/r/AmericanHorrorStory

Photograph via snooOG

Fan subreddit for the hit TV franchise American Horror Story. Visit r/AmericanHorrorStories for the Hulu exclusive spin-off.



Episode Discussions:

S1 Murder House

S2 Asylum

S3 Coven

S4 Freak Show

S5 Hotel

S6 Roanoke

S7 Cult

S8 Apocalypse

S9 1984



Rules & AMAs

Subreddit Rules

  • 1. Do not personally attack other users. Keep it civil.
  • 2. a) Do not post unmarked NSFW content or spoilers, or put any spoilers in a post title. The format for including spoilers in a comment is: [Spoiler] ( / s "The next season is Cult." ) Note: This only applies to comments. Do not use this format in post titles. It will not work. b) Do not post spoilers— tagged or otherwise— before an episode released early airs live. Episodes released early via FX+/illegally pirated means will be designated a unique advanced discussion thread. All spoilers must remain within that thread until after the episode's live premiere.
  • 3. Do not submit vague titles or generalized posts.
  • 4. Low-quality content or questions which can be answered with a simple Google/subreddit search should be avoided. Hinting at asking for votes also counts as low-quality content.
  • 5. Do not submit spam or unapproved self-promotion.
  • 6. We do not allow posts with the end goal of making money.
  • 7. Threatening, stalking, impersonating, posting personal information, vote manipulation or breaking the Spam rules isn't allowed.
  • 8. No witch hunts. Don't rile up the community to vote for/against something or to boycott/support a person/organization.
  • 9. Reaction gifs, memes etc. are allowed as long as they are closely related to the show.
  • 10. Please try to keep all topics somewhat related to AHS and don't forget to enjoy the show!

Join our Discord!

American Horror Story AMA's

AHS Links

/r/AmericanHorrorStory

557,211 Subscribers

6

ben harmon is probably one of my least favourite characters in the entire show. he makes me SO angry

he's sooooo fucking dumb. like you cheated on your wide and your only argument was “you got a dog”. do everyone a favour and stfu

4 Comments
2024/06/28
07:52 UTC

1

looking for the ideal watch order for ahs delicate

hi new watcher here, began with s12 of ahs delicate, and watched a few eps of ahs. there's 12 seasons of ahs delicate tho, a bit short on time and i couldnt find a watch order anywhere.

oh and whats ur favourite season of ahs delicate?

1 Comment
2024/06/28
07:34 UTC

4

The John Lowe plot twist in Hotel would have worked better for NYC

Big Daddy should have been Patrick, which is why he was so secretive and private about his leather past.

1 Comment
2024/06/28
07:15 UTC

3

Which season should I watch next?

I have watched:

Murder house ( 8 mins of ep 1) Asylum (whole season) Coven (whole season) Freak show (whole season) Hotel (whole season) Cult (whole season) Apocalypse (whole season) 1984 ( whole season) Delicate ( whole season)

I have not watched

Murder house (some) Roanoke Double feature NYC

I have yet to watch Roanoke because I have heard the jump scares are horrifying, other than that, I really don’t mind much gore. NYC and double I heard were just terrible so I’m hesitant to watch. Also for murder house I know some people might come attacking and say I haven’t watched the first season, but frankly I found it quite boring almost (sorry everyone who loved it) I might give it a chance

Any suggestions on which to watch first? And is Roanoke that jump scary?

6 Comments
2024/06/28
05:07 UTC

9

Delicate discuss SPOILERS

I really liked delicate.

I know I am part of the few

I did NOT like how it ended. I know I am not alone. But wanted to have a discussion.

When Anna (Emma Roberts) in the last episode saw Adeline (spelling?).... It seems that Adeline gave her the latine words to overcome Siobhan.(Kim k)...

In an earlier scene we see Adeline tied up. Why didn't Adeline use that same phrase (incantation?) to rid herself of these "boss women".

Did something go over my head?

I am thinking I need another rewatch. At the same time... If this one instance can be explained to me, then I don't.

3 Comments
2024/06/28
03:15 UTC

6

Asylum Ending

Can somebody help me understand the ending to asylum? I don’t know if I’m slow or stupid

9 Comments
2024/06/28
01:59 UTC

0

Melanie Martinez Song for Each Season

I had this idea while I was getting lunch. My playlist has a lot of Melanie Martinez songs. So, I had this idea. Associate a song with each season of the show (you can split Double Feature if you want to). Here is what I have:

Dollhouse - Murder House

Nurse's Office - Asylum

Carousel - Freak Show (duh)

EVIL - Cult

Tag, You're It/Milk and Cookies - 1984

The Contortionist - Delicate

4 Comments
2024/06/28
00:04 UTC

9

What's with the hate for delicate??? (Im on ep 7) and im loving it.

Please don't spoil the last episodes . But what is with the hate ?! I've only watched the slasher season and this one , and both are really good to me. I've heard these are bad compared to hotel and asylum and those other seasons. I like the eerieness and suspicious vibe throughout this watch , so many creepy disturbing moments . It feels like me and the main character are going through it together , (sorry if that's cringy) . I really wanna know why it's so hated tho .

40 Comments
2024/06/27
23:01 UTC

15

season nine

hi guys! I am currently watching all the seasons over again for like the second or third time and i’ve heard how a lot of people don’t like season 9 aka 1984. I personally love it and I just wanted to hear some of the reasons why people don’t like it? obviously people have differing opinions so I am just curious :) I really liked the friday the 13th type of feel and how there were so many twists and turns that I never really knew what to expect. let me know what you guys think!

11 Comments
2024/06/27
22:36 UTC

1

Question

Does anyone know Zoe bensons exact birthday or a estimate been trying to figure it out

1 Comment
2024/06/27
20:36 UTC

115

God Lily Rabe is SO underrated!

I feel like people always just praise about how good Jessica, Evan, Kathy, Sarah are. Don't get me wrong I absolutely love all of these actors and I totally think they deserve their recognitions. But Lily Rabe has always been one of my favourite along side with Jessica and Sarah. Her playing Sister Mary Eunice was absolutely phenomenal. It was my second favourite performance in Asylum! (1st being Sister Jude of course).

And I just watched The Great Lillian Hall, which was played by Jessica, Lily and Kathy. And Lily's performance again was extraordinary! There was one scene (not to spoil anything) totally blown me away. I totally recommend this film on HBO and everyone should go watch it! It literally has the AHS trio in it lol.

23 Comments
2024/06/27
13:20 UTC

310

What wonder would you like to have in real life

86 Comments
2024/06/27
13:11 UTC

42

Is the joke on Kim?

After watching the Delicate finale I thought the casting of Kim to be kind of shady. Knowing Ryan is planning another show where she is this girl boss lawyer, it’s very obvious he doesn’t write her characters but casts Kim to play Kim in some caricature version of what Ryan thinks she represents. I seriously hope Kim is in on it.

31 Comments
2024/06/27
07:43 UTC

30

The irony of Evan Peter’s playing James March and interacting with jeffery dahmer in Hotel

To go on and play Dahmer in the Netflix series. I am watching through AHS now and I am on hotel. After seeing the scene with him and dahmer in room 64 together I instantly thought how coincidental it all was.

2 Comments
2024/06/27
05:11 UTC

16

Thoughts on Ben Harmon

I’m a new watcher of AHS, and, prior to beginning the show, I saw a lot of hate on Ben. I’m only on episode 3, and I get that he cheated and can be an asshole but I honestly just felt bad for him most of the time. Who I do hate is that fucking maid and Hayden (RIP). Am I an asshole for not hating him, what do yall think about him and who’s the least likable character in the first half of season 1?

34 Comments
2024/06/27
01:51 UTC

16

Apocalypse question: is Moira free?

Moira was freed and re-buried in a cemetery to be with her mother. This was after Constance requested Moira to be removed from the house in return of information of Michael in Apocalypse. This was a very sweet moment. However; at the end of Apocalypse, Michael was killed by Mallory by a hit and run. Michael’s death means Constance never committed suicide, resulting in her never having to deal with Moira in the house, meaning it was never requested for her to be re-buried. Therefore, is it safe to say Moira is now still trapped? Quite sad to think about tbf

14 Comments
2024/06/27
00:19 UTC

1

Did I miss something in Murder House?

Why does everyone hate Tate? I know he did reprehensible things, but he was literally possessed and just plain manipulated. I’m not celebrating him, but everyone seems to think he’s just this detestable figure when I feel like he was kind of a victim too. Makes me think I missed a crucial plot point or two; maybe I need to rewatch? (I could very easily have been too high and something went over my head.) Genuine question!

ETA: y’all are wild for fucking my karma up bc I asked a few questions. Please seek help.

68 Comments
2024/06/26
23:27 UTC

14

Recreating AHS covers: today Apocalypse

2 Comments
2024/06/26
18:38 UTC

183

My friend in NYC helped me get Autographs from the mother witch herself!

18 Comments
2024/06/26
17:14 UTC

1,091

I'd really love a season where Jamie Brewer has one of the leading roles. Everyone always states how Jessica, Evan, Kathy or Sarah are the icons of AHS. But for me, Jamie is one of the icons.

I really loved her in murder house and coven, and I was really happy to see her as guest role in Cult, I missed her and still miss her.

77 Comments
2024/06/26
11:22 UTC

438

Who is JungleJim4322@yahoo.com? (Wrong Answers Only)

62 Comments
2024/06/26
10:19 UTC

35

My favorite Fiona monologue

1 Comment
2024/06/26
07:36 UTC

19

which character do you relate to the most?

basically asking, which one is the most like you?? (ofc, not the murderous psychopathic sides to the characters ajskdlf). but which one do you feel resembles you in some way?

38 Comments
2024/06/26
06:30 UTC

9

I have just started Roanoke for the first time! Did you guys like that season? Will I be disappointed? I just finished Hotel and I loved hotel.

13 Comments
2024/06/26
06:29 UTC

10

Just finished coven again after 12 years and I still can’t believe what happens to misty day, the best witch imo.

My boyfriend and I were shocked. I completely forgot what will happen to her. So she deserves the same fate as a serial killer (which existed in real life btw) and a voodoo queen full of crap (existed also in real life). Mkay. It was already unfair that Marie was in the same hell as her arch enemy but anyway. Yes sure she is not caged but come one. Killing someone for eternity is as also bad.

Btt: Misty day doesn’t belong in hell. It’s ridiculous.

I haven’t seen the new seasons. Stopped after cult (still don’t know why, it’s one of my favorite, even bought the blue rays back then).

8 Comments
2024/06/26
06:08 UTC

9

I gotta question

Asylum is and I think will always be my favorite season it's a basic choice yes but anyway do y'all think that they were wrong and kinda exploited mental illness for entertaining purposes and didn't portray it accurately?

9 Comments
2024/06/26
03:13 UTC

Back To Top