/r/AmericanHorrorStory

Photograph via snooOG

Fan subreddit for the hit TV franchise American Horror Story. Visit r/AmericanHorrorStories for the Hulu exclusive spin-off.



Episode Discussions:

S1 Murder House

S2 Asylum

S3 Coven

S4 Freak Show

S5 Hotel

S6 Roanoke

S7 Cult

S8 Apocalypse

S9 1984



Rules & AMAs

Subreddit Rules

  • 1. Do not personally attack other users. Keep it civil.
  • 2. a) Do not post unmarked NSFW content or spoilers, or put any spoilers in a post title. The format for including spoilers in a comment is: [Spoiler] ( / s "The next season is Cult." ) Note: This only applies to comments. Do not use this format in post titles. It will not work. b) Do not post spoilers— tagged or otherwise— before an episode released early airs live. Episodes released early via FX+/illegally pirated means will be designated a unique advanced discussion thread. All spoilers must remain within that thread until after the episode's live premiere.
  • 3. Do not submit vague titles or generalized posts.
  • 4. Low-quality content or questions which can be answered with a simple Google/subreddit search should be avoided. Hinting at asking for votes also counts as low-quality content.
  • 5. Do not submit spam or unapproved self-promotion.
  • 6. We do not allow posts with the end goal of making money.
  • 7. Threatening, stalking, impersonating, posting personal information, vote manipulation or breaking the Spam rules isn't allowed.
  • 8. No witch hunts. Don't rile up the community to vote for/against something or to boycott/support a person/organization.
  • 9. Reaction gifs, memes etc. are allowed as long as they are closely related to the show.
  • 10. Please try to keep all topics somewhat related to AHS and don't forget to enjoy the show!

Join our Discord!

American Horror Story AMA's

AHS Links

/r/AmericanHorrorStory

749,848 Subscribers

9

Adam AHS New York

I loved Adam! What a cutie. And relentless in his pursuit of justice. Do we think Adam survived HIV/AIDS longer than his friends? I think Adam went to start the New York Buyers club :) and spread the word about alternate treatments vs toxic AZT

Haha what do y’all think

0 Comments
2024/12/19
11:43 UTC

1

Which Ryan Murphy collabs would you guys like to see in a new season of American horror story?

I was thinking it would be nice to have Lea Michelle again. I don’t know if she could lead but she should be part of a main cast. Also, Ricky Martin and Darren Criss (Glee and Versace), Matthew Morrison (1984) and Matt Bomer again. What about you guys!

8 Comments
2024/12/19
02:17 UTC

282

Why is Kyle even in the show

I mean, I’ll take any excuse to throw in Evan peters for a season but Kyle doesn’t do anything and just becomes a weird sex slave for the witches. I mean, why would the coven ever need a “ guard dog” all the witches are stronger than Kyle 🤦🏾‍♂️

74 Comments
2024/12/19
00:58 UTC

8

Couldn't they hide it any better? or throw it away?

3 Comments
2024/12/18
20:44 UTC

39

Denis O’Hare

He does not get enough credit for his versatility. Each season he is in, it’s hard to tell it’s him! Liz Taylor is my personal favorite role Denis plays. Something about Liz is so comforting.

5 Comments
2024/12/18
18:43 UTC

378

Random, but I never knew Emma Roberts was in this pic too. I’ve only seen it posted here with Evan, Sarah and Ryan lolol but also…

as

47 Comments
2024/12/18
17:28 UTC

17

Red Tide

Just been doing my yearly rewatch and don’t usually bother with double feature, but just finished Red Tide and actually really enjoyed it. Apart from Alma being a lil bitch, I thought the cast was great and the story was interesting albeit a little rushed - wish they’d just continued this into a full season and done something really interesting with it.

What do you guys think?

18 Comments
2024/12/18
14:56 UTC

44

Jessica Lange singing

Does anybody absolutely love the couple of song Jessica Lange does in Freak Show. Gods and Monsters and the other one is Life On Mars. I’ve seen people trash on the songs and she can’t sing but I love them so much. I have them downloaded on my phone

20 Comments
2024/12/18
14:35 UTC

0

Season 12 Part 2 - where u at?

So I’m a bit late to watch season 12 and realised I only have 5 episodes available on Disney plus. after some searching I can see it was released in April but it’s December and still nothing.

I’m from Australia so not sure if that means they delayed it but this long? Tf?

6 Comments
2024/12/18
11:03 UTC

222

We listen we don't judge:AHS characters. I'll start:Madison Montogomery is so disgusting it makes her character unlikable to me

90 Comments
2024/12/18
01:20 UTC

20

These were probably the cringiest moments for the actors in the show

10 Comments
2024/12/17
17:35 UTC

203

The Queen

10 Comments
2024/12/17
07:18 UTC

2

Season 10

Ok I loved the first half, red tide was really good! BUTTT I got like 30 minutes into Death Valley and thought it was so freaking cheesy….are red tide and Death Valley connected at all?

8 Comments
2024/12/17
04:45 UTC

584

I loved her as the angel of death

14 Comments
2024/12/16
16:32 UTC

33

Did you guys trusted him on first watch? He looked very convincing to me

16 Comments
2024/12/16
16:05 UTC

17

Was Fiona really that evil? Or did just the writing change?

Hey Guys! I recently watched Coven again, like once a year kinda, cause it's my favorite season ... but somehow i feel now more and more that Fiona was not that evil, at least not from the start of the season.

There are some big plotholes ... for example i don't think that she "wanted" to kill Madison at this evening. It felt like she really asked Madison to end her first.

Or when Cordelia lost her sight cause of the acid ... Fiona kinda stuck to her THE WHOLE TIME! in the hospital etc.

It really felt like that Fiona tried at least to fix a few things. She would not have cared about Cordelia or anybody else if she really tried to kill everybody, imo.

But in the second half of the season i think the writing just changed massively kinda. The burning of Myrtle, the random killing of Nan, without any use for Fiona.

Or the vision of Cordelia that Fiona will kill everyone in the Coven ... i don't know, after rewatching it, it felt very off.

It felt too much kinda, some things were not necessary. What are your feelings about that?

And just some other plotholes i thought of:

• Why did Fiona end up with Papa Legba without signing a deal or "not having a soul" to sell?

• Did Zoe have Pyrokinesis in the first episode already?

• Did Zoe have ALL 7 wonders? She showed everything kinda, if she had Pyrokinesis 🤔

• Why did they even kill Madison off in the end? She was always my favorite :/

After rewatching Season 8 somehow even more plotholes appeared 🥲 especially the whole deleted timeline scenario ...

23 Comments
2024/12/16
15:35 UTC

0

I didn’t understand Roanoke (season 6)

I mean, my Roanoke nightmare was a tv show. Then “return to Roanoke” seemed to be another show??? Cause they all died and then all the cast appeared together with fans. So was everything fake? Nothing happened to them in the house? Even the scenes of the trial of Lee and Flora, was everything supposed to be a part of some kind of tv show? Please I need an explanation of all the season.

17 Comments
2024/12/16
14:49 UTC

62

It was the most horrific scene ever why did they made her reflection like that

6 Comments
2024/12/16
14:21 UTC

21

Is 1984 and beyond worth watching?

I’ve been a huge fan of the show for years. I started watching it as a teenager when the first season aired and I was absolutely hooked.

I watched the show religiously for years, all the way up until 1984.

By then my love for the show just kind of dwindled out for one reason or another.

However, I’ve recently felt the urge to get back into the show. So my question is, are any of the seasons after Apocalypse worth watching? Or should I just do a rewatch of my favourite seasons?

48 Comments
2024/12/16
07:35 UTC

Back To Top