeda Galaxy, Orion, Jupiter and etc. What settings do I need?

2 Comments
2024/11/29
10:14 UTC

Back To Top