Taylor Tomlinson welcomes comic Matt Mathews, comic Guy Branum and actress Gillian Jacobs. Original Air Date: Oct 17, 2024

• Season 2 Episode 28

Actor Nick Kocher; actor Brian McElhaney; writer Demi Adejuyigbe.

• S2 E40
• Lisa Gilroy; Chris Fleming; Oscar Montoya

It's the end of the week. Let's see what you guys really liked this week. I will tally the results; and we'll see what panelists and what segments were your favorites from last week!

12/2-12/5 Results

Best Panelist - Kurt Braunohler (50%)

Best Episode - Monday, December 2, 2024 (Kurt Braunohler, Mamrie Hart, Opey Olagbaju) (50%)

Best Prize - TIE: Tuesday - Loaf of Bread With A Party Hat On, Wednesday - Mostly Opened Advent Calendar (33.3%)

Best Final Game - Hashtag War (50%)

Best FTW - TIE: Tuesday - Number Guess - Guy Fieri's Net Worth, Wednesday - Category Game - Name The Most Fake Car Models (33.3%)

Predictions - Congrats to /u/rayogata and /u/DocCrapologist for getting 2/4 right last week in winner predictions!

Survey Closes next episode premieres (December 16th)

#SURVEY HERE

The authenticity of when she laughs or is annoyed/excited by a game she doesn’t know the outcome of is spectacular.

You can tell when shes laughing to be polite and when shes just killed.

Best show on tv because of her.

:(

@fter Midnight if off through the holidays, we'll see you the week of the 6th for...

MONDAY JANUARY 6 - FIRST SHOW OF 2025

TUESDAY JANUARY 7

WEDNESDAY JANUARY 8

THURSDAY JANUARY 9

Read Previous Episode Results and Statistics HERE

 After Midnight Appearances BOLDED / All other appearances are for @midnight

This tree in Iowa has major cake vibes.

https://preview.redd.it/1kvb6ofl1n6e1.jpg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=91b334487e3cc286a15603fe4ce48c2d7321cba6

Roast goose for everyone!

Friday, Dec. 13 (OAD: 11/19/24)

• Milana Vayntrub
• Jessica Lowe
• Jason Ritter-MATLOCK (CBS)

LAST EPISODE STANDINGS:

I'm /u/bjkman, and welcome to the OFFICIAL episode discussion thread for "@fter midnight with Taylor Tomlinson" on CBS at @ ~12:37AM EST. And remember... "Be Nice To Each Other God Dammit!"

Follow the Show and Play Along on Threads/Insta/TikTok!

Tonight's Comedians:

How can Frozen be a Christmas movie? It takes place in July! "A real howler in July, ja?"

LAST EPISODE STANDINGS:

I'm /u/bjkman, and welcome to the OFFICIAL episode discussion thread for "@fter midnight with Taylor Tomlinson" on CBS at @ ~12:37AM EST. And remember... "Be Nice To Each Other God Dammit!"

Follow the Show and Play Along on Threads/Insta/TikTok!

Tonight's Comedians:

Okay this is a dumb idea I had the other day but as Taylor has said, a lot, this show is dumb.

This game has two kinds of players; dancers and guessers, and they rotate each round. Each round two (three?) song titles are given, the dancer puts on headphones and dances to one of the songs, meanwhile the guessers watch them and discuss why they think it's this or that song. They don't dance the whole song.

When they are done, the guessers guess. At the end of the round they replay the video and play the music with it so we can all see how the moves lined up.

Is this brilliant or am I just stoned? What should this be called?

Do showrunners keep an eye on reddit? No one wants to play this with me so I'll settle for watching Chris Fleming play it instead.

LAST EPISODE STANDINGS:

I'm /u/bjkman, and welcome to the OFFICIAL episode discussion thread for "@fter midnight with Taylor Tomlinson" on CBS at @ ~12:37AM EST. And remember... "Be Nice To Each Other God Dammit!"

Follow the Show and Play Along on Threads/Insta/TikTok!

Tonight's Comedians:

Pretty sure Taylor was joking about Robbie subbing for her when she’s sick, because Robbie had just objected to the word “juicy” in the intro to the episode’s first game. (Robbie hosting an episode might be funny and interesting, but probably sort of exhausting too.)

So, who would you seriously like to see as a (temporary) substitute for Taylor?

I’ll start: Lisa Gilroy.

...may you be forbidden from any future tickets.

would

For example,

Nightmare on Elf Street

Or

The Last Temptation of Christmas

AND BEGIN!

11/10 would share my snacks with

LAST EPISODE STANDINGS:

I'm /u/bjkman, and welcome to the OFFICIAL episode discussion thread for "@fter midnight with Taylor Tomlinson" on CBS at @ ~12:37AM EST. And remember... "Be Nice To Each Other God Dammit!"

Follow the Show and Play Along on Threads/Insta/TikTok!

Tonight's Comedians:

Hashtag War:

Does anyone else refer to Madam Esquire Tomlinson as TayTom? Or is it just me 😅

Okay I like Taylor Tomlinson a lot. I've seen all her specials but I don't really care about late night shows. So I was happy for her but wasn't planning to watch. But now I've seen at least 10 monologues in dumb little clips. She got me.

What is the best way for me to watch the full monologue/show in a way where my views count and they get paid?

I'm in Canada and won't stay up until actually after midnight because I'm a 9 to 5er.

Yesterday we went to watch the latest After Midnight episode on Pluto TV and the series has been removed from my favorites and is nowhere to be found. I’m so bummed because this show is wonderful.

Did they kill the deal with Pluto to get people to sign up with Paramount+?

Sorry, sorry. I was having a moment.

Trying Something New! One main post to cap off this week's episodes. Let me know what you thought about last week and who you think will win next week... VIA SURVEY!! I will tally the results and we'll see who picked the winners correctly; and what panelists and what segments were your favorites from the previous week!

Survey Closes when the next episode premieres (December 9th)

#SURVEY HERE